r/PMsFeedback • • Feb 18 '21

[NEGATIVE] sidewayslipper (update)

256 Upvotes

—You can refer to my previous negative posts on this user for the background information. I am going to provide a couple of updates from some blogs that I have written as I think this process may shed some light on the use of PayPal for precious metals purchases.

Post 1: I often see it debated in these precious metals forums if precious metals are covered by PayPal goods and services buyer‘s protection program. I have recently completed pre-trial mediation and a 4 hour trial where I sued Paypal concerning a transaction resulting in such a dispute. If allowed by Admin, I will gladly post what I have learned through my experience in the Comments upon approval. Thanks in advance.

Post 2: I have just recently completed pre-trial mediation and a four hour trial with PayPal concerning a transaction of precious metals that I had with a buyer. At this time, I am awaiting the judges deliberation and decision. I do not have an idea how long that will take. In the event I am offered an acceptable settlement from PayPal, I would also expect that they will include a nondisclosure agreement. Therefore I will go ahead and post my story.

On Reddit, I sold a few thousand dollars worth of precious metals in the form of bullion to a buyer in Canada. I shipped to the address that he specifically told me to multiple times in our correspondence. The package was tracked through the USPS and Canada Post and subsequently marked as successfully delivered. In spite of it being marked as successfully delivered, the buyer claimed he did not receive the package. He had paid through PayPal goods and services and subsequently filed a claim with them through the Buyer’s Protection Program. PayPal, to my surprise, sided with the buyer and reversed the transaction out of my account. I subsequently appealed the decision, but they again refused to refund the money they had taken from me and told me I had no additional course of action. As this did not sit well with me, I subsequently filed a lawsuit against PayPal. I have no legal training whatsoever and no legal experience. I filed this lawsuit for a cost to me of approximately $70 in filing fees. I spent about 30 minutes of prep time to prepare for this trial. I represented myself. At pre-trial mediation and subsequently at trial, I was met by a specialized attorney representing PayPal. They also called another attorney as a witness during the course of the trial. With my lawsuit, I was simply seeking approximately $6000 in damages, the max that I was allowed by the court where I filed. The attorney let me know that PayPal took my lawsuit very seriously and he had billed well in excess of my $6000 asking price in order to defend this lawsuit. I was offered a lowball offer in order to dismiss the suit at mediation. I would’ve also been expected to sign a non-disclosure agreement if I had accepted that offer. The money in this case is of little consequence to me. I proceeded more based on the principle and the ability to share my experience with others in the precious metal forums.

I will share some of the lessons that I learned through the course of my lawsuit. First, if you ever have an issue with PayPal, they are going to assume that you have read in its entirety the user agreement for PayPal service, which is an approximate 60 page document. This user agreement will also make reference to a privacy statement, an acceptable use policy, and an electronic communications delivery policy. They will also assume that you have read the entirety of these three documents for a total of about 100 pages of documentation. As I mentioned, I spent about 30 minutes prep time for this trial. I had not even read these documents in their entirety. And still have not to this date.

According to the acceptable use policy, PayPal requires pre-approval to accept payment for precious metals. They do provide an email address in order to obtain this permission. I seriously doubt many people have ever obtained prior approval before they conduct a transaction involving precious metals with PayPal as payment. Simply entering into an agreement to buy and sell precious metals without prior approval is a breach of the contract with PayPal. The judge seemed to state that both parties were in breach, yet I was the only one being punished by PayPal. Hopefully that bodes well for me.

According to the PayPal user agreement, shipping of a package with a value of $750 or more requires a signature confirmation. If the buyer were to make an item not received claim, the seller has to provide either proof of shipment or proof of delivery. Without a signature confirmation, they will not consider it proof of delivery. You still can provide proof of shipment. In my particular case, the buyer had a different address listed on his email transaction form that was different from the one he gave me in our correspondence. Since I shipped to the one that he directed me to in our correspondence, I shipped to a different address than what was on the Paypal transaction form. They tried to argue that I did not have proof of shipment as I did not ship to the address that was on the proof of transaction form. My arguments were that signature confirmation has not been collected since the start of the pandemic. Given shipments that I send or receive that are registered, restricted delivery have not been obtaining signatures. This is the highest security form of shipment through the US PS and how confidential government documents are shipped through the USPS. The judge also seem to dismiss the address discrepancy as irrelevant as the buyer was not claiming he did not order the product or it was shipped to him without his prior consent. He simply states he did not receive it at the address he was expecting it. The judge seemed to side with me on this point.

A big part of my argument relies on the user agreement specifically excluding financial product or investment of any type from protection from the buyer’s protection program. In the past, in earlier versions of this user agreement, it specifically mentioned precious metals and bullion. They do periodically update it. I strongly argued, and I believe convincingly, that Canadian gold maples have a face value, are legal tender, are a financial product, and are an investment. This alone should prove that PayPal‘s decision was in breach of contract. PayPal attempted to argue that my lack of proof of delivery or proof of shipment superseded this point.

