She’s fine, not bad. I would never say mediocre at all, but a passionless and timid performance. I also realize that she could very well have been strictly following Scorsese’s direction.
By this I mean that as a relative newcomer, with absolutely none of the gravitas of DeNiro and DiCaprio, she might not have been able to flex her thespian muscles more and be given more freedom in how she portrayed her character.
I can imagine being her, being directed by probably the greatest living film director, co-starring with two of the most iconic movie stars ever, men of titanic Hollywood power and reputation, and not fully being able to call her own shots. Or feeling like she couldn’t.
It is mostly a one note performance. Mollie suffers a lot and internalizes it. Mollie feels melancholy and keeps it to herself - and the camera. Mollie rests her head on her husband’s shoulder. Mollie loses loved ones. Molly is sad.
I honestly never got the feeling of a multi dimensional person with various shades of good, bad, high and low. An alive personality with charm and a winning style to make me want to care about what was happening to her. We know it’s a quiet performance, but that’s not it.
One of the finest best actress winners ever is Jodie Foster in The Silence of the Lambs A truly quiet performance, except when a sparkle in Clarice’s eyes, tears with too much pride to fully manifest themselves, or a quick look of terror on her face create a woman with hundreds of thoughts and emotions and life struggles that we take on as our own.
We want to accompany her on this scary journey and watch her triumph in the end. A subtle performance that in the hands of a brilliant actress wins us over even when she’s sharing the screen with the most spooky movie monster ever, one that tries to chew the scenery and steal the spotlight. He does a remarkable job, but Clarice is still never overshadowed by him. She’s too strong - yes, quietly so - to let Lecter make us forget her.
In this film, Mollie rests her head in a perpetual state of sullenness and Gladstone attempts to make us feel awful for her. And we do. And then that’s it.
She’s the woman that is suffering, and that seems to be the totality of her character. Gladstone provides no further depth to her Mollie other than, quite frankly, wanting us to feel terrible for her. We do, but it gets to a point where she’s no longer an interesting investment in our pity. We can feel sorry for her, but she’s not someone we’d like to be around much longer.
This is ultimately on Gladstone, and for that reason the laurels and lavish praise are surprising. Subtle performances can be superb, but we must have more than sympathy for the character and a much more fully realized human being to feel for.
The Oscar for 2023’s best actress must be far more deserving than this.