I have been arguing about this for way too long now, so I want to explain what I actually mean as clearly as I can.
I understand the standard math.
0.999... = 1 in the real numbers because the infinite decimal is defined by its limit.
I am not confused about that.
My problem is literally with that definition.
If I have:
0.9
0.99
0.999
0.9999
0.99999
and I keep adding 9s forever, then there is never a final step where I suddenly go from "less than 1" to "exactly 1."
There is no last 9.
There is no final stage.
The process just keeps going.
That is the thing I am trying to describe.
I have been informally writing it as:
0.999~
To me, 0.999~ means "keeps approaching 1 forever without ever claiming that 1 has actually been reached."
That is NOT the same thing I mean when I write the standard 0.999...
I know standard mathematics uses 0.999... to represent the limit, which is 1.
My issue is that I think that hides a distinction that matters.
The limit is 1.
The process approaching that limit is not the same thing as the limit.
The easiest real-world example I can think of is a machine.
Imagine we keep improving its reliability:
90%
99%
99.9%
99.99%
99.999%
and so on.
We could theoretically keep improving it forever.
Every improvement adds another 9.
But there is never a point where I would feel justified saying:
"This machine is now literally perfect and failure is impossible."
It can keep getting closer to perfect forever without ever actually becoming perfect.
That is what I mean by 0.999~.
1 = perfection has been reached.
0.999~ = perfection is being approached indefinitely.
And yes, I understand that standard math already has sequences, limits, asymptotes, Cauchy sequences, etc. I am starting to learn more about those because this argument sent me down a massive rabbit hole.
What I keep getting hung up on is the philosophical choice to let an infinite decimal represent the finite value of its limit instead of preserving the endless process as something distinct.
I understand why it is useful....
I understand why decimal notation works better that way....
I just do not think "useful representation" and "the endless process itself" are necessarily the same thing.
So I guess my actual question is:
Is there a serious philosophy of mathematics argument for keeping an endless process conceptually separate from the value of its limit, especially when the math is being used to describe something physical?
Because at this point I am less interested in another proof that 0.999... = 1 and more interested in why we decided that an endless expansion should represent its limit in the first place.