Material available in the internet referenced in this post:
Foreword
This text is a collection of interpretations that I (random fan) put together with the purpose of structuring my own understanding of the topic, and of trying to informally entertain the idea that Syd Barrett might have been a victim of abuse, specifically due to being a neurodivergent individual. With this out of the way...
Baby lemonade
Syd Barrett (6 January 1946 – 7 July 2006) was the original front man of Pink Floyd until a few years after their first album, "The piper at the gates of dawn". The controversies of the story of how Syd would be excluded from the band in 1969 are old news to many people. Understanding what went on, though, might involve considering the group dynamics and the psychological profiles of all of the band members, and not only Syd's, which is rarely what we find when we read stories of that time.
Waters, for example. People who knew Waters would often attribute to him qualities that are commonly attributed to people with obsessive compulsive disorders. I’m not saying that he was obsessive compulsive, I’m not a doctor, nor I got to know him personally. My vague impressions as a fan are all I have to offer, besides, hopefully more meaningful, the way this story rings to me, and hopefully to people that had a life experience similar to mine.
Gilmour, another key character in the story, is a much more sociable individual, who seems to have been kind of dragged into his position in the band, back when he got into the Floyd.
Wright seemed to be a more relaxed person, but maybe not conscious enough to prevent the idea of becoming the next Beatles going up his head. Mason was likely less relaxed and less conscious than Wright.
Syd's mother and sister were probably scared with Syd going so deep into the psychedelic scene, and wanted to rescue him.
The definition of Autism has been reformulated in recent years. Syd seemed to be introverted, maybe in the autistic spectrum, but the way we define it today. He also was known to have committed drug abuse with LSD by the time of the facts, which could increase communication problems.
As is likely to happen when one interprets history from interviews, I might be misinterpreting or projecting. Still, this interpretation seems not only appealing, but plausible and coherent with the interviews linked above, to me, by the time I had access to that material, and as I write this post.
"Pink Floyd The Story Of Wish You Were Here" movie
There they were, Waters and Gilmour, giving interviews about the beginnings of the band, and that's when they tell the Syd Barret story. I just couldn't help but feel that Waters and Gilmour seemed to be uncomfortable with the topic. Their interview oozes a bit a feeling as if there were maybe something off.
Although I came to find years later that some people are of the opinion that "the straight Pinks sacked psychedelic Syd" (meaning the other band members took ownership of Syd's visionary work), most people nowadays spread the old official story (in which Syd would have had permanent narcotics damage, and that the other band members are survivor heroes that had to deal with the trauma) – A story that is heavily biased towards an outdated understanding of mental illness, a narrative that was largely fueled by Waters, Gilmour, Mason and Wright. A story that now – half a century later – is being re-flavoured by attributing Syd with revisionist labels such as schizophrenia, old definitions of autism, depression, etc. I believe this story needs revision, but in the opposite direction.
Pulse
I got in touch with Pink Floyd's music, image, and ideas when I was a teen, in the nineties. For many people of my generation, the Pulse version of Pink Floyd is what we saw first. The grandiose. The lack of a face. We didn't know who the musicians were. It could be session musicians and hired lyrics writers, for all we could see and hear.
The band name "Pink Floyd" came from Syd's idea to put two Blues musicians names together: Pink Anderson and Floyd Council. It still sounds like a person's name, so people would ask "which one is Pink", referring to which one of the band members would be called Pink Floyd. Waters immortalized this in his "Have a Cigar" lyrics. One might ask "who is Pink?", though, in the sense of wanting to know where are the psychedelic and radical freedom ideas coming from, if all the post-Syd band members seem to be anything but inclined to that, and dedicated their whole careers to preach against those very ideas that brought them to the spotlight in the first place.
The Pulse's and The Wall's message against the system have an evident controversy on the fact that Pink Floyd represents a rebellion against the system and criticizes the industry while that post-Syd version of Pink Floyd exists first and foremost as a product for the market. That makes it impossible for their message to be committed with an honest vision of a new world, as once was the case. The post-Syd Pink's scope is to sell tickets, albums, and merchandise by trying to fulfill Syd Barret's promise. His work and success, being in the right place at the right time, getting the attention from the Beatles and so on. The band used to have different ambitions when it started, someone who was looking inwards first and not only outwards. It was Syd.
