r/physicsdrama • u/MaoGo • 5d ago
Peter Woit comment on Yang-Mills publicity stunt
r/physicsdrama • u/MaoGo • Feb 04 '26
Not much has changed from previous post 3 months ago, but the sub is advancing and I wanted to update the pinned post. Here is the description of the sub
---
Welcome everybody. This sub is an experiment. The idea is to post here every PHYSICS (or astronomy) news posts that are not about a discovery itself but about problems with some physics celebrity. It is also a place to discuss and rant about public physicists.
What this sub is NOT for:
Drama about chemists, biologists or any non-scientific academics (mathematicians can be accepted sometimes)
Discussing physics or your own scientific work or self-theories
Drama about non publicly known physicists
Criticizing academia and science
Promoting the work of non-professional physicists (they need to have a PhD and published papers)
Politics of science spending or scientific politics
Promoting pseudoscience
Reddit drama
Discuss how a subject is taught
If you want to contribute please consider to:
Use specific and descriptive titles (clickbaity titles are not allowed even if it’s the original title)
Be clear about WHO are you talking about
It is great we got to 500 members. Let's see how far this experiment goes.
r/physicsdrama • u/MaoGo • 5d ago
r/physicsdrama • u/MaoGo • 5d ago
r/physicsdrama • u/MaoGo • 6d ago
r/physicsdrama • u/MaoGo • Oct 15 '26
r/physicsdrama • u/MaoGo • Sep 15 '26
r/physicsdrama • u/MaoGo • Sep 08 '26
r/physicsdrama • u/MaoGo • Sep 01 '26
r/physicsdrama • u/MaoGo • Aug 08 '26
r/physicsdrama • u/MaoGo • Jul 09 '26
r/physicsdrama • u/MaoGo • Jun 30 '26
r/physicsdrama • u/Interesting_Fold_485 • Jun 25 '26
Original Paper (Microsoft): Interferometric single-shot parity measurement in InAs–Al hybrid devices
Henry Legg's Original Rebuttal: Comment on “Interferometric single-shot parity measurement in InAs–Al hybrid devices”, Microsoft Quantum, Nature 638, 651–655 (2025)
Matters Arising (Henry Legg): On the robustness of topological gap detection via transport
Response to Matters Arising (Microsoft): Microsoft Quantum's Response
Henry Legg has been Microsoft Quantum's biggest critic since they first claimed to have observed the requisite conditions for Majorana fermions in superconducting nanowires. His arXiv rebuttal demonstrated that the computational methods used to determine the presence of a superconducting gap were highly flawed (overly sensitive to data ranges/resolutions). Still, Microsoft continued to back their claim.
Earlier this month, Microsoft announced the Majorana 2 while still having no concrete evidence to refute Henry Legg's claims. Here's the interesting part: Henry Legg submitted his Matters Arising article to nature on March 27, 2025. It took over a year for Nature's publishers to release it, but this is fairly normal for Matters Arising. Still, for such high profile research, it seems like it would have been prudent for Nature to release the comments earlier. Perhaps a even a few months earlier.
In his Matters Arising article, Legg argues that the transport data demonstrates an "abundance of of low-energy states" which confound the existence of Majorana by allowing for quasiparticle excitations instead. He also states that there are marked signatures of quantum dot formation (particle-hole symmetry breaking inducing asymmetry in low-bias regions of transport measurements), which offers an alternative non-topological mechanism for the other signatures of "topological superconductivity" reported in the original paper.
In their response to Legg's Matters Arising, Microsoft Quantum writes that "The symmetry relationships described in ref. 4 are derived under idealized assumptions that need not hold in experimental settings." They also state that his interpretation "points to generic complications" without addressing that these are still actually complications that should be addressed. Their concluding statement is "Critically, Legg offers no alternative physical model capable of reproducing the capacitance signal or the RTS phenomenology, and does not constitute a substantial scientific challenge to our findings." IMO the burden of developing a suitable physical mechanism to explain a result is on the authors. If enough holes are poked in their explanation, it is their obligation to the scientific community to do things properly and stop with the overhyping of their product.
Maybe slightly less of an issue, but their rebuttal stinks of LLM writing. It obfuscates the point of the original Matters Arising in a way that's hard to put your finger on. Considering that their new chip was developed with the help of "Microsoft Discovery’s agentic AI", it would not surprise me if their retort was also developed with an LLM.
r/physicsdrama • u/MaoGo • Jun 25 '26
r/physicsdrama • u/MaoGo • Jun 23 '26
r/physicsdrama • u/MaoGo • Jun 17 '26
r/physicsdrama • u/MaoGo • Jun 17 '26
r/physicsdrama • u/MaoGo • Jun 16 '26
r/physicsdrama • u/MaoGo • Jun 05 '26
r/physicsdrama • u/MaoGo • Mar 28 '26
r/physicsdrama • u/MaoGo • Mar 28 '26
r/physicsdrama • u/MaoGo • Feb 17 '26
r/physicsdrama • u/Beautiful_Battle6622 • Feb 04 '26
r/physicsdrama • u/MaoGo • Feb 03 '26