r/PhilosophyofMath • • Oct 17 '25

My hypothesis: everything converges on the hyperreal numbers.

0 Upvotes

In mathematics, divergence is a pain. Wouldn't it be wonderful if divergence didn't exist?

My hypothesis, which has been in print for almost 20 years now, is the following.

Start with the ZF axioms. Discard the Axiom of Infinity and the Axiom of Power Set. Replace them with the Transfer Principle ( https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transfer_principle ) and the Principle of Rejecting pure fluctuations at infinity.

Then every series, sequence, function and integral on the real numbers converges to a unique evaluation on the hyperreal numbers.

I don't have a proof, but I have tested a selection of pathological examples, and it's always worked so far. Here are some of the pathological examples that have a unique evaluation.

The integral from 0 to infinity of 1/x.

The integral from 0 to infinity of ex sin x

The sequence |tan(n)|

The series 1+2+3+4+5+...

The Cauchy-Hamel function defined f(x+y) = f(x) + f(y) where f(1) = 1 and f(π) = 0


r/PhilosophyofMath • • Sep 30 '24

Why is multiplication first ?

0 Upvotes

Im am not realy great at math so maybe this will not make any sense , but why is multiplication first. From what i could find online multiplication is the oldest and most powerful calculation operation, but what is that was wrong from the start did we possibly hinder our progress. Mathematicians say Math is the language of the universe and if we ever discover aliens we could communicate with them through math because math is math and its the same everywhere. But what if we started learning the universal language of the universe all wrong maybe somewhere else subtraction is first and they are light-years more advanced then us.

Sorry if there are some grammar mistakes english is not my first language.


r/PhilosophyofMath • • May 07 '26 Diamonds are Forever

The only post that’s upvoted on the first page is a post about aliens. Every single post questioning the subjective foundation of math is downvoted into the negative

0 Upvotes

Scroll through the sub. It’s a sea of fucking 0s. Every single post questioning the subjective foundation of math downvote botted into the negative.

Yet a post about aliens, on a philosophy of math subreddit is apparently not too much, but the second you question the foundation of math on a philophsy of math subreddit then that’s too much…

That’s very telling.

This is obviously not organic and getting astroturfed. You’re not allowed to question the subjective foundations of math anywhere. You’ll get censored, derailed, and suppressed.(already got valid epistemic arguments mod removed from several subs) (also other people like Karma penny just get straight removed from everywhere)


r/PhilosophyofMath • • Nov 03 '19

I have a new philosophy of numbers, I call it realism. [Not nominalism, platonism or fictionalism]

1 Upvotes

Numbers describe things. They picture features, physical objects or properties about certain type of either object or another numbers or function. They are real, because they represent a part of our world, could be a number of things (one apple, two apples, ⅓ of an apple), a certain number that appears in certain conditions (for example: π, because it represents the relationship between the length of a circle and its diameter.) Or a any type of number that tries to do something. 

√-1 at alones shows us what happens when we try to do the square root of a negative number. Any number used in a math equation is showing us the way to the result, and the result is describing either a physical fenomen or an imaginary situation, therefore numbers must be always either a channel in which we learn the solution that pictures something, or the thing that picture itself.

It's not fictionalism because it shows that numbers are real. It's not platonism because it shows that numbers describe things in real life too. It's not nominalism because it can explain non rational numbers also.


r/PhilosophyofMath • • Oct 05 '26

Does infinity exist in reality?

1 Upvotes

No thing that I've observed in our universe is infinite, however there are traces of infinity in my sight.
Draw a circle and either its radius or circumference lives in the π world.
Or many aspects in nature like flowers, develop themselves in a φ ratio (1+sqrt(5))/2.

Even though no event or anything is "Non-ending"/infinite, underneath many aspects of reality there are patterns which can only be fully described using infinity.

You can't describe irrational numbers to their extent without any notion of infinite/limits/sequences... And many aspects within our World show their true behaviour only with aid of infinity.

