r/PMsFeedback • • Aug 11 '26 Popcorn

[NEGATIVE] for /u/ColdWaterBottle03 [seller]

0 Upvotes

I bought an 1871 dollar from seller. He listed it as damaged and details. He had a video , but I couldn't see the damage, so I asked for some more pics. He sent them which highlighted the scratches, but I couldn't tell it was heavily polished. When I read the post I assumed details and damaged were the scratches. I didn't expect it to be polished, which is a separate thing. I couldn't really see in the video, couldn't zoom in (eyesight not what it was) We agreed on $550 for the coin.

After getting the coin and saw it super polished and very different from the pics, I reached out about a refund, and he said no, it was a details coins and he listed it as such. He disclosed the damage but not the polishing. I told him in the chat it was hard to see the damage. I reached out about fixing this before leaving this feedback, and he went ahead and tried to post negative feedback about me extorting. I was just trying to resolve this before having to write all this out.

Fixed chat log (thought I cut that off when cropping)

OGpost: https://www.reddit.com/r/CoinSales/comments/1vdybuz/wts_new_items_daily_deal_1880o_87_vam6a_ear_gouge/ 

Pics he sent: https://imgur.com/a/zHLnXPL 

Pics of coin showing polishing: https://imgur.com/a/8MwGgoD

Chat log: https://imgur.com/a/eDs528F


r/PMsFeedback • • May 19 '25

[NEUTRAL] for /u/parabox1 [seller]

0 Upvotes

not the best at responding to communication and we did have a problem with the items that were shipped but everything was eventually made right


r/PMsFeedback • • Aug 01 '24

[NEUTRAL] for /u/ColdWaterBottle03 [seller]

0 Upvotes

Opted for risky mail, seller didn't put enough postage, envelope arrived empty and late. I wonder if enough postage was applied if it would have arrived properly to me.


r/PMsFeedback • • Jul 18 '19

[Negative] for u/JinKesef (seller)

1 Upvotes

Reneged on a deal after we agreed on payment, shipping and terms. I looked at his feedback history, considered him trustworthy, and contacted my client to let them know I'd have more GSA's for them next week.

Don't even get me started on how his wife sold them in the one hour between when he listed them and backed out... What?

Further, he refused to compensate me for his alleged selling them out from under me, so now I have to go out of pocket to go find some GSA's for my client, and I'll probably lose money just to keep them happy.

Best guess, he realized he was under wholesale and changed his mind.

I don't usually post screenshots of private messages but I feel it is appropriate this time.


r/PMsFeedback • • Oct 02 '25

[NEUTRAL] for u/Federal_Pie_9978 [seller]

0 Upvotes

I paid $370 for silver and got nothing.

First, the seller shipped my package to the wrong buyer. Package delayed for weeks. I waited until that buyer shipped it back to u/Federal_Pie_9978 who then attempted to ship it to me again… at least I assumed.

USPS tracking shows item delivered, but nothing ever came or was dropped off. USPS insurance program reimbursed $108 for the lost package.

Seller was responsive, but would not reimburse me for the loss. Personally, I would have reimbursed for the loss if I was the seller. This is just good business, and I will not buy from him ever again due to this.

I don’t think this seller is a scammer, but he’s new, and I’ve never had this problem before in about 1,000 transactions spanning many years.

Two shipping attempts to me with ZERO package received warrants neutral feedback.


r/PMsFeedback • • Aug 14 '20

[Negative] for u/xphilluciferx (seller)

1 Upvotes

We agreed upon a trade for my COVID 10oz bar for his 5g gold bar. He shipped first as he didn’t have any feedback. I asked him for the tracking info and he said he couldn’t give it to me. RED FLAG. When I received the bar it was fake. It’s the version with the comma but everything was off. He said he purchased it from an authorized dealer but could have switched the bar from its packaging. Said it was verified by a local coin dealer but I don’t believe him. Be very cautious when dealing with u/xphilluciferx . I will be blocking him with no further dealings.


