r/PMsFeedback
•
u/spraackler
•
Aug 11 '26
[NEGATIVE] for /u/ColdWaterBottle03 [seller]
I bought an 1871 dollar from seller. He listed it as damaged and details. He had a video , but I couldn't see the damage, so I asked for some more pics. He sent them which highlighted the scratches, but I couldn't tell it was heavily polished. When I read the post I assumed details and damaged were the scratches. I didn't expect it to be polished, which is a separate thing. I couldn't really see in the video, couldn't zoom in (eyesight not what it was) We agreed on $550 for the coin.
After getting the coin and saw it super polished and very different from the pics, I reached out about a refund, and he said no, it was a details coins and he listed it as such. He disclosed the damage but not the polishing. I told him in the chat it was hard to see the damage. I reached out about fixing this before leaving this feedback, and he went ahead and tried to post negative feedback about me extorting. I was just trying to resolve this before having to write all this out.
Fixed chat log (thought I cut that off when cropping)
Pics he sent: https://imgur.com/a/zHLnXPL
Pics of coin showing polishing: https://imgur.com/a/8MwGgoD
Chat log: https://imgur.com/a/eDs528F