r/piratesofthrones • • Apr 15 '15

About episode's 4 ending...

Post image
219 Upvotes

r/piratesofthrones • • Apr 14 '15

Every Spoiler EVER...and more ;) The future of this sub...

207 Upvotes

Hello Everyone! I know some of you have asked about the future on this sub, and this is what I plan on doing. I think we are going to make this sub a safe haven for everyone, both show fans and book fans. But, I hope there is still people who would be willing come to this subreddit after the leaks. Furthermore, I plan on having as little as rules as possible, as to not become like the other subs. Also, I think this sub would not explicitly promote piracy, but rather acceptable of it. So, this would be a sub where you guys have the say, and we mods are just here to keep it running. We are the free folk of reddit! haha....

Also, please share any ideas that you may have about what to do!


r/piratesofthrones • • Apr 14 '15

That R + L = J Setup Doe

179 Upvotes

I interpreted the scene with Sansa and Littlefinger at Lyanna's tomb as a total setup for the R + L = J reveal, or at least one of the first major hints.

I see no other reason for us to be talking about Rhaegar, Lyanna, and the Tourney at Harrenhal. This needs to be fresh in people's minds if they want the reveal to feel natural and make sense.


r/piratesofthrones • • Apr 14 '15

Everything about Dorne is a total train wreck.

160 Upvotes

Okay, I guess not everything. Doran seems pretty cool based on that one scene, and the scenery in Sunspear is surely amazing. Areo Hotah is cool enough.

But my gods, those sandsnakes. These have to be the most cringey, campy characters on the show now. Everything about them is just over the top and ridiculous. Just imagine if all eight of them made the show. And Ellaria's character seems to have been ruined as well.

Not to mention the whole Jaime mess. Why does he have to go to Dorne again? He keeps saying that he's not trying to start a war, but literally everything he's done now has been an act of aggression against the Martells and Sands. I mean, aren't the Lannisters supposed to be pretty intelligent? Why would they just immediately take the bait?

All of this would have made perfect sense if the show just skipped the sandsnakes and kept the far more important Arianne Martell - a character's whose personality is actually believable and interesting within the show. At the very least let Ellaria take up her role as she's doing now, just without her annoying daughters. And instead of making Jaime go to Dorne, just send Bronn alone, letting him take the place of Balon Swann and a little bit of Arys Oakheart. That frees up Jaime to go to the Riverlands, where there is still an unresolved plot point with the Blackfish, Edmure, and the stuff that was never cleared up after the end of Season 3.


r/piratesofthrones • • Apr 14 '15

Stannis and Shireen.

153 Upvotes

I felt that this scene was an instant classic as far as smaller scenes go, up there with Oberyn's "I will be you champion" speech, and Jaime and Brienne's bathtub scenes. It was very poignant and showed us a side of Stannis we haven't scene before in an extremely effective way. Anyone else agree?


r/piratesofthrones • • Apr 12 '15

Its official lads, we are the wildlings! Haha, we aren't inside the 'wall' that is r/gameofthrones...

122 Upvotes

Here is what the /r/gameofthrones mods had to say, We are not stopping people from visiting your subreddit or from pirating in general, but /r/gameofthrones[1] does not participate in what we call "active" piracy, meaning asking for or providing the means of piracy is prohibited. Linking to /r/priatesofthrones[2] is the same as linking to thepiratebay in that they are both just repositories for links/streams/other means of piracy, therefore neither is permitted here. We don't condone downloading or watching the leaked episodes for all the reasons stated in our official post on the matter, and linking to your subreddit would send a contradictory message. Feel free to build your subreddit via some other means, but you won't be allowed to advertise it on /r/gameofthrones[3] .


r/piratesofthrones • • Apr 27 '15

FUCKING LOL.

Thumbnail
reddit.com
119 Upvotes

r/piratesofthrones • • Apr 12 '15

Links for the leaked episodes... (Not torrents)

115 Upvotes

*If you want the torrents check out kickass torrents..

E01- http://jheberg.net/download/gameofthroness05e01webripxvid-fum/

E02 http://jheberg.net/download/gameofthroness05e02webripxvid-fum/

E03- http://jheberg.net/download/gameofthroness05e03webripxvid-fum-2/

E04-http://jheberg.net/download/gameofthroness05e04webripxvid-fum/

Go to MEGA that is the fastest, and try to get an adblock...Also I'll add more links to 720p or newer episodes when available


r/piratesofthrones • • Apr 13 '15

Ser Barristan

101 Upvotes

Really?? really...?? REALLY?! Ser Barristan the fucking bold beaten by like 5 greasy slavers? These guys have next to no combat experience. Barristan could cut down like 100 of these worthless nobodies. Wtf HBO. Doesn't help that is the first and probably last time we ever see him in a real fight.


r/piratesofthrones • • Apr 13 '15

I got banned from /r/gameofthrones for linking to this sub, be warned.

