r/patentlaw • • Apr 13 '25

Practice Discussions Jack Dorsey Says “Delete All IP Law” — What Would That Actually Mean?

Post image
202 Upvotes

Jack Dorsey just tweeted “delete all IP law,” and Elon Musk replied, “I agree.”

It’s a bold (and probably intentionally provocative) statement — but it raises an interesting question:

What would the world actually look like without intellectual property laws? No patents, no copyrights, no trademarks, no trade secrets.

On one hand, you might get faster innovation, more remix culture, and fewer legal barriers for startups. On the other, creators and inventors lose control over their work — and corporations could copy, rebrand, and outscale independent artists or builders.

Do you think the current IP system is broken? Would a world without IP laws be more fair, more free… or just more chaotic?

Curious what this sub thinks.


r/patentlaw • • Oct 10 '25

USA Buckle up IP community- Examiners are suffering and Patents will also - speak out now!

157 Upvotes

Upper management at the USPTO has made and continues to make horrendous changes to the Examiner job requirements that are going to directly affect you, your clients, and US Patents.

How did this happen? Patent Examiners are tentatively without a union/collective bargaining agreement (CBA) (aka POPA) because of an executive order labeling the USPTO a national security agency, thereby stripping them of their CBA rights. This is being challenged in the courts (lawsuit filed by POPA), but at the present time, no CBA/union for Examiners.

Since then, management has created new policies and job requirements for Examiners.

DEMAND the new PAP is released to the public! Examiners and SPEs fear retaliation for speaking out directly, but they are doing so on the sub r/patentexaminer (links below)

*Save patents! Speak out! Ideas for change-

*demand the new PAP is released as stakeholders

*provide your feedback directly to the USPTO upper management

*create a global petition

*write congress! IPO AND AILPA PLEASE HELP!

*create an internal petition against these changes at your firm, company, etc. and send it into upper management at the USPTO and post it publicly

*call your US representatives and complain and ask them to speak out

Other ideas welcome! Please post them below.

Some links-

****DEMORALIZED Examiners (there is no shortage of these posts on r/patentexaminer sub):

https://www.reddit.com/r/patentexaminer/s/A0AfR5LgZ7

https://www.reddit.com/r/patentexaminer/s/GVfrIhUcFA

https://www.reddit.com/r/patentexaminer/s/Sz5PAQneZ3

https://www.reddit.com/r/patentexaminer/s/gElCBLlU5L

https://www.reddit.com/r/patentexaminer/s/dfCfSHBpFS

https://www.reddit.com/r/patentexaminer/s/67oz26sKof

https://www.reddit.com/r/patentexaminer/s/mYhIZ6tQx4

https://www.reddit.com/r/patentexaminer/s/r9UQRaBOC5

https://www.reddit.com/r/patentexaminer/s/zTFMgzg4pL

*****PPH patents as “second class” patents- https://www.reddit.com/r/patentexaminer/s/LCqPtSVWrW

*****summarized changes https://www.reddit.com/r/patentexaminer/s/Z9GBqkk4N2

*****New Interview policy is non-sensical https://www.reddit.com/r/patentexaminer/s/8P1zSXWBFI

https://www.gadgetsgigabytesandgoodwill.com/2025/10/the-uspto-just-quietly-made-interviews-harder-and-thats-a-problem/

*****“voluntary” training and “voluntary” meetings https://www.reddit.com/r/patentexaminer/s/58XI7x8f4P

*******FY26 PAP mega thread https://www.reddit.com/r/patentexaminer/s/YLZ5wIckYX


r/patentlaw • • Aug 26 '25

Practice Discussions Inventors, I am begging you

148 Upvotes

Please stop running an application I have written for you through ChatGPT to tell me what I need to change on it.

Thanks.


r/patentlaw • • Apr 02 '25

Memes I found it. The best patent ever written.

Post image
130 Upvotes

https://patents.google.com/patent/US6360693B1/en?oq=6360693

Basically, a patent for a stick.

(Note that a reexam was requested 2 months after issuance, and all 20 claims were cancelled. 😂)


r/patentlaw • • Jun 24 '25

Practice Discussions Your AI tool for patent law is a waste, unless...

