r/piratesofthecaribbean • • Feb 08 '24

DISCUSSION I disagree that POTC can't exist without Captain Jack Sparrow.

0 Upvotes

We've all seen a bunch of news lately, that Disney wants to make a POTC movie with a female lead, and a lot of people state in response to this, that there's no Pirates without Johnny. Now, I obviously adore Johnny Depp as Captain Jack Sparrow, and I'd take him over any other potential lead character, but I think it's a bit unfair to say that the franchise can't exist without him. The movies have created a rich world with so many interesting concepts and fun characters, and I reckon that there is plenty of potential for new stories in this setting.

To sum up: I'd rather we have POTC movies with Johnny Depp, whilst we still can, but I'm not opposed to the idea of new stories with new characters in the world of the POTC, when Johnny retires from acting.


r/piratesofthecaribbean • • Feb 15 '24

DISCUSSION I don’t see enough people talking about how Norrington tried to marry Elizabeth, when he was like 30 and she was like 12 Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/piratesofthecaribbean • • Feb 15 '25

QUESTION If Davey Jones told Jack his debt will be settled if he let him smash him would Jack agree on that?

0 Upvotes

Will Jack give up his bussy to Jones if it meant settling his debt with him?


r/piratesofthecaribbean • • Mar 15 '25

REVIEW My apologies "Dead Man's Chest"

2 Upvotes

So... I've just re-watched the fifth movie (Dead Men Tell No Tales) for the thousandth time and I'm afraid I'm going to have to change my top movies in the franchise again.

It currently looks like this:

  1. OST

  2. AWE

  3. TCOTBP

  4. DMC

  5. DMTNT

One day DMC (4th) took the place of DMTNT (5th)... and I think it will happen again.

A thousand apologies, DMC... Welcome back to the 5th position. DMTNT, welcome back to the 4th position.


r/piratesofthecaribbean • • Jul 11 '20

During a rewatch my friend and I agreed we could pinpoint when the movies lost the plot

Post image
32 Upvotes

r/piratesofthecaribbean • • Oct 12 '25

DISCUSSION The last movie is sooo good Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Idk what the general consensus was on the last movie when it released but after watching it omg does it SLAP! Salazar is cool and don't even get me started on Barbossas last line like this shit is CINEMA!


r/piratesofthecaribbean • • Mar 12 '25

THE CURSE OF THE BLACK PEARL Norrington

0 Upvotes

I am rewatching the movies for the first time in a LONG time (shame on me!) And I have to say… I feel Norrington (first movie only) Like the pirates are major criminals, ofc he is antagonising them AS HE SHOULD! and in the first movie? I think he is hot. BUT: Why would someone want to marry a girl you met when she was 11 and you were a full grown adult! :‘( man what in the p3dophilia


r/piratesofthecaribbean • • Nov 10 '23

IMAGE Quem quer ver as minhas criações em Inteligência Artificial sobre Piratas 6?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/piratesofthecaribbean • • Oct 15 '25

AT WORLD’S END So Will just killed a bunch of people to make a trail for Beckett?

0 Upvotes

Literally ended innocent lives just to leave a trace? Why is no one talking about that? That's serial killer type sht


r/piratesofthecaribbean • • Sep 04 '26

DISCUSSION DMTNT is a great standalone movie - not part of the POTC franchise.

0 Upvotes

Everything off about Dead Men Tell No Tales is apparent only when it’s compared to the previous 4 movies (especially the trilogy). Yes, it’s retcon but is it a terrible piece of cinema with awful dialogue? No, not really. People make it out as if it were insanely bad but I think that’s because they focus on how different everything is from the rest of the movies instead of taking it for what it is.

I tried rewatching it with the mindset of it being a completely alternate universe and found it to be compelling in its own way.

Jack Sparrow is not Jack Sparrow anymore but he’s still a darn good pirate and funny fellow. I will say, I couldn’t help but feel that Johnny wasn’t convinced by Jack in this movie either… he was sort of playing the playing of Jack Sparrow, if that makes. He was probably not feeling it with Disney turning awful.

I love this rumour that Johnny is asking for “upwards of $40 million” to come back for POTC 6. He deserves all that and more after Disney’s embarrassing behaviour toward him during his court cases.

Take what you can,

give nothing back!🏴‍☠️

The best innuendos are usually played out between Jack Sparrow and someone else but in this movie, they were between the youngest additions! Henry and Carina with the “port and stern” dialogue.

Henry Turner is convincing as the son of Elizabeth and Will Turner. His motives for breaking Jack out of prison mirror how Will broke Jack out of prison to rescue Elizabeth from Barbossa.

The Barbossa and Carina connection was made convincing not because of the screenwriters but the convincing acting of both Kaya Scondelario and Geoffrey Rush.

Javier Bardem playing Salazar is convincing too although as someone pointed out on this sub, pirates killed his family so his villain arc is a bit contrived given the circumstances.

The Red Coats in this movie were the least interesting in the whole franchise. Corny lines and no real threat to the pirates — just the comedic elements of the first scene were engaging: the Red Coat’s wife found mingling with Jack in the bank vault.