96 Upvotes

Yeah, it's bullshit. In an attempt to provide a link to an appropriate place to discuss episodes, as to avoid spoiling the official sub, I was banned. Because we all know the high sparrows over at the official sub haven't watched a single episode of s5 /s.

God forbid HBO look down upon that particular subreddit. All men must die r/gameofthrones. Your hypocrisy has been noted.


r/piratesofthrones • • Apr 13 '15

Discussion Threads for Episode 1-4

94 Upvotes

I think there are a lot of /r/gameofthrones fans who want to discuss the Show only without stuff from the books.

If you want to talk about, or include information from only the TV Show, please check out these threads:

If you want to talk about, or include information from the books or other sources, please check out these threads:

-Creds to /u/cgmcnama


r/piratesofthrones • • Apr 20 '15

So who else is looking forward to the sequel to the "Only Cat" Meltdown next week on /r/asoiaf?

90 Upvotes

I refer of course to the omission of "Ed, fetch me a block" in favor of "Ollie, get my sword".


r/piratesofthrones • • Apr 28 '15

ASOIAF Mods doing the Censorship thing again

88 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/asoiaf/comments/342xoe/spoilers_aired_i_call_for_the_ban_of_umilitant/

1000+ upvotes and deleted as of this morning. I can't be the only one who just unsubscribed.

We can still get to Bryndon Bfish's blog via google, after all.


r/piratesofthrones • • Apr 26 '15

Official "Olly, get my sword" popcorn thread

84 Upvotes

If "your sister" was any indication, we're in for a legendary meltdown tonight over on /r/asoiaf.

I love that sub to bits, but the purist mentatlity gets on my nerves. "They changed one line? Oh gods, no! Let's tip somethin' over!"

This thread is a place where we can laugh about what's happening in the other threads, and post/link the best bits. Let's have fun tonight, guys!


r/piratesofthrones • • Apr 13 '15

The Nod

Thumbnail
imgur.com
84 Upvotes

r/piratesofthrones • • Apr 12 '15

[Season 5 Spoilers] Post-Episode Discussion - 5.4 "The Sons of the Harpy"

82 Upvotes

Post-Episode Discussion Thread

Discuss your reactions to the episode with perspective. Talk about the latest plot twist or secret reveal. Discuss an actor who is totally nailing their part (or not). Point out details that you noticed that others may have missed. In general, what did you think about the last episode and where the story is going?


r/piratesofthrones • • Apr 20 '15

A collected summary of all that we know about Episode 5 and beyond so far!

78 Upvotes

Note: This post will look into all the details that I was able to find for the remaining 6 episodes in order to discuss how we think the season will progress. If you do not want to be spoiled for anything, even though it's just speculation, it has a high chance of coming true, and thus you are strongly advised to read no further.

Anyways, here are all the things we know about.

Episode names/directors/writers/brief speculation on the episodes we know about:

Episode 5: Kill the Boy

  • Episode 5 is probably named after the line by Aemon Targaryen to Jon Snow: "Kill the boy, and let the man be born". It is also interesting that these are the last words that Aemon says to Jon in the books.

  • Directed by: Jeremy Podeswa

  • Written by: Bryan Cogman

Episode 6: Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken

  • This episode probably has Dorne as its major plot-line, as is evident from the Martell words being the title of the episode.

  • Directed by: Jeremy Podeswa

  • Written by: Bryan Cogman

Episode 7: The Gift

  • There might be two reasons for this title: 1: The Gift is a plot of land south of The Wall. 2: Arya delivers "the gift of mercy" to Meryn Trant.

  • Directed by: Miguel Sapochnik

  • Written by: D&D

Other details we know:

  • there will be a battle taking place in Hardhome, which is a wildling village beyond The Wall. Apparently, there will be wights there, and, on IMDB, the actor who played the awesome Night King is set to return, so there will be Others too. Also, in the weapons promo that HBO had released, we see stuntmen practicing with what looks like an ice sword (at I think around 0:18, I'm not sure since I haven't watched that in a few months), so we can probably assume there's going to be humans vs Others action. Very cool. Also, we have had confirmation that the Battle of Hardhome will take place in Episode 8, and the actual battle itself will be 17 minutes long.