The bottom line: if you enter into an agreement to buy and ship precious metals without prior authorization or without prior approval for a transaction exceeding $750 or without signature confirmation of delivery, you are in breach of contract. As a buyer, if you enter into an agreement to purchase precious metals without prior approval, you are in breach of contract. If a dispute such as mine arises, PayPal may be forced to take a side one way or the other. Regardless of PayPal‘s actions, there will be a party that is impoverished or harmed, and can seek legal remedy. Of course, this only becomes an issue if a dispute arises. Utilizing the goods and services features of PayPal in no way alters the contractual obligation. It may help PayPal to side with the buyer initially, but I will have to await the outcome of my verdict to see if that holds up. whenever I see debate back-and-forth about if precious metals are covered by PayPal‘s policy. I understand the confusion. They are specifically excluded per the user agreement. But, that may only be one factor that PayPal takes into consideration.

Sorry for the length of this. Hopefully, some may find it useful. The fact that the judge has asked for time to deliberate his decision hopefully means I put up a formidable fight. I was outmatched in legal knowledge. Nothing will replace dealing with reputable people with a proven history.

Post 3: So I went back to court today with the impression that I would have a quick and simple trial with the buyer. A couple of amateurs. It was before the same judge as my trial with PayPal. So the judge consolidated the two cases. So I was again met by a high-priced attorney representing PayPal. We end up in the court room for another 2 1/2 hr trial in what can only be described as a legal menage a trois between myself, Paypal, and the buyer. Three different parties, three different interests. To open, PayPal‘s attorney presents about an inch thick file with all of the research and case law as he sees pertains to the previous trial that is still under consideration. At one point, the judge made a comment that PayPal has to have spent more than $14,000 to defend a small claims case. I suspect that PayPal is taking this so seriously because for $70 and no experience, I think I have made a worthy case to punch holes in their user agreement. I suspect this may have much larger implications and consequences on the line for them.

I found it somewhat awkward and put me at a disadvantage to first have to argue that I fulfilled all of my obligations to the buyer as a seller. There are many unnecessary details to this case that I won’t go into detail here, but in our communication, the buyer was offered insurance and declined and agreed to be responsible for the risk of shipping. So I had to argue that he was responsible for any potential loss. At the same time, I had to argue that the transaction between the buyer and myself was complete. It was PayPal who came in after the fact to reverse those charges and take the money from me. And I argued that this was done in breach of their contract as it specifically does not cover financial product or investment of any type. The buyer argued that since he paid with PayPal, he believed he was under the terms of PayPal which required confirmation of shipping, signature confirmation, etc. The judge also made the comment that the buyer could say he completed his obligation by making payment. It was PayPal that took the money from me, not the buyer. This was something he would have to consider. PayPal argued that because we were both in breach of contract and had a dispute between us, that it is their right to arbitrarily decide.

In short, it is a triangular mess but with some important points to consider for the judge and PayPal as a whole that could have much wider ranging implications. The judge states that he will have to research the decision and it would be 3 to 4 weeks, at a minimum, before he would have a written decision. In any event, I get the feeling that should this decision go against PayPal where they would be liable for the charges, I suspect that they may file an appeal to a higher court. Let’s keep running up the legal charges for them. STICKING IT TO THE MAN, 2021!


r/PMsFeedback • • Feb 03 '26 Regret

[NEGATIVE] for /u/CommiRhick [seller]

207 Upvotes

I arranged a trade with u/CommiRhick through a [WTT] listing I posted. We agreed to terms of the trade that were somewhat in his favor and agreed to use a middleman to facilitate the deal.

After both of us mailed our packages, the relative prices of silver and gold fluctuated in a way that made the trade less favorable for him. Without notifying myself or the middleman, u/CommiRhick decided to renege on the deal and contacted the post office to have his package intercepted and returned.

After I noticed the tracking showed his package as intercepted, the middleman reached out to u/CommiRhick who ultimately paid the middleman his fee and sent a nominal amount of money to cover my shipping costs. u/CommiRhick did not have the courage to message me and instead only spoke to the middleman.


r/PMsFeedback • • Aug 31 '26

[NEGATIVE] for /u/Sweaty-Beautiful225 (BAN)

190 Upvotes

Hate has no home in the r/Pmsforsale community. ALL are welcome and should feel comfortable buying the metal they love.

If someone is asking for a Liberation of Palestine 1oz Silver Coin, then you simply do not offer a 1967 Israel Liberation coin in the comments.

Nobody in the community is dumb enough to think you did that out of kindness or to be helpful. This kind of backhanded racism does not have a home here.

Stay shiny people. And may we someday live in peace, all of us.

With love,
The Mod Team


r/PMsFeedback • • Oct 01 '25

[Negative] for u/feelinspaced [BUYER] BIN BANDIT

171 Upvotes

Has me hold a $3750 coin for him to make payment arrangements. Proceeds to make a WTB post and BIN coins on another post. After telling me the next day payment would be made that day and i receive nothing i reach out today only to be told "Sorry I had a big silver purchase come up that I had to jump on"

Not someone I want to deal with and want to warn other sellers so they don't waste time holding product like I did.


r/PMsFeedback • • Aug 29 '25

[NEGATIVE] for /u/Goldandsilver1 [SELLER]

167 Upvotes

A few hours ago another Redittor characterized this seller as either a scammer or grossly negligent. I will clarify here: there is no doubt that this seller is a scammer.