Sure you can take a world that lives in something like 10¹⁰⁰ and it looks like infinity to us, sometimes we only see the difference after the 10⁶ decimal place, nevertheless the pattern they follow is a pattern that only "infinity" can yield to the truest precision.

Do you believe the axiom of infinity, and the continuous to really exist? Even if not in the ordinary sense? haha


r/PhilosophyofMath • • Sep 05 '26

Does Pi contain itself?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • 25d ago

Is all math just language (up to PhD or done by math researchers)? Like you're just counting or doing calculations, shortened to rules and symbols?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • Dec 19 '21

Everybody, and every system, can rationalise its own bad behaviour.

0 Upvotes

It seems to me that describing a system or a function as 'chaotic' or saying that its output is non-deterministic is naive, maybe even lazy.

Theoretically, a perfect tree can be grown from a perfect seed in a hydroponics laboratory where temperature, nutrients, UV light, air flow and such are all tightly regulated.

Consider a tree growing in a field. Do we say that the tree is knarly and misshapen because it was destined to be that way? Even if the defect in a tree came from the genetic makeup of its seed, that's a reason. To say its growth is affected by future events is to say that there was no reason the tree grew that way because we haven't been able to think of the reason.

If a tree could think, remember and talk as we can, and we asked it why it had grown as it has, maybe it would tell us "ah well, in the winter of '87 there was this evil frost and the wind wouldn't let up. Then in the next spring there seemed to be a shortage of potassium, and I found this lump..."

Let's now imagine a second tree growing next to the first, and this tree, although also sentient and communicative, is a little less in tune with what had been going in with it, and when questioned about its deformations, it just describes its life as chaotic.

When a geologist considers a rock formation, they try to figure out what events led to the formations and deformations observed. They wouldn't say "this rock was meant to look like this, it grew funky like this so it would intrigue me and I'd go on to study it."

A parent sees some ill behaviour in a child and questions them about it. The child explains things from their point of view and the parent might go "ah right, you were right to do that then." Or their conclusion might be that an attitude in the child had grown and caused the problem. Would a responsible parent decide that their progeny was destined to be a leader of men and decide all of their child's actions were to go unchallenged? Could a decision to take this latter route be seen as lazy as well as silly?

If a computer analyst filled out a bug report with "nothing is deterministic", would they get paid?

Maybe we can't track everything that happens to a foetus or an acorn, but why can't we be trying to do that with numbers? I've written a few notes on trying to track what is being done to numbers of different types, what information such as spatiality we might have been naively throwing out when we square a number and then still notate it in the same we we notate its root. There's logic we aren't seeing because of the way we evaluate 43 and 82 as 64. There are links between ternary computations and the construction of tetrahedra and factorials that we haven't properly plumbed the depths of, before considering if other such links exist. Tautologies are generally accepted as useless because they point out flaws in our evaluations.

If you get what I'm banging on about and fancy writing with me, drop me a message.

Peace.

M.


r/PhilosophyofMath • • Nov 05 '24

Have mathematicians given up too much in their pursuit of certainty?

0 Upvotes

The title basically. Any mathematical theorem holds only in the axiomatical system its in (obviously some systems are stronger than others but still). If you change the axioms, the theorem might be wrong and there is really nothing stopping you from changing the axioms (unless you think they're "interesting"). So in their pursuit of rigour and certainty, mathematicians have made everything relative.

Now, don't get me wrong, this is precisely why i love pure math. I love the honesty and freedom of it. But sometimes if feel like it's all just a game. What do you guys think?


r/PhilosophyofMath • • Jul 03 '21

Is there an issue with the halting problem ?

0 Upvotes

Why can you not apply halting problem method of proof to disprove existence of other machines which would however result in nonsense? Imagine there is a machine B that tells wether the colour of the machine is blue or not(input machine- > outputs yes or no). Now create a machine B' which reverses the outputs of B, so if the machine B outputs yes for blue B' outputs no for not blue; conversely if B outputs no b" outputs yes. Then feed description of B' into B' and if B' is blue then it is not blue and otherwise


r/PhilosophyofMath • • Sep 04 '24

Mathematical proofs are informal. Why do we act otherwise?