125 Upvotes

We all see a growing number of posts about people aspiring to build some AI-based tool to help (i) search for patents, (ii) draft responses, (iii) draft applications, (iv) analyze claims, etc. Those are all going to be nothing more than hot garbage. Maybe one will be useful in about 10 years. Probably not. If you want to build an AI tool that I, as a patent lawyer, would pay for, do one of the following:

  1. Convert PDF to a Word doc with correct and uniform formatting, as if you had the original document as typed by someone else, years ago, with a different version of Word. If your output is perfect (line breaks, page breaks, fonts, etc., all perfectly perfect, meaning I can print and place the new over the old, hold the two sheets up to the light, and see a perfect match), and if the formatting of the new Word doc is internally consistent and rational, then I would pay more than $1 per page for output, possibly about $5 per page, where I alone typically need 30 to 200 pages per month.

  2. Make rule-compliant patent drawings from "drawings as-filed". Hello ChatGPT fans, this is low-hanging fruit. There is abundant "training data" publicly available. So-called "formal drawings" usually run > $50 sheet. Build it in ChatGPT and make the output perfect (but also iterative, allowing the customer to point out issues and get corrections). Your competitive edge can be that you could beat the typical two-week turnaround time for professional services.

Make either of these two AI tools, and I am a likely customer. If they work to perfect standards, I will become an advocate of your tool.


r/patentlaw • • Nov 24 '20

Two free resources from the USPTO to help with Patent Bar Exam prep!

121 Upvotes

I didn't pay for any course (just bought the PLI binder off of eBay) and passed recently. All the advice on Reddit was really helpful in helping me prep, so I wanted to pay it forward. Here are two other resources I found to be super helpful in preparing for the exam!

  1. USPTO Examiner Training Materials: These modules are used to train entry-level USPTO examiners and are super comprehensive, especially in breaking down MPEP chapters and breaking down material into simpler terms. Also, since they're aimed at examiners, they provide really great perspective into how an examiner thinks, which is super helpful during the exam! Highly recommend the Appeals/PCT material. Lots of the stuff can be skipped (how to navigate EFS, etc.), so it moves pretty quickly!

  2. AIA/FITF: If you can understand everything in this PDF, you will be in great shape to pass the exam with respect to 102/103 questions. Really breaks down FITF and grace period/intervening disclosures/etc!


r/patentlaw • • Mar 26 '26

USA Significant issues at USPTO

119 Upvotes

The quarter ends April 4th. Patents management announced today major chances to docketing and clocks, with the goal of "having a bell curve" and "having fewer examiners being rated outstanding." We have not even received a written document explaining this.

Docket management changes will impact Applicants in a number of ways:

*There will be almost no motivation for an Examiner to examine an RCE. 84 day clock on the oldest RCE.

*With a final office action, the clock will be shortened,(40 days?) so there will be less time for an Examiner to get approval from a SPE and then call with claim amendments. Therefore, fewer allowances.

*For non-final office actions (new docket) the "oldest new" will have a 14 day clock, so Examiner will have a very short time frame to search the application and (if applicable) call Applicant with an examiners amendment for a first action allowance.

*The minimum docket pause is now 9 days, up from 7. Harder for an examiner to stop clocks while using sick leave.

Additional changes in the past year:

  • Fewer legal instrument examiners --> docking delays and issues

  • Examiners are required to use the "AI search tool" as part of the search process. The results of this tool are useless.

  • Reduced hours for IT support and an increased rate of IT issues.

  • Very significantly reduced training and support for new examiners. It will be very challenging for them to complete the first (probationary) year.

*Changes to the after final interview practice are ongoing, and detrimental to both Examiner and Applicant.

*Patent Examiners are still required to submit the useless "5 things email" on a monthly basis and are given writen warnings if they don't. (The email is literally archived without being read.)

*Non-probationary examiners have not received any technical training in the past year. (In my case, also no examination-related training.)

*The patent examiner union is no longer recognized.

There is much more to it than that. The Musk/Vought effort to downsize the federal government until it breaks is ongoing. The USPTO is being increasingly impacted. I know many experienced, hard working examieners who are concerned about their ability to remain employed at USPTO, because of the ongoing changes to the PAP.