I purchased a roll of ASEs (20 1 oz. coins). I received a photo of the package which looked fine. After a few days delay the seller told me that they had to make a new label because they “Accidently did flat rate label but didn’t use box lol.” I received a new tracking number but no photo. I tracked both numbers through USPS; they were apparently generated in different cities.

Well today I received my package. It is small shipping bag that is nowhere near large enough to hold a roll. The weight on the mailing label is 4 oz. The package seems to be filled with cotton balls, but I haven’t bothered to open it. I’ll allow the police to do that when I file my report tomorrow.


r/PMsFeedback • • Jan 21 '26

[NEGATIVE] u/Only_interest_5535

148 Upvotes

Please be careful out here, some folks can’t be trusted to do the right thing when that time comes.

Proof: https://imgur.com/a/lz4X54K

I made a proposal to buy 25 ozt of silver from seller, they agreed. Responded that something was wrong. I remained patient. Turns out they mailed my package to another buyer. I still remained patient. Other buyer was supposed to then mail it to me, didn’t happen, went back to seller. By this point silver had already went up in price by a decent amount. Asks what I would like to do, in short I said refund me for the time being until you receive the metals then I would like to proceed at the agreed upon rate. Seller refunded me and seems to be in agreement to those terms (at this point I’m just trying to figure out if I’d been scammed, if no refund the I obviously was. If refund then we can proceed as planned). Doesn’t let me know they got the metals back until I ask about it 3 days later. Then goes on to say HE gifted the (other) buyer $143 for shipping and a tip and that I WOULD HAVE TO PAY THAT if I wanted to continue.

I don’t enjoy dogging people and tried to prevent that. But in my nearly a year of buying and selling this has to be some of the worst etiquette as far as integrity that I’ve dealt with in at least 6 months.

If this post isn’t allowed, please let me know where this is best posted. Maybe in every other transaction this person is amazing… but in my opinion, this is dirty work and even if I had great transactions in the past with this person this would raise a red flag for me.


r/PMsFeedback • • Aug 28 '25

[NEGATIVE] for /u/Goldandsilver1 [SELLER] Scammer or gross negligence in shipping

132 Upvotes

Got an empty bag shipped to me. Seller claimed in listing it would be shipped priority mail which I prefer as it usually means flat rate box and at least some minimum standard in shipping.

It was "shipped" ground advantage in a reused poly bag with minimal padding. .

This is for a $1,700 coin. At the very best he half assed shipping causing the coin to be easily stolen and the package retaped. At worst he shipped an empty bag in a manner that created plausible deniability. Even if not a scammer buyer beware there are better sellers to use.

In hindsight despite prior confirmed transactions the warning signs for a scam were there. Selling a massive amount of gold all at once after much smaller tx ni the past and a long gap in feedback. I got careless and complacent and it cost me $1,700.

on edit: I can't change the title but at this point it is very clear this was 100% a scam and mail fraud.


r/PMsFeedback • • Aug 15 '25

[NEGATIVE] for /u/errienftw999 (buyer)

129 Upvotes

As someone who has nearly 500 transactions completed with upstanding members of our coin and precious metals communities on here, this post pains me.

On July 25, 2025, I entered into an agreement to sell my 1992 1 oz. gold panda to u/errienftw999. (Sale post: https://www.reddit.com/r/CoinSales/comments/1m8krti/comment/n55o6lm/). I’d previously completed a notable sale to this individual and had been in touch a few times between.

The individual claimed financial hardship due to a recent robbery and requested payment on delivery (he claimed to have a buyer lined up that wouldn’t make an upfront payment and assured me I’d be paid once he had the funds). I was apprehensive about this given he’s an international buyer, but it’s also common for dealers with prior relationships to agree to cash on delivery (helps manage working capital, especially with shipping delays/etc.), and I thought this would help him recover from the robbery (now I question if that was even real).

As I was leaving for an international trip myself, we agreed I’d ship the coin and he would pay by Wednesday, July 30, 2025. He assured me payment would be made, as he didn’t want to jeopardize our relationship or his reputation on the sub. I shipped via UPS as we’d done in the past, and I provided him info to make payment via all the means I can receive (Zelle, Venmo, PP, Cash App, Wire). 

On July 30, 2025, I followed up as no payment had been received. He claimed he would get the wire sent that day.

On July 31, 2025, I followed up and received no reply.

On Aug. 1, 2025, I followed up again and was told he sent the wire and would follow up with his bank about why I hadn’t received it.

I received no further communication or responses from him via Reddit after that. I then began trying to make contact via WhatsApp using the number he provided for UPS.

The coin was delivered and signed for on Aug. 3, 2025.