9 Upvotes

I want to start by clarifying that this post is not about whether informal proofs are good or bad, but rather how we tend to forget that most proofs we deal with are informal.

We often hear, "Math is objective because everything is proved." But if you press a mathematician familiar with proof theory, they will likely admit that most proofs are more about intuitive logic applied to an intuitive understanding of ZFC (Zermelo-Fraenkel set theory with Choice). This weakens the common claim of math being purely objective.

Think of it like a programmer who confidently claims they know exactly what their code will do, despite not fully understanding the compiler—which could be faulty. Similarly, we treat mathematical proofs as unquestionably correct, even though they’re often based on shared assumptions that aren’t rigorously examined each time.

Imagine your professor just walked through a complex proof. If a classmate said, “I don’t believe the proof,” most students and professors would likely think poorly of them. Why? Because we’re taught that “it doesn’t matter if you believe it—proofs are objectively correct.” But is that really the case?

I believe this dynamic—where we treat proofs as beyond skepticism—occurs often, and it raises the question: Why? Is it because we are expected to defer to the consensus of mathematicians? Is it some leftover from Platonism? Or maybe it's because most mathematicians are uninterested in philosophy, preferring to avoid these messy questions. It could also be that teachers want to motivate students and don’t want to introduce doubts about the objectivity of math, which might be discouraging for future mathematicians.

What do you think? I highly value any opinion you can give me on both my question and propositions. As a side note, you might as well throw in the general aversion to not mention rival schools to the kind of formalism that is common today. Because "duh they are obviously wrong" which is a paraphrase from a professor I know personally. Thank you.


r/PhilosophyofMath • • Dec 21 '22

Platonian Theory of Everything, published in a peer-reviewed journal, Link: http://www.sapub.org/global/showpaperpdf.aspx?doi=10.5923/j.ijtmp.20221202.03

0 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • Oct 17 '11

Null Sets

Thumbnail
quickmeme.com
0 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • Apr 09 '12

What do you guys think about the flower of life?

0 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • Oct 14 '22

This is the best paper I have ever read.

Thumbnail ckraju.net
0 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • Mar 19 '22

I think much of the issues discussed in phil. of math can be traced back to the history of measures of distance in terms of things with mass (pharoah's arm, a foot, 10,000 steps, the earth's ground surface from the north pole to the equator etc).

0 Upvotes

Distance has never been defined as or in terms of lengths of empty space.

When we think of modern problems in philosophy, continuity always plays a central role -- especially in applied math found in science and engineering. Even causing problems in physics (predictably), where quantum observables are discrete but QM is written in continuous terms. Etc.

Geometry, greek 'lines' were first to come up with an idea of a tiny no mass line of pure distance. But this made/makes little sense in terms of our units and SI unit of distance, leading to goofy ideas such as irrational quantities and infinite divisibility.

A forearm is composed of molecules that cannot be fractional quantities. An indivisible length. As is a foot, or a strip of the earth's crust. Or a platinum rod.

Distance should have been defined as physical integer multiples of molecules which make up the unit. A foot, integer multiples of molecules in feet. Ditto for a forearm and even a strip of earth's crust or even a platinum rod.

Rather than '1 meter' it should rather be said 'n(molecules) long'. Distance should have been a measure of how many physical molecules fit in between two locations. That captures the true essence of distance and what distance means. Absent of matter, distance would make little sense.


r/PhilosophyofMath • • Oct 06 '26

I get why 0.999... = 1 in standard math. I just think the thing standard math is doing there is weird.

0 Upvotes

I have been arguing about this for way too long now, so I want to explain what I actually mean as clearly as I can.

I understand the standard math.

0.999... = 1 in the real numbers because the infinite decimal is defined by its limit.

I am not confused about that.

My problem is literally with that definition.

If I have:

0.9

0.99

0.999

0.9999

0.99999

and I keep adding 9s forever, then there is never a final step where I suddenly go from "less than 1" to "exactly 1."

There is no last 9.