r/PMsFeedback • • Jul 14 '24

[NEUTRAL] for u/Josh416

1 Upvotes

Asks for additional pictures then ghosts, at this point I’m sick of people doing it so they get neutrals going forward. Sure he’s completely good to go, but commenting for other deals just ticks me off when saying pass is very easy. I blocked him


r/PMsFeedback • • Apr 19 '22

[NEGATIVE] for /u/Mycomar [seller]

1 Upvotes

Very dishonest seller. Intentionally hid the fact that he was selling a product with damaged packaging. This was a Royal Mint 5g henna Brittania bar, The only reason for buying this high premium bar is the beautiful packaging. Well, his had sticky residue on the sleeve, and a giant ugly white sticker on the back. He didn’t show the sticker in his pictures, and he blurred out the sticky residue. He didn’t mention it in the sale post either. He didn’t mention it in his messages to me, even though I told him it was a gift for someone. By the time I got it, it was too late to get another one elsewhere, the gift was ruined I couldn’t even give it to the person, I had to try to resell it just to break even. Being the honest seller I am, I disclosed the issues with it in my post. Very disappointing transaction, if he had just been honest and forthcoming from the start, it could’ve saved me a lot of hassle, tying my money up etc. And not being able to give the gift that I was so excited to give to someone who is special to me. It’s too late now. I would avoid dealing with this seller.

Edit - FYI, the only reason I gave this guy a negative feedback, is because after Everything was said and done, we worked something out, he admitted he Should have disclosed the issues with the packaging, and said He would do so in the future. I figured it was over. So I left him a blank positive, because the last thing I wanna do is leave someone a negative. But then he turned around and left me a neutral feedback, when I had done absolutely nothing wrong. Are you freaking kidding me? You’re going to foist something on to me, waste my time, tie up my money, and then leave me a neutral? So at that point, yeah, I decided to leave him a negative


r/PMsFeedback • • May 11 '16

[Neutral] for /u/Chnkr (trade)

1 Upvotes

I sent this guy one 10 oz and three 1 oz Perth Lunar Goats for a total of 13 oz of silver in mint condition. He sent the Mercury Gold coin but the box was damaged;

http://imgur.com/jM2JSK7

In my opinion this hurts the resale value and I think I'm being reasonable when I asked him for a replacement box, which he refused.


r/PMsFeedback • • Jul 30 '25

[NEUTRAL] for /u/FuddFudge [buyer]

12 Upvotes

Really hate having to do this because the buyer is newer on the sub and was friendly enough about it, even offered to compensate me for a bad bin which wasn't necessary, but a bad bin and backing out after payment info was sent justify this review.

Buyer binned one of my lots for sale. In chat they asked for more pics of the half dollars, no issue here, I always welcome requests for additional pictures. After sending additional pics I sent my payment info. Upon realizing that the lot contained modern proof halves (this was shown in the original pictures) instead of '64 proof halves, they decided to back out of their BIN. They stated that since the half dollars were newer years, they thought they were non silver. After sending additional proof of them being silver (pic of all the rims of the coins, pic of them on the sigma) buyer still insisted on backing out.


r/PMsFeedback • • Nov 09 '20

[Negative] for u/mustang__mike (trade) deceptive piece of trash - avoid at all costs

10 Upvotes

It’s unfortunate I have to go through this and I've had to defend my standing here. I can't remain silent about this. This user is a deceptive, manipulative piece of trash. They took deceptive pictures of their listing and after I realized, they took every opportunity to attack me personally and defame me. This person is piece of garbage. Hands down dealing with this user has been the worst experience here. I truly hope that people realize, there are plenty of legitimate and honest sellers here - no one needs narcissistic trash like u/mustang__mike

just leaving the check mate move here - proof the pics i took are the coins he sent. and proof he is therefore a deceptive piece of trash His Original Pic - My Pic to Him


r/PMsFeedback • • Aug 13 '26

Buyers Feedback

0 Upvotes

r/PMsFeedback • • Sep 12 '26

[POSITIVE] for /u/L0stT1me [seller]

0 Upvotes

Super smooth transaction. So smooth I don't have much to say because everything went perfectly. Easy breezy. Fair priced, fast shipping, and all around nice guy.

