Hey guys. I am a current Peace Corps Volunteer. I want to write a very frank post about the Peace Corps.
I had a lot of questions and concerns about PC before I joined. I asked questions on here. I decided to join PC because I wanted to learn about a new place and do meaningful work. I dont regret joining, but I feel like a lot of people here just say the good stuff. There's a lot of hindsight bias.
I'm going to be completely honest. PC has the potential to be a huge waste of time. If you want 2 years of cultural exchange it is great, but if you want to do any sort of development work it is not.
Don't expect to have that much to do or to make a difference. I didn't come into this expecting to save the world, but I wanted meaningful work. I'm on my ass 90% of the time. Not to toot my own horn, but I have some nice projects going and I do work outside of my sector. Peace Corps has even commended me on my work but i still feel very idle. It's taboo to admit it.... but all of the other volunteers I have talked to also have too much free time.
Ed volunteers usually have more to do but it's still usually just a part time job at most. Teaching English is also very difficult and takes special training. Peace corps training, at least in my country, is very lackluster. Very few people in my cohort are actually good English teachers. Some of them have realized they hate teaching English. Oftentimes the Peace corps teachers are better than local teachers and it is hard to get truly good teachers to work without pay. So it's better than nothing, but still, is it how you want to use 2 years? Just know that speaking English does not mean you will be good at teaching it or like teaching it.
And as for ag volunteers. Do you really think you can teach farming to people that live or die based on the success of their harvest? In my country they can't take risks. Why would they listen to someone that doesn't need to farm to live? I'm being a bit dramatic... people do listen to some things, but overall it's incredibly hard to make any sort of change and for the most part the job is ridiculous. An outside perspective can always be helpful but expect to have very little impact and even less to do. (Edit: yes you can connect people with resources. That is a valuable part about ag that someone brought up in the comments. But being an occasional middleman for 2 years, although important and sometimes fulfilling, leads to a lot of time without having work)
I don't know much about health volunteers so I can't comment there.
Also, take a good hard look at yourself. I'm sure you are amazing! I think that people who join Peace Corps have some good intentions. But do you really think you have the experience necessary to do good work in a 3rd world country with minimal support? Maybe it's better in other places but in my country peace corps has almost no involvement with any of the work I do. If you are like me you are young, naïve, poor, and inexperienced. To actually make a meaningful change I think you need a lot of money or skill. In my country the training wasnt great and it is very difficult to get PC to give you money. I think Peace Corps does do some good! But I have heard very few concrete success stories. Usually the success stories are "so and so famous person knew a PC volunteer when they were young." Also oftentimes you hear people say they learned English from a PC volunteer. That's amazing! But I think the key word there is that they learned the English, they weren't taught it. Most people you teach English to will be disinterested. There will be a few who are motivated and will learn from you, but in my opinion they would have done that regardless of our amateur teaching.
Maybe some of you are joining to chill in another country and have everything paid for. If so, this is the job for you! And I'm not being facetious.
Just keep in mind that you have almost no choice in where you get put. Peace Corps, who knows almost nothing about you, will make a lot of life changing choices for you. Don't expect to go somewhere where you can use your specialized skills. Don't expect to go somewhere with things to do or natural beauty. You aren't a tourist who gets to decide what you do. There is beauty in that, but you have to decide if the freedom you give up is worth the good you do. Depending where you go, it is likely that you will be pit in a small town with nothing to do and nobody with common interests. In my town the 2 options for social recreation are playing soccer or getting shitfaced drunk. There might be some natural beauty where you live but it's just as likely that where you live will be overexploited and polluted. You aren't a tourist. Don't expect that this will be some dream destination. Also, it is likely that you will find a lot of the aspects of the culture unpleasant such as: Sexism, racism, homophobia, lack of privacy, harrassment, bad hygiene practices, etc. Even the cuisine might not be to your taste. This is all part of cultural exchange. I think everyone knows this stuff to a degree before they join. But get rid of the expectation that you will be in some sort of paradise. I think everyone has that dream to a degree.
