r/phillies • • Oct 05 '25

Text Post Rob has always been a problem and this should be the nail in the coffin

9 Upvotes

Does Rob owe David Robertson money or something? Why on earth is he coming in in a jam in the 6th? He’s been terrible for weeks. Tanner Banks has bailed Robertson and Alvarado out of jams that they created for the last month. You’d think Thompson would notice that. Banks has saved him late in games multiple times down the stretch.

If bringing Robertson in in the 6th wasn’t enough, why does he start the 7th? Kerkering was right there. Strahm was right there. You still have banks. What is the point of leaving Robertson in? He’s like the 5th best pitcher in the pen if that, why are you riding him so hard with 1 game the next 3 days?

Then to clean up the mess in the 7th you go to Strahm? I like Strahm, but his whole thing this year is that he gets the ball to start an inning (typically the 8th). Again, Banks has been your guy to get you out of jams and he was never close to coming in.

I don’t know the full situation with Bader. Obviously if he’s hurt he’s hurt but there was no indication of that until after the move. Whole thing just felt really weird…

Also, there was no real roster chatter before this game but why is Weston Wilson on the team with Rojas at home? Sosa and Kemp are pinch hitters vs LHP, Sosa can play everywhere in the infield, kemp can play corner outfield as good as Wilson. What does he bring to the table? How are we 1 injury away from a Wilson/Kepler/Castellanos outfield?

The most frustrating thing about this loss is Rob seemingly has his roster figured out at the end of this season. He sits in the dugout every day; how does he not know what’s going on??

I genuinely think Rob would rather lose with his guys than win and hurt someone’s feelings in the process. Hitting casty behind Bryce all of the ‘22 playoffs, the Craig Kimbrel obsession, the Jose Alvarado obsession, the David Robertson obsession. It’s like little league where if he likes you, you get to play.

You made me yell in front of my fiancé Rob. Multiple times. Not cool.


r/phillies • • Oct 09 '24

Question This HAS to be the end of the Rob Thomson era right?

44 Upvotes

He’s a great regular season manager and a great “vibes” guy but he’s gotta go. This is his third bad postseason in a row


r/phillies • • Oct 10 '19

Gabe Kapler Dismissed UPVOTE PARTY

19 Upvotes

r/phillies • • Feb 08 '24

Question Seriously asking, is it possible that JT is the best pure catcher ever? Maybe his hitting stats aren’t the best, but I mean literally catching, not just the position at a whole

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/phillies • • Apr 05 '24

City Connects :(

Post image
5 Upvotes

Did I fix it???


r/phillies • • Apr 04 '25

Text Post I miss the song

2 Upvotes

I know why people don't want it back, I get it. But when the team adopted Dancing on My Own, it felt like there was a little extra "life" added to the games. Singing that song after a win with 40,000+ others at CBP, or even just 30 people in a bar, personally brought a lot of joy and a more tangible sense of community to the city that I love.

Maybe it's just me, but it looked like the team was having more FUN when we had a song and The Daycare (which I am not as beat up about being gone). After 2023 there were a lot of expectations put on them, so they locked in and got serious, which is a valid response to that kind of pressure. But despite that they still got knocked out early, to the fucking Mets no less (not that the team matters, I'm just still salty it was to them).

Since last year everyone has looked so stiff at the plate and seems to get frustrated with themself a lot easier whenever they aren't having the best game. They have jobs to keep and expectations to meet, but at the end of the day, they're paid millions to play a game that they love but it doesn't feel like they're loving it right now. Winning is the goal as it is with any professional sport, but I don't think relaxing a bit/having fun and being serious about winning have to be mutually exclusive.

Obviously, I don't know these guys or what motivates them, I'm just rattling off my own thoughts and opinions. Maybe it's not even the song I miss, just the vibes brought with it.


r/phillies • • Jul 11 '22

Megathread The One Covid Thread to Rule Them All

1 Upvotes

Listen, we get it, Covid is again affecting the Phillies and you all want a place to talk about it. So here is the deal, you can use THIS thread and this thread will be locked come Friday when we start against the Fish. You have between now and then since Covid is actually affecting the team. Otherwise, we won't allow this or any political talk because we are a SPORTS subreddit and many people (on the left and right) use sports to avoid worrying about bigger picture items. This thread will be, mostly, unmoderated. There are XX very simple rules, you follow them and you are good to go, you don't you will see your posts get removed and you will likely find yourself with a ban until after the Toronto series. If you feel that you didn't violate these rules but one of the mods removed your post or gave you a ban, send a respectful note to the mod team and we will discuss it and get back to you.

  1. No self promotion (I don't know what you would try to self promote, but it's one of the things I personally hate most about Reddit so I'm adding it here on top of our normal rules)

  2. No calls for violence. Period. Not the players, not the Canadian government, not another user. Anything beyond simple name calling that even hints at violence will be taken care of, we can get in trouble with Reddit for this if we don't take care of it

  3. No doxxing (again, feels like this one should go without being said)

  4. No obviously fake information, you want to tell me that vaccines don't work then show me some credible medical peer reviewed information. Just to be clear, this does NOT mean you can't point out that Covid is not as big of a deal as it used to, because it's not (thank you vaccines)

  5. No other politics, words like Trump and Biden and all kinds of other words will still get caught by the auto mod

  6. Be patient if your post isn't posting, we have a pretty strict auto mod and we all have lives and don't get paid for this, if a post isn't there after a good 4-6 hours or so during a normal work day or the game then ask the mod team respectfully about it and we will either approve it (because we hadn't seen it yet) or explain to you why it isn't there.

  7. Have a thick skin, people are going to piss you off in this thread, it's going to happen and we are not moderating it, so if you can't handle that don't engage

Listen, we all want Covid to be over and we hate that it's affecting our season. This is your forum to talk about it and get all of your talking points that will literally not change a single person's mind out, but this is it, unless we play Toronto again in the World Series.

Have fun and be respectful.

Also, Go Phils!


r/phillies • • Aug 24 '24

Image Look Guys! It says POOKC!

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/phillies • • Sep 27 '26

Text Post Phillies Appreciation Post 2

3 Upvotes

So the game didn’t go well in terms of on field performance, and it was hard. We still have one more game to go, but we might not make it. However, I had a lot of fun and I’m glad I was able to go. I got to take home one of those green dumpling things, I thought all the staff members and fans were really nice and I enjoyed the admittedly expensive cheesesteak.

I‘m going to come back next year and I’m gonna be rooting for the Phillies while I’m living in New Jersey. If nothing else, I made some good memories with a new place.


r/phillies • • Jun 29 '23

Despite the wins from good pitching, I’m still questioning Topper’s lineup choices

0 Upvotes

Brandon Marsh has the second best OPS of our offense so far the last time I checked. How on earth are we still platooning him? Are his splits vs lefty really that bad? And even if they are, his overall numbers this year should earn him a spot higher in the lineup - but he keeps getting put near the bottom.

I find myself doubting too that Schwarber’s mindset would really be that messed up if we moved him down to the 5 hole. He’s absolutely valuable with his home runs, but it’s hard to understand keeping somebody with his average as leadoff.

Harrison shouldn’t be getting the amount of at-bat’s he does. He’s okay as a backup but he’s 35 and isn’t going to suddenly be great.

And finally, I’m at the point where I’m wondering if we need to accept this is just going to be a bad year for trea and move him down in the lineup as well.

But Topper just doesn’t seem to want to make any of these changes that would probably be helpful to the offense.


r/phillies • • Jul 02 '26

Text Post Observations from a VERY hot CPB.

0 Upvotes

Went to the Pittsburgh game on 7/2 and yes, it was hot. (How hot was it? Saw a dog chasing a cat and they were both walking.) 104 degrees was the highest I saw on the scoreboard and it felt every bit of that. Fortunately, we had seats in the back of the 210 section. Still great views and in the shade, under cover, which was a difference maker. For future reference, those 210 - 215 sections, especially in the back 3 or 4 rows, are shaded and under cover.

The stadium policy is no backpacks or bags unless they're clear. I was able to score a nice sized clear backpack for $10 before going. Definitely clear, could definitely see everything in it (water, snacks and towels), but they searched it anyway. Still trying to figure that one out.

A lot of people go to the game but pay very little attention to it, at least when we went. One guy is on his phone playing games, another lady is up and down the aisle all game long, busy not watching the game. Dozens of the same people making constant snack runs. (If it was just water breaks I'd get it in the heat, but it was everything from hot dogs to ice cream, and it was back and forth all game long.) And then there's the seat hoppers. I mean, I get it; they're grabbing empty shady seats in the heat. But how do you enjoy the game, moving around so much? Guess it must be the old dude in me; I go to watch the game and that's what I do.

By the way, the staff at CBP are all great. Helpful, friendly and responsive. Can't ask for better people.

If you've never been, the CBP experience is well worth it.

Edited to add: Sorry if anyone took this as somehow "judgmental" or "mean spirited" in any way. As noted in the title, these are things I saw on my visit (i.e. observations). Having been a kid, and having raised kids, I know how challenging an outing to the ballpark can be. It was just eye-opening for me to see how trips to the ballpark have changed. Never intended to offend those who've obviously been offended.

And I know many people here have been to CBP, but many have not. I actually learned about the benefits of the 200 level by reading this sub-reddit. I've been in other sections but hadn't sat there before and I'm glad I did. Just wanted to "pay it forward" with my observations, for those who might find them helpful.

Thanks for reading all this. Enjoy your weekend!


r/phillies • • Feb 16 '24

Rating Phillies Starters Heading into 2024

2 Upvotes

(This will not include Pitchers)

9. Nick Castellanos:

I've already talked about this... man plenty already. If his contract wasn't 20 million dollars a year he'd be the most replaceable positional player on this team and it's not even close.

8.

Alec Bohm: His defense is still average at best and he has yet to hit for an ops over .800 at a corner infield position. He is not a young player full of potential anymore, he's 28 and is likely at or near his ceiling for what he's going to reach as a player, and I'm sorry but it's not good enough. He is the most replaceable player on this team right now.

7. Johan Rojas:

This man only needs to hit .for an ops of about .650-.670 to be able to start. His defense is actually that good. Arguments to the contrary are just false.

6. JT Realmuto:

JT is on the downside of his career, as much as I love him, he is starting to age. JT needs to be playing significantly less games this year in my opinion, I'd say around 120 (down 15 from last year). His framing was down to the bottom two percentile in baseball last year. That absolutely needs to improve, Especially given the fact that it is now nearly impossible to throw runners out because of the new rules. I think he absolutely can bounce back, but I don't know if that's something I'd take to the bank, hence the low rating.

5. Kyle Schwarber:

Daddy Schwarber (as my friends and I call him) is the king of pissing off traditionalists that still obsess over batting averages. He gets love from me just for that. I keep a GIF of "because he gets on base" on my phone just because of him. But he is this low mainly because he is a DH and he's not a spectacular one either (.817 ops is good not great for a DH). But Kyle is fine, 0 complaints from me on him. He is what you expect he's going to be, a ton of three true outcomes.

4. Brandon Marsh:

I'm putting Marsh below Stott purely because I believe there's more room for regression in Marshs' game than Stotts. He needs to bring the strikeouts down below 30 percent this year. Also, although his batted ball luck has always been good, there's basically no way it will be as good as last year so there is some regression incoming.

3. Bryson Stott:

I just want to say I was calling this mans walk up a song that was gonna get sung along with in the playoffs the moment I heard it for the first time. But on the serious front, gold glove candidate at second base, amazing bat to ball skills to just be an absolute nuisance at the plate in a way that rivals Odubel when he was on a hot streak, but the ability to occasionally draw a walk. His babip says he's not in line for major regression, he barely strikes out, and if he can avoid that end of year slump we saw last year then oh man.

2. Trea Turner:

Let's keep this short, if he doesn't get off to a slow start this year he has the potential to win an MVP. While he would porbably really do well defensively on the arm side of things from moving to second, that isn't going to happen and frankly doesn't matter if he hits like he did in the last third of last year. I'm not going to act like him magically improving his ability to not wave at bad pitches is going to improve because it's not.

  1. Bryce Harper:

I don't really have to write anything here. He's the man, we all know he's the man, post over. Make sure to give an animal sacrifice for the first year of fully healthy harper in three seasons.


r/phillies • • Jan 21 '25

Rule Changes to r/Phillies Prior to the 2025 Season

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

The mod team recently underwent a review of our rules, as we do every offseason. After consultation, we have decided to establish three new rules for r/Phillies, effective immediately. 

  1. Sexual references are no longer allowed. Frequently, we see comments like “that home run gave me a boner”, “that guy has a fat ass”, or “I’m going to cum if we win”. These comments are not appropriate, and can make other users feel unwelcome. 

  2. Our “be respectful” rule is being updated to specifically include targeted harassment of others. There are some users in this subreddit that have made a habit of targeting others or seeking attention in obtrusive way. This has never been okay, but by clearly outlining this as against our rules, consider this to be one final warning.

  3. Excessive toxicity is no longer allowed. There are always going to be times where people are negative about the team, and that’s not at all what this rule is about. It’s okay to not think that the team or a specific player is doing well. A good barometer to see if you are being overly toxic is if the vast majority of your contributions to the subreddit are excessively negative. There is a big difference between saying “JT is really struggling right now and needs to get it together”, and “JT is a worthless piece of shit who provides nothing of value to this team and the world”. If your comment history shows a lot of excessively toxic comments, and they keep getting reported to us, we will take action. We understand that this is subjective, and mod discretion will be used responsibly. As always, please report comments that you think we should take a look at - it really helps us out!

Mod action can include comments being removed, or temporary/permanent bans. People that have been warned or had temporary bans in the past are more likely to get permanently banned.

If anyone has questions, please let us know. Thanks!


r/phillies • • Aug 02 '25

Text Post Oh hey look, the platoons worked again

8 Upvotes

Thomson was getting flamed before the game started yesterday, and into the 7th inning, for DARING to start Max Kepler and Brandon Marsh instead of Harrison Bader.