The band used to have a brain from which the ideas and values that I connected with came. Ideas that were simplified and processed to fit within Waters and Gilmour level of consciousness and vision of the world. Those original ideas are still being echoed in that less original version of Pink Floyd and attracting listeners searching for counter-culture ideas to this day.
The 2001 Dave Gilmour interview
In the 2001 Dave Gilmour interview, Gilmour says that the very members of the band don't agree on when Syd would have gone mad. This seems to point out that he didn't really "go mad" after one LSD weekend as some people imply.
Gilmour says in this interview that (bolds are mine) "the fame they [Syd] had was enticing", that "most people including myself had a certain jealousy of what a bright light Syd appeared to be", giving a clearer image of the motivations behind the abuses they seem to have committed at the time.
At the same time, Gilmour talks in this interview about the Pink Floyd before he himself joined it in a very dismissive way, saying Waters and Mason were rather pedestrian musicians by then, giving us a glimpse of a not so healthy dynamic of competition in the group.
Hey ho, huff the Talbot
(Octopus - Song by Syd Barrett)
The image of Syd that Pink Floyd created and sold – the story that Syd had too much LSD and became disabled – was pushed through many interviews, movies, and albums, and reached many people. It's the official story, per say. In suspicion of this version of the facts, some people, like me, think the other band members might have gaslit Syd in a moment of weakness in order to unfairly take over the band and its contract with EMI.
I also believe that it's more likely the breakup of the band that sparked a crisis in Syd's life, rather than Syd's personal situation being ultimately disruptive in the group.
The two interviews with Barrett that I link to in this post are on YouTube for free, and the Rolling Stone magazine transcription linked above is accessible for free as well. Those interviews seem to reveal a Syd that was painfully aware of what was going on.
You're rocking towards the red and yellow mane of a stallion horse
(No Good Trying - Song by Syd Barrett)
It was in 1969 when the breakup took place. Pink Floyd had different tours that year. An interview Syd gave to the Rolling Stone magazine gives us insight to what was happening at that point in Syd's head.
Syd seemed to be impressed by Hendrix. That's suggested by the interview Syd gave to the Rolling Stone magazine (bolds are mine): “Hendrix was a perfect guitarist. And that’s all I wanted to do as a kid. Play a guitar properly and jump around. But too many people got in the way. It’s always been too slow for me. Playing. The pace of things. I mean, I’m a fast sprinter. The trouble was, after playing in the group for a few months, I couldn’t reach that point.”
There was a time when Jimi Hendrix was the main act in a package tour with Pink Floyd, when Syd was still in the group. Syd didn't have access to proper music education. He's very intuitive in the way he composes his melodies. What happens when a person takes hallucinogens and goes to do gigs is that you get very exposed, very vulnerable, you often need to be looked after.
Syd got super impressed with the virtuosity of Jimi playing the guitar. Both Jimi and Syd were self-taught musicians who invented their ways into performing, and that's what makes them so original. But although they both played the guitar and composed lyrics, Jimi's approach was much more heavily based on expressing deep emotions through his guitar virtuosity and virility, while Syd's approach leaned more on using his big imagination to create contemplative atmospheres through progressive harmony developments, his poetry and his deep relationship to the English language. It's a bit of a futile exercise to compare them, it's like comparing apples and oranges. Or fire and the night. What I mean is that they were very different beasts, even if they were both contemporary legendary rock band lead guitar players from the psychedelic scene.
Suddenly being faced with Hendrix’s musical style depth was clearly, by the interview quoted above, a shock that made Syd rethink his own guitar playing, and perhaps also his foremanship in the group.
You can hear the jams and "freak outs" Pink Floyd did in the mid-sixties, like Astronomy Domine. They would often have this type of uneducated sound, with distortion and a lot of attitude. But Waters and Mason didn't particularly have extensive music education, so the concerts were more focused on effects and atmospheres than on the music in a traditional sense. Young people hanging around, drinking, or trying drugs, in local concerts after university classes. This style went well with the idea to play for video projections in live performances, as they did at the beginning. Their music would explore the projected video. I imagine in this kind of set up Syd could be high and explore the deepest experiences without caring for other people's eyeballs staring at him.
Gilmour (who was a language student) and Wright (architecture student) were different, in which they had a bit more extensive formal music education, and had support from their families to do so.