  • the actors playing Theon, Sansa, and Ramsay all said that there was a scene they were all involved in close the middle of the season (so probably episodes 5, 6 or 7) that was extremely unpleasant to film, and will likely make many viewers very angry. Alfie Allen said that it was very important that he be able to convey the horrors of the scene through his face. (although Sophie Turner gave it a 6/10 on the RW scale). I don't know for sure, but I recall reading somewhere that it might be written by Bryan Cogman, so we can probably expect it in either Episode 5 or 6. Maybe it's their first post-marriage scene?

  • in the trailers, we see Stannis's camp on fire. Also, we see Brienne in snow. I am assuming this means that their paths cross. Also, actors from the north storyline have said that there will be a scene with Melisandre that is very shocking, and Liam Cunningham said that the conclusion of events with Stannis this season "will be extraordinary". Hype! (but I also fear for Stannis' death :( )

  • Daznakh's pit looks like it is going to be adapted, and is going to be on a huge scale. It involves Tyrion, Jorah, Daario, Dany, Hizdahr, Missandei, and the Sons of the Harpies. The producers said that Daznakh's pit and Hardhome were the two hardest to film but grandest sequences that they have ever shot on the show (in terms of the amount of time it took them to film).

  • Sophie Turner said that, while Sansa is a prisoner, she is going to be more in control of her situation

  • Alfie Allen (Theon) said that he has a very emotional scene with a tree this season. This is probably the adaptation of the Heart Tree scene in ADWD. Could this be after the traumatic scene they keep talking about?

  • Dany has yet to give her "I will break the wheel" monologue.

  • Missandei is seen kissing Grey Worm during the trailers, so maybe he lives? Although it may be a death-bed kiss. Also, Barristan is not present in any future shots after episode 4, but I highly believe that he might have at least one more conversation with Dany, since there must be a reason why they just didn't get him killed outright in Episode 4's skirmish.

  • there's supposed to be a very important fight that takes place in Dorne this season around the middle of the season. It was filmed close to the beach, which was closed off for around 3 days I think. It is probably either in episode 5 and episode 6. It should also be noted that Bronn is supposed to have a private moment with one of the Sand Snakes (or someone Dornish, can't recall who), and Jaime is seen entering a Dornish palace in the trailer. Therefore, I doubt that either die in it.

  • There are three shots of Jorah fighting in a fighting pit (not the one used for Daznakh's Pit), so maybe he is made a pit fighter for some time?

  • There's a Ramsay scene with Myranda, as seen many times in the trailers.

  • There's a scene where Tyrion sees Drogon flying. Looks amazing!

  • The cool shot of the dragon breathing fire into the camera hasn't been used in the show yet. Could it be an adaptation of the Quentyn scene from the books (maybe without Quentyn)?

  • There's a Stannis scene with him strategising against the Boltons with Davos and Mel.

  • The High Sparrow says "You are the few; we are the many" at some point in time. He also talks about the "gods demanding justice".

  • There's a scene with spears pointed at Ellaria.

  • Sophie Turner said that this was "the peak" season for her character. Expect exciting things!

  • There are supposed to be three weddings this season. Margaery and Tommen, done. Dany and Hizdahr? Sansa and Ramsay?

  • The final scene of the season takes place in the books too.

  • According to recapped.com, which is usually accurate, Sam and Gilly have sex in episode 6.

  • There's supposed to be a funeral at the wall, judging from the promos. Aemon's?

  • There's supposed to be a scene with Dany inspecting the gladiators from the fighting pit.

  • Cersei has her Walk of Shame. For anyone who wants more details on the walk, WOTW has a comprehensive summary here (FUTURE SPOILERS): http://watchersonthewall.com/littlefinger-returns-kings-landing/

  • David Nutter (the director of The Rains of Castamere) is directing episodes 9 and 10.

  • On her travels, Brienne meets an elderly woman, who serves as her "ally in dangerous territory". Appears for a few episodes.

  • There's a scene between Doran, Ellaria and Jaime in Episode 9.

  • Littlefinger and Olenna have a conversation in a brothel.

Ok, that's all that comes to mind at the moment folks!

So, what do you guys think of what we know about so far? Season looking good? What else do you speculate will happen? Please feel free to add anything that I might have missed!


r/piratesofthrones • • Apr 13 '15

Edd, don't fetch me a block.

78 Upvotes

Why are they purposely leaving out the most fan lauded catch phrases? I'm doing a reread of AGOT, and D&D took nearly every single line of dialogue directly from the book. This season, they don't have a whole lot of book to go off of so you'd think they'd use the most iconic ones that they could.

