r/paranatural • • Nov 09 '18

halfway through hiatus and can't stop thinking about spender </3 we gotta get more spender content

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/paranatural • • Jul 25 '18

Half baked theory time :)

3 Upvotes

So, maybe Dimitri and Isabel are siblings and after their parents died (or whatever happened) they lived with their divorced grandparents, Isabel with the grandfather and Dim with the Grandmother. You know what, im probably high on orange juice right now so NAAAAAHH.


r/paranatural • • Oct 27 '24

Went back to grab this panel for a friend and. Lisa's outfit feels rather specific except it CAN'T be because Digital Circus came out FIVE YEARS after this page so why does it WORK

Post image
22 Upvotes

r/paranatural • • Sep 19 '24

Paranatural ROYGBIV Strawpoll: RED (two votes each)

Thumbnail
strawpoll.com
3 Upvotes

r/paranatural • • May 19 '17

Is it fair to say that paranatural rivals homestuck?

0 Upvotes

r/paranatural • • Aug 19 '18

Rereading Paranatural, surprised to find that Max is disgustingly callous on this page.

Thumbnail
paranatural.net
9 Upvotes

r/paranatural • • May 19 '20

he do be lookin kinda cute tho

Post image
33 Upvotes

r/paranatural • • Jan 15 '21

Man so uh. Chapter six guys. (Sad self-reflection post) NSFW

21 Upvotes

Kindve hits different after the Jan 6 riot and learning about QAnon....

I just wanted to read the Cute Doggy story again, not trigger PTSD


r/paranatural • • May 20 '17

This is probably controversial...but I have very conflicted feelings about Chapter 5 Page 104.

10 Upvotes

Hi there. I honestly feel pretty awkward writing such a big text post, since this account's pretty new and made to solely post here...but I had something that was really bugging me for a long time (should've said this the day the page came out, but I didn't notice anything amiss back then and when I eventually did, my points needed well fleshing out and enough proof to back up) and I wanted to let it out of my system.

You know how there's that one page where Isaac is explicitly established to be 13 or Grade 8? I have two very conflicting feelings about that page. First off, brace yourselves for the skeptical side of me to come in...:

THE BAD

I. Execution: it came out of frickin' nowhere

Why establish Isaac's age now in this chapter and not back when the core protagonists were introduced in Chapter 1? Why just this one page to tell us he's 13, when we barely even see his class for just one page? (Isaac might just as well be in the same grade as Max et al but with different schedules!) The page feels like a jump scare in exposition form: shocking, yes, but also annoying as it came out of nowhere. At least for, say, Isaac's preference for vegetables, you could conclude to that from minor yet reasonable details...but that page was really bewildering and out of field. TVTropes has a more coarser term for that. I could argue that page even stalls the story flow and it doesn't really need to be there... [See page order without P104 for comparison]

Even the supposedly justifying exposition felt not very convincing...

Max: "I'm sorry, it's just...that explains so much. The angst, the mood swings, the smell..."

Really? The mood swings are just because of his age, and not because of his Consortium-hazard weather spirit that he hosts? The angst is because "that's what 8th graders do" and not because of being impacted by Spender's negligent and secretive behavior? It's wasted ambiguity and intrigue that's being thrown out the window as implied by the dialogue, that's all I'm saying. Besides, the exchange sounded to me like an unfunny "OMG ur one of those gross mythical Teenagers i see in cartoons" joke (think Kids Next Door's comically demonizing view of teenagers), which is really grasping at straws when Max should be aware that he's in a middle school. Where 13-year olds are supposed to go to too. And you're the one to talk about being a brooding guy, Max.

II. Less believable team dynamics

You see, groups of characters that are the main focal point of stories taking place in schools tend to be of the same age range because they get to met and interact with one another in the same period, and everyone's taking on the same plan at the same time when the plot desires. Thus, how the main gang from Recess or the Fenton-Foley-Manson trio of Danny Phantom tend to be of the same age for example. I don't see any comics or cartoons taking place in schools that have protagonist groups so diverse in age, do they?

It's challenging enough that Max happens to be at certain classes as Isabel and Ed due to what the school administration organized for his schedule. Having Isaac as part of a group that really doesn't interact with people younger than their group (because higher priorities) is really pushing too hard. It almost throws away the willing suspension of disbelief for me personally: one of the driving forces of Paranatural as whole is how a spirit-hunting middle school group has to work together albeit not so intertwined friendships to protect the school from spectral shenanigans...how are we suppose to believe that they're really a legit team even as dysfunctional as they are when they're not able to interact with each other wholly due to not being at the same grade?