And Syd, although rooted in that type of simplistic artsy rock, was different in that he had a huge brute talent that allowed him to create universes through the composition of harmonies and rhythms intuitively, flowing from the poetry that would be laid out in very personal melodies. David Bowie said Syd was a poet in a rock band.
Jimi, on another hand, learned the guitar as a child and as a teenager was already playing in professional groups like Little Richard, King Curtis and the Isley Brothers. He then proceeds to reinvent rock and the instrument, but coming from a background where he had made a name by improvising solos that express the harmony and so much more, performing with pro musicians.
It's possible that, after being confronted with Jimi's musical and instrumental mastery, Syd starts to try to change his own solos. In interviews, the other members of the group complain of different things about Syd. Syd would hold the same note for a long time in his solo, and it would sound weird. This is one thing Jimi did very well (holding a guitar note through a surprisingly long time and making it sound amazing). But that worked for Hendrix's setlist songs, that had specific drum beats very different from Mason's. One could think Syd was simply trying to reproduce that effect, learning live on stage.
At the same time, Syd is super high, and is likely undergoing all those feelings of questioning his convictions for being the front man of the band that was sharing stage with Hendrix, and was attracting the attention of the Beatles and taking a totally different dimension. Stakes were higher.
The difference in the audience reaction to a live performance of Hendrix compared to the one of Pink Floyd is imaginable, so when people went to talk to Syd in the gig, he must have sound off in the conversations. Jimi nicknames him "laughing Syd", to make fun of how dead serious he looked.
Having to face this problem in the concerts, plus seeing the front man of the band lose his conviction, let's say for the sake of the argument that Waters decides to replace Syd. It's documented that Waters pressures the managers Jenners and King to exclude Syd, and starts to gaslight Syd in band meetings. It would seem this idea found resonance among the less expressive band members, such as Mason. Perhaps Waters with his inflated ego was pushing everyone around so much that people didn't realize that what they were doing was immoral. It probably seemed like the responsible thing to do, business first.
What if the story had unrolled in a different way? The band would have given Syd some time off, looked after him. Then they would investigate ways in which they could work with Syd. Instead of discarding the whole LSD subject as a taboo subject, the band could have surrounded and supported Syd, as I imagine the Beatles did with John Lennon when he was taking big doses of LSD in 65. Of course the Beatles were already a confirmed hit by 65, and Pink had everything to prove by 67, so it's not a completely fair comparison.
It's a shame if the encounter between Syd and Jimi was really so traumatic to Syd, because Jimi seemed to appreciate Pink Floyd, and said in 1970 that "Pink Floyd are the mad scientists of this day and age". And also “They’re doing like a different type of music. They’re doing more kind of a space thing. Technically, they are getting electronics and all this. They do like a space kind of thing, like an inner space. Sometimes you have to lay back by yourself and appreciate them.”
The caterpillar hood won't cover the head of you
(No Good Trying - Song by Syd Barrett)
Now you have, on one side, Syd, emotionally exhausted from the daily acid trips and the harsh concert experiences. He would take LSD in the morning, and be too mentally tired to be able to go up stage at night sometimes, what was interpreted as him being unstable, and understandably must have annoyed his bandmates.
It's likely he believed that the LSD would make him more apt to deal with that situation. That to be more in contact with his inner self would release him from the constraints of the super-ego, and allow him to be his true self as a person and as an artist.
On the other side, we have the other band members, not equipped as people to even understand that situation, even less to deal with it in a way we could deem appropriate today.
People that are interested in psychedelia might be surprised to find that the post-Syd Pink Floyd treats psychedelia as a taboo subject. This seems to be the reason why.
I always wondered how it could be that someone would really get fried on LSD like Waters, Wright, Gilmour (and Syd's family reportedly) say Syd did. The interviews I had access to seemed to show that that's just not what happened at the time. He seemed emotionally struck and maybe needed to gather the troops and reorganize. But nobody would listen, under the pretense that the opportunity was too great to miss.