Thanks!


r/PMsFeedback • • Dec 20 '18

[Neutral] for /u/snarlpill Seller

0 Upvotes

I message the seller about the lot that he had for sale he responded with that it was spoken for and I told him the sale falls through that ill take it.

A few hours later he responded with "It looks like the lot fell through so the whole lot is yours for $90 shipped if you want it! Just send the money via PayPal F&F to __________ and then shoot me your shipping info. and I will get it sent out today. ". I immediately sent the money, and he responded with "Hey there, I received your $90 but unfortunately the original guy who completely ghosted my response yesterday seriously just got online and sent the $90 literally 8 minutes before you did. So I'm very sorry but since he was the first to respond I have to go with him and refund your $90. Please let me know which email address you'd like it sent to or I will just send it to the same address that sent it. Again, very sorry bud. "

Now I get it, first come first serve but we agreed on a price, money was sent and from my perspective the item was mine.

He did refund me my money which is now sitting in pending with paypal which means I don't have it yet and that's not his fault that paypal does that but it is his fault that he doesn't seem to be able to manage his messages which is disappointing.

He has a good amount of feedback that is 100% positive so hopefully this just a fluke but I wouldn't buy from him again without the item being shipped first before payment to avoid this nonsense.


r/PMsFeedback • • Jan 09 '20

[NEGATIVE] /Gage88

4 Upvotes

Backed out on a deal. Had gold coin up for $410...he offered $400 and I accepted then didn't hear back.

During this time I had other offers but told them it was pending. Contacted /Gage88 again and he said he couldn't do the deal anymore. When contacting other interested parties back, they had already bought somewhere so I missed out.

He did respond and said sorry....but I still got a coin to.sell and lost a couple potential buyers expexting to have it sold.


r/PMsFeedback • • Jun 01 '18

[Neutral] for /u/Dynwyrm (Seller)

3 Upvotes

Made payment two nights ago (May 30th). Asked about tracking number yesterday (May 31), said he didn't want to make several trips to Post Office so he would ship today. Messaged him an hour ago asking how its looking, he said he is going to refund me because I have been messaging him too much and he feels "uncomfortable". About half the messages were for his poor math skills and errors in his listing. Lackluster communication at best.

Summary: Held my money for two days and now I am waiting on a pending transaction through Paypal until June 5th.


r/PMsFeedback • • Sep 02 '25

[NEUTRAL]%20for%20/u/Agreeable_Ad1136%20[seller]

5 Upvotes

First time ever leaving less than super positive feedback - packaging was not great, but it got here quickly. Would work with them again!


r/PMsFeedback • • Aug 11 '23

[NEGATIVE] for /u/kemsprite [SELLER]

