r/petpeeve • u/sierbrow • Sep 13 '26
when people use “our grandparents did it” as an argument.
i don’t know exactly what this is called, but it annoys me when people compare things we do today to things people had to do in the past, as if that automatically means we should be okay with doing the same thing now.
for example, i saw a woman with a jar of home-canned beef stew from 2022. personally, i would not eat it. maybe it’s perfectly safe, maybe it isn’t, but i don’t know how it was canned, stored, or handled, so i’m good.
someone commented:
“everyone doubting canned food longevity wouldn’t survive an actual food shortage. our grandparents and great grandparents did this during the depression.”
and that’s what annoys me. they HAD to.
we’re not living through the great depression. we have refrigeration, commercially processed food, modern food-safety knowledge, better technology, etc.
i feel like people do this with everything. “people used to live without air conditioning.” “people used to walk everywhere.” “our grandparents didn’t have ___.”
okay. and?
just because people had to do something in the past doesn’t mean we have to do it now. that’s kind of the whole point of progress.
\*\*to be clear, i’m not judging the woman who canned the stew. if she knows what she’s doing and feels comfortable eating it, that’s fine. this is about the logic in that comment, not her.