r/PhilosophyofMath • • 4d ago

A father developed an app to explain Zeno's paradox to his daughter and show why their fingers never actually touch

441 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • 16d ago

Can someone explain what is a number? Independent of the symbols we use to denote them?

Post image
286 Upvotes

Let me break my question down.

Numbers are natural things, right? Manifesting itself in the form of natural laws, phenomena, and objects. Then we use the symbols to bring a particular phenomena down to an equation, which is a complex pattern of numbers. Right?

But what are or is a particular number? Independent of human efforts of objectifying nature into symbols and equations, what is one? What is two? And so on?

Do we have to use spiritual terms to understand it? For example, should one in nature by default be explained via using the idea of oneness, two with duality, three with trinity?

Am I making sense? Please help me understand.


r/PhilosophyofMath • • Oct 31 '22

Egypt's Rhind Papyrus clearly showing triangles and rectangles dating back to 1650BC, 800 years before Ancient Greece.

Post image
158 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • 28d ago

Terrence Tao says AI proofs are like helicopter rides to a remote destination of interest.

148 Upvotes

Terrence Tao compared AI proofs to a helicopter delivering explorers to a remote destination of interest. He says the explorers miss out because they don't learn anything about the surrounding terrain or how to get to the destination on foot.

This analogy is pretty good. But as a defense of the status quo in Mathematics it is a double edged sword.

  • For example, why are counter examples acceptable as disproofs? What do we learn about the terrain from that?

  • Why teach math at all? Why not let every student struggle until they discover calculus on their own?

  • If we have helicopters, do we need to have people trained to traverse the wilderness and arrive at a particular destination?

  • This sounds like the original arguments lamenting the invention of mechanical calculators.

  • Maybe satellites can map out the terrain in more detail than humans taking a single path?


r/PhilosophyofMath • • Sep 21 '26 Mindblown

What if there are proofs that humans cannot comprehend?

143 Upvotes

I have been thinking about this after hearing Terence Tao's latest statement regarding the rapid development of LLMs. He argues that something should only count as a proof if it can be understood by at least one human.

Considering how quickly LLMs are improving, it is not unreasonable to assume that we will soon run out of proofs that a human can actually comprehend.

What happens when we encounter new problems with proofs that are thousands of pages long, making them far too complex for any human to grasp in a lifetime?

If these proofs are verified in Lean and lead to significant breakthroughs, should we simply dismiss them?

How should we handle these new kinds of proofs?


r/PhilosophyofMath • • Oct 12 '26

So mathematics really does belong with The Arts

134 Upvotes

I have learned that the mindset, goals, and ways of operating of pure mathematics is closer to the English Department than to Engineering. I was wrong all along. Shame on me.


r/PhilosophyofMath • • May 26 '21

Saw this on another page. Thought I would share for fun.

Post image
102 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • Dec 10 '23

Has this quote aged well?(From Gottlob Frege)

Post image
83 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • May 23 '18

Free MIT philosophy of math course -- 24.118x Paradox & Infinity -- set theory, probability, computability, Godel's theorem, and more -- starts June 6!

Thumbnail
edx.org
71 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • Jul 07 '25

Rate the reading

Post image
65 Upvotes

I am beginner in philosophy of mathematics would like to start the journey by this book. I would like get opinions about it.


r/PhilosophyofMath • • Sep 27 '25

Is mathematics discovered or invented?

Thumbnail reddit.com
55 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • Aug 11 '24

About to read philosophy of math. Has anyone read this before?

Post image
53 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • Jun 24 '18

The Mods need to do something about u/qiling.

52 Upvotes

As I am sure most of you know, the user qiling has been spamming this sub and others with links to his crank papers. His papers are little more than nonsensical rambling, and have no place in this subreddit, or any serious sub related to either math or philosophy.

This is not an active sub. As a result, qiling's posts often end up near the top of my front page, despite getting downvoted. His most recent post is at the very top of my front page.

This user is responsible for:

  • 5/9 posts to this sub in the last month.

  • 5/7 posts to this sub in the last two weeks.

  • 3/4 posts to this sub in the last week.

  • 3/3 posts to this sub in the last day.

It is time for the mods u/HenryAudubon and /u/BennyG02 to do something about this user. Personally, if qiling's posts keep showing up on my front page because of this sub, I will simply leave.


r/PhilosophyofMath • • Aug 24 '26

Mathematics In The Age Of AI: When More Proofs Mean Less Understanding

47 Upvotes

Recent discussions regarding artificial intelligence and mathematics frequently diagnose a foundational crisis in mathematical practice. It is projected that AI could soon absorb a significant portion of core mathematical activity — specifically proof generation and problem-solving.

