UPDATED with responses, 3pmish EST # I'll check back again in a bit and try and do another round.
We need to come together. There are a number of reasons why many of the proposals made so far are or should be unattractive to the developer. It is my concern that a diverse set of suggestions will only lead us around in the same circles we've been running. The following is, in my opinion, the best path forward. Is is my hope that I can get this post to find strong support from the playerbase, and that Epic will see the strength of this support, and take the following steps:
Original Posts Here: https://www.epicgames.com/paragon/forums/news/announcements/837881-an-open-discussion-on-where-we-re-at?p=838024#post838024
Why I'm reposting this in a more accessible format than: https://www.reddit.com/r/paragon/comments/7qx3x6/stepbystep_guide_to_costeffectively_getting_this/?ref=share&ref_source=link I found a good an okay formatting guide
[...]Sevrahn makes several good points in his post, but more than anything, you need to recognize that content, not cosmetics, will be what grows your game. Absolutely the best idea of his is to add additional game modes. Seriously. Like Yesterday.
You already have the assets to do so! Here, I'll show you. The following is a clear outline for the steps to take to cost-efficiently jumpstart the growth of your player base:
OUTLINE
Repurpose whatever version of legacy is easiest to implement into a "MOST COMPLEX" Mode which shoots to draw competitive players and provide 45-1 hour matches. You can use everything that is in place now on that map and call it a day. Seriously, you can leave the harvesters there, take them out, whatever requires you the least cost/manpower. I promise you the playerbase will be better for it in the long run. Put New OP where Old OP was and Put Fangtooth where the raptor/ black buff was. Boom. Done. Now you have a draw for competitive players / "try-hards".
Repurpose monolith into a faster "THIS PORRIDGE IS JUST RIGHT" Mode, that is more or less how it is at the moment. (can change teal/aqua buff back to another gold buff and just let it be a smaller competitive 5v5 gamemode aimed at shorter times (15-30), with asymmetrical lanes to foster that.) Seriously, don't even need to change anything. Boom, done. Now you have a draw for weekend-pros / "competitive-casuals".
Take the tutorial map, and use it to create a 3v3, "we have One Lane" mode, aimed at 10-15 minute games. Boom, done.
I know what you're saying to yourselves: "This is ridiculous, even if we could get this going, our now meager playerbase spread across three modes would be our death knell!"
Bear with me here, but all you have to do to make this work is. . . .
4) Create separate queues for each of these modes;
5) Allow people to queue for any number of these three modes at once; and
6) ALLOW PEOPLE TO CREATE CUSTOM GAMES IN ANY MODE WITH LESS THAN THE FULL AMOUNT OF PLAYERS (Make us fill wit A.I. or let us leave slots empty, or hell, both! Doesn't Matter.)
7) Sit back. Seriously. Trust me. Let the Garden Grow. Announce that the team will be gone for a month while the community adjusts to the changes. Let them all go mess with fortnite. Sit back for a month, and then come back and see where things are at. I promise you will have more players, and more DAUs.
8) Then, at this point, make a note of what needs balancing. In balancing, consider that maybe things like (hey this character is easy to use ahem Morigeshahem) and (hey this character can stunlock another player AhemSteelahem*) Should be factors that weigh against those characters being able to do similar impacts to the game as more complex or difficult characters (ahemoldHowieoldSeverOGahem).
[You might not have noticed, but at almost all levels of player skill, players find it less obnoxious to be completely worked over by an enemy hero who requires finesse and skill, than one who just had a kit full of auto-locks and I win cause HERO].
9) Add THREE CARDS. 1) a team wide purify (white) 2) a passive card that makes you immune to stuns for six seconds after you have been hit with a stun (green) 3) an active card than makes you immune to stuns for the next ten seconds.
10) Take another month. Sit back. Watch as . . .what!? The Player base is growing even more!?
11) At the end of that month, have an AMA with the development team, direction team, whathaveyou, where a couple of managers high up the development chain discuss the state of the game openly with the playerbase. Hell, bring in a business guy or a number cruncher. We understand that you're in this for the money. We're in this for the entertainment. We can both help each other get what we want.