He finally replied on Aug. 4, 2025, claiming his wires weren’t working and he was trying to resolve the issue.

I then started hearing from other r/pmsforsale and r/coinsales members that they were also awaiting payments. I called him out on this and pressed for a straightforward response about what was happening. He proceeded to ignore my outreach until Friday, Aug. 8, 2025, when he said I should ask the mods (from pmsforsale) to pay me. In following communications, he claimed that he’s withholding payments to all sub members in retaliation for being temporarily banned and negative feedback posted about him, along with racist remarks and threats received.

As we had a business relationship prior to this, I tried repeatedly to reason with him and offered to advocate for him and try to restore his reputation if he held up his end of our deal. I’ve remained non-combative through all communications, but nothing has worked. Unfortunately, as of Aug. 15, 2025, I still haven’t received payment for the coin, despite him confirming that he had sold it to the client he bought it for. He won’t provide a reason for why he won’t pay me specifically (other than being collateral damage in his retaliation against those that seemingly wronged him in his mind) and has been entirely unresponsive since Saturday, Aug. 9, 2025.

I can’t explain why this individual has gone from a reliable buyer in the community to an apparent thief and scammer, but it’s incredibly disappointing to see. Why someone would steal from someone that they know and done business with before baffles me further, but I guess that’s why I’m not a criminal.

At this point, I recommend to all r/pmsforsale, r/coinsales, etc. users to break communications with u/errienftw999. If you have packages in route to him that you haven’t been compensated for, do all you can to have them intercepted and returned to you.

I suspect at some point he’ll try to make a new account, and he’s also known to be active in some Facebook coin/precious metals groups, so be especially mindful of anyone who reaches out to you to make a deal that's from Haifa or Shfar'am, Israel, and asking you to ship first. Google them, check socials, etc. If something looks suspect, don't move forward. I'd love to share more personal information, but that's against the law.

We can only hope this person comes to their senses and does what’s right, but there’s been no indication to me or any of the other individuals he’s withholding payments to that anything will change about this unfortunate situation.

Reddit conversation is being shared since his ghosting should be proof enough my feedback is legit, and our WhatsApp would require more redacting to protect personal information that can't be shared online. https://imgur.com/a/scammed-igKYKfu


r/PMsFeedback • • Jan 27 '26

[NEGATIVE] for u/SoepjesKoekjes [seller]

127 Upvotes

Hey all, just wanted to give everyone a heads up on this guy. Bunch of red flags, so let’s run through them together:

•Did not comment “chat” on my WTB post

•Not a member that is joined in the r/PMsforsale subreddit

•Offered to sell me 3 tubes of ASE’s at $900/each, or $2k for 3 tubes (jesus christ could you imagine that?)

•When you look up his username on reddit, 3 other posts (as of today) mention him scamming people or phishing for payment.

•Called him out and blocked immediately.

Be safe from losers like this guy who don’t have a job lol


r/PMsFeedback • • Aug 29 '26

[POSITIVE] for /u/pmsforsale [Mod Team]

123 Upvotes

I think it’s time we all take a moment to THANK our r/Pmsforsale mod team publicly for all the work and BS they have to put up with.

Having had a glimpse behind the curtain myself, I can say with absolute certainty that the number of turds they have to deal with greatly outnumbers the praise they rightfully deserve.

Are they perfect? No, of course not.
(The only perfect human is Scarlett Johansson, and I will fight you if you say otherwise.)

Could they respond to messages faster? Sometimes yes, and sometimes no. Sometimes they need time to research an issue, discuss it with all parties involved, and have an internal discussion before making a decision to ensure things are handled fairly.

Keep in mind these people have wives, kids, day jobs, dogs to walk, dirty diapers to deal with, and lives outside of Reddit, not to mention their own sales and customer issues - all while dealing with an endless stream of redditors who think their particular issue is the biggest fucking problem on the entire sub that day.

Seriously, whether you agree with every decision they make or not, keeping this place running while dealing with scammers, assholes, disputes, reports, rule violations, nuked accounts, and the general mental condition of this sub is a thankless job.

So, for once, let’s give the mods some credit.

Thanks, mods. 🍻


r/PMsFeedback • • Apr 24 '20

[Negative] for /u/NunedQ

122 Upvotes

He said he wants to meet up to sell a gold maple, because he doesn't trust Zelle since he was scammed before.

He then tried to play dumb and try to negotiate a deal over online anyway.

I had a hunch he was a scammer so I asked where he lived. I said I was in the same state and I can meet him at his local police department this weekend.

He quickly changed his position from "I want to meet in person" to "Not while there is quarantine...once it's over".

He is actually a German and I have contacted the proper authorities as well as the Bundespolizei for attempted fraud.


r/PMsFeedback • • Dec 03 '24

[NEGATIVE] for u/nickinny [Buyer]

116 Upvotes

Current Status 12/19/24: A week after this post, I sent u/nickinny a respectful message seeking resolution. He refuses to communicate with me, the original mod who offered to mediate, or even his own friends who tried to help. He finally responded to a different mod. The only resolution he was willing to agree to was returning the chain through that mod as a middleman, which he shipped today after having it since 11/23. I'll post a follow-up once the chain is returned and inspected.