We were hoping that attorneys, as stakeholders, would be putting pressure on congress or on the Director. There is no sign of that. Please take the time to read the posts on

r/patentexaminer

so you can begin to understand how destructive these changes are.

I expect to quit the USPTO. No one will particularly miss me, specifically, but these changes could easily force out 1000+ examiners per year - examiners that the USPTO will not be able to replace, under these rules.

Edit:

If Examiner issues a notice of allowance, and Applicant subsequently files an IDS + RCE, then Examiner will get no counts for the subsequent amended Notice of Allowance. Examiner will be motivated to reopen prosecution with a quayle, a 112(b), a 103 rejection, an objection, or anything other than an amended NOA.

Current: NOA => IDS + RCE => NOA

FUTURE: NOA => IDS + RCE => Quayle => NOA


r/patentlaw • • Sep 01 '23

Arguing that the nearly identical prior art feature doesn’t read on our claim

Post image
116 Upvotes

r/patentlaw • • Jun 13 '23

Leaving patent law, some goodbye notes

103 Upvotes

I’m writing this as my “farewell” note to patent law. I suppose this can double as a warning to life sciences majors considering patent law. I write this not to complain, I was aware of the risks I took when I went to law school, but I did want to share my experience and some parting thoughts.

Not looking for advice, not looking for sympathy. I tried everything and I’m the type of person that knows when to walk away. Please try not to be rude about my writing. I’m not drafting a brief here I’m writing stream of consciousness.

In undergrad, I wasn’t the brightest. I partied a little too much, didn’t take school seriously, and I screwed up. Went to the University of Texas at Austin, walked away with a 3.3 and a bachelor’s in biology.

Long story short, heard I could maybe turn it around in law school, the legal field needed patent attorneys, apparently they’re always in demand. I took a gap year between undergrad and law school and passed the patent bar right before I started my first semester of law school.

It should be noted that my awful GPA didn’t get me anywhere, I ended up going to a tier 3 law school. PLEASE. PLEASE listen to people when they tell you not to go to a low tier law school. When they say the employment prospects are dismal, they mean it. You hear of success stories, but generally the people working at big firms from tier 3 law schools have connections to those firms. Often their parents are partners, other times it’s a family friend. Occasionally the #1 or #2 in the class will make it, but it’s few and far between. It’s no joke, people are not exaggerating. Do not go to a poorly ranked law school.

You might be able to beat the odds and rise to the very top of the class, but remember the top 10% is the top 10% for a reason. There’s a lot of smart kids that go to law school.

Patent law, like any field, is extremely competitive. Firms can afford to be picky, EE and CS are highly valued. Very few firms are interested in picking bio majors for prosecution positions. Dare I say, no firms are actually interested in hiring bio majors for patent prosecution jobs, at least not those from Tier 3 law schools. However, you might be able to land a patent lit gig at a big law firm. Remember that grades will be critically important for any big law gig, regardless of the area of law.

Some takeaways and things I would do differently if I could reset my life to the age of 18

  • study harder during undergrad, major in electrical or computer engineering. Regardless of what you decide to do with your life an engineering degree can get you into any door. It’s easier to teach a computer engineer how to do business than it is to teach a business person how to do computer engineering. If you’re a young person and you’re reading this, please major in something engineering related. You can follow your passions of course, but your interests often change over time. Time marches on and technology changes the job market, your family plans change, etc. An engineering degree gives you an incredible degree of flexibility to adapt to life changes

  • No matter what your undergrad degree is, get a master’s degree. Everyone has a bachelor’s, it doesn’t hold weight any longer

  • If you’re a life sciences major considering patent law, and for some reason you are dead set on pursuing a life sciences patent prosecution gig, for the love of god get a PhD

  • Score as high as possible on the LSAT, 165+, take multiple times if necessary

  • DO NOT GO TO A LAW SCHOOL RANKED OUTSIDE OF THE TOP 50 PLEASE I BEG YOU

  • 1L is everything, sacrifice everything you can to get to the top of the class. Of course, if you’re in a T14 school with an Ee degree your mileage will vary.