And now, for the optimistic side:

THE GOOD

I. Possible further exploration into the Mayview Middle School setting

Should Zack be able to exploit on this page cleverly (especially when that one page made that bit of information as such a big deal), we might have a chance of arcs that involve spectral shenanigans menacing kids of the same grade as him. Heck, why not go even further and delve into the sixth graders since we never even hear about them so far. It will be sort of interesting further explorations into the setting of Mayview Middle School beyond Max's class. Like, I feel it very jarring and wonky that almost all of the school students that are in the limelight, normal or spectral, so far are of the same age except for Isaac...at least the additional demographic from other grades will bring some variety into the school environment if Zack expands upon this potential well (of course, as long as it doesn't bloat the big story, that would be alright). Emphasis on if...it's all up to Zack if he wants to pull it off.

In relation to that, we might have a better understanding to Isaac's point of view and behavior: This especially so with stuff outside the paranatural as he interacts with his normal classmates and teachers. Only then we'll get why he gets so jumpy and cocky, as we see of him. (I refuse to believe that he acts so flippantly due to age, or that he is supposedly brooding because his animes told him to...there must be another side to his story.)

Well, I've let it all out. I am deeply sorry if my writing had really riled up everyone here. I have no intentions whatsoever to discredit Zack, his work or his readers. Heck, I really appreciate this gem of a webcomic. It's just that those bad nitpicks especially has really pressed hard on my head for a long time, I needed some place to really vent this. I'm just so puzzled by this page for its inconsistency and I really want clear answers from it...t'is all.

Have any rebukes / counterarguments on the "Bad"? Were my "Good" points feasible? Feel free to reply with that. I've probably shared some of the points in this post with the people back at Tumblr and 4chan (I like hearing from views of all sorts), but I wanna hear from you guys here at Reddit too. Again, I apologize if I ever sounded rude to you all...I'm just so confused.


r/paranatural • • May 04 '26

Why did Mina gain weight?

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

Not that there’s anything wrong with it, of course, but why exactly was our girl pleasantly plump in chapter 7? I don’t believe that was ever elaborated on.

Edit: I know it’s a flashback lol

Edit 2: I think some people here don’t understand. I’m not asking why Zack made her fat. What he chooses to do with his characters is his decision alone. What I’m asking for is an in-universe explanation as to why she’s wonderfully big.


r/paranatural • • Feb 16 '23

Quick Question

7 Upvotes

I haven't been keeping up with the comic lately, but is the comic ever going to be a comic again, or has it full committed to the storybook approach? I thought it was just going to be for a portion of the flashback story.


r/paranatural • • Mar 18 '19

did zach die D:

0 Upvotes

f


r/paranatural • • Aug 22 '18

LEFTY BELONGS TO HOOK-HAND DAD

18 Upvotes

http://www.paranatural.net/comic/chapter-5-page-292

http://www.paranatural.net/comic/chapter-5-page-283

Hook-hand-car-man-doors left hand is missing. Lefty is... well... a disembodied left hand. I wonder if PJ has any connections to the vampire family?

I'm seeing the matrix, u guise.


r/paranatural • • Jul 29 '15

wow guys this is getting pretty spooky jeez

Thumbnail
imgur.com
8 Upvotes

r/paranatural • • Jul 30 '15

Not the best at this, but I did catch onto some of those DBZ references

Thumbnail
goldfisharmada.deviantart.com
4 Upvotes

r/paranatural • • Feb 15 '15

What do I even say to this...

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/paranatural • • Feb 15 '16

I can't into emotes please help

4 Upvotes

r/paranatural • • Jun 13 '15

ColabHQ's Let's Read Paranatural project continues! (Chapter 1, Part 3)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
4 Upvotes

r/paranatural • • Sep 28 '17

A reader off Tumblr proposes something serious: Isaac is going through emotional abuse - particularly "gaslighting" - by the Club.

14 Upvotes

Archived here and here...any thoughts on this?


r/paranatural • • Jun 06 '14

[Modpost]: Don't downvote relevant posts (i.e. Page Links).

5 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I think it should go without saying, but downvotes should only be used for content that is not relevant to the subreddit. They aren't for disagreements or for pushing down posts from people you don't like. We don't have a whole lot of subscribers or upvoters in general, so every downvote, especially on relevant links, can have a lot of impact.

Please think before you hit that blue arrow, everyone. Next update is on normal schedule.


r/paranatural • • Oct 06 '17

Meanwhile at 4chan: an anon calculates how much time Zack would take to finish 20 (unconfirmed?) chapters of Paranatural with the current page update rate.

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/paranatural • • Nov 09 '17

Omfg this was a fucking guy.

Thumbnail
imgur.com
26 Upvotes

r/paranatural • • May 26 '15

"Our love will burn bright!" - Forge/Spender slash comic by Taylor Carilli (Zack's GF, "Monsterkind" author), now in a more coherent arrangement!

Thumbnail
imgur.com
6 Upvotes

r/paranatural • • Jan 01 '16

JOHNNY IS A SPECTRAL?!?!?!?!

6 Upvotes

Read today's comic, I totally called this one!