At this point, u/nickinny still owes me $1,740 and still has the goods in his possession. He refused to pay the full amount he agreed to. And he's declined to send back the goods in good faith and stopped responding to communication.  

I believe the community should know how this transaction unfolded to protect future sellers. In transparency, I’ve only made 4 sales, and he’s had many transactions in r/Pmsforsale over the years. However, his past, positive transactions don’t make up for his actions here. He acted agreeably at first but later became completely uncooperative.  

Newer sellers take a risk in shipping first to trusted members of the community. And it’s expected that we will be paid promptly. In any other circumstance, when you buy something, you have to pay at the time of purchase. My trust and patience have been taken advantage of.  

Despite promising to pay the full amount within a day of receiving the chain, u/nickinny has failed to do so, made excuses for days, and ultimately threatened to keep the chain unless I accepted a return and provided a full refund.  

Because this isn’t bullion, it’s a wearable piece that he's actively worn, I didn’t want to accept a return. But since he’s unwilling to pay, one of the Mod’s offered to help mediate the return. In good faith, I agreed to the Mod’s proposal. As a middleman, the Mod would've ensured I get the chain back. And u/nickinny would’ve gotten the refund he wanted. u/nickinny declined the Mod’s proposal for the return. 

This behavior shows a complete lack of accountability and respect for sellers. Keeping an item without paying in full makes him, by definition, a thief.   

If u/nickinny ever wants to redeem himself in this community, the honorable and fair action is to follow through on the remaining balance or to return the item (if the goods are still in new condition). Doing the right thing is better late than never. 

If he decides to make things right, I will update this post and the mods.   

If any sellers have faced a similar situation, please let me know if you have any advice.  

TL;DR:  

  • I sold a new .999 solid platinum chain to u/nickinny. Agreed price: $2740. 

  • I shipped first. He promised to pay in full the day of delivery or the next. 

  • The day of delivery, he said he liked the chain and was wearing it. 

  • The next day, he paid $1,000 (36% of total cost). 

  • He made excuses for 5 days to delay payment. 

  • When I sought advice from the Mods, he flipped out, demanded a return, and threatened to keep the chain unless I accepted the return. 

  • I eventually agreed and provided return instructions and an address. 

  • Instead of providing proof of the chain’s condition, he continued stalling and asking when he’d receive a refund. 

  • A Mod offered to mediate the return as a neutral party to ensure fairness. I agreed to it. 

  • u/Nickinny declined the Mod’s offer to mediate and has since stopped responding to me. 

  • He’s now had the chain for 10 days and still owes me $1,740. 

DETAILED TIMELINE 

*For the sake of readability, I’ve only included relevant events and quotes. To show I have nothing to hide, I’ve included a link to the whole chat at the bottom. 

Friday, 11/22/24:  

9:46 AM: After he kept asking for a lower price, we finally made a deal at $2740 for the platinum chain  

I agree to ship first since I’m a new seller and he has a gold flair in the subreddit. 

9:00 AM: u/Nickinny: “I will pay you the same day or next” 

10:00 AM: u/Nickinny: “you’re kinda lucky because I actually want a platinum chain” 

He asks for certificate of authenticity from manufacturer, original box from manufacturer, and receipts which show he’s getting the chain for a discounted price and I’m not making any profit from this deal.  

I include all that. I inspect, clean, polish and pack the chain exactly how you’d get it directly from the manufacturer.  

I included a note saying thank you for putting his trust in me as a new seller, and hope he likes the chain. I also included a polishing cloth as a kind gesture. 

I stated Venmo or Paypal were the only acceptable payment methods. He makes no objections. 

1:44 PM: I ship it out insured the exact same day we made the deal. 

1:46: I sent photos of the packaging that he requested. 

Saturday, 11/23/24: 

10:34 AM: Package is delivered. 

2:36 PM: u/Nickinny: “Got it! It’s gorgeous! I’m wearing it now. Excellent packaging by the way.” 

2:43 PM: Me: “Would you be willing to pay for it today or tomorrow?” 

2:51 PM: u/Nickinny: “I can pay after I get it tested. Will try this weekend and pay Monday. I can pay $1000 today as goodwill and trust it is pure.” 

3:08 PM: I provided my Venmo info. 

9:58 PM: Me: “Hi. It’s a bit unsettling not hearing back” 

Sunday, 11/24/24: 

10:51 AM: u/Nickinny sends me $1000 via Paypal (still owes $1740). 

11:06 AM: u/Nickinny: “Take a deep breath... I need to officially test it even though every instinct tells me it’s authentic.” 

Monday, 11/25/24: 

u/Nickinny provides no updates. 

Tuesday, 11/26/24: 

12:46 AM: Me: “Hi Nick. Were you able to get it tested?” 

5:40 AM: u/Nickinny: “Not yet! Hopefully today. One way or another I’ll pay you Thursday at the latest.” 

