Hey everyone.
I haven't played Outward heaps; only around 30 hours. I played Outward 2 for just under an hour to get the feel of it, but since I haven't played 1 much and didn't want spoilers, I decided not to spend long on it.
I have various characters in Outward in Chersonese, and a couple in Enmerkar Forest, and I think I made it to Hallowed Marsh and/or Abrassar Desert briefly with a friend. So yes, my experience is limited and thus there may be feedback I provide that isn't actually relevant by later on or something like that. However, I do believe it's important to take on more casual players' experiences since they always make up a decent portion of the playerbase, and sometimes I find veterans (even myself) can forget what it's like to be a new/casual/inexperienced player.
And of course, this is my subjective preference. If I say "should" or "bad" or "good", that's just my opinion. Feel free to disagree or ask for more details.
Anyway, here we go!
Gathering
Trees shouldn't have infinite wood, but instead have bark that disappears when you harvest it with your hands, and their wood can be harvested with an axe.
World
Much more of the world should be interactable. There are so many doodads all over the place that look like they could be interacted with.
It’d be great if more of the world opened up through more options, eg. Berg house should become available after X days, no matter your quest states.
Combat
Enemies could have more items and make better use of them, eg. Antidote potions when they’re poisoned.
Defeat Scenarios should never repeat within the same area or within a short space of time, especially for ones like The Hole that specify “you were so lucky to survive”.
Negative effects could cause more screen obfuscation.
Dialogue
Much more dialogue, such as asking villagers about local happenings, where they explain nearby bandit camps and such. For example, the Innkeeper in Berg doesn’t give directions to other towns after joining a faction - this kind of dialogue should always be there.
UI
Hold Menu button to bring up wheel of Menus.
I’m torn on whether CombatHUD should be integrated. On one hand, it’s really nice to be able to see specific numbers without having to go into your Menu. On the other, it’s somewhat more immersive to just have a quick overview, kind of like how you would “feel” about your health and stamina, and to get more specific info you’d have to stop everything and really take a look at yourself.
Bestiary, or some sort of compendium that slowly updates as you do things, kill things, talk to people, acquire recipes/explanations, etc, that explains typically where to find things, what monsters are resistant to, etc.
Change Indigestion to Food Poisoning. You could consider making Indigestion a thing from eating too much.
Edit: An in-game journal that lets the player note things would go a long way, as would improvements to pins on the map like being able to name them.
QoL
When the Menu is open, allow still moving the player with left stick and camera with right stick, and only use the D-pad to navigate the Menu.
Allow going to the end of a list/grid in a menu and then trying to continue in that direction to go back to the start of the list or other side of the grid.
Allow changing speed of Hold Y.
Allow going to next/previous tip on loading screens.
Bugfixes
Changing hotkeys causes issues, eg. I remapped Dodge to B (Xbox controller), but when I tried LT+B or RT+B, it would often (but not always) Dodge instead of using my quick bar action.
New systems/mechanics
Jumping.
Swimming.