In this debate, prominent figures such as Terence Tao emphasize that the primary value of a mathematical proof lies in its exposition and communicability, not in its mere formal existence. At the same time, Tao observes that even prior to the integration of AI, mathematical research was moving “too fast,” meaning the rate of production exceeded the community’s capacity to contextualize and explain new results (cf. his recent essay, *“*[*Mathematics in the age of AI”*](https://arxiv.org/html/2608.16753v1)).

[](https://medium.com/download-app?source=promotion_paragraph---post_body_banner_surround_blocks--ce6a211fb262---------------------------------------)

This pairing reveals a fundamental structural contradiction: If a primary problem in mathematics is already a deficit in human understanding and clear exposition, accelerating the raw production of formal proofs through automated tools does not resolve the issue. It exacerbates it.

From an epistemological standpoint, the core issue lies in the decoupling of formal validity from human insight. While a machine-generated proof of a central problem (imagine the Riemann Hypothesis) would have immediate pragmatic utility, the long-term integrity of mathematics relies on holistic engagement. The cognitive process of discovering, formulating, and structuring a proof is precisely what builds the intuition required for effective exposition. Furthermore, if human researchers are degraded to retroactive interpreters of machine proofs, an institutional incentive arises to increasingly replace mathematical expertise with the ability to interpret machine-generated results.

A common reaction to these dilemmas is a form of technological determinism, the assumption that technological developments follow autonomous laws to which academic institutions must passively adapt. A rigorous policy framework requires, in principle, the evaluation of all options, including placing the development of artificial intelligence into public hands in order to, for example, deliberately slow it down. Dismissing non-market options out of hand conflates pragmatic implementation hurdles with theoretical impossibility.

If the goal of science is the accumulation and preservation of meaningful knowledge, rather than the mere aggregation of uncomprehended information, the mathematical community must address this directly. Instead of accelerating production further, the discipline requires institutional space for composure.


r/PhilosophyofMath • • Nov 20 '25

Am I the only one noticing a vibe shift in the aesthetic value of math?

47 Upvotes

I first encountered philosophical work on the beauty of math in high school when I discovered writings from people like Kant, Spinoza, Plato, and Einstein. The way they all roughly described the aesthetic experience as being the communication of truth through perfect forms for our imaginations to grasp so as to cause a kind of explosion of associative connections within the recipient resonated with me deeply as around the same time, I had begun taking linear algebra, where I first started learning math with a focus on structures rather than computation. Caring about this sort of beauty in math has defined my relationship with mathematics throughout my career, and it still does today.

Fast forward to when I was in college, where I TA’d a linear algebra course. This happened to be during a COVID semester, so I definitely taught more than a usual TA, and my professors emphasized the importance of maintaining engagement from the students. I thought I would do this by emphasizing the beauty that I felt when I first learned linear algebra. This approach was an utter failure. The psychology of jokes helps account for part of the problem in teaching the beauty of math. We all know that there is no quicker way to empty a joke of its peculiar magic than to try to explain it, and trying to explain to my students the aesthetic value of what they were learning felt very similar. However, to motivate the topics we were covering, when I started describing their applications to fields like quantum mechanics or machine learning, my students were glued.

Though I didn't stay in academia, I did get a PhD, and a lot of my friends from college did stay in academia. I get the sense that the dominating feeling of enjoyment amongst them also strays very utilitarian. I am not trying to be a snob; I think math’s explanatory power and the satisfaction of scientific curiosity are absolutely an aesthetic value. What made me really question the importance of this difference is that I recently met a managing editor of a mathematics journal via a friend. He said the criteria that he asked referees to use in recommending acceptance of a paper were whether it was original, correct, and interesting, arguing that one does not want to publish what has already been published, or what is wrong, or what is new and correct but of no interest. This sentiment also feels in line with much of the work (not all) even my “pure” mathematician friends are publishing. I like to read their manuscripts sometimes, and so many times the work is coded in, or outright focused around, machine learning, theoretical computer science, or theoretical physics.
Over the long run, I now think this may do some damage because the kind of beauty you care about in mathematics is not just an aesthetic quirk; I think it quietly shapes what kinds of knowledge you seek and in turn we end up having. I also believe many of the ideas that generalize and endure come from the classical sense of beauty in math. I would be curious to see if others have noticed a similar trend, and whether they agree with me on the consequences of this, or if I am just being neurotic about a trivial epistemic condition.


r/PhilosophyofMath • • Aug 28 '26

Can mathematical objects exist independently of physical reality?