2 Upvotes

Short version of events:u/kemsprite advertised a solid gold necklace and locket on the r/Pmsforsale subreddit. When I received the goods the necklace was hallmarked as gold filled. Kemsprite agreed to a return/refund but the whole business was unnecessarily drawn out and I did not receive a refund until 5 days after the returned items were marked as delivered to Kemsprite’s address. Just overall, not a professional person to work with, though I am not accusing them of any planned deception or dissembling.Longer version of events:7/26/2023: Kemsprite posts several gold necklaces and pendant at spot prices on the PMsForSale subreddit and I message to enquire about a specific chain and locket for sale. I confirm with them that the piece is solid 14 k gold, which they affirm. I pay the asking price via Venmo and Kemsprite mentions he has a 3 day return policy. Kemsprite ships same day and provides me with tracking number7/29/2023: I receive package and let Kemsprite know7/30/2023: I reach out to Kemsprite to let him know that I would like to return the chain and locket because upon closer inspection, the chain is hallmarked as “1/20 12 KT GF” and not as solid gold. I can find no hallmarks on the locket and I make no assumptions or assertions about the gold content of the locket. But based on the chain being misrepresented I would just prefer to return the whole thing and be refunded. Kemsprite apologizes and offers to send a replacement chain, but I decline and would prefer to proceed with the return. He agrees.7/31/2023: I mail the goods back and give Kemsprite a tracking number.8/2/2023: I check the USPS tracking and it’s not been updated through the website. So I reach out to Kemsprite with a screenshot of the USPS receipt that is date marked, has tracking number, and has expected delivery of 8/2/2023. I say I’m not sure what’s going on with the tracking but please let me know when the package is received. They confirm.8/4/2023: I check in again asking if the package has been received. Kemsprite states they haven’t been home and would tell me in the morning8/5/2023: I check the tracking and USPS says package was delivered Wednesday, 8/2/2023. I message Kemsprite and ask if he’s received. He says he received it yesterday but would not be able to refund me until Monday (8/7/2023) as he needs to go to the bank first. I express displeasure with the delay in refund since he’s now had the package for 3 days.8/6/2023: Kemsprite cannot make it to bank as they experienced severe weather in the area making the road around their house impassable.8/7/2023: Venmo refund received by me and our business is concluded.

EDIT: chat logs + original post were asked for so I'm obliging

Original Listing: https://www.reddit.com/r/Pmsforsale/comments/159tscn/wts_14k_gold_jewelry_at_5_over_spot_1972/

Specifically, i was interested in the chain + locket which is labeled as "14k gold item 5 necklace with diamond 5g asking $194.00"

Chat logs: https://imgur.com/a/YN4t75H


r/PMsFeedback • • Feb 14 '26

[NEUTRAL] for u/Straight-Ad1714

39 Upvotes

This might be my first neutral feedback. I'm not sure. I sure don't do this a lot.

Chat logs and screenshots: https://coindex.app/a/f7eI8R

I post a 2024-W ASE for sale for $120. Below that, a couple other US Mint coins for $100 each. I try to be clear about what price goes with what item. Dude posts "bin 2024 w". Screenshots are with logs.

First DM I get, is him asking "was I fast enough for the 2024 w 1oz" - clearly rushing to grab what he wanted.

We agree on shipping, agree on Venmo, I send him payment info and confirm the total to send. At that point ... he backs out, saying that he misread the price.

He is "apologetic" and tries to justify by throwing out cheaper prices elsewhere (his APMEX link was for a BU coin??) but as soon as I point out this is a rules violation, he stops responding.

After an hour, I message him again. He says he has "no malicious intent", I tell him that's not the problem, the problem is I need to know if he's going to rush too fast again and do this to someone else.

His only response was, "I wish you the best going forward man. have a good night" - and then he stopped responding.

If he BINs your post, don't be surprised if he bails and thinks "sorry" cuts it.


r/PMsFeedback • • Jun 24 '22

[NEGATIVE] for /u/Key_Cheetah_1688 [seller]

14 Upvotes

I have been buying a bit of silver from that subreddit for about a year with 0 incidents and friendly and professional interactions from people but this last bit of silver i bought so many things went wrong that could have led to lost silver.

  1. Bought 20oz of buffalos in a tube [FL to NY]

  2. Seller said he dropped package off at post office (6/19) and said that his post office is a little slow to scan packages. then 2 days later (6/21) usps marked it as "picked up package"

  3. Package arrived at my doorstep (6/24) and not the mailbox because the seller labeled the incorrect address but luckily my mailman knows my name and which apartment i live in so it did not go to the wrong person.

  4. When i opened the box all 20 of the buffalos were scattered inside the box and out of the tube because seller only used 1 flimsy piece of scotch tape to secure the lid. (Not a big deal since they are just buffalos but super irritating on top of everything else.)