Kevin McNally as Joshamee Gibbs is consistently excellent, he’s irreplaceable. 🏆

Many more points to be made but the main point is: ON ITS OWN, it’s a pretty good movie. It may ever be better than On Stranger Tides (I found the relationship between Anjelica and Blackbeard to be assumed and rushed through without enough contextualization to really make it believable or even interesting to begin with, for example).

Would love to know if others agree/disagree!
Can we start to see this movie in a new light almost a decade after it’s release (2017)?


r/piratesofthecaribbean • • May 10 '25

QUESTION Aye Captain...

Post image
0 Upvotes

Who would this character be if writers added him to a new POTC film?


r/piratesofthecaribbean • • Jun 17 '23

DISCUSSION Does Elizabeth really deserve all the epic moments she easily gets? Spoiler

4 Upvotes

Watched the trilogy when I was young and wanted to give it a re-watch after like 10 years. Just the first three movies, I've heard bad things about the rest. So I'm pretty much diving in like a newbie. Elizabeth as a character, her motivations and her way of handling problems is well written.

In the climax of the first one, she literally would've just watched jack get killed if not will stepping in. And from the second movie onwards, I feel she's written to use a little too much of her sex appeal like charming and deceiving jack is her biggest highlight moment and on top of that her subtle emotional cheating with Jack (of which poor Elizabeth-obsessed Will gets a glimpse of) doesn't really persuade me to empathize with her motivations. Yeah, kiss was just a bait to take advantage of Jack. But given that she was supposed to be a woman who was about to be married, I think she had fair amount of explaining to do to will 😆. Which she confirms she didn't in the third movie. And then comes the third installment and a new kisser found, Ex fiance norrington 🤣. Another issue that sticks out to me is... sometimes she just gets handed important stuff without any effort on her part to deserve them. Like when she was made King, why? Like literally why? I tried to rewind the already convoluted af plot in my mind and all of those selfish ass decisions she made in part 2 and 1 made it hard to watch her being rewarded kingship.

When you look at Elizabeth as a sum of all of this shit, I couldn't help but cringe at her last speech to encourage the pirates to fight. Like i couldn't take that seriously at all. I feel like Will, for all the shit he has gone through up until that point, deserved to give that speech. I guess in the grand scheme of things, none of my nitpicky points should seem this egregious or stand out cuz literally everybody in the series has their own selfish motivations and the insane amount of twists that result from those selfish ass decisions they'all make. But Elizabeth just stands out so much to me because of.....Will. He's a little too chivalrous and sweet for a (suprisingly super liberal) upper class white lady. And I guess Elizabeth's carefree and reckless decision-making in part 2 and 3 that doesn't involve Will or the crew contrasts a little too much with Will's selfless nature. Like I've lost count on how many times Will literally bids on his life (sometimes even literally) to save Elizabeth throughout the trilogy which is why Elizabeth's actions leave me more bittersweet than the other selfish clowns of the cast.

I get that there's nothing wrong in Elizabeth being just that, a character that's intentionally written to be so morally grey adventurous while not caring about who gets hurt in the process by her actions and all but in that case the writers should at least make effort to make that clear yknow? As in they don't endorse or glorify Elizabeth's character but just let her be. Which is how Captain Jack sparrow is portrayed.

Anyways, what do y'all think?


r/piratesofthecaribbean • • Sep 29 '24

DISCUSSION My ranking of the movies, what's yours?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I know I am going to get some hate for mine but I can't help it.


r/piratesofthecaribbean • • 22h ago

ART Anyone here familiar with the comic book heroine character, Vampirella? NSFW

Post image
9 Upvotes

Based on a dream I had back in 2018.

Credit goes to Corbis2.


r/piratesofthecaribbean • • Dec 21 '22

META ‘Be civil, be kind’ says the mods… because of what exactly?

0 Upvotes

Oh that’s right, ‘Margot Robbie hate’ and ‘Johnny Depp trolling’ or in other words, thinking that Margot shouldn’t take over from Johnny, AN OPINION!

Are we not allowed opinions anymore? Or are we as long as they suit the feminist agenda?

We’re only allowed to post if we think that Margot should be the new lead of the franchise, and if we think she shouldn’t we need to Be Kind! Honestly I can’t believe more people aren’t talking about this, it’s a ridiculous statement from the mods, was this discussed? How could an entire mod team come to that conclusion? Or was it just u/starmapleleaf doing something off their own back? u/rocksunic u/jimiv1 u/POTCMod u/TheDidact118 u/CAPTAIN_Jack-Sparrow please provide answers!

I have rarely seen hateful comments regarding Margot personally, people just don’t want her in the franchise, the same way some people do, without discussion and the choice for opinion what is the point of this subreddit existing, shame on you mods, shame on you.


r/piratesofthecaribbean • • Aug 15 '24

DISCUSSION World's ends final battle still disappoints me.