44 Upvotes

If numbers, sets, and structures are genuinely abstract, what makes mathematical truths objectively necessary rather than merely consequences of human formal systems? Could an incorporeal ontology explain mathematical existence by treating mathematical structures as fundamentally non-physical entities, and if so, what would distinguish this position from Platonism?


r/PhilosophyofMath • • Jun 15 '21

Free MIT math & philosophy course -- Paradox & Infinity -- starts June 22!

44 Upvotes

Link. With MIT's Agustín Rayo (discoverer of Rayo's number!). Here's the course trailer.

Topics covered include:

... and much, much more.

We hope many of you will sign up and join our discussion forum for the coming months!


r/PhilosophyofMath • • Jun 22 '26

On Gödel: What Exactly Is Incomplete?

43 Upvotes

Gödel’s incompleteness theorems are often presented as showing that mathematics is incomplete, that there can be no mathematical “theory of everything,” or that truth outruns proof. I want to separate the precise technical theorem from those broader conclusions.

There are three different objects here: the mathematical domain, the total ledger of truths about that domain, and a fixed effective proof-generator. Gödel limits the third. It does not by itself show that the domain is unfinished or that the complete truth-ledger fails to exist.

So when the broader slogan is used, is it only shorthand for the limits of effective formal systems, or is a further claim about mathematical truth itself intended? If the latter than what warrants the move from limits on proof to limits on truth?


r/PhilosophyofMath • • Aug 26 '13

Ask PhilosophyofMath: Is there a good book that presents and shows differences between most well known ASTs like ZF, Godel's, Von Neumann's, etc?

37 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • Jul 27 '26

Proof Abundance and the New Practice of Mathematics - Terence Tao on AI, LLM breakthroughs, and the bottleneck of mathematical understanding

Thumbnail
4m4.it
36 Upvotes

Terence Tao’s position on artificial intelligence is best understood as verification-centered institutional realism rather than unqualified technological evangelism or defensive skepticism. He treats frontier models as stochastic, unreliable, but increasingly powerful generators whose mathematical value depends on independent verification, informed human supervision, formal tools, and carefully designed research workflows. His central question is therefore no longer only whether machines can solve research problems, but what mathematics should optimize when producing candidate proofs becomes substantially cheaper.

Recent evidence includes an AI-generated disproof of the conjectured near-linear behavior of the planar unit-distance function, an LLM-assisted proof of an identity for jamming critical exponents, and the controlled First Proof evaluation of systems on unpublished research problems. These cases do not establish uniform mathematical competence, dependable self-verification, or human-like understanding. They do establish that general-purpose language and reasoning models can sometimes produce novel constructions, connect distant mathematical domains, and generate arguments that survive expert scrutiny.

The article interprets these developments as an early transition from proof scarcity to proof abundance. In this regime, the limiting resources become verification, exposition, contextualization, selection, and canonicalization. The resulting human–machine system is better described as cognitive infrastructure than as an autonomous artificial mathematician: models generate and explore, proof assistants and executable tests constrain error, and mathematicians retain responsibility for meaning, relevance, attribution, pedagogy, and judgment.

Public demonstrations remain affected by selection bias, incomplete disclosure, uneven reproducibility, and commercial incentives. Formal correctness also does not establish that a theorem is important, explanatory, novel, or even stated in the intended form. The article concludes that AI’s durable contribution to mathematics will depend less on maximizing the number of generated proofs than on constructing institutions capable of verifying, digesting, crediting, and selectively preserving machine-assisted knowledge.


r/PhilosophyofMath • • Jun 09 '20

Beauty Is Not Simplicity: An Analysis of Mathematicians' Proof Appraisals. "[C]ontrary to the classical view, beauty and simplicity are almost entirely unrelated in mathematics."

Thumbnail
academic.oup.com
36 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • May 09 '22

Philosophy of Mathematics final exam questions

35 Upvotes

Here are the questions of the exam I gave for undergraduate Philosophy of Mathematics this term---the students did very well and I was pleased.

How would you answer? Students had a choice of 4. I posted brief suggestions for answers in the thread at https://twitter.com/JDHamkins/status/1523054938523574272.


r/PhilosophyofMath • • Jun 08 '12

Do numbers *exist*? (x-post from r/philosophy)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
35 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • Sep 01 '11

Why Philosophers Should Care About Computational Complexity [Scott Aaronson]

34 Upvotes

The paper can be found here: http://eccc.hpi-web.de/report/2011/108/

From Scott Aaronson's famous blog Shtetl-Optimized

This was also posted on /r/compsci.


r/PhilosophyofMath • • Jan 30 '15

What are the most relevant problems in philosophy of mathematics and in logic right now?

33 Upvotes

Thank you in advance.