Forgive me for the clickbait title, but it's sort of a genuine question!
I guess it's primarily a question for anyone familiar with Edinburgh shows in the late 2000s-early 2010s, and/or Dan Atkinson, a quality stand-up who's apparently more of a producer these days. That's according to his profile on Avalon's website (his management). On said profile, this line jumped out at me:
[Dan] hosted the late night, copyright-infringing Comedy Countdown for eight consecutive years
I had not heard of the copyright-infringing Comedy Countdown, but upon further inspection, it looks like it was an Edinburgh Fringe show that started at the Gilded Balloon in 2008 with quite a DIY, but distinctly Countdown-inspired, aesthetic. A short Guardian review from 2009 confirms that the previous year was the inaugural contest. And a 2011 British Comedy Guide write-up describes it as follows:
See comedians pitted against each other in something almost resembling everybody's favourite teatime quiz! Previous contestants included Mark Watson, Sarah Millican, Richard Herring, Josie Long and Alex Horne. With regular host Dan Atkinson, and Paul Sinha as Carol.
Love the idea of quiz whiz Paul Sinha as "the Carol" (now Rachel) of the show, as seen here. Also, photographic evidence of Horne and Watson taking part in 2008, and Paul Foot was there too in 2011.
My final piece of lazily-Googled evidence comes from Dan Atkinson's website, where he recounts the Comedy Countdown experience thusly:
Many years ago, in Edinburgh, I was the host for a few festivals’ worth of Comedy Countdown, a very stupid midnight version of the TV teatime quizshow ‘Countdown’. I think it’s worth pointing out that this pre-dated Cats does Countdown by some years. It’s about the most fun I ever had on stage, and was nearly always sold-out. As you can see from the poster, the kinds of guests that came along to play were seriously good comics, and a handful of them were seriously good at Countdown. Although a huge minority.
Also interesting that one of the seriously good comics listed on the aforementioned poster was none other than future Cats Does Countdown team captain Jon Richardson...
So just thinking about the timing here - it was November 2011 when Countdown and 8 out of 10 Cats formed one of several show mash-ups than Channel 4 commissioned as a one-off special. By July 2013, after a couple more Cats Does Countdown specials, it was commissioned as a full series. Meanwhile, Comedy Countdown supposedly ran as an annual Edinburgh show between 2008 and 2015. We know the jump from Edinburgh show to TV series in that time is possible, because Taskmaster began life as an Edinburgh show in 2010 and 2011, before premiering as a series on Dave in 2015.
There's also the fact that Jon Richardson, Sarah Millican, Alex Horne, Josie Long, and Paul Foot all appeared on Comedy Countdown before 2012, and then went on to make multiple appearances on the televised Cats Does Countdown...
Now obviously I'm not literally accusing Channel 4 of stealing a copyrighted format or anything. It sounds like the Edinburgh version of Comedy Countdown was quite an unofficial unserious business. But I guess I was just wondering if anyone knows a bit more about the history of Comedy Countdown, and why its existence as an apparent predecessor to one of the most popular panel shows of the last decade isn't really acknowledged? Was it the brainchild of Dan Atkinson and/or Paul Sinha? On his little website blurb, Dan only claimed to be the host, not the creator. Also, while Paul's name shows up alongside Dan in the 2011 write-up, the 2013 one (couldn't see 2012) only shows Dan, no Paul. Curious that he'd drop out once the TV format took off. And while I'm at it, how come neither Dan nor Paul ever appeared on Cats Does Countdown, despite appearing on other TV shows around the same time? And furthermore, how come Jon's name appears on the poster on Dan's website, but not on the list of previous contestants in any of the historical write-ups on the still-active British Comedy Guide website?
Okay semi-conspiratorial rant over, you may now return to this sub's regularly scheduled programming of pirated comedy shows 😅