Out of all my transactions with sellers on here i have never had back to back issues with either packaging or delivery. had this been someone else's first time buying silver it may have very well been lost. so far that i have to leave negative feedback. Hopefully the seller is more aware of packaging / shipping in the future.


r/PMsFeedback • • Sep 16 '16

(NEGATIVE) for /u/Silverlitecoin (wager)

1 Upvotes

Fuck this guy. see post below--

Greetings friends, This is something I would have preferred to not talk about, as I'm not really one to slander other people in the community for no reason. /u/silverlitecoin essentially forced my hand, and as a result, I will also be leaving a negative feedback in pmsfeedback as well. /u/silverlitecoin once made a spot wager for silver (I believe it was a Kilo) and ended up paying out, quite some time ago. Turns out, he decided to make another wager with /u/theshoebox. The wager was that silver had to HIT $25 per ounce BEFORE July 15th, and silverlite would win 10 oz from Shoebox. It didn't have to stay there. just hit it. If it didn't happen, shoebox would win. Once Shoebox told me about what they had set up, being the natural gambler that I am, I pmed silverlite and hopped in on the action. I participate in many of the bets around here, whether they be sports or spot bets. I like getting in on the action. Long story short, Silverlite and I modified the bet to $22 rather than $25, and somehow back to $25. At the time of the bet silver was about $15 / oz. I thought there was no way I was going to lose. Then Brexit happened. And a bunch more stuff. Before I knew it, I'm sitting in my yard on the 4th of July with an Angry Orchard in my hand refreshing the spot chart over and over when China markets opened, watching it soar up towards $20.50, then $21. Then $21.50. All the way up to just about $22. Man that I was exciting. I remember me and shoebox texting shitting our pants Haha! Was all in good fun. Well thankfully that emotional rollercoaster passed and we were about 3 market days from our bet being done and over with, and Silver was not going to hit $25. Then I get a message from Silverlitecoin wanting to back out of the bet. Where was he when silver was running past the 20's? Where was he the last 30+ days when the bet was already made? Shoebox even tried giving him an out after the first week. He refused. He wanted to bet. I explained that I wasn't really interested in backing out, and he became rather insulting. I tried to lower the bet amount and save him 5 oz but he spat in my face and said he didn't want my charity (unless I was willing to waive the entire 42 oz.... you wanted that charity though huh?). In the Imgur are the main messages we exchanged. I didn't enjoy my experience with him. Yes, he came through and paid out. However, he put me and Shoebox through a rollercoaster with his whole stunt at the end. I even said lets stick to our 10 oz bet. I don't want to make you uncomfortable. HE was the one that messaged me and said OK I'm betting this Kilo too. Of course I said yes. I considered posting a negative feedback or saying something to the community about it after the bet was over. I even discussed it with /u/AndrewNathaniel and /u/purargent. At the end of the day, I voted not to say anything to anyone, and figured he was just mad he lost silver and he didn't mean the things he was saying. I thought that would be the last I'd hear from this guy. But I had a transaction go wrong with another member here, and here comes silverlite publicly accusing of scamming the user. people wanted explanations, so I explain this here: "No problem I'll explain what he's talking about. Buyer bought silver from me. Silver was shipped. Buyer claimed there was no silver in box. I asked for photos multiple times of the box so I can look for signs of damage/tampering (I pack my silver the same way every time. I'd be able to tell.) Buyer never provided photos. Buyer proceeds to tell me he has filed a claim with his bank without even discussing options with me. I receive a notification my PP funds were reversed and being held until further notice. I provide evidence to PP of package weight and shipping confirmation. PP ruled in my favor. There's a disclosure at the bottom of every one of my WTS posts that say I offer insurance through u-pic for $1 per $100 insured and that I'm not responsible for USPS errors once the package ships. Silver lite (who had zero to do with the transaction above) is butt hurt that him and I made a bet and he lost 42oz of silver to me (he tried asking me to let him out of the bet 2 days before the date of the bet ended. We had this bet established for 30+ days) I said no. And he continued to lash out on me via PM even after I told him he could just send me 30oz instead of he 42 we originally bet. http://imgur.com/a/6x7YY I won't proceed to show what else he said to me (and it gets quite worse). All because I refused to cancel the bet. I've never had an issue in any of the transactions I've done here ($50k+). Here we have an angry kid trying to tarnish my name in the community, which is fine. I'd be pissed too if I lost 42 oz. But I don't bet what I'm not willing to lose." I'm an asshole. That I will admit. But I am not a scammer. Not in my blood. Everything I have, I've worked for, and I understand what it feels like to be scammed. So to have someone sit here and try to tarnish my reputation as a seller in this community is sickening to me. Especially since I know the real reason he is trying to get involved in a transaction that had NOTHING to do with him. He's mad about the bet. Still. I tried doing everything I could for that user. The user reversed the transaction through his bank without even giving me an opportunity to try and figure out if I can do something for him. Refused to send me photos. AND DID NOT PAY FOR INSURANCE. It's at the bottom of all of my posts people. Im not responsible if insurance isn't purchased. If you're spending several hundreds of dollars, you can afford $3-5 for insurance, especially since you are getting a discount by cutting out the large vendors at /r/pmsforsale. Companies like Apmex do cover their shipments. However, they are charging you for this service due to their higher prices. They can afford to take a loss. We at /r/pmsforsale are the little guys. Things go wrong. This is what insurance is for. You're already saving a bunch by buying through there. Just buy insurance. Shit happens. Shit goes wrong. We can't help that. Insurance is to protect YOU not US. Long story short, I fought the case, and PP ruled in my favor based on the evidence I provided. That's all I'm going to say about that. Silverlite isn't a pleasant person. He's slanderous. Disrespectful. Unappreciative. And I will never deal or bet with him ever again. Slandering the name I've built as a seller is where I draw the line. I've been respectful til now. Fuck you guy. End of rant.