Sadly, you also can't always expect to go somewhere safe for you either. In my country, peace corps has put people with host families that were drunkards or violent. They have been slow to respond to requests for people to change houses to escape from stalkers and sexual assault. The bureaucracy can be overwhelming.
A lot of people online and in my cohort say that "the worst thing about peace corps is the peace corps itself." I completely agree with this. It might be better in other countries but in my country I am honestly ashamed to be a part of this organization.
Peace Corps seems far more interested in micromanaging the volunteers than in doing any sort of aid work. For example, there was a meeting with several town mayors and volunteers with the Peace corps. It would have been a wonderful opportunity to discuss projects. Overwhelmingly, the focus of the talk was on how volunteers were allowed to use their vacation days. The mayors took time away from their busy schedules to come learn how PC could help them in their community. Instead they were lectured on how they should report to PC about misuse of vacation days by volunteers. Which I might add, hadn't even been an issue. We even had to make skits about using vacation days. It seemed like a big waste of everyone's time.
People absolutely LOVE peace corps volunteers but every HCN I have met that has interacted with peace corps realizes that the organization is a joke. When it comes down to it, that makes sense. We aren't really here to do work, we are here to be American mascots. People love having an American live in their town and hang out with them even if that American and their organization isn't necessarily useful.
An example of PC's uselessness In my country is how they lost all of the records from past volunteers. Whenever we ask about past successful projects we get a shrug. Peace corps is NOT an effective development agency. If they were, they would have improved and learned from their mistakes over their decades of existence. Some people will say "they never were one" but they sure act like one when it looks good for them to. Peace Corps' main goal, in my opinion, is not to help the world, it is for the continued existence of peace corps. For this, they need to protect their reputation above all else. It is why they do crazy stuff like spirit away a director who ran over people while drunk driving.
PCs incompetence can also be dangerous! Probably PCs worst offense in my country was when our director banned volunteers from speaking to trainees. This was done because the trainees were very afraid after hearing warnings from current volunteers about sexual assaults and harrassment. Their excuse was that they hadn't had a chance to give the trainees a presentation about it yet. This made me completely lose my trust in PC. That they would censor this sort of information. Out cohort had the PC's presentation and it hadn't protected us.
Some people will say that they learned so much about themselves and about another culture. That is true! You can grow here a lot. Personally, I already knew how to live without amenities. Life here hasn't been too hard. The thing I learned was to appreciate my opportunities more and to appreciate my friends and family back home. This is a valuable lesson but I probably could have grown and learned it elsewhere. As for learning about another culture in a unique way I think that is very valuable and true! I dont regret joining because of that. My host country is magical and I have loved learning about it!
But do I feel like I need 2 years of cultural exchange here? Personally, I also want to do some fulfilling work. I think I might look for it elsewhere soon.
I don't write this to discourage you. Like I said, I don't regret joining. I just think it's important to take a long realistic look at yourself and your goals. It's easy to get swept up in this romantic idea that it will be this amazing life transforming experience. It could be. But if you want to spend 2 years in some natural paradise it's unlikely. If you want to help people and do meaningful work you might be disappointed. If you want to work for a competent development organization you might want to look elsewhere. If you want 2 years of unpaid self reflection and cultural exchange by all means do it!
EDIT: A lot of people said PC is not a development organization. They definitely advertise themselves as such and thrive off of that reputation. The only time I hear people say that peace corps is not a development agency is whenever it is accused of being bad at being a development agency. A lot of people brought up goals 2 and 3. Yes 2 and 3 are about cultural exchange but goal 1 is absolutely about development work. "to help the peoples of interested countries in meeting their need for trained men and women". I don't think Peace Corps does the best job at that and that is the reason for my post.
UPDATE: I still don’t regret my service. When rereading this I think it is still true and honest but maybe a bit harsh. Peace Corps was one of my life’s greatest adventures. It made a big impact on me even if the impact I made in my host country wasn’t huge. I still think about my host country all the time. I’d love to go back and do more in my own. I think PC does need to improve though.