Waters was frustrated with not managing to steer the group in a different direction and wanted more control over the band. He called Gilmour, someone he felt was more in line with the type of music production Waters wanted to follow, I imagine, resilient besides being arguably a skilled musician. They played a few gigs with Syd to make sure Gilmour learned Syd's part, and when everything seemed right, then they erased Syd. They don't have the decency to tell him. They just don't fetch him for the concert as they were supposed to. They act like he had never existed, it's not important to them, clearly, to talk to him, or to stop the concerts.
Five concerts were played with Syd and Gilmour together (as stated by Dave in the 2001 Dave Gilmour interview). Just five. That's the length of the experience Gilmour had with Syd's said madness. Among hundreds of gigs that had taken them to the point where they were.
This right there is a blow, even more for a vulnerable person. There's nothing else they want from Syd. He's weak, they could easily get him out of the way. Misunderstood, bullied, emotionally exhausted and about to have his own image destroyed for the next decades to come by the people that were supposed to be his friends, without any money, Syd would have then retired to his mother's house.
The news must have come as a surprise to Syd, the guy who composed most of the songs of the only album the band had up until that point, the guy who created the band name. But because he wouldn't impose himself on others because of his emotional state and his beliefs, he was intimidated and basically jedi-tricked into forgetting his own authorial work. "Jedi-tricked", because it probably didn't feel natural to continue performing under the given conditions. And he was trapped into gifting the other band members his legacy.
Syd's mother, Winifred Barrett, and sister, Rosemary Breen, would then shield Syd from the world. Rosemary's interview from 2009 is insightful, and clearly sets a distinction between schizophrenia and Syd's case: "With schizophrenia it can be helped or controlled with the use of drugs which benefit enormously. But with someone like Syd, and like a lot of people, their brains just work in a different way and it's perfectly acceptable".
But back to when they ooops, forgot to fetch Syd for the gig, Waters and the rest of the old group didn’t bother to have news from Syd until years after. One day in 75 Barrett drops by at the Abbey Road studio while they are recording the Wish You Were Here album, and he has his eyebrows shaved, and head shaved, and looks like he has 200 kilos. There’s that famous photo.
Then Waters and Gilmour say they cried. How wouldn’t they. They had to feel the responsibility, even if they didn't know how to help him. Because they could have just not helped, but what they did was they adopted a patronizing attitude that repulsed Syd, then in a psycho move deprived Syd from his own work. Then they used the band's notoriety against Syd's public and private image, spreading the word that he had become a lunatic.
It's wicked if they made huge careers based on the fact that they took ownership of Syd's conquests and used it to voice their version of the story of how they did it.
Free as a bird on the wing
(Bob Dylan blues - Song by Syd Barrett)
Syd’s solo career has three albums. The first album is called "The Madcap Laughs". The second is called "Barrett". The third album, "Opel", is more of a collection of previously released songs.
As mentioned, thanks to Syd, Pink Floyd had obtained a contract with EMI/Abbey Road. Syd's Pink Floyd had been granted access to unlimited studio hours, as mentioned in Tobby Manning's book. Unfortunately, without Pink Floyd, Syd had very limited resources. If it's in you gives a sense of the precarity of not being able to cut a track and start again while recording. I had never seen an album where you can actually hear the artist complaining that he can't cut the track and start again, it's the first time I see this.
When asked, in an interview, about why they left those embarrassing parts in Syd's album, Waters, who was supposedly "helping" Syd to record the album, said that maybe they did that because they wanted to punish him. Well, besides punishing him, they were also leaving evidence of bullying and gaslighting.
Syd had the songs of "The Madcap Laughs" recorded in four or less attempts each, some songs on the first attempt. The album title came from Gilmour misunderstanding the lyrics "the mad cat laughs". To me it seems this alternate version of the title misheard by Gilmour might have sounded so appealing because it works as a sardonic take on the rumor that Syd had become a lunatic.
The second album has a little bit more production, but it’s clear that he didn’t have the means to have musicians and producer around him for very long, although he clearly had the goods. Some songs from the solo career are solid gold (octopus, long gone, wined and dined, no good trying, dominoes, etc). Those songs have progressive developments that we would never find at the Pink Floyd without Syd.
The "progressive" term used to refer to the music of that time was still being coined. Another band to share the new connotation of the adjective was Jethro Tull. While with Tull the progressiveness came from instrumental ideas, in the old Floyd, the progressiveness (not obvious, non-symmetrical form) came from the lyrics.