At this point, the payment date has changed from Saturday/Sunday, to Monday, to Thursday. 

Wednesday, 11/27/24: 

6:48 PM: Me: “Hey Nick. Just checking in again. Not sure if you’d be able to get it tested on Thanksgiving” 

7:09 PM: U/Nickinny didn’t reply, but he was commenting on another seller’s post interested in another deal. https://imgur.com/a/11-27-24-7-09-pm-cpaXQ4y

At this point, I was concerned but still hopeful he was going to pay soon. 

I talked to the Mods about writing a neutral review after he does pay because of the delay 

Thursday, 11/28/24: 

5:56 AM: The Mods tell u/Nickinny: “It is the buyer’s right to test purchases, but it should be done quickly especially in ship first situations. If we understand the seller correctly, this needs to be resolved shortly.” 

7:45 AM: u/Nickinny: “I’m so sorry you’re so nervous. Let’s cancel the transaction. I will mail back your chain today. What is your address?” 

8:56 AM: u/Nickinny replies to the Mods: “I sent $1000 already to seller on same day which was almost half of the purchase price. I suspect seller did not disclose this.” 

→ This was a lie. He sent $1000 after having the chain for 24 hours. And he only paid 36% of the agreed price, not nearly half. 

8:37 AM: Me: “I want to believe that your reasons for delaying payment are genuine. Can you pay the rest by today or Friday at noon EST? It would help me not resort to writing a negative review.” 

8:57 AM: u/Nickinny tells me & the Mods that this transaction has “soured” 

8:57 AM: u/Nickinny: “I understand your first time seller but you do need to have some more patience.” 

8:57 AM: u/Nickinny asks for my address for a 2nd time 

9:06 AM: u/Nickinny: “Please leave negative feedback. It will be good for me.” 

9:18 AM: u/Nickinny asks for my address for a 3rd time 

9:45 AM: I tried to de-escalate the situation (my full response: https://imgur.com/a/11-28-24-9-45-am-yqTfUQP )

9:45 AM: Me: “You're the one who first promised to pay on the day of delivery or a day after and kept pushing it. I haven't done anything to make this transaction sour other than politely checking in about getting paid what we agreed upon... I don't feel comfortable providing my address with how you're talking to me now.” 

At this point, I didn’t want to accept a return. He’s had the chain for 6 days and wore it.  

But if I had no other choice I said: “I want to go thru a middleman for the return so I know the chain is still in new condition.” 

9:47 AM: u/Nickinny asks for my address a 4th time 

9:47 AM: u/Nickinny: “You can refund my payment less your shipping charges... I will also compensate you for any losses due to spot market fluctuations since you sent the chain.” 

10:07 AM: I told him I’m not obligated to accept a return, and he should pay what he said would. 

10:08 AM: u/Nickinny refuses to pay and tells me to accept the return 

10:08 AM: u/Nickinny: “Alternatively I would accept the chain for the $1000 sent to you already.” 

10:09 AM: Me: “That's literally less than half the cost. You're a scammer” 

10:10 AM: u/Nickinny: “I’m willing to return your chain less costs.” 

10:10 AM: u/Nickinny: “...You may think that the honorable thing will be for me to get the chain tested and pay you quickly. Perhaps. But that’s not what we are discussing...” 

At this point, I’m being forced to accept a used chain, because he has threatened to just keep the chain after only paying 36% of the cost. 

10:18 AM: I state a deduction amount including drop in spot price like he suggested, and an inconvenience fee for all the trouble I’ve gone through. 

10:19 AM: u/Nickinny refuses. He asks me to start off by showing my receipt for shipping. 

10:35 AM: I provided my receipt for shipping: $34.61. As he suggested, I showed how platinum spot price has dropped 3.58% from 11/22 to 11/28. 3.58% of $2740 = $98.09. I asked for $32 for the inconvenience. In total, I asked for $200 deducted from refund. 

No reply for the next couple of days. But he continues to post & comment in r/Pmsforsale  

Friday, 11/29/24: 

8:09 AM: The Mods told me they talked to u/Nickinny on 11/28. He will be reaching out soon about the return.  

From what the Mods told me, it sounded like u/Nickinny told them he’s completely against any deductions for spot price fluctuations.  

Keep in mind, u/Nickinny is the one who FIRST offered to pay for the reduction in spot price.  

No messages from u/Nickinny. 

Saturday, 11/30/24: 

8:19 AM: I let the Mods know u/Nickinny hasn’t reached out about a return since my last message on 11/28 at 10:35 AM. 

8:46 AM: Mods messaged u/Nickinny. 

After Mods talked to u/Nickinny again, Mods told me the only options are for him to pay the remaining amount or for me to accept the return and only deduct my shipping. 

I suspect u/Nickinny reiterated to the Mods that he's only going to return if I don’t deduct the drop in spot price (originally his suggestion). 

8:55 AM: u/Nickinny: “I will ship back to you Monday. I expect a refund of my payment less your shipping” 

10:41 AM: Me: “Fine. Pack it as securely as I did with the certificate of authenticity if you have any decency left.”  