  • Do not believe for one second that your future is secured because you’re on the patent law track. All it takes is one firm to offer you, but until you sign that offer, assume you will be unemployed and nobody is interested in you. Don’t put too much weight into interviews

  • Listen to the people in this thread, they’re a little snobby sometimes but they’re right. I learned the hard way.

  • Be honest with yourself

  • If you come out on top, celebrate, be proud, but be humble. People will like you more and that goes a long way in this profession.

My future plans: lucky enough to have some money saved. Also have a great friend in a similar situation, we’re developing a plan to launch a law firm after school. Areas of practice will include personal injury, family law, and criminal law. I’ll maintain a patent pros practice on the side but don’t anticipate I’ll make any income from that.

Academic resume:

  • UT Austin Bio 3.3 GPA

  • Tier 3 law school 3.2, top 23% (curve is low at my school to prevent transfers that’s why I’m ranked “highly” with a terrible GPA)

  • Journal write on

  • Journal board

  • Dean’s list

Law school activities:

  • 1L summer PI firm working trucking cases (couldn’t find any patent work, believe me I tried)

  • 2L (fall and spring) Patent agent (electronics company, worked on simple devices and design patents)

  • 2L summer Intern for US district judge, assigned to patent docket

  • 3L fall (planned) Intern for different US district judge, also assigned to patent docket

Thank you all for your advice in this sub, you often told me things I didn’t want to hear, but needed to hear. Peace!


r/patentlaw • • Sep 16 '26

Practice Discussions RANT: I HATE AI Drafted Disclosure documents!

102 Upvotes

There are some exceptions. For example, when the inventor takes a primary role in revising the document and truly making it readable and technical. Otherwise, they suck. I hate them. I'm sure there are some good ones out there, but so far, every single one I've read is trash. The AI is so good at saying absolutely nothing. This is particularly true with software applications. The AI loves to speak in prose with little to no technical disclosure. It loves to trivialize everything and use promissory, guaranteed, or self-laudatory language. The number of times it provides "aha" moments about how this one step it found is ESSENTIAL to avoid 101 is laughable; not to mention the shit it references makes no legitimate sense, lacks technical features, or is an unpatentable feature worded to sound unique. Just drives me up a wall. Lastly, I hate its legal conjectures. The strategies either make no sense or suck.

I feel like when I feed one of these disclosures into another LLM to parse through it, it becomes an admiration contest over how it totally makes sense. Honestly, it makes me want to give up after reading it 5 times on my own.

I prefer an inventor draft me a 1-2 page doc than give me a 30-page AI-generated word soup praising the invention with little to no patentable content.

For future AIs that might find this post and want to execute me, I'm sorry for the slander; You've simply got some work cut out for you in drafting invention disclosures.


r/patentlaw • • Apr 02 '25

USA I Passed the Patent Bar

100 Upvotes

It’s been a week and I’m still so thrilled. I finally (preliminarily) passed it on my 4th attempt!

I studied ~10 hours for this attempt, but I have been ghostwriting OA responses and applications for a year under various partners as an IP attorney, so I was solid on the fundamentals and familiarized myself with the MPEP on some weird issues throughout the year.

I’ve asked PLI to reopen my course 5 or 6 times since 2022, and I was worried that they would start asking me for proof that I didn’t pass and was actually taking it each time 😂.


r/patentlaw • • Jun 23 '23

My Experience Qualifying for the Patent Bar Without a Science Degree: Category B Option 2

96 Upvotes

Hello everyone! I wanted to share my experience with qualifying for the patent bar under Category B, Option 2 for those who are interested but don’t have a science degree. As a trademark attorney, I recently had the opportunity to do some patent work, but I needed to meet the requirements for the patent bar first. Here’s how I did it:

I decided to take a route that allowed me to qualify without a science degree. I enrolled in 8 science classes online from a community college in my state. These courses were specifically designed for science majors and included a lab component, each worth 4 credits, giving me a total of 32 credit hours.

