The quarter ends April 4th. Patents management announced today major chances to docketing and clocks, with the goal of "having a bell curve" and "having fewer examiners being rated outstanding." We have not even received a written document explaining this.
Docket management changes will impact Applicants in a number of ways:
*There will be almost no motivation for an Examiner to examine an RCE. 84 day clock on the oldest RCE.
*With a final office action, the clock will be shortened,(40 days?) so there will be less time for an Examiner to get approval from a SPE and then call with claim amendments. Therefore, fewer allowances.
*For non-final office actions (new docket) the "oldest new" will have a 14 day clock, so Examiner will have a very short time frame to search the application and (if applicable) call Applicant with an examiners amendment for a first action allowance.
*The minimum docket pause is now 9 days, up from 7. Harder for an examiner to stop clocks while using sick leave.
Additional changes in the past year:
Fewer legal instrument examiners --> docking delays and issues
Examiners are required to use the "AI search tool" as part of the search process. The results of this tool are useless.
Reduced hours for IT support and an increased rate of IT issues.
Very significantly reduced training and support for new examiners. It will be very challenging for them to complete the first (probationary) year.
*Changes to the after final interview practice are ongoing, and detrimental to both Examiner and Applicant.
*Patent Examiners are still required to submit the useless "5 things email" on a monthly basis and are given writen warnings if they don't. (The email is literally archived without being read.)
*Non-probationary examiners have not received any technical training in the past year. (In my case, also no examination-related training.)
*The patent examiner union is no longer recognized.
There is much more to it than that. The Musk/Vought effort to downsize the federal government until it breaks is ongoing. The USPTO is being increasingly impacted. I know many experienced, hard working examieners who are concerned about their ability to remain employed at USPTO, because of the ongoing changes to the PAP.
We were hoping that attorneys, as stakeholders, would be putting pressure on congress or on the Director. There is no sign of that. Please take the time to read the posts on
r/patentexaminer
so you can begin to understand how destructive these changes are.
I expect to quit the USPTO. No one will particularly miss me, specifically, but these changes could easily force out 1000+ examiners per year - examiners that the USPTO will not be able to replace, under these rules.
Edit:
If Examiner issues a notice of allowance, and Applicant subsequently files an IDS + RCE, then Examiner will get no counts for the subsequent amended Notice of Allowance. Examiner will be motivated to reopen prosecution with a quayle, a 112(b), a 103 rejection, an objection, or anything other than an amended NOA.
Current: NOA => IDS + RCE => NOA
FUTURE: NOA => IDS + RCE => Quayle => NOA