10:41 AM: Me: “And just for the record, these were your words: ‘I will also compensate you for any losses due to spot market fluctuations since you sent the chain.’” 

u/Nickinny ignores his exact quote about deducting the difference in spot price for the return. 

10:44 AM: u/Nickinny asks for my address. 

11:23 AM: I provide a return address. 

11:38 AM: I ask for picures for proof that everything I sent is included. And I ask for the tracking number  

u/Nickinny ignores me. 

5:15 PM: u/Nickinny: “When will you send my money back?” 

At this point, I decided it would be best to wait for him to follow through with the return. He has all the return information. And I will no longer keep feeding into his stalling tactics. 

Sunday, 12/1/24: 

2:40 PM: u/Nickinny asks again about the refund. 

2:21 PM: u/Nickinny: “I am currently banned from pmsforsale because of you. You will need to work with them to get me unbanned. Part of the reset we discussed.” 

3:09 PM: I asked u/Nickinny to reflect on his actions. I explained that WE never “discussed” a “reset.” The only reason why I was accepting a return was because he threatened to keep it without paying.  

3:10 PM: u/Nickinny says I’m not complying and he’ll “be dropping off Reddit for a bit.” 

3:13 PM: Me: “So am I understanding correctly that you're not going pay and you're not going to return?” 

No response from u/Nickinny. 

3:43 PM: One of the Mods offers to mediate the return. The Mod offered to be a middleman and inspect the chain and to ensure that I provide a full refund minus shipping.  

4:16 PM: Although I didn’t want to accept a used chain, I decided to comply and messaged the Mod agreeing that I would only deduct $35 from the refund for shipping assuming the chain is in good condition. 

8:02 PM: The Mods notifies me that u/Nickinny refused the mod’s offer for the middleman return. 

Here’s the link to the entire chat. The last line of each picture is the beginning of the next, so nothing is missing. Out of respect, all personal information has been hidden. 

https://imgur.com/a/u-nickinny-full-chat-vtRYY3Y


r/PMsFeedback • • Aug 06 '25

[NEGATIVE] for /u/errienftw999 (buyer)

113 Upvotes

screenshot

Timeline:

This is my first time engaging with PMsForSale as well as my first sale as a new seller. I shipped a 1oz gold bar to u/errienftw999 in Israel. Both of us confirmed that the item was delivered on July 27. He mentioned he was on a business trip at the time but acknowledged receipt.

On July 29, he claimed to have sent a bank wire on July 28, but did not provide any receipt.

From July 30 to August 1, I followed up consistently but received no payment and no confirmation of the transfer.

On August 4, he returned from his trip and stated that his bank had not approved the transaction. I asked him to resend the payment.

As of August 5 and 6, I’ve had no further response.

I’ve confirmed with some of his previous sellers that they typically received their wire payments from him within 30 hours.

I’ve kept in touch with the Mod team, who suggested I leave negative feedback at this point.

If he responds and completes the payment, I’m happy to work with the Mods to update this post accordingly.


r/PMsFeedback • • Feb 06 '26

[NEUTRAL] for /u/elcapitanig [seller]

112 Upvotes

Monday 2/2 we agree on a ship first sale

Seller states they will ship Wednesday 2/4

Thursday 2/5 I inquire about a tracking number

Seller informs me they are no longer interested in a ship first sale and will not be sending.

Seller is new to the sub and hopefully finds their footing. No hard feelings and no negative financial impact for me but "a deal is a deal" is the backbone of this whole sub so need to call out when it is not being adhered to.

chat log: https://imgur.com/a/2mI8wYl


r/PMsFeedback • • Mar 20 '21

[EXTREMELY POSITIVE] for /u/woychowskib [A Good Samaritan]

112 Upvotes

I had a brain fart and shipped two packages to this buyer. While I was freaking out and waiting for tracking to show up for the "lost" package, he messaged me and let me know he had received the package and would ship it to the buyer for me. If he wasn't such an honorable person, he could of kept the package and I would be none the wiser. He shipped it out the next day, I repaid him for the shipping and sent him some silver as a thank you.

If this doesn't prove that we have one of the greatest communities here, with honest and nice people, I don't know what would.

Again, thank you u/woychowskib for being genuinely nice, and being so willing to help out with my mistake.


r/PMsFeedback • • Feb 01 '26

[NEGATIVE] u/Cordobra

108 Upvotes

SCAMMER ALERT. MODS PLEASE BAN AND ADD TO WATCH LIST. I posted a [WTB] and this user approached me. They did not leave a comment on my post to avoid me seeing their flair. I searched them on Reddit as their profile history was hidden and they are on multiple scammer alerts for various pages including watches. They tried to sell me ASEs at an obviously low price and I called them out and they blocked me immediately.


r/PMsFeedback • • Oct 04 '21

[Negative] for u/Dependent-candy701 (SCAMMER)

107 Upvotes

This person is apart of the famous highly coveted r/fitzgoldandsilver crew below is his very comical message to me today after getting caught stealing legitimate dealers photos and saying their his own.