12) Take in the feedback. Bring the Paragon team into a conference room and determine by general consensus which balance and new card suggestions seem: 1) Cost effective, 2) Necessary to balance gameplay, 3) Easy to implement, 4) Like Fun ideas (in that order). Maybe put the top FIFTY (or less) suggestions on a white board.
13) THEN, I know this is crazy, but stick with me. Use the survey system you already have pop up at the end of some matches. Have it pop up the first time ANYONE completes a game and run it for a week, maybe two weeks. Have it explain that you are trying to improve the game, and ask players if they are willing to take a survey for that. Have willing players pick their top 3 of the 20 (or less, idk what you'd end up with) things that they would want you to add to the game.
14) After two weeks, compile the data, get everyone back into that damn conference room, and discuss. Take the minutes.
15) Make a forum post, posting the minutes (after review and redaction by legal as necessary) and asking for feedback. Ask responding parties to provide an explanation of why they agree or disagree about whatever.
16) Let it sit for a week.
17) Take in the top rated comments, get everyone back into the damn conference room for third f***ing time and discuss what you as a team are going to do. (seriously, if it is just one manager talking over everyone and then deciding that the team is wrong, that's not going to work, and there's enough about the history here that suggests this has already happened to some extent).
18) Then, post your conclusions and findings in the community. Explain that _____ is where you think we should go from here, and that ____ and _____ are the reasons you think that. SHOW YOUR MATH. Let the community be your sounding board and give them the opportunity to head you off at the pass if you start heading in the wrong direction.
19) After things settle out a little. Start working on adding heroes and cards and gems. Discuss them with the community, get people theory crafting and maybe even have a "community pick card" event, who knows. Aside from discussions of new content, bugs, and balance changes, disregard any further feedback from the community that isn't related to balance for the next six months.
20) After six months, you should have a few new heroes (hey! we reached and passed a roster of 39! Yay!) a lot of new cards (that have smoothed out ramping and disparity problems between affinities!).
21) Take another two-three months to stop adding new, non-cosmetic content. Dedicate the team to competitive balance (top down folks), bug fixing, and optimizations. Explain to the community that the focus is on optimizing the game as it is in preparation for adding better matchmaking and ranked now that the player-base has grown (what!? no matchmaking overhaul for almost a year from now!? Yes. By adding the above game modes and the ability to custom match with a handful of friends, you will have allowed the playerbase to work around the current matchmaking system and will have enabled them to have fun without it (whether people start matching up through LFG destiny like sites, discord, or what have you) and will have at the same time drawn in a steady influx of players who spread out among the three game modes.
22) News that ranked and matchmaking overhauls are coming will further drive interest, and hey, you guessed it, draw in more players, and increase the use by established players who are hyped for ranked play.
23) Take your time with the ranked play. Focus on making ranked play for the Legacy / Large symmetrical map first, and maybe exclusively.
24) Optimize it in QA.
25) Quasi-release a BETA version of Ranked Mode.
26) Test and modify as needed for about a month to three months after. (continue adding fun cosmetic items to the shop during this time, and making necessary balance changes to get the characters as balanced as possible, but make these lower priorities. Do not worry about adding additional/new content during this period).
27) When Ranked is 80% of the way to perfect, release it officially. [literally just remove the "Beta" tag.] (You'll never get past 90% anyway, and will have eternity to keep tinkering with it.)
28) Let it sit for a week. Send everyone on vacation. The game is in the best shape ever, and everything is trending up. Slowly, sure. But Rome wasn't built in a day and these games have a fifteen year lifecycle, if not longer.
29) Get everyone back. Everyone is feeling happy, refreshed, life is good!
30) Go WAAAAAAY back up to the top of this outline where we talk about doing an AMA with the community. (Step 11) Start there, and do this again from there. Get your survey information in and start a conversation about where to go next. Gosh, what a great job you've all done.