Using a throwaway to ask these questions.
Okay, I have to ask. Pardon me if this sounds stupid and just completely moronic, but this is a legitimate list of questions and my personal thought pattern towards this matter.
As of late, I’ve been running into a lot of Otherkin. Otherkin is something I learned of back when Avatar released. This was the first time I experienced the term or what it meant. As you can imagine, it was met with a lot of absolute horror and ridicule. People were absolutely terrified of the idea that someone wants to live the Na’vi life and raise their kids the Na’vi way. It was such a huge piece of ridicule because up until this point, many of the folks who identified as Na’vi Otherkin were those that were severely dependent upon the technology that their species would reject. But I’ll get to that later.
The Origin. How did you discover that you were an Otherkin?
How did the legal implications of that ‘discovery’ or ‘revealing’ (if you ‘came out’) work for you? If for example, you identify with an animal and you truly feel you were switched at birth and therefore that is your body, do you take that animal home with you? I wouldn’t want to leave my body somewhere, I don’t do it in WoW. Or Guild Wars. But seriously, would you take that animal home with you, regardless of what species it is or where it came from. If so, isn’t that considered stealing, especially if the person who owns said animal catches you? Or is that part of the ‘privileged’ commentary I’ve been noticing because some might take that to mean “It was my body first, therefore it is legally mine despite society’s laws.” I’m really asking though, I don’t mean to ridicule or to smear on someone’s beliefs. And this only goes for SOME Otherkin. I know everyone’s is not a “I found my real body” story.
2. Do you have different ‘badges’ or ‘labels’ in the community? I’ve seen some folks refer to themselves as just ‘Otherkin’. Others identify as their creature, such as saying, “I’m a Dragonkin” or “I’m a Dragon”.
Does the Otherkin of one species have an issue with the Otherkin of another species, especially if they are natural predators in the wild?
What about the Otherkin that identify as creatures that are not of this world? Like the Na’vi, the Homestuck Trolls, or creatures purely created out of a person’s head or even something that science has shown to be the results of human fantasy (Such as an Elephant skull looking like a Cyclops head).
3. If you truly believe and identify with an Otherkin to the point that you desire to transition to that species, how do you change your lifestyle? How do you cope if you’re in a current relationship that does not accept nor agree to wanting to be in love with say, a tiger? What about your eating habits? Do those of carnivores naturally or habitually pit themselves into a lifestyle of eating raw meats? I ran into an Otherkin recently while researching that is supposed to be a natural predator of mice and insects, but they also identify as a vegan. Is it possible to consider yourself an Otherkin, and be a piece of that species if you do not share the exact ‘customs’ and behaviors of your species?
4. With the question above, what about traditions and morals? One thing I’ve noticed is that Otherkin tend to have a species dysphoria, as you would if you really identified with that species. As I’ve seen in cultures and species alike, there are rules that species lives by. Survival of the Fittest in every shape and form. Do you begin to express those traditions and morals of those species?
As a Lion, do you seek to have a pride and engage in homosexual practices as well as the common practice of taking over another Lion’s pride and ensuring your legacy by murdering the cubs of the previous male?
With your dysphoria, is it worse to you than someone who is transsexual or transgender?
For them, it’s a matter of switching genders. For you, it is a matter of switching your entire anatomy around. How do you deal with your homosapien body? How do you furthermore cope with that when the only cure for that dysphoria is the complete reconstruction of your body and your mental stability through the use of medication and research—-something that is only really accessed to the degree that you need it by human usage?
5. Do you consider ‘Otherkin’ an evolutionary matter? If you don’t take on the complete behaviors of the species that you identify as, do you shun the human body completely in order to accept your identity as Otherkin, or do you accept it because it is all part of the evolutionary process? There are many species which science and history both have extensively researched to have a lack of mental capacity. They can only think so far, and it normally extends to ‘What is going to keep me alive?’. A lot of Otherkin I’ve seen speak about human privileges and how we really do have an overwhelming surplus of absolutely bullshit objects at our disposal. Do you learn to only use what you need? What do you consider a necessity? What is part of your survival to ensure that Otherkin continue to exist? Some species have no religion. Some have not even the ability to mate in the ‘common’ respect. What causes you to justify and decide for yourself while still remaining in the spirit of what makes you an Otherkin?
6. What about the language? I’m sure this will be answered with a ‘Common’ language as there is no ‘cat’ language or ‘dog’ language that can (to my knowledge) be extensively written for. Do Otherkins of various species cooperate despite their origins being savage for survival in some cases? Do you have language barriers? Have you created your own language for one another? I’ve seen a lot of insane pronouns and titles that Otherkin can go by. How do you decide what determines that? Is it the same as the individual who just picks what makes them feel comfortable, or is it a case of “If you are Cat, you must use the “Mewself” “Mewr” “Mews” pronouns.”? I’m just guessing here, I can’t imagine what folks use for themselves.
7. This one is a problem. This particular question may seem extremely insensitive to many folks and might even be the biggest reason for why this post is going to be hated on, but I have to ask it. Every single Otherkin that I have encountered thusfar has in some way become disabled or suffering from a rather heavy and serious mental disorder. With this, it can be argued that the Otherkin is no more the byproduct of a bunch of folks that feel useless, and therefore need something to rekindle that idea of being valuable. On a psychological level, one could say four legs is better than two, especially if you don’t have any. But regardless, every single Otherkin I know and have read about, is disabled or suffering from a heavy mental disorder.
With this in mind, how do you cope with that? How do you cope with the fact that in your mind, you are in the wrong body, possibly the wrong gender to boot (especially if you happen to be of a species that is genderless or possesses both genders or is capable of switching between the two freely)? In addition to those, how do you cope with the fact that in your own species’ eyes (based on what your species is), you are considered worthless. You are considered not even worth mentioning or acknowledging the existence of. How do you deal with that in addition to the hatred and ignorance of the human population around you?
As an Otherkin, how do you deal with the fact that your very species is raised to survive, and those that are not going to are automatically banished from the majority of the group and/or parent and left to their fate. I ask this specifically for those that do have a mental disorder that’s been diagnosed or are truly disabled in some form or fashion. How do you deal with the idea that even with all the changes and whatnot made, you will not be accepted as a worthwhile ‘being’? We already have a differentiation between folks who are disabled and those who are able. That war rages constantly. We already hate on each other for just how we think and act and work and play. For you guys, you’re fighting against what to me essentially feels like “The group they left me with doesn’t want me, and my own family doesn’t want me. Where do I fit in?”
The Otherkin are an entirely different story. You guys have one title. Otherkin. (For the sexual folks, depending on who you talk to, it could be ‘Queer’) It is within that singular title that you have your subcategories, and from what I understand, they go solely by their species after that. There are THOUSANDS of species and subspecies. That’s just covering what science considers “legit” and not a cryptid or extinct or fictional.
So how does tolerance and whatnot work for you guys? How does any of this work for you guys?
Please educate me. I don't know what to really think of any of this. I am just a confused outsider really I suppose.
<3 <3 <3 Thank you in advance! <3 <3 <3