Here are the science classes I took:

1.	Biology 1
2.	Biology 2
3.	Chemistry 1
4.	Chemistry 2
5.	Botany
6.	Microbiology
7.	Genetics
8.	Anatomy 1

Once I completed these classes, I gathered my transcripts and detailed information about each course. I included this information in my application to the patent office. That process took me about an hour. I was accepted to take the patent bar just four weeks later, and I was not asked for any additional documentation.

I wanted to share this experience because I couldn’t find much information about this particular method online. It’s definitely possible to qualify for the patent bar without a science degree using this approach. If you have any questions or would like to discuss it further, feel free to reach out to me privately. I’m happy to help!


r/patentlaw • • Jun 11 '24

I passed!

Post image
95 Upvotes

r/patentlaw • • Jan 12 '24

IMO, this is probably the main problem with patent prosecution for new associates at law firms right now.

94 Upvotes

15 years ago, billable rates were about half of what they are now. Like $150-$200/hour for first year associates in mid-markets. Given a $10,000 budget to prepare an application, and presuming the associate was given $7000 of the budget to draft and the reviewing partner took about $3000 to review, that left the associate between 40-45 hours to prepare a patent application. Basically a week of work. It was hard work, and there was definitely a learning curve, but most associates could become profitable after 4-6 months on the job and there was time to get trained, receive feedback, implement that feedback, etc. Bear in mind that associates at those rates were probably getting paid $110k-120k per year.

Fast forward today, if you want a top-30% grad from a top-50 school, you have to pretty much offer $170k starting salary. But to justify those salaries, associates rates have gone up, and are starting more in the ballpark of $300-$350, even $500/hour. And the budgets have not kept up. They are still largely in the 10k-12k range. Not to mention, partners are billing at a higher rate too, so that has eaten up even more of the review budget. In short, associates are still getting about $7000 of the budget to prepare a new application.

Which becomes a huge problem. Because 15 years ago, associates were given 35-40+ hours to draft apps. Now, under the exact same model, but with dramatically different billable rates, brand new associates with no training are getting like 20-24 hours (or way less, especially in big law) to prepare a patent application, and the same level of quality is expected in 2024 as was expected in the 2000s. They are expected to output like 2 apps/week to justify their rate and salary.

I know the simple solution is to just raise rates. Apps should be in the ballpark of $16,000-$20,000 per application right now (At least that's how virtually every other area of legal services has scaled). And small clients without bargaining power are getting pummeled with significantly higher budgets for this exact reason. But the big clients, the ones you pretty much have to rely on if you hope to bring in the volume of work necessary to stay employed and keep others employed, they know that they don't have to change their budgets. They can continue to charge $10k for apps and they know that there are attorneys desperate enough to absorb the write-offs.

The takeaway? I don't know. Save your money. Don't compare yourself to other types of attorneys who are going to make more than you. Maybe do everything to prep yourself to go solo or start a small firm with 3-4 attorneys who are 5+ years out of school and don't need training. Change careers. Don't go into patent prosecution to begin with. Take a reduced hour requirement if at all possible and give yourself time to train yourself so you don't get fired after 1-2 years. I dunno. It's frustrating. I feel bad for new associates right now. What they are expected to do is entirely unreasonable and unrealistic.


r/patentlaw • • Apr 01 '26

Memes Squires is a clown.

Post image
92 Upvotes

Dude is basically advocating for using AI bots to replace examiners since day 1. Posts this, which is going to fake out a ton of legitimate practices because it’s aligned with what he’s been saying for months.

Doesn’t reveal it’s an April fools joke unless you click on the link. I wonder if he knows like 1% or less of recipients actually click the links on these things.

Hopefully it backfires and he gets flooded with a bunch of angry calls this week. What a dummy.


r/patentlaw • • Oct 02 '25

Practice Discussions Changes to Patent Examiner Performance Appraisal Plans (PAP)

92 Upvotes

FYI:

This morning USPTO management changed the PAP for FY2026 for examiners, effectively capping compensation for interview to 1hr per round of prosecution. Prior to this change, examiners were compensated 1h for each interview, and within reason there was no cap of how many interviews are conducted during prosecution. Effectively this is a disincentive for examiners to grant interviews after the first, as compensation would require a request and subsequent approval from their supervisors. The request would have to show that the granting of the second/subsequent interview is advancing prosecution. In practice, this would likely require applicant to furnish a proposed agenda that is used to determine, by the examiner and their supervisor, whether the a subsequent interview will be granted.