There is no final stage.

The process just keeps going.

That is the thing I am trying to describe.

I have been informally writing it as:

0.999~

To me, 0.999~ means "keeps approaching 1 forever without ever claiming that 1 has actually been reached."

That is NOT the same thing I mean when I write the standard 0.999...

I know standard mathematics uses 0.999... to represent the limit, which is 1.

My issue is that I think that hides a distinction that matters.

The limit is 1.

The process approaching that limit is not the same thing as the limit.

The easiest real-world example I can think of is a machine.

Imagine we keep improving its reliability:

90%

99%

99.9%

99.99%

99.999%

and so on.

We could theoretically keep improving it forever.

Every improvement adds another 9.

But there is never a point where I would feel justified saying:

"This machine is now literally perfect and failure is impossible."

It can keep getting closer to perfect forever without ever actually becoming perfect.

That is what I mean by 0.999~.

1 = perfection has been reached.

0.999~ = perfection is being approached indefinitely.

And yes, I understand that standard math already has sequences, limits, asymptotes, Cauchy sequences, etc. I am starting to learn more about those because this argument sent me down a massive rabbit hole.

What I keep getting hung up on is the philosophical choice to let an infinite decimal represent the finite value of its limit instead of preserving the endless process as something distinct.

I understand why it is useful....

I understand why decimal notation works better that way....

I just do not think "useful representation" and "the endless process itself" are necessarily the same thing.

So I guess my actual question is:

Is there a serious philosophy of mathematics argument for keeping an endless process conceptually separate from the value of its limit, especially when the math is being used to describe something physical?
Because at this point I am less interested in another proof that 0.999... = 1 and more interested in why we decided that an endless expansion should represent its limit in the first place.


r/PhilosophyofMath • • Jul 30 '14

The locus of mathematical reality: An anthropological footnote

0 Upvotes

The locus of mathematical reality: An anthropological footnote [PDF] (Alternate link).

Money quote:

But apart from cultural tradition, mathematical concepts have neither existence nor meaning, and of course, cultural tradition has no existence apart from the human species. Mathematical realities thus have an existence independent of the individual mind, but are wholly dependent upon the mind of the species. Or, to put the matter in anthropological terminology: mathematics in its entirety, its “truths” and its “realities,” is a part of human culture, nothing more.


r/PhilosophyofMath • • Sep 17 '26

The entire infinity concept

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • Sep 20 '26

How far have human reached to define Cantor' Absolute Infinity as a mathematical entity?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • Jan 19 '23

Does Studying Maths and Logic Improve Logical Reasoning? No.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofMath • • Jul 05 '14

Can anyone recommend any good starting places for a good foundation in categories and simulations?

0 Upvotes

I'm a chemistry major and I've been having a lot of questions come up during the lectures and reading that in order to answer, would require me to be more familiar with coding and algorithms to make predictive simulations. I'm missing a guiding foundation in math higher than calculus, and I learn best through deconstruction and moving things around, but the relationships I'm trying to understand are difficult for a teacher to demonstrate during class. I'd really like to be able to learn the rules of the mechanics of chemistry by being able to program a simulation with the rules and exceptions, and see what patterns and those of their integrations that arise.

I'm hoping this question isn't so vague that it's unclear what I'm asking for. A lot of the google searches of topos, categories, and sets that I've been looking up keep leading me back to differential geometry, set theory, combinatorics, and intuitionism. Is there a good overview of the philosophy of these subjects, especially ones related to computer simulations and algorithm programming? I took a class in intro computer logics and visual basic, but wouldn't mind learning any new coding language, if anyone's familiar with something encompassing these topics. I'm hopeful that if I had a better understanding, I could use it to have a more complete foundational overview of the relationship between math and science.


r/PhilosophyofMath • • Oct 11 '26

Is math discovered, or an invention of human scale? We don't care about subatomic chaos daily, making zero natural. But if aliens evolved seeing constant fields and quarks, would zero and whole numbers exist to them, or is mathematics just our species' custom user interface for reality?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes