r/phallo • u/[deleted] • Aug 05 '23
Discussion Anybody who wants phallo deserves to be included and respected on this sub NSFW
I'm honestly feeling very appalled at how exclusive and unkind a lot of the trans men on this sub are being to people who aren't binary trans men seeking phallo.
The rule asks for us to not use UNNECESSARY gendered language. That doesn't mean you can't refer to your own experience with terms you identify with, it just means don't gender phallo as a whole, or everybody on this sub because not all of us are binary trans men and not all of us refer to our body parts as "male". Using terms like "guys, male, men" etc. for phallo or when referring to this entire sub MISGENDERS those of us who are not men. Using terms like "people, everyone, folks" etc. INCLUDES everyone.
Non binary people get phallo. Genderfluid people get phallo. Intersex people get phallo. I even saw a cis woman post about wanting phallo. Anybody who wants phallo deserves to be included on this sub. I want phallo, but I'm not a man. Phallo is for anybody who wants phallo.
It's concerning to me that so many trans men on this sub seem to believe that genitalia is inherently gendered and defines somebodys identity. This isn't to say that phallo isn't connected to someone's gender dysphoria, sense of identity, and euphoria. If phallo helps you feel more at home in your body and identity as a man, that's fantastic and extremely valid. But thats not the case for everyone and its important we be mindful of that in spaces that are meant to support people seeking these surgeries. People who aren't binary trans men who don't experience phallo as "male genitalia" doesn't discredit a binary trans man experiencing phallo as male. But equating ALL dicks to men and ALL vaginas to women is inherently transphobic to trans people and is exclusive to intersex people and people who identify outside the binary. Not to mention defining people's gender by their genitalia is also a great way to venture into misogynistic, gender critical, and transmedicalist territory.
We've spent our entire lives having transphobic cis people tell us that our genitalia defines our gender and invalidates our identities and we shouldn't have to put up with that kind of rhetoric in our own spaces. It also really concerns me to hear so many trans men using the "mostly trans men get phallo so we shouldn't have to be inclusive to non-binary, intersex, and genderfluid etc. people" argument as it is extremely similar to the kind of rhetoric transphobic cis people use when it comes to not wanting to make spaces safe and inclusive for trans people in general. Just because there's more cisgender people in the world doesn't mean they shouldn't make spaces safe and inclusive for trans people. The same goes for there being more trans men on this sub not meaning that they shouldn't make the space safe and inclusive for folks who aren't binary trans men.
We are all seeking phallo to improve our quality of life. We all came to this sub to seek and give support. We all deserve to be included. It costs us all nothing to be inclusive and to make this space safe and welcoming for everyone.
Edit: The whole point of using gender inclusive language when referring to a group of people of different genders is to include everybody. Using gender inclusive language in groups of people misgenders no one. That's the whole point. Also there's a huge difference between saying "hey guys" and "guys who have had phallo". The second one misgenders people who aren't trans men. You all need to do some serious soul searching if using gender inclusive language so you don't misgender your fellow trans siblings makes you feel this attacked. I am in absolute disbelief that so many of you are unwilling to make this space safe and welcoming for all people pursuing phallo, especially when this sub is all most of us have to access support and information on phallo.