Kepler was 0 for 2 last night, including a 400-foot flyout barely missing a homer in his first AB. Marsh was also 0 for 2 last night.

However, because Thomson is smarter than we are, he was able to use Otto Kemp and Harrison Bader in the 7th inning when they were facing a lefty reliever instead of the righty starter. Kemp was 2 for 2, and Bader was 0 for 1 with a walk. They combined for three runs scored.

Thomson won the game for the Phillies.


r/phillies • • Oct 09 '24

Meme Dave and John, I beg of you both, sign Juan Soto this offseason

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/phillies • • Feb 17 '24

Anybody know how many times the Phillies brass is going to screw up my Friday night this year by putting the game on AppleTV+?

0 Upvotes

Most Fridays in the summer I just want to be done with work, bump the AC, put the Phillies on, drink some beer, take a gummy and order a pizza. They ruined that for me like six times last year.


r/phillies • • Oct 21 '24

Text Post Beating a cold, dead Phillies team was the Mets’ World Series

292 Upvotes

Their sub is hilarious. You fuckers had the highest payroll in the MLB acting like the Mets are some underdogs and “shouldn’t even be here”. At least the Mets glazing by Fox sports is over, but they’re still in their victim mentality mode over there.

Phillies have been dogshit for the 2nd half of the season. Mets fans acted like they beat some record setting, 100+ win, hot Phillies team


r/phillies • • Apr 20 '25

Text Post Daycare

2 Upvotes

I honestly really miss the daycare antics! After a win watching Bohm, Stotty, and Marsh pouring water and celebrating with the player of the game was always something I looked forward to.


r/phillies • • Oct 11 '25

Text Post Mets fans are so insufferable

15 Upvotes

They came across my feed recently and some cornball was asking why Harper wasn't fined for spraying his bat even though it happend months ago. And go in they're sub and you'll see posts making fun of the Phillies for losing the NLDS. They didn't even make the postseason despite having Lindor, Soto, and Alonso and the 2nd highest payroll in the big 4 American sports. They couldn't even beat the Reds to a postseason spot. Watching the Phillies lose is their world series. Fuck the Mets


r/phillies • • Oct 04 '25

Image Random Phillies Jerseys

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

r/phillies • • Nov 02 '25

Text Post Anyone just want this to be over

0 Upvotes

This has been a good series honestly one of the better ones in recent history. I just want it to be over to know what’s happening with our team next year


r/phillies • • Aug 09 '23

Basic Etiquette At Ball Game

0 Upvotes

If you are going to a baseball game and are walking to or from your seat in the middle of an at bat, you’re an asshole. Like just wait. This hasn’t been a problem for years because the only people at philleis games were the diehards like me. But it’s just incredibly rude to walk in front of the game like that. Please don’t. Unless your usher is forcing you to, just stand there and wait a minute or two.

Also just shut up with the Eagles chants, this isn’t an Eagles game. Start a let’s go Phillies chant or something. At least pretend you actually care about the Phillies and aren’t just using them as a means to pass time until football seaosn


r/phillies • • Oct 21 '23

Honestly can’t put too much blame on Thomper here

0 Upvotes

We scored 5 runs in a park that’s going to be a tougher park to score in for us. The bats were fine. The problems were threefold:

Sanchez didn’t have his changeup nor did he have enough control, which meant this game became a bullpen game when we were already down, meaning that we couldn’t bring in low leverage guys early so we didn’t bleed runs.

Kerkering was brought in to make one out, but gave up a run before he could. High leverage, sure, but not expected to retire the side. His slider is just worse when he’s pitching from the stretch, it seems.

Kimbrel really wasn’t brought into super high leverage. He was up for 6 thru 8. Kimbrel blew it, and Alvarado just wasn’t warm until it was too late.

Could he have used Lorenzen at some point? Probably - I think using him in the 8th would’ve made sense - but earlier in the game? He hasn’t pitched enough, and a team getting barreled in the first couple innings is brutal. Walker really was only going to come in for extras. His first inning is consistently awful, and Thomper said outright that his routine to get ready to pitch is very long and regimented - he’s never come out of the bullpen before.

IMO the big mistake was not going Walker as pitcher 4, but Sanchez as a lefty made sense. He just didn’t have it. Series is far from over though.


r/phillies • • Jul 30 '26

Question How long do we have to suck before ticket prices come down?

1 Upvotes

I'll be in town next month. Already planning to catch a game. I always buy tickets off of Seat Geek because I like being in certain sections, and that's the only way to get them. Ticket prices are still the same or more than they were before the All Star break. Will they come down?