The third album was released later with songs recorded previously, with the support of the old band members. Most songs in this album had already been released. Syd wanted to use two songs recorded in the Pink Floyd times, but were vetoed by the old band members. I can't help but imagine that they might have vetoed those two songs because they might have reused those song ideas in future songs, or that they just weren't satisfied with their own performances.
Today it’s Pink Floyd who owns the rights of Syd’s songs, even the ones from the solo career.
And they also own the official version of the story, in which Syd gets “erratic” or something along those lines. This could be the lie they had to tell themselves in order to continue to be able to pose as admirable people while they were enjoying the fruits of the conquests of a missing person that wasn't missing. Syd still seemed to be the same unconventional guy who wrote Bicycle, even if he was going through substance abuse by the time. The schizophrenia stigma by then was even more misunderstood than today.
When asked for examples of Syd's schizophrenia, the story that "Barrett slowly detuned his guitar" was often used in interviews as if it was the ultimate evidence that he had gone crazy. But the band members knew that Syd was known for detuning his guitar for psychedelic effect in the concerts with Pink Floyd at the event called UFO in 1967, according to Toby Mannings book.
Guy Pratt (bass from Astronomy Domine) in an interview for the "Pink Floyd The Story Of Wish You Were Here" movie, highlights the character differences between Syd and the rest of the group, as in Mason, Wright, Gilmour and Waters being a bit snobs, which also makes me think that Syd was super sensitive and just couldn't cope with the bullshit that was being handed to him by his entourage, on many different levels.
Pink Floyd will sermonize him on the lyrics "Well you wore out your welcome with random precision”. Then they go and use Syd as a character in their movie, and then again in the "Wish you were here" album. Besides the bad taste (embodying a conservative role to constrict a radical freedom message in the middle of the psychedelic revolution), this is evidence of how the original message of belief in living in faith and being one's authentic true self was hijacked and overridden by a message of belief in living in fear and forcing the conservative "order" through imposed control.
The album name "Dark side of the moon" implies that Syd was the bright side of the moon, and that there was an equivalent side that simply wasn't being illuminated. The album name "Eclipse" implies the idea that the non-Syd-Floyds would eclipse Syd. Why are they using Syd again and again? Because Syd is rock and roll, and it’s probably the only rock and roll thing they ever came across. They couldn't possibly write rock lyrics about their squash playing lives, or at best it would be songs about how they became comfortably numb. They were in direct competition with Syd, and Syd didn't get into their game, it wasn't in him.
In a way, Waters wounded the counterculture deeply when he started inciting the producers and the other band members to take Syd out of the project. Because in not accepting Syd, and spreading the message that Syd couldn't be accepted, they are attacking what Syd represents.
True, Syd couldn't cope with the busy agenda they were being forced to follow. Not while taking acid in gig days. But there are other ways to deal with this situation. Syd should have been preserved, not excluded. Cared for, given time to. But most importantly, his conquests belonged to him for a reason, and to deprive him of that was wrong. When the Beatles faced the situation of John Lennon taking big doses of LSD in 65, the other Beatles didn't just exclude him and leave him behind, which seems to me like a good example of how people with more integrity would act.
Later, after they got rid of Syd, the old band would very soon find out that they themselves could not keep up with the hours they were demanding Syd to do. After the first album without Syd, the band took months of vacation. A few years later, they would themselves perform unsatisfactorily and see years without concerts at times. A less frenetic rhythm would be installed. And the media access to them was also restricted. In theory, all those things could have helped Syd to keep up his creative work a few years earlier when, instead, he would run across his old group acting as if he had been dumped.
In 71, when Waters writes "the lunatic is in my head", although he says it was inspired by Syd's experience, it sounds to me like Waters was actually expressing a personal feeling about himself being the lunatic, who created this whole mental breakdown story to cover up for his luxury for taking over Syd's career.
But back to 1969 where we were, when Waters sensed the opportunity to take over the contract Syd had gotten for the band. A legend had been born. Right at that period in 69 when so much of today's music was being defined. The next many years to come, the new band called Pink Floyd would try to transform the popularity of that legend, the money and contract the old band had acquired, into something new. An echo of an idea (of belief in honest creativity and full commitment to a vision of how the world could be) that had been abandoned by the new band. If Syd Barrett's Pink Floyd core dynamics was content flowing from his genius and defining the form of the songs, the post-Syd band would be primarily defined by concerns with the form (appearance / atmosphere), and with content being relegated to a filling-up/padding purpose.
Syd’s short solo career, that spanned for a few years after he was excluded from the band, has plenty of compositions that show his creative genius in melodies that have his personality. Those signature melodies and his vision and musical persona are present in Pink Floyd’s post-Syd (like the similarities between Dominoes and Welcome to the machine and have a cigar) and will live forever.
The progressiveness and free flow that Pink Floyd had with Syd will appear again in Syd's solo career. But not in the new band that took the Pink Floyd name.
The ideas that started with Syd, to transform how concerts were made in the sixties, were taken ahead, but the outcome was to transform their concerts into Disneyland-like night-time amusement parks. The only thread linking them to counterculture being that fragile umbilical cord that link them to Syd.
With the huge amount of money that was being invested in their image, brilliant influences like Hockney's artwork for the covers is terrific. But that would have happened had Syd been there to continue his work. Or something else. Nobody knows. My guess is that Pink Floyd would sound a bit like Robert Wyatt's solo work. Wyatt, the drummer who played on some of Syd's solo albums. I highly recommend that anyone who likes Syd Barrett’s work to check Robert Wyatt if you haven’t already.
By the time Waters, Mason, Wright and Gilmour decide to erase Syd in 69, the biggest value the band had was by far Syd’s vision. The poetry, the message of freedom, the faith in good, the subversion of conventionalism. Even if there were other band formations before Pink Floyd under the names Sigma 6 and Tea Set, that were a pre-Syd band, it was Syd that made it Pink Floyd, it was thanks to Syd that the Floyd won the public interest, from 65 to 68.
In 1968, Waters, backed by Mason and Wright, replaced Syd when they thought was best, and if it was for Waters, Mason and Wright, they wouldn’t have even checked how Syd was years after in 1975.
All I think is that all involved people underperformed in a way or another in that situation, when looking at it in hindsight. In this anachronism, Waters, Wright, Mason and then Gilmour, by looking at their own petty interests and fears at the time, would have acted as backstabbers.
It is said that once Syd was buying candies in a supermarket, and dropped everything on the floor and ran away when he saw Waters. Maybe he was running from a bully.
Just a hot take on the topic, hope you enjoyed the gathering of links and stories. The rest of you, ice-cream'scuse me for the controversy.
Disclaimer
This is not a post from an expert on the subject. I’m also not a doctor nor have a psychology degree. I don't have access to restricted or secret information, nor was I there or knew any of the involved people personally. This text is a collection of interpretations that I put together with the purpose of structuring my own understanding of the topic, and of trying to informally entertain the idea that Syd might have been a victim of abuse, specifically due to being a neurodivergent individual. It's all speculation. This text is meant to be honest and written in good faith and to serve as another brick in the wall of the great Pink Floyd mythology if anything.
Afterword
This post, written for the general public in the internet, was a great opportunity for me to get to know how this whole internet thing actually works. Being a teenager in the nineties (early millennial), I was still educated in the world before the internet. Back then, people took pride in differentiating from the "cattle" by reading a bit. There was a general understanding that the masses were ignorant. Anybody who took the time to break up with common sense and propose a different way to see something would take pride in being different. Nowadays the general internet user is weaponized to defend ideas everyone is used with, feels like justice to do their best to exterminate non-common-sense ideas by anonymously voting down and leaving angry comments that just state old moldy ideas like if they were reinventing the wheel. Someone went like "hey, you wrote 69 instead of 68, I'm not buying any of this crap". Or "Jimi didn't open for Pink, it was the other way around, I don't even want to debate you" (I'm paraphrasing), as if it changed anything about the jist of this text, when it really doesn't. As if it justified to discard the whole interpretation proposed as being imbecilic: that's what the general person wants to do in the first place, as fast as they can, reduce the brain usage, and put their anger out there. My turn to vent. I'm not saying my text is not wrong. I'm just saying the interpretation I propose here can be useful to someone as it is to me. I suppose the way the internet works is one of the boosting reasons why the world is going extreme right wing nowadays. Conservative ideas are easy, warm and welcoming. As usual, feast on them in the comments' sections here and everywhere. Have you got it yet?