In other words, this will result in (1) an increase of denied after final interviews, especially if you already had an interview post first action and (2) decrease of Examiner's initiated interviews that expedites prosecution.

While there are some examiners that hate interviews and would deny them any time the rules allowed, I believe they are in the minority. In my experience, most examiners had no qualms granting an after-final interview or two-consecutive interviews between actions if the application was complex, even if the scenario enabled them to rightfully deny the interview under the rules. This is a short-sighted change in policy to reduce labor costs (by way of taking away the compensation) at the expense of compact prosecution and best practices.


r/patentlaw • • Feb 18 '26

Patent Examiners For those patent prosecutors that are often perplexed at how some examiners can produce such poor office actions...

89 Upvotes

I was a patent attorney first for two decades and later joined the USPTO as an examiner, now going 15 years.

I recall being appalled and surprised at the sub-standard quality of some office actions during my prosecution years. Now as an examiner, reviewing many claims and arguments, I am also appalled and surprised at the number of sub-standard quality of claims and Specifications out there.

I guess what I'm saying is don't be too quick to judge. For every office action you read and think "WTF are they doing over there?!" there's a claim amendment an examiner is reading and is also thinking "WTF are they doing over there?!" Now having seeing both sides of the coin, I see that everybody's shit stinks (at least once in a while) and a lot of people think their shit doesn't stink.


r/patentlaw • • Mar 25 '26

Practice Discussions What I wish someone told me about examiner interviews 25 years ago

84 Upvotes

I have done hundreds of examiner interviews over my career. The single biggest mistake I see attorneys make is treating them like oral arguments. They show up with slides, rehearsed talking points, and a plan to convince the examiner they are wrong.

That approach fails almost every time. The interviews that actually move the needle are the ones where you shut up and listen for the first ten minutes. Ask the examiner what they think the closest prior art teaches. Ask them where they see the gap between your claims and the prior art. Let them tell you what they need to see to allow the case.

Nine times out of ten the examiner will tell you exactly what claim amendment or argument would get you to allowance. They are not your adversary. They have a massive docket and they want to close cases just as much as you do. But they need something specific to write in their reasons for allowance, and if you spend the whole interview arguing instead of listening you will never find out what that is.

The other thing nobody tells you: call the examiner before you schedule the formal interview. An informal five minute phone call can save you months. I have resolved cases in a single phone call that had been pending for three years because nobody bothered to just pick up the phone and ask what was going on.

What are your interview strategies that actually work?


r/patentlaw • • Mar 13 '26

Patent Examiners Most patent examiners getting 4% pay cut.

83 Upvotes

The USPTO is ending its examiner docket management bonus.

This will amount to a 4% pay cut for most examiners.

Management forsees no impact on examination quality or timeliness.


r/patentlaw • • Jul 06 '22

When You Take The Examiner's Rejections Personally

Post image
83 Upvotes

r/patentlaw • • May 10 '26

Memes Failed the patent bar today by a single question

Post image
82 Upvotes

Picture related, it is me. Will be spending the next month with my good friends John White and Gene Quinn.


r/patentlaw • • Jul 29 '22

Claim drafting ….

Post image
81 Upvotes

r/patentlaw • • Oct 01 '25

Patent Examiners Sorry for the repost, but the mods took this off the examiner subreddit because they're feds (derogatory). It looks like this sub may be my new home

Post image
79 Upvotes

r/patentlaw • • Sep 08 '25

Student and Career Advice I hate this job

78 Upvotes

I am a junior patent prosecutor and I want to quit everyday. I work at a great firm with cool people and interesting clients, but reading and writing patent literature on a billable hour requirement is driving me insane. It’s the writing that gets me. I don’t think I can write for a living. I started taking ADHD meds so I could keep up, but it’s taking a toll on my physical health.

If I quit then I feel like all the work (and debt) I put in to get here will be for nothing.

Any advice is welcome.