First of all, the biggest plothole is that it's convenient that nobody aged in the 20 years of the movie's runtime, if Andy was 35ish at the start of his sentence he would have been super tired and weak at 55. I don't care what anyone says, it's impossible to not age. LOL
I simply cannot believe a rock could break through IRON pipes. All sewer piping installed before 1960 were made out of iron according to multiple sources online.
https://blog.envirosight.com/a-brief-history-of-pipe-materials
Smashing a rock against an iron pipe would crumble the rock to pieces before making a dent in the iron pipe.
He either had the clairvoyance necessary know to bring this magical BIG rock that is stronger than iron with him or he conveniently found one above the sewer piping.
Neither are possible or likely.
If he knew he had to bring a magical rock with him then he probably did some trial escape runs to see what obstacles he would be facing. BUT any trial runs of his escape would have been impossible to return from, since that would require jumping FROM the floor of the sewer system BACK into the hole he crawled though (an impossible feat especially since he was 55 years old at that point, despite the movie making it seem like he was frozen in time in his 30s)
or
he conveniently found this magical rock above the sewage pipes he broke though, this is even more unlikely and would have been a huge variable in his plans to depend on something being there... when a sufficiently heavy rock couldn't have conceivably been there in the first place.
There's no way he would find ANY rock in the area above the piping he broke through, that is HIGHLY improbable. There's no way there would be available rocks above the piping ready to use, that's not an area where rocks from the outside would magically get to. This magical rock would have to leap from the outside into the sewer piping, TRAVEL UPSTREAM against shit, and then penetrate the iron pipes so he could grab it. LOL
If the piping was supposedly weak enough to be easily broken by a simple rock they would have a ton of sewage and piping issues in that prison over the years and they would have been upgraded/reinforced the piping as a result the deteriorating sewer piping.
------- other observations -------
If he spent all night digging holes for 20 years, how the living hell did he get enough sleep to properly function everyday.. I'm sure everyone here is familiar with how difficult it is to function while being sleep deprived, not just physically but also cognitively, but there he is everyday completely invulnerable to the effects of sleep deprivation. Puhhh-leeze.
After gaining freedom, he also casually strolled all about town and to different banks despite inevitable breaking news coverage on tv and "wanted" signs with his mugshot plastered everywhere.. but he's cruising in his convertible without even making a MINIMUM effort to slightly modify his appearance. His mugshot would have definitely been everywhere due to the sensational nature of his escape. This was 1966, so at this point mass media and television was already in full swing, but he is just casually walking about like nobody was looking for him. Get a disguise before you cruise around your convertible at least. shave your head, get a fake beard, etc.
It's also funny to me that they magically found his mini pick axe while searching for him the next morning and immediately made the presumption that it was used in his escape instead of just some random object that could have been discarded by anyone. It seems like a stretch to automatically make that connection. For someone who supposedly hatched a meticulous prison break, it's out of character for Andy to have sloppily left behind his tool of escape.
Also he dragged a clean perfectly tailored suit through a half mile of shit and it still looked perfect when going around town?
The guards and warden still raided his room during routine searches. He was not exempt from routine searches despite winning the favor from the warden, and not once in 20 years did anyone bother to look behind the poster?
Lastly, how is Red not making up for 50 years of lost time of having sexual intimacy with women, he immediately seeks out reconnecting with his buddy he spent twenty years in prison with? Umm ok.
I love this movie but that doesn't mean there is no logic in the film that doesn't make me roll my eyes. I have to suspend a lot of disbelief watching this again many years later.
Edit: Minor Pet Peeve, stop putting damn spoilers on your movie poster
Edit: if your only explanation for gaps in the story and lapses in logic/realism is making things up that potentially happened but the movie never made clear explicitly or implicitly then you are just making shit up lol.
You can theoretically explain ANY plot hole by making shit up. Plot holes should be shut down by information contained in the film, not by information you made up to potentially explain them.
y'all are unwilling to concede undeniable facts that violate laws of nature like
They could not have prevented aging for 20 years
Andy could not have prevented physical and mental exhaustion due to sleep deprivation from digging several hours every night
He could have never found available rocks in the area above the piping to use. No rocks could have entered the piping from the outside, swam upstream against shit, and then magically penetrated the piping so he could grab them for the purpose of breaking the piping. lol wtf
I can't even expect y'all to concede on these very simple undeniable flaws in the story so why would I expect y'all to budge on anything else. I can recognize when I'm wasting my time and debating a wall that won't budge. lol ✌️