EDD, FETCH ME A FUCKING BLOCK!

I swear they are doing this to grief the "YOUR SISTER" crowd. That's something that would have gone over so well with people I think. The Stannis look was good but I could have gone with a little bit more affirmation.

Please tell me you are as pissed as me.

edit: punctuation, clarification


r/piratesofthrones • • Apr 12 '15

ASOIAF sub is the whiniest place ever.

Thumbnail
imgur.com
76 Upvotes

puzzled history nine slap groovy overconfident alleged hard-to-find unpack elastic

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact


r/piratesofthrones • • Apr 19 '15

The Winds of Winter cover revealed!

Post image
75 Upvotes

r/piratesofthrones • • Apr 14 '15

Barristan Selmy (Spoilers show)

74 Upvotes

Did they really just write in Barristan's death in episode 4? Everyone knows that Barristan is the greatest fighter in Westeros according to the books. Ned Stark and Jaimie Lannister (with both hands), claimed he is the one man they would never fight. As well as the books saying that he has won more duels than anyone in the seven kingdoms. Not to mention this quote,

"The commander of the City Watch himself confronted me, emboldened by my empty scabbard, but he had only three men with him and I still had my knife." - Barristan Selmy

Did D&D really just make him die to a few masked rebels in Mereen? That's a disgrace, and a god damned shame.


r/piratesofthrones • • Apr 16 '15

Littlefinger is not an idiot, ya'll need to let the man scheme.

72 Upvotes

EDIT: Seems I need to preface this for a lot of people (surprisingly). Littlefinger is a liar. Like, he lies a lot. It's basically his favorite thing. I'm not sure we've seen him tell a truth yet on the show (maybe "your sister"). So since we know he likes to lie all the time, why are we suddenly thinking that what he told Sansa about his plans for her is true?

I've posted this theory in a number of places but I felt it needed its own thread. So much LF hate in this sub, it's time to set the record straight on the Lord Protector of the Vale. So here goes:

Baelish sees opportunity everywhere, and the more chaos the more opportunities. We learned that season 1. The Red Wedding gave him a huge opportunity. The North is in disarray, out a King and under the control of the most hated Boltons. Winter is coming and it looks bleak. Littlefinger reaches out to them and makes them a deal. He already has his plan to take control of the Vale in motion, but now he has a chance to get the North too. He tells the lords of the North that he can rescue the last remaining living Stark and deliver her to them. In exchange he wants an alliance between North and Vale.

Then, he rescues Sansa while also ensuring problems between Lannister and Tyrell (I'm sure this upcoming trip to KL will be to further push that hatred). While Sansa is in his care, he works daily on getting her to appreciate and care for him. He needs her to love him (not necessarily romantically, just care about him and feel allegiance to him). He also needs her to eventually be capable of ruling, so he starts teaching her the game.

He then delivers her to her home (and future seat), just in time to watch the two largest threats to his plan (Stannis and Bolton) go to war with each other and wipe each other's forces out. Then the Northern Conspirators can make their move, overthrow whichever side was victorious, and establish Sansa as Queen in the North, with her close ally and mentor Petyr Baelish in control of the Vale. They marry creating a powerful and secure kingdom.

Kings Landing will be in disarray by the fighting between Lannister and Tyrell, Dorne doesn't care about the North. The Ironborn seem to have vanished. The only threat would be Dany, but I'm sure LF has something in his back pocket to deal with her.


So, that's what I think LF is up to. He didn't leave Sansa alone with dangerous people and a shitty plan to ally with someone who will most definitely execute him anyway. He has plenty of his Northern conspirators in place to keep Sansa (relatively) safe until the time is right to revolt.

I want his plan to succeed so badly, but I think Theon is gonna fuck it up when he "rescues" Sansa. Why is it always the eunuchs fucking things up for Littlefinger?

TLDR: Littlefinger hopes Bolton and Barathean will destroy each other's armies, making way for a Northern uprising which establishes Sansa as Queen in the North.

EDIT:

"But Roose will clearly betray Littlefinger and use Sansa for his own gain!"

Who cares? Littlefinger doesn't care about what Roose's long term goals are, as long as he values Sansa enough to keep her alive for the time being. He obviously does.


"Why doesn't he just wait with Sansa in his possession until after the fighting and the Northern revolt?"

