r/osr • • Dec 21 '25 Diamonds are Forever

Blog Anti-colonial Dungeon

Thumbnail
afraidofencounters.bearblog.dev
10 Upvotes

I made this as a follow up to my friend's blogpost, the default dungeon is colonial. Since dungeons are important part of OSR (and I happen to love dungeons), I try to write my perspective on how an Anti-colonial Dungeon can be.


r/osr • • Oct 25 '23

discussion ACKS and other OSR compatibility

0 Upvotes

Since ACKS is such a hot system to discuss right now, I was curious some of it's compatibility. So I had a few questions.

  1. How easy is it to pull rules from it into another OSR or AD&D based games? I know it's race as class but I read there's a class creator system in other books.

  2. How much are the rules are system agnostic? Or do I need to run the setting from the books to really use the rules?

  3. Domains play and mass combat, I see it has it. How easy is it to pull that into another system/setting? I've often run AD&D and WWN, and never found a good faction/domain or mass combat system that really works with them. AD&D Battlesystem is very hit or miss. I know An Echo, Resounding has a bit of both but it's not very detailed, much like the faction systems in the Without Number books.

  4. Gold pieces or silver piece standard?

  5. With the new edition coming, are there still any "must have books" for rules?

  6. Anything else you think would be worth mentioning about the system?

Please just discuss the system, I'm don't care to hear about the drama of things outside of that.


r/osr • • Dec 19 '23

This is EXACTLY why I moved over to the OSR

0 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/DnD/comments/18lzg58/player_argues_with_my_rulings_says_im_not_letting/ke1nkhl/?context=3

from the dnd subreddit... a DM explains how their player is trying to use their spells in unique and creative ways and it's given them an unfair advantage in some situations... GASP!!!

the amount of people in the comments shitting on the notion that someone would try and be creative with their toolkit is mind-boggling to me.


r/osr • • Jun 02 '26

AD&D 2nd Edition Anti-Fascist Fight-Song

Post image
0 Upvotes

I wrote this song inspired by my time helping out at protests and have been playing it at direct actions and I thought it would be cute to post a (very rough) demo here because of the title. PS if you know what folk punk is and you hate it you will probs hate this but I am not offended <3

Really like all the ideas and stories people post here, thanks for making my dnd-ish game better :)

I uploaded the song to my proton drive and you can listen here.

Have a great week!


r/osr • • Jul 21 '26

Any OSR games made by progressive companies?

130 Upvotes

Hey all

Looking to vote with my wallet to support companies that I align more with. What are some OSR companies that are progressive?

Note: If you don’t care about this or are here to declare your “anti-wokeness”. Cool. You do you.


r/osr • • Feb 18 '24

industry news Not Affiliated with LotFP, currently they are having a sale.

2 Upvotes

Lamentations of the Flame Princess US site Currently having a two for one deal. Just wanting to share. Went ahead and grabbed some stuff myself. Just spreading the word if anyone is interested as well.


r/osr • • Sep 22 '23

Neurocity is the first book in history to feature an A.I. free logo.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Hope that the idea catches on and helps grow awareness!

Get the pdf here https://www.drivethrurpg.com/product/318907/NEUROCITY


r/osr • • Jul 19 '26

discussion The Thoughtlessness of Deathbringer's Marketing

Thumbnail
magnoliakeep.blogspot.com
5 Upvotes

What are people's thoughts on Magnolia Keeps discourse?

I am disappointed that the artwork doesn't reflect the old school style it feels like a pathfinder or 3.5 vibe more than OSR vibe profDM suggests from his videos.

Altogether it feels like a cheap money grab rather than some meaningful old school game.


r/osr • • Sep 26 '23

Non-Gonzo OSR Actual Plays w/ Good Microphones

0 Upvotes

Looking for OSR Actual Plays where the following are true:

  • Non-gonzo campaign. I don't want to watch the Ultra-acid Psycho-sorcerer's Interdimensional Zoo of Doom.

  • Quality production. I don't want to listen to people's laptop microphones or $100 headset microphones.

  • Bonus: Everyone is in the same room

  • Bonus: It's not all 40 year old white guys

Maybe I'm hunting a unicorn, but I figured this is the place to source this request.

EDIT: Concern trolls, downvote all you want. I got my answers already, so it doesn’t do anything. 🤡


r/osr • • May 10 '25

industry news PSA: Goodman Games' is deliberately being misleading about their "contractual obligation" to do business with the Neo-Nazi Judge's Guild licensor. Do not support them.

0 Upvotes

SHORT VERSION:

-Goodman Games has possibly lied about cutting ties with Judges' Guild since 2020.

-They claimed five years ago swearing to never work with them again...

-...Then stated their newest project with them started production 3 years ago!

-Money will still go to the Bledsaws if the Kickstarter goes over the funds needed to be backed.

-Refund money will only be given to those who demand it. If you don't or can't do that, tough shit.

-There is no legal obligation for the Bledsaws to give money they receive to charity. It's purely out of "goodwill."

-Goodman Games was not under contractual obligation to finish the City State project.

-They've admitted to resurrecting the project solely because they "like it." They had no binding with Judge's Guild until the project was resurrected. (Read: They could've not negotiated with Nazis, but they did anyways.)

-The Bledsaws will not lose anything financially from this.

-No matter what Goodman Games says, they are most likely still giving money to Nazis.

Want more? Read on!

In 2020, Goodman Games put out a statement stating that their rerelease of Jennell Jaquays' works would be "the last time" they worked with the Judge's Guild on a TTRPG product.

We have one remaining product to release, which is a collector’s edition focused on the works of Jennell Jaquays. Jennell’s story is one quite different from the views espoused by Bob Bledsaw Jr. Judges Guild and Bob Bledsaw Jr. have agreed to receive no royalties of any kind from this title. To say it bluntly: Bob Bledsaw Jr. and Judges Guild will not profit from the Judges Guild Deluxe Collector’s Edition Vol. 2 focused on the works of Jennell Jaquays.

After this final volume, we have no plans to release future Judges Guild titles.

But in the first video they developed about this, they claimed the City State project had started three years ago. The same project fans are claiming they're forced to do by contractual reasons?

2020 was five years ago. What the hell happened?

They claim more recently, that the City State project was started "before 2020," but again, here's the thing. Why didn't they mention that in the first place?

Either they are lying now, and are purely making up a fake justification to justify working with the Judge's Guild, or they were lying then, and secretly intending to work with those Nazis all while claiming to pay tribute to Jaquays' work.

Either way, it doesn't look good for them to engage in Double Think.

(Thanks to MorsRattus for pointing this out!)

Nor that their claims the Bledsaws will solely use the money as "repayment for the Kickstarter refunds," is entirely on the Bledsaws.

Judge’s Guild has committed to Goodman Games that any funds received by them from our moving forward with the OAR City State of the Invincible Overlord will be used to fund refunds from the 2010 Kickstarter.

Or not? Once again, they flip-flop. They've since claimed the money will be received by a "third party" (of which they have, not shared the identity of) on their recent stream to ensure the refund money goes to the right channels. That'd be nice of them...if they didn't also state there is a chance the Judge's Guild will be paid left over money not spent on refunds. (Thanks to EntrepreneurLong9830 for catching this!) They then claim that the Bledsaws are agree via pinkie promise that the money goes to a charity of Goodman's chosen. There is no contract holding them to this.

Pro tip: NAZIS ARE NOT GOOD AT TELLING THE TRUTH. Go ask any Holocaust Denier. Or Goebbels. Or the Bledsaws themselves.

Don't believe me? Ask Frog God Games:

All Judge’s Guild royalties are contractually required to ONLY support the City State of the Invincible Overlord Kickstarter.

The exact same Kickstarter that the Bledsaws are claiming to pay for with this new Kickstarter. FYI, this never happened, and Frog God Games have since broken contact with the Bledsaws, who did not paid any of the money given towards refunding that failed Kickstarter. Or any god damn charity for that matter.

Until now. We'll get to that later.

Why does this matter? Aside from revealing Nazis are SHOCK, often liars? Because that means there's no evidence of a contractual agreement that the Bledsaws or the third party must follow. Unless we get legal consul from their lawyers, there's no reason to assume that the Bledsaws won't just take the money and run off to buy luxury items like they have done in the past.

I keep seeing people say "Goodman MUST finish the project, they're contractually agreed to do so!"

Here's the thing. The original Kickstarter had nothing to do with Goodman. It was entirely Judge's Guild ran. They didn't take it up till, if their side of the story is true, after they had made the deals to republish Judge's Guild products. Even if that's true, they could've prematurely terminated the project themselves. We know this because they have said so themselves.

Our OAR of the City State of the Invincible Overlord faced one of two paths: We could simply choose to shut down our work and let the project end or proceed knowing that the monies going to Judges Guild would be supporting something that all of us at Goodman Games found reprehensible.

So the only reason they're even bothering to give the Neo-Nazis "hopefully they won't screw us over" money is because they were that attached to their project. Not to "repay the people who were scammed by the Bledsaws" like all of the apologists are grasping their jewels for, solely because they can't let their precious little project go.

Repurpose the project as a new IP? Release the project's remnants for free as goodwill to the fanbase? Just accept it's done and over and move on?

No. Instead of just telling Nazis to fuck off, they've chosen to create a position for themselves in which they are allegedly not paying money to, unless they make more money than expected on a Kickstarter (read: known for going over target on money) that they began working on after claiming to stop working with said Nazis in the first place, that will totally go to charity and/or refunding a project they were never contractually obligated to do, based on the promises of Nazis.

But there's good news at least! The Bledsaws ARE starting to give refunds back!

...At a first come first served order.

Why does this matter you might ask? "Doesn't it prove that the Bledsaws actually WILL give the money away?"

It matters because the Bledsaws will not lose anything financially from the project. If the Kickstarter fails, they do not pay the backers back, and the money (which was already gone years ago) remains with them. If the Kickstarter succeeds, the money will go back to a very small population of people, leaving the remaining money with the Bledsaws. The later is not new news in the Kickstarter world, but the fact they have started the refunds this early suggests that the Bledsaws are fully aware they will be in a financial situation to recover from this months from now.

Now consider that Goodman Games needs the Kickstarter money to actually fund the damn product. Unless they intend to fund more than $85,130 on it alone, there won't be nearly enough to refund everyone and release the project at the same time. This means they'll either ask for less, and prioritize the money towards production costs, preventing the refunders from getting their due; or they'll ask for more, increasing the chance of giving people back their money...which, unless every single person involved in the old kickstarter pitches in for refunds, will probably instead go to the Bledsaws.

The house always wins.

Oh, and the comments on the post above are claiming to have issues actually getting refunds through. This is my shocked face.

Final Word

All in all, the thing that is most baffling me is Goodman's insistence on preaching the greatness of "Invincible Overlord" to the masses. They have never failed to mention in their press releases how much they love the product. They'll even spend time doing it on streams filled with Nazi commenters whining about "bringing politics into DnD".

Here's the thing, Invincible Overlord is just a fucking game. It's an book of pretend play, of fantastical situations you wouldn't encounter in real life, of pure escapism from reality.

Nazis are real. They are not a stat block that gives you XP upon being killed (although the games that do depict them as such aren't wrong to do so!), they are a chaotic nightmare of an ideology based on falsehood more than actual ideals that has and continues to kill groups I and many of my friends belong to. They didn't just wake up one day and do this. They won the privilege to do so through manipulation, misinformation, and intimidation. People like them are doing it again in the streets, in the public office, and at the gaming table.

I do not care if Invincible Overlord is the best Module ever made. I do not care if the "intended plan" is to prevent Nazis from getting money. Not only has Goodman Games lied directly to us at least once, but they have admitted to the possibly of Nazis getting money directly from them. Their only assurance that they won't use it to fund their favorite orange colored politicians is solely on the Nazi's shoulders.

It doesn't matter how much money they may not get. Through this deal, Goodman Games have placed trust in Nazis. It's not bringing unwanted politics onto the table to do this when Goodman Games have already made a pact with members of the most shameful ideology on Earth. It's not damaging the game to fight against this, it's damaging the game to bring in a ideology that inherently views other's worth based on skin color. You don't make half-measures with Nazis. They'll just stab you in the back just as they did to their own country.

Fuck Goodman Games, fuck anyone who funds this Kickstarter, fuck the Bledsaws, and fuck Nazis. End of story.


r/osr • • Mar 23 '24

After delays, and still no shipping date for backers, the folks behind the Knave 2e Kickstarter are selling copies at GaryCon while backers fume.

0 Upvotes

Right out of the gate, let's be clear about two things. One, is this the end of the world? Nope. And two, is it the sole prerogative of Jacob Hurst (the agent for Swordfish Island, the publisher of the game) and Ben Milton (the creator of the game) to sell their books to whomever, and whenever they want? Yes; absolutely, 100%, that is their call to make.

It is also, as one commenter in the backer discussion thread put it, a total dick move.


On Thursday, March 21st, Jacob (who has been the only contact person for project for many months now) posted an update from GaryCon, which contained the following snippet:

The printer was able to air freight two boxes (~60 copies) of the premium cover version of Knave to us on Tuesday of this week so that have some available at Gary Con. We weren't sure up until the last minute if that was going to be possible, but it all came together. If you see a copy of Knave pop up on social media somewhere, that's where it came from.

So, a few things worth noting:

  1. Mr. Hurst still hasn't informed the backers when their orders will be shipping. Essentially, he's saying the printer is keeping him in the dark. (And to be clear about this, too; there's no reason to think he's bullshitting us on this point. I shouldn't have to explicitly state this, but people love jumping to conclusions unfairly.) But nevertheless, the backers who paid for those copies to be created in the first place are still waiting while they get to basically watch other people buy they the thing for they've been waiting for, if they were following Knave 2e's development via Ben's Patreon, for over a year.

  2. The game has been delayed. Now, sure, delays are pretty much the standard operating procedure for crowdfunded projects like this, but the funding period closed on on May 2nd of last year! And last year, when the folks running the project were a little light on updates, and admitted they were running a bit behind schedule, the backers were pretty gracious about it. Sure, there might have been one or two people who got a little huffy (there're always a couple in any group, right?), but by and large, most of the comments from backers were along the lines of "no problem," "take your time and do it right," and so on.

  3. It's not just the "standard" version they're selling at GaryCon; it's the fancy, "deluxe" version.

  4. Most notable of all, the project was funded at over 6000% of its goal! Now I, personally, have absolutely no idea what sort of profit margin these guys are working with, but at $50 a pop, the aforementioned 60 books will sell for $3000. Regardless of how much they clear per book, that sum will be just a tiny fraction of the $645,580 the project received in pledges! This clearly isn't a "we gots ta sell them 60 books at GaryCon, or we gonna lose the farm!," situation.

Now, as you can imagine, some of the backers are pretty upset. But, to be clear, the backer discussion thread doesn't have expletive-filled rants or anything; it's mostly just people commenting how disappointed and slighted they feel. (One poor bastard even commented "I backed at the 'completely all in' [pledge level], and am here at GaryCon with no copy, and others are getting one"). Still, the organizers probably could have nipped any backlash in the bud by posting a consolatory "oops, sorry, our bad" comment, and agreeing to not sell any more copies at the con. But that is absolutely not what happened. One of the first comments was from a "superbacker" who pointed out the disservice that was being done to the folks whose money allowed the books to be printed in the first place, and Mr. Hurst was unapologetic:

I'm a book publisher. I'm here to sell books. That's what I'm going to do. Also, as a creator myself, I think it's important for a creator to be able to have copies of their book available at a convention they're physically attending whenever possible. If I can make that happen, I'm going to do so.

And lest there be any confusion about the motivation here, it really does seem to boil down to money. Responding to another "superbacker" who commented on how much it "stings that the people that made the books possible get to watch as copies of those books go to other people first," Mr. Hurst said this:

It's a once a year sales opportunity. I made the call to try and have some here to sell. As I said in the update, the printer wasn't even sure if it would be possible to accomplish with the way they had things scheduled.

To another person, he wrote:

Should you bypass a once a year opportunity? Or try and sieze it? As I said in the update, the printer didn't know if it would even be possible to accomplish this.

Again: I don't know much about the publishing industry, much less what this specific company's margins are on this specific book. But, even if they were doubling their money (which surely they can't be, right?), they're only making $1500 on 60 sales! One quarter of one percent (!) of the total funds raised for the project seems like a pretty paltry sum in exchange for pissing off your heretofore loyal, enthusiastic base, doesn't it? And, as at least one person commented in the KS backers' discussion thread, it's absolutely not a "once-a-year sales opportunity," because there are a whole bunch of other cons throughout the year. Also again: the project received over a half million dollars in pledges! I think this is an important point to keep in mind.

But, it didn't have to be this way. There were so many other routes the organizers could have taken to, ultimately, make more money for themselves, and promote Knave 2e:

  • If they just wanted to generate a "buzz" at the con, they could have had a few "teaser" or "preview" copies at their booth to get people excited, while offering pre-orders and, I dunno, maybe some special con-only bundle discount or something?

  • If they really, really wanted to put a copy into circulation, they could've done a raffle or something for a single book with a nice, personal dedication from Ben about how awesome GaryCon 2024 was, thanks for supporting our project, etc, etc.

  • If they just had to sell those 60 copies, they could have increased the price above their normal selling price, and donated the surplus (or all of it, if they wanted to be really awesome) as a fundraiser for the family of the now-recently-deceased Jennell Jaquays whose death is, as I understand it, a thing that people are collectively, and acutely aware of at this year's con.

  • If they absolutely. positively couldn't not sell books at the con, at the very least, they didn't have to sell the fancy deluxe versions, did they? As a few backers have commented, this really does feel like salt in the wound.


I realize the fact that I wrote all of this might make it seem like I'm super pissed off. Some of the other backers sure seem to be, but what I feel, personally, is just super disappointed. This seems like the sport of thing Hasbro would do, not a small indie publisher.

I don't know this "Jacob Hurst" guy is (and frankly, given his behavior, I don't care to), but Swordfish does have some neat stuff; Hot Springs Island seems to get great reviews, and I've personally wanted a copy of The Tomb of Black Sand for a while now. It feels particularly bad to get it from an indie publisher. ...And, man, now I have to go through the hassle of finding a copy of Black Sand on the second-hand market, because, screw this guy if he thinks I can actually give him my money.

And, Ben? I've never met the guy, but I am predisposed to liking him because I genuinely appreciate his work and his advocacy for our hobby, and I think he's among a group of people that that OSR community owes a debt of thanks. Hell, I even supported his Patreon for about a year or so. (And not for nothing, he's a teacher, too, which is an admirable profession.) But there's just no way he could have been out of the loop on this because he's at the con right now! Obviously I don't know all the details of the greater situation, but right now I don't see any way he could be reasonably absolved from culpability on this decision, either. Feels bad, man. Feels real frickin' bad.

Obviously, I don't know how all of this is gonna pan out. As another one of the backers commented:

I'm guessing they will lie low for a few days, and hope everything dies down. Maybe they miscalculated how people would respond to this incident, maybe they figured "Everyone else does this nowadays, so we can too!" (which isn't true at all, many TTRPG creators will not sell to the public before they start shipping to backers, no matter what). Whatever reason they have for choosing this action, it was in error, and is a major blow to both Jacob and Ben's reputation...This will not be forgotten on their future crowdfunding endeavors.

And, I hope it isn't forgotten; this kind of behavior shouldn't be acceptable in a small community like ours. That's why I wanted to share the situation with the community. As somebody who typically makes pretty good-sized pledges to indie projects that I like...well, if I am considering backing crowdfunded project, I would want to know if the organizers had kicked their previous backers in the teeth like this. (Pirate Borg, anyone?) Other people can give their money to whatever creators they want but, personally, the next time there is a crowdfunded project that involves either Swordfish Island, or Ben Milton I won't be signing up. And, if I just have to own it, I'll just wait until it goes retail.

Personally, I am not really interested in engaging in a back-and-forth with other people in the comments below; that's not why I posted this. Doubtless there are other backers here, and maybe some of the ones who are expressing their irritation in the KS backers' discussion will chime in, or discuss the situation further. You all can do with this information as you please, but as I said, it seems like a situation that should be known about.


edit: Oh, FFS. Look, the people running the Kickstarter did something that pissed off some of the backers. And while I'm not personally as pissed-off as some of those people are, I can definitely see their point. Why did I post all of this? Because I think we should have higher ethical expectations for indie game creators than we do for giants like Hasbro, and I do think this was a crappy thing for the organizers to so. I hoped that by sharing this, future creators won't pull the same thing as the Knave, or the Pirate Borg creators did, because I think backers should always get their stuff first, period. If you don't agree with that opinion, fine.

It's not like any of this is a secret; the project has tens of thousands of backers, and the backers' chat is visible to all. It's simple to verify. But, fine, here you go: a screenshot of the discussion, with everybody's identities redacted except for the organizer. But, again, since the discussion is available to anybody who backed the project, it's not like this is some big conspiracy; just log in and read who said what for yourself, and form your own opinion. The tinfoil hat comments here are ridiculous.

If you don't care about any of this, fine, just hide this thread and move on with your life. If you don't see why some of the backers are upset with the situation, fine, just hide this thread and move on with your life. If you don't share my opinion that the organizers shouldn't have done this, fine, just hide this thread and move on with your life.

And, because I don't need to receive psychotic PMs, I'm going to delete this throwaway account, and move on with my life as well. FFS.


r/osr • • Jun 14 '24

No Artpunk III - High level adventures - PWYW

6 Upvotes

This looks to have come out today - some looked interesting on the guy's blog: https://princeofnothing.itch.io/no-artpunk-iii


r/osr • • Nov 29 '24

Blog Monsters and Manuals: Bridging the Representative Diversity Divide

Thumbnail monstersandmanuals.blogspot.com
0 Upvotes

r/osr • • Jun 11 '26

I made a thing Leathers, a queer, slice of life TTRPG.

0 Upvotes

Leathers is an erotic table top roleplaying game cut from the cloth of En Garde and Meatheads. It's a social simulation game, and while there is no "dungeon crawling" it does use at matrix for resolutions like Chainmail.

It is currently funding a donation to the Leather Archive & Museum of Chicago, all digital sales add to this fund. We are nearly half way to our goal. Physical copies are available on demand, printed and bound by myself.

Curious? Check it out here: https://halforc.itch.io/leathers


r/osr • • Feb 27 '23

Shelfie Shame?

1 Upvotes

Is it just me, or is there a distinct lack of LotFP publications in these shelfies?

At one time, every third post on this subreddit was about LotFP.

Perhaps people have a secret bookcase, mayhaps behind a curtain, like the ones you used to find in certain bookshops in the 80s?

:O|


r/osr • • Aug 22 '24

Blog SETTING BOUNDARIES: The Ruin That Befell Dolmenwood

Thumbnail
torchless.substack.com
0 Upvotes

r/osr • • Feb 15 '19

Zak S.'s books are not Zak S.

18 Upvotes

After the recent revelations about Zak S. and his terrible character (if, in fact, the allegations are true - it seems likely that they are), there have been numerous calls for his work to be completely abandoned and replaced by something else.

I am not sure if this is a sentiment shared by much of the OSR, or if it is just one shared by the people most likely to be vocal about things like this, which for the most part, they actually know nothing about and are likely using it as an opportunity to virtue signal. At best, I think that people who are calling for his books to be used no more and replaced are misguided.

First of all, the utility of these books, often seen as a product of prolific talent, can never be replicated.

You can't create a good city supplement, setting, dungeon, or whatever because someone who already did those things turns out to be a terrible person. You can only create those things if you have good ideas. Certainly, some of the people calling for this action have good ideas, but it seems strange that they would come up with ideas that perfectly replace the resources people have been using to much acclaim at the exact moment the need arises.

Second, the character of the man who authored the words of the book (and much more the art) is completely separate from the quality of the book's content.

When this information came out about Zak S, the content of his books did not change. In fact, much of what has been revealed has been going on for a long time - a period of time that we used his books to great effect.

We must learn to separate the art from the artist if we want this community to continue to thrive.

If what Zak S. has been accused of is true (which again, I think it likely is), he is scum, and he he be punished to the full extent of the law, your pocket book (or the lack thereof towards him), and public exile. I bear no sympathy for him.

However, if we, as a community, allow events like this to define the supplements, tools, and settings we create and use, we have failed to understand an artist's relationship to his work, and we have set ourselves on a path that ends in artistic entropy and decay.


r/osr • • May 08 '24

discussion Good Night :3

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/osr • • Mar 26 '23

OSR adjacent DnD 'Honour among Thieves' review: It's good [minor spoilers] Spoiler

2 Upvotes

TLDR: It's a good fun movie; not great, but solidily fun with an incredibly charasmatic cast.

I was not going to watch the movie as the whole OGL scandal really soured me on WotC, but the early reviews were good and I liked some of the actors involved so went to an early screening last night - and the movie was good.

It's not particularly risky or revolutionary, but it has some great humour and some big laugh out loud moments in the cinema and is very enjoyable.

I don't know how but they managed to find possibly the most charasmatic cast in Hollywood, and they are pretty uniformly great - Chris Pine, Michelle Rodriguez, Rege Page, Sophia Lillis, Daisy Head all are very watchable with Justice Smith as Simon the Sorcerer and Hugh Grant being the stand outs.

The plot is standard fair. It's nothing special and I'd even say some of the plot turns are not that logical and sometimes feel forced, but the film works because of the humour and the general 'good feeling'.

The Red Wizards were a bit too cartoon villainy for my liking. The main female baddy is good but we get a shot of Szass Tan and there is none of the subtley of the character; they just went for 'shadowy evil'. I guess it''s fair enough but even Megatron has some campy evil about him.

As to the 'DnD'ness of it, the Forgotten Realms is such a compelling setting and it's really great to see it come to life and see some Iconic DnD monsters and locales; I particularly liked the detour into the underdark.

Overall I would recommend the movie to all DnD fans, even if they are soured on WotC, as it's a fun night in the cinema, and to all non DnD fans as the movie stands on it's own merits.

7.5/10

EDIT: I forgot to mention it feels like they threw money at the movie; some of the fight scenes and set pieces are just brilliant.


r/osr • • Mar 17 '25

discussion On LotFP and genre

1 Upvotes

I see here a fairly frequent assertion on this sub that LotFP is extreme horror akin to Martyrs or Terrifier. Which is absolutely the genre of its full color core book art, and seems to be the objective. But I don't think it's more image sparse black and white adventures really fall into that genre, because the whole genre of extremity requires a level of detail that the books' writing does not support, so when we without full color art it falls short of this genre aim. Primarily texture extreme horror requires more descriptive writing than most LotFP books have, and generally more space than most OSR adventures have room for. The main books I'm thinking of as comparison points are Stokoe's Cows and LaRocca's Things HaveGotten Worse Since We Last Spoke.

What I think LotFP adventures fall into more and why there is a divisive reaction to them is the hopeless and pointless nature of the horrible things rather than the extremity. More akin to the Descent, the Poughkeepsie Tapes, or the Smiles series than the grindhouse its art seeks to imitate. I personally think most (though not all) LotFP adventures miss the mark on what makes to of those three examples good and falls more into Smile territory, where the consequences are less of a "how horrifying" and more of a "whomp whomp, anyways roll up new dudes".

Sorry if all of this is obvious or dumb sounding. Just a feeling I had to get off my chest.


r/osr • • Mar 10 '23

Shadowdark ‘better’ than Old School Essentials?

4 Upvotes

Hey friends!

So I just stumbled onto the current Shadowdark kickstarter and played around with the quick start yadda yadda. It’s felt really smooth and clear. Easy to find what I needed when I needed it etc.

As I searched YouTube I came across Runehammer (ICRPG creator) and he said that Shadowdark will replace OSE for him, which leads me here.

For those who have checked out both, does one stand out as ‘better’ than the other? And I know it’s totally subjective, just really interested in others opinions.


r/osr • • Jan 05 '23

industry news Now we know why "the article" was written to smear us.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/osr • • Dec 31 '23

Old Tunnels & Trolls adventure I made. Ran it twice & they never survive the bucket.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/osr • • Jun 25 '22

This limited edition Black Rifle coffee looks strangely familiar...

Post image
0 Upvotes