Oh man, I feel like I'm going to get downvoted a lot for this.
But, I want to start a little discussion about power creep. It's something I've seen many people complain about, and I somewhat understand why. However, I want to make this post to talk in detail about power creep, why it happens, why it causes problems, and most importantly, why it is necessary.
Please read the post before insulting me or anything. If you disagree, I'd be happy to be proven wrong.
Power creep is a process that involves making the cards in a game increasingly stronger, rendering older cards less usable over time. In extreme cases, power creep can completely change the game. The most well-known example is Yu-Gi-Oh, which today is nothing like it was originally. Even with Pokémon, many things have changed significantly due to power creep. Nowadays, any card that requires more than one turn of setup is completely unusable, and the average game involves hundreds of damage by the second turn. Special conditions such as burn or confusion are also simply useless now because the damage they cause no longer has a strong impact on the game.
One of the biggest problems with power creep is that it forces players to always get new cards to play, even in expanded formats. It's simply unrealistic to hope to have a balanced match against an opponent with a deck that's six or seven years old. Another big issue with power creep is that it makes the basic mechanics of the game increasingly negligible. In Pokémon, this translates to special conditions becoming bad as mentioned earlier, but also the energy system no longer being played in the same way, etc. Power creep means that a player who enjoyed playing 20 years ago no longer finds the same game today.
But if power creep has so many negative repercussions, why do they do it?
The most logical and predictable reason would simply be marketing. Designers put bigger numbers on the cards to make them look "cooler" and more desirable, encouraging players to want to buy them.
However, I think that's far from the only reason, or even the main reason. Let me explain.
For this, we need to ask how to balance a card game.
Imagine that each card in a game has a number that defines its power. This number takes into account the difficulty of playing the card, the negative and positive effects the card has, how situational the card is, and its potential synergy with other cards.
In a perfectly balanced game, all cards would have exactly the same power value.
In reality, of course, this is impossible for three main reasons:
Synergies between cards necessarily change a card's power as they are released, so a card's power is not constant in itself.
Game designers are simply not capable of making all cards have exactly the same power because it's just impossible.
Game designers may not necessarily want all cards to have the same power either. They generally like to give a bit more to legendary or popular Pokémon.
All these reasons mean that the power of the cards, instead of looking like this:
100 100 100 100 100 100
looks more like this:
94 102 101 98 100 84 120
In reality, this means that some cards and decks stand out and create what we call the meta.
Now, let's return to card balancing and I'll now talk about more concrete and precise things.
Imagine that designers create new cards for the new series. For now, the average cards have a power of 100 and the meta cards have a power of 140. I remind you that this difference is due to several unintentional factors. To make sure the new cards created are not unplayable, they then aim for a power of 140 for their cards. Gradually, the average cards have a power of 140 but again, the developers will have made mistakes and will accidentally create cards with a power of 160, and the new meta is now at 160. Power creep has been created.
We can observe this in the current meta with Charizard. It's a simply overpowered Pokémon with 330 HP and can charge itself with energy. They did it simply because they wanted to make a card capable of competing with Gardevoir, which they had made to compete with Lugia, which they had made to compete with Mew VMAX, etc.
Power creep is simply necessary to catch up with their past balancing mistakes. Currently, without it, we would still be in a meta dominated by Lost Zone... That's also why the vast majority of printed cards are very weak and almost unplayable. Designers don't want to take many risks to avoid accelerating power creep and ending up like Yu-Gi-Oh.
Now the responses I see coming and to which I will directly respond:
"There is rotation for cards older than 3 years, power creep is not necessary."
Yes, rotation reduces the necessity of power creep and slows it down, but having a format dominated by one archetype for 3 years is not ideal either...
"They can ban cards that are too powerful instead of trying to print others."
Yes, but banning cards too often can be annoying for all players who buy cards. Moreover, the game aims to be accessible and having banned cards makes deckbuilding more complex because it adds restrictions that are not printed on the cards and require external documentation.