r/PMsFeedback • • Jan 29 '18

[Neutral] for /u/dynwyrm (seller)

1 Upvotes

Did a deal for some slabs, he even threw in a graded Walker for free! He was easy to work with, so I decided to purchase even more items that he had listed. After that, he was extremely slow to respond and did not communicate that the shipment was delayed (the entire process took three weeks). When I opened the box, everything was packaged with care. However, I was disappointed to see that the Barber dimes that he had advertised in an album were all taken out and put into a tube. When I asked him about the discrepancy, I was met with more silence.


r/PMsFeedback • • Mar 08 '19

[Positive] for u/RobertJFClarke

1 Upvotes

Quick response to my PM. Easy to talk with. Quickly struck a deal. Shipped super quick including providing me with a tracking number. Would not hesitate to deal with again.

Note: After we had concluded our transaction, I logged on the next day to see a wee bit of drama had erupted. Although my transaction did not include any of the items in question, I suddenly felt a minor sense of dread.

My mailbox today confirmed those worries were baseless.

From what I could see in the comments, another transaction from the sellers post may have been in "bad form" but it did not strike me as against any rules. A deal should be concluded once agreed upon by both parties but the seller did state he would give preference to those that paid first.

I am always weary of any transaction where little recourse is available but I did review the sellers account and felt the risk was reasonable. Hopefully this feedback will let others know the dealer was dependable.

I certainly understand that it is incumbent upon all members of this sub to work hard to ensure this place is one where all buyers and sellers can feel confident in dealing with each other. That said, I would advise all to ratchet down the aggressive rhetoric in order to allow a fair evaluation of participants. Tough but civil will ensure a successful environment where name calling and threats will invite toxicity.


r/PMsFeedback • • Oct 16 '23

[Positive] for u/Mountain_Mud3769 (Seller)

1 Upvotes

Another amazing transaction. Exactly what was promised. Seller went above and beyond dealing with the post office.

Highly recommend, will continue buying.