This one is more difficult to explain, but perhaps the other conspirators needed proof of Petyr's loyalty to the cause. Maybe they needed to see Sansa first hand to agree to his plan. But there's another possible reason. Littlefinger, for reasons not yet revealed, needs to go to Kings Landing (perhaps to further escalate the Tyrell/Lannister hostilities). He can't very well bring Sansa with him, and stashing her anywhere will be risky. One person he knows will keep her in place is Roose, since Roose can't very well leave Winterfell right now, and he needs to keep his eye on his new prize. So as weird as it sounds, in Roose's possession is the next best thing to Littlefinger's own. Of course, all of this could backfire since it doesn't account for Ramsey's crazy. Maybe LF actually did underestimate his cruelty. Maybe he overestimated Roose's ability to control his son. That we shall see.


r/piratesofthrones • • Apr 15 '15

Just discovered this subreddit and I have a question/statement:

72 Upvotes

I really hope the activity and discussion will continue here even long after everyone else catches up to the 4th episode and starts discussing it on the other major GoT subs. I enjoy the discussion and banter on display here and would like to see it continue. What are you guys' thoughts on how things will play out here?


r/piratesofthrones • • Apr 21 '15

Tyrion will meet and speak with Dany before Daznak

71 Upvotes

So I was rewatching the second trailer and I have no idea if someone else discovered this but there's a really short shot of Tyrion's face in the trailer and judging from the background it seems like he's in the Great Pyramid in Dany's throne room. What's more, the lighting of that scene matches the one with Dany giving the "I will break the wheel" speech, so I think we now also know the context of that speech, it's her meeting Tyrion for the first time, there's really no other alternative. Why would she even think of Westeros when she's already having enough problems with the Sons of the Harpy. Here are the screenshots of both scenes: Tyrion: http://i.imgur.com/uxVbbzX.jpg Daenerys (wheel speech) : http://i.imgur.com/Hxu2whT.jpg


r/piratesofthrones • • Apr 18 '15

[Spoilers All] Why I am disappointed with the coming Sparrows-Loras storyline

70 Upvotes

The show very clearly seems to be heading down a path where Loras will stand trial for 'crime' of being gay, possibly serving as the replacement for the pending book-trial of Margaery. Leaving aside the myriad implications this course would have in the realpolitik-driven world of ASOIAF - that the show will probably, and annoyingly ignore completely - I feel this strips the whole Sparrows storyline of deeper meaning and the powerful message GRRM was trying to tell.

Compared to the books, the Sparrows are deprived of their motivation for coming to King's Landing. In the books it's repeatedly emphasised that the Sparrows are largely desperate people from the Riverlands, who have lost quite literally everything they had. Their homes were burnt, their lands pillaged, their harvests and stores seized, and parents, siblings, or spouses killed in a war that wasn't theirs. And to top it all off, even some of their septs were despoiled and destroyed.

The message is clear to me. When the lords of the realm play at war from behind castle walls, real people bear the brunt of the pain. And that when people are desperate, and they have nothing left, they will seek solace in religious fervour, placing their last shreds of hope in the idea that all this iniquity is a trial of their faith by the Gods. It's very poignant, and it’s one of the things that sets ASOIAF apart from traditional high fantasy tales, where war is glorious.

In the show, there is very little of this. While the High Sparrow is introduced ministering to the needy, later the focus of the rise of the Sparrows becomes a more traditional form of fire and brimstone. They want temperance, prostitutes and unbelievers out of the city, and for the deviant homosexuals to get what the Gods have planned for them right quick. And rather than it being a mass movement from all parts of the smallfolk, the Sparrows are seemingly just a bunch of jacked-up thugs who want to fuck stuff up. It’s Westerosi ISIS, basically. The moral D&D seem to be imparting to the audience will be that bigots are going to bigot, and that when given an inch, religious thugs will be more thuggish than pious.

It’s not that the latter message isn’t important. But it’s also something we’ve been viewing and reading about for decades. It’s an easy story to tell. And while I'm overjoyed that our culture has advanced so far that even in a fantasy tale about knights and dragons the makers are going out of their way to introduce a gay-positive subplot, it’s also not really the deeper message of the books.

There is still time for this to be repaired, and all will be forgiven from my side. I really hope that the High Sparrow gets Septon Meribalds speech from AFFC. Some of the most hauntingly tragic writing GRRM has done throughout the entire series. It would go a long way to give some poignancy and deeper meaning to the subplot, with in only a few minutes of screen time.

TL;DR The double-D’s seem to be dumbing down the Sparrows plot from a profound message about the iniquity and evils of war for the common man, to a simple parable about empowering religious whackjobs.

Anyone with me on this?