As a general rule, concerning food, statements on packaging or in commercials regarding the healthiness of the product at hand are to be taken as red flags for the simple reason that a product that is truly healthy will not have to brag about being so.
The same seems to have been proven true about the concept of "openness" in consumer electronics, single-handedly by OUYA.
As for the current state of affairs, there are some ways in which the OUYA can be considered open:
It was funded by way of an open model.
It is open for most people to enjoy: the console is cheap and a great amount of entertainment can potentially be enjoyed without any payments whatsoever apart from that for the console.
Development is open.
The general goodness of any one game is very open: you don't like what you play, you don't have to buy the game.
The design of the hardware is open.
While I applaud the OUYA for these decisions and accomplishments -- a Kickstarter fundraising record in particular speaks for the fact that there is strong public wish for entertainment delivered in an open fashion -- I feel that there is strong dissonance between the word "open" as defined by OUYA and as supposedly defined by the public.
While this undoubtedly will in some part be an angry rant by a geek wanting to unlock the bootloader, there are more lacking aspects of "open" in OUYA than that.
Company Internals
This problem is probably the most bleeding and the widest.
Basically, in funding an "open" console, I expected to, at the same time, be able to follow the development of the console. Being funded the traditional way, through a few mostly private funders, you will keep your investors up to date about practically everything regarding the progress of the business, as the disappointment of even one of them has the potential to crash your whole project. With thousands of funders, as is the case with the open funding system utilized by among others OUYA, there is absolutely no reason not to be completely public about every little detail of progress and problems along the way.
Instead, we got a very closed development coupled with an arrogant public face, culminating in the absolute disaster that was the early backer shipping fiasco as well as some minor (?) problems such as hardware flaws. By any traditional funding method, all investors would have pulled out very promptly as the problems became apparent, but as the crowdfunding model does not allow this (an inherent flaw IMHO), we as investors were instead punished by at the same time not getting what we were promised and seeing the product of our investments turn into less and less of what we supported in the first place.
What I really hoped, albeit somewhat naïvely, that the open funding and development model would have accomplished, is put a noticeable dent in the credibility of the level of secrecy commonly practiced by most major actors in the fields of digital entertainment and general consumer electronics. Gaining momentum to e.g. the idea that a firm developing a product should have strong interaction with the potential consumers would have been seriously valuable. Instead, we get almost the same level of secrecy as previously so often seen, this time powered by our hard earned money.
Public Relations
This was, in part, covered in the previous part. Basically, in following an open model, the company should portray a feeling of nearness to its potential consumer base, and investors especially. This would include flawless customer support (admittedly hard for a startup, but social media can do wonders), a very open attitude towards questions and inquiries, and, above all, an open and mature attitude towards the industry and the competition.
Enter a practically nonexistant customer support, the previously mentioned arrogant public communication policy, and maturity the level of a postmaturely pubertal spoiled CoD-fanboy - just look at the leaked (or not) vomit commercial. Where is the counterweight to the stiff-upper-lip-attitude normally seen in the business?
Technology
In supporting an "open" console, I felt comfortable with the idea that if I did not like what I got or if the project did not turn out successful after all, I would at least be left with a decent-powered Raspberry Pi on steroids to play around with, maybe use as a non-intrusive living room TV web browsing machine powered by a lightweight Linux distro of my choice.
Except, no. The closed bootloader keeps tinkerers on miles' distance.
This is a serious weakness for the indirect OUYA PR. Even though electronics tinkering will always be a niche, tinkerers are quick to go public (via forums, blogs etc.) about whatever internet-connected toaster status indicators or something they have come up with, and in 99% of cases these posts clearly mention the computing platform they are realized on. The OUYA would most certainly get absolute shittons of free advertising if it were completely tinkerer-friendly - "XYZ geeky internet sensor thingy written in Python running on an OUYA" - in many cases reported in popular online tech newsletters.
Even though many units would not get the use that the creators ultimately hope for the volume of sold units would most probably soar - it seems that whatever tinkerer friendly budget priced tech gets an unbelievable following. Most of these tinkerer buyers would naturally try out their newly bought gadget as it was intended before starting tinkering, some of these would eventually stick with the intended mode of use if they like it enough.
If they like it enough, maybe they would buy two, one to tinker with and another to get the OUYA experience from - $200 total for a general purpose budget tinker computer and dedicated casual or not-so-casual console is not much at all for many.
The OUYA team has to believe in their own service enough to rely on people choosing it even if they have a choice to do otherwise.
However, in the name of fairness, this may be a temporary thing. A somewhat possible scenario is this: the OUYA team could probably foresee their limited shipping bandwidth and chose to keep the console closed during the initial wave to attract first and foremost those mainly interested in the gaming abilities of the console, and give the console main renown as a gaming console (which TBH is not well on its way) instead of as a shortcut to light budget computing. Choosing to open up the console bootloader along with a major update to the menu at some time before Christmas could prove an excellent way to boost Christmas sales and give the console a popularity upswing along with opening the doors for tinkerers by in the process getting people to make a lot of DIY project progress over the holidays for others to replicate.
Bottom Line
As matters currently stand, OUYA is a disgrace to the concept of openness, and I regret backing it in retrospect, seeing what it has turned into. I have had my share of joy with it (really loved playing Knightmare Tower and Ittle Dew to pieces) and generally approve of its gaming capabilities, and don't think that the hardware problems of it ultimately ruin anything, considering the price, but representing the term "open" in the way they are doing is just wrong. The OUYA team have lied to their backers, and are hard pressed to correct their acts of wrongness.
I hope that they will do so, however. I did believe in OUYA in the first place, which the brown console I have standing on my desk is proof of, and still believe that the ~$200 stuck to it can feel as money well spent one day.
And more importantly, the thought that a completely open model of console gaming can prove commercially viable, or at least a proof of concept thereof, keeps my hopes high, hopefully not in vain.