https://imgur.com/gallery/3H1WxmU


r/PMsFeedback • • Feb 21 '26

[Neutral] for u/AsianGuySilver [buyer]

99 Upvotes

I've been around the sub for quite a while and never had to do this. I've always given people a chance or the benefit of the doubt. Today is different. I posted a sale and got a chat from u/AsianGuySilver he said he wanted to buy a 5oz that I listed below spot and he would pay in the morning. We live in different times zones and it was late, so I gave him the benefit of the doubt and agreed. I slept in, but I got back to him and the deal was still good. I had other interested people, but I made a deal. I gave u/AsianGuySilver my zelle and he responded with my name and he will get me paid. I never heard back from him and I went to look at the post and he deleted his chat comment. The fact that he ghosted me and deleted the chat after information was exchanged is enough for a neutral. To add insult to injury the other person interested already bought something else. So now I lost a deal cause u/AsianGuySilver wasn't mature enough to tell me he didnt have the money or he wasn't interested anymore.

https://imgur.com/a/2pdvhkL


r/PMsFeedback • • Feb 22 '26

[Negative] for u/Driverprestigious825 (Seller)

95 Upvotes

Had a similar experience with another user who got scammed recently by this seller.

Proof: https://imgur.com/a/1n6h3rt

We had agreed to trade my rayban metas for their silver eagles. They then requested if I could ship priority if they added a silver quarter. I agreed as long as they could send the eagles priority as well. I shipped my box, they never did. Kept coming up with random excuses.

Only gave me their last name for the shipping label as well. Then eventually I requested a picture of the package and come to find out they used a different name on the return address and for whatever reason decided to add Pokémon cards to the mailer, probably to make the excuse it was stolen.

Luckily a mod messaged me and let me know to intercept the package and I was able to do it in the knick of time. Thank you to the wonderful mods at r/pmsforsale for saving me on this one. Definitely beware and middleman when in doubt! I was told middle man fees for something like this are typically only 1% so very worth it!


r/PMsFeedback • • Sep 16 '21

[NEGATIVE] for /u/usmint (seller)

90 Upvotes

Seller backed out of deal 4 days after payment was sent. I even paid seller $20 extra for faster shipping. Seller cancelled 4 days after payment. Seller also refuses to issue immediate refund and says refund will take 2-4 weeks. No explanation as to why seller can no longer fulfil their end of the transaction.


r/PMsFeedback • • Jul 19 '26

[NEUTRAL] for /u/L0stT1me [Seller]

88 Upvotes

We had a trade worked out and he wanted to change it after we made a deal. I obliged and we reworked it. He then didn’t ship on Friday like he was supposed to. No big deal, stuff happens. He then told me he would ship Saturday. Again, didn’t ship. Sent me a message early Sunday morning that he got a better deal. Not a good way to do business. I’m not out any money, but my time has been wasted.

https://imgur.com/a/KHP4knu


r/PMsFeedback • • Feb 18 '26

[NEGATIVE]%20for%20/u/Sad_Stretch2713%20[buyer]

87 Upvotes

This guy bought 3 ASE and a few Canadian wildlife coins from me over a month ago. Today I noticed that he disputed the charges via Venmo. Claims that his “inspector” said that the ASEs are fake and he now wants a full refund. No mention of the other coins that he paid for but now also wants money back for. Has not offered to ship back any of the coins.

In my opinion, he’s a scammer. All of my coins are legit, he just thinks he can get away with it and get his money back. Sellers beware.

Original post: https://www.reddit.com/r/Pmsforsale/s/F1JG3g9NMr

Screenshots of chat: https://imgur.com/a/5RZTrQc

Update: https://imgur.com/a/aK5FgiC


r/PMsFeedback • • Sep 03 '25 Popcorn

[NEUTRAL] for /u/OrganizationFalse668 [seller]

85 Upvotes

I locked in a deal on 8/18. I sent the money just after midnight on Tuesday the 19th. Money and address were confirmed within the hour from both parties.

On the evening on 8/22, I asked for the shipping information. They said "not yet" maybe tomorrow.

I did not get the tracking the next day, but they made a post that night, and I reached out asking, "What gives?" He said sorry and said the package was shipped.

I got a photo of the tracking along with other buyers tracking info from a photo of a receipt from the USPS monday morning.

The coin arrived safe and sound, but it would have been nice to know it would be almost a week before being shipped and thought it was unprofessional to share others' information.

Edit: he never said sorry.

Edit #2: His personal response after I shared the logs.

https://imgur.com/a/WOQYK57

I never said I was going on vacation, but I used it as an example of a good seller.


r/PMsFeedback • • Dec 15 '24

/u/nickinny has permanently been banned from /r/pmsforsale.

84 Upvotes

/u/nickinny has permanently been banned from /r/pmsforsale.

Reason: Scammer. Full details here.

/u/nickinny has been given every opportunity and ample time to rectify the situation and has failed to do so after multiple outreaches from the r/pmsforsale mod team, individual mods, a trusted intermediary, and the seller themself.