13 Upvotes

You had multiple pirate ships and East India ones and yet all we get is a 1v1...come on disney wtf! We could have had an epic full scale fleet battle! Wasted opportunity right there and it still hurts to think what we could have had!


r/piratesofthecaribbean • • Feb 24 '25

DISCUSSION After recent marvel flop, how much does Disney need Johnny Depp?

0 Upvotes

Flop after flop from Disney, ESPN not doing so hot either. Looking forward to possibly seeing Depp in P6, its gaurenteed to make money and I think that even though Depp is reluctant to work with the rat again he would be willing to do it for his fans at this point.


r/piratesofthecaribbean • • 22d ago

DISCUSSION This Movie Is Underrapreciated

Post image
0 Upvotes

I understand the criticisms that Jack just became a cartoon and it lacks all the traditional backstabbing of a Pirates movie.

However, as an actual film, it’s far better made and more involving than On Stranger Tides.

If you actually view both movies as actual separate films rather than just part of the series I think this one is vastly superior.


r/piratesofthecaribbean • • Nov 09 '24

DISCUSSION Am I the only one shipping these two ol' chaps together?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/piratesofthecaribbean • • Jan 24 '24

DISCUSSION Will Orlando Bloom come back for pirates 6?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/piratesofthecaribbean • • May 28 '23

DISCUSSION Unpopular opinion: We need a film thats a direct sequel to at worlds end that decanonizes 4 and 5

6 Upvotes

r/piratesofthecaribbean • • Mar 23 '25

FAN CONTENT Awesome FAN MADE Pirates 6 looks more promising than the real one

Thumbnail
indiegogo.com
0 Upvotes

It’s great and all that Disney’s in the process of making Pirates 6 but I just feel that it’s really only being made for the money because of the brand name. But this FAN FILM “Secrets of the Lamp” looks EXTREMELY impressive for not just a Pirates of the Caribbean fan film, but for all fan films in general. The cinematography, set design, costumes, cast, and more look super top notch and highly ambitious for a small scale film. The campaign is ending soon but I think that contributing your support for this fan film will be more worth it in some ways than a movie ticket to the real Pirates 6.

I think the project looks promising and has so much potential 🔥


r/piratesofthecaribbean • • Sep 10 '24

QUESTION What key was (Captain) Jack referring to?

0 Upvotes

In the third installment “At World’s End”, (Captain) Jack and Davy Jones duel on the mast of The Flying Dutchman. During their duel, (Captain) Jack says, “I already have the key!” to which Davy Jones responds with, “No you don’t, haha.” The last sentence said by (Captain) Jack is, “Oh that key.” and the duel continues. What key was (Captain) Jack referring to? It just popped in my mind when I was taking a shower, and I haven’t been able to figure it out. Any ideas?


r/piratesofthecaribbean • • 3d ago

DISCUSSION As an INFP male, I relate with Davy Jones so much

0 Upvotes

I mean, I ain't no tentacle beard captain.

But his personality is something I can relate with.

He 'worships' the idea of someone;Calypso with all his heart. He would do anything for her until he realizes he got dumped.

I also worship the idea of someone I hold dear. Friends, acquaintances. I do things for them until I realize they aren't what I THOUGHT them to be.

Then I get disappointed and hurt a LOT. Although I don't bind them in curse.

Davy respects integrity and bravery even in resentment. James norrington and that namelss guy who would 'take his chance'.

Which I relate with too.

The last thing I like is someone who is opportunistic manipulator. Like Jack Sparrow.

Even to those whom I hate, I actually respect those with integrity.

And most important of all, he is quite passive most of the time and only pours ALL his energy on something that depends on his code/morality.

Like chasing Jack to the end of the world. NOT just because he hates him, but because of the deal. It justifies his hatred.

I also tend to walk away from people I resent, but when given a 'justifications' based on my morality, I go apeshit and try to rip them apart. Honestly, sometimes I am kinda glad when someone I resent crosses my morality code because that is the prime motivator for me.

Remember how Davy screamed 'you will NOT forestall my judgement!!' ?

Yep, that's how I explode my energy and resentment towards someone. I justify it with morality. So when I tear someone apart, I try to make it as 'judgement'.

And of course, playing cruel 'games' with someone I hate. Davy plays with Will and Elizabeth by the end of the fight with 'love'

He makes Bill whip Will. Cruelty without any pragmatic motivations.

Exactly how I operate when I get a chance to play with my resented ones. I hurt them with methods that will definitely hurt me.

I bring up every single emotional insecurity the other guy has and rub it in his face because fuck him. I even humiliate someone I resent bringing up his family and loved ones because FUCK him.

Davy just going 'huhuhuh' when Jack threatening to stab the heart is also something I relate with.

When motivated by my 'justification', no amount of pressure can do jack shit.

However, let's talk about the toxic, pathetic sides of him I also relate with.

He sulks playing organs, I sulk listening to music and reliving my wounds.

He is passive most of the time and lets himself get manipulated, which I also do all the time. Because until I see a clear 'justifications' to wreck shit, I am just passive as hell.

I also say too much info to let the other guy manipulate me, like Davy telling shits about Calypso;the wants to get understood EVEN by enemies is very very strong.

This guy is a typical INFP.