r/oscarrace • • Dec 01 '24

Is the Academy really brave enough to nominate a Transwoman for Best Actress?

0 Upvotes

I think people are underestimating the extent to how controversial this would be. Even with the decline in ratings, I would argue that The Oscars are an intrinsic part of the American cultural identity on par with The Super Bowl. Even with the people who mock the Oscars, it's still a big topic of discussion. This is the case especially with controversial moments like The Slap.

American society as a whole, even self-proclaimed moderates, have not reached a place of acceptance with trans women competing against cis women. It won't be some small corner of the internet that's mad, it will be a very vocal and possible majority. They will spam every corner of the internet, news channels, podcast, etc. The backlash against the Oscars as a whole will be astronomical. Look at how much the allegedly intersex boxer was harassed this past year at Olympics. I sincerely think this would be magnitudes above that.

Let's face it, ABC and its parent company Disney are businesses. Are they really brave enough to let anything threaten the remaining ratings/popularity of the Oscars?


r/oscarrace • • Sep 19 '26

Discussion Just realized… is The Social Reckoning NOT Oscar contender, but Razzie contender!

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Saw that terrible international poster and it finally clicked.

Isn’t this movie heading down the exact same path as Joker: Folie à Deux?

The Razzies even have a Worst Prequel, Remake, Rip-Off or Sequel category, and they love nominating big-name sequels that flop.


r/oscarrace • • Dec 14 '24

Unpopular opinion: Dune part 2 is a total slugfest and suffers from "2nd movie in a triolgy" syndrome

1 Upvotes

Action adventure movies aren't my thing, but this one was more boring than I could have ever imagined. I appreciate the work that went into it, but the music and acting was just such a downgrade from the first one (which I wasn't the biggest fan of anyways). I just couldn't stay engaged (disclaimer: ADHD probably played a factor in that aswell). Also what little dialog is just the cheesest, most unnatural, "I'm so bad ass and wise and humble" poetic garbage ever. It's ridiculous that they would spend so much money to make something this visually stunning just to have the driest plot known to man.

TL;DR - Not my kind of movie, I don't really get the hype.


r/oscarrace • • Jan 09 '25

Unpopular opinion: Cynthia Erivo as Elphaba isn't worthy of a Best Actress Oscar nomination

1 Upvotes

Let me start off by saying I really enjoyed Wicked. It was such a fun, thoughtful love letter to both the musical and the book, and also The Wizard of Oz in general. John Chu ensured that every detail mattered. I loved the production values that went into it and their decision to build actual sets to utilize practical effects vs CGI, and every actor COMMITTED to their roles. EVERY actor.

However, I have been surprised at all the Oscar buzz surrounding Cynthia Erivo for Elphaba. I just don't see it. Ariana Grande absolutely deserves a nomination - she was the true heart and soul among all of the actors, and went above and beyond to knock it out of the ball park as Glinda. Cynthia was a fantastic choice for Elphaba. She's a great actress, an even greater singer/performer, and she truly delivered a solid performance. But I just don't understand the Oscar buzz surrounding her for this role.

I can't help but compare it to the Oscar buzz surrounding Jlo for Hustlers and Angela Bassett for BP: Wakanda Forever. Both pretty good performances that really weren't Oscar caliber. I hate to use the term, but in this context, overrated. Someone explain it to me why she shouldn't be the one to miss out on the fifth spot, over actresses like MJB and Fernanda Torres.

Let the downvoting commence.


r/oscarrace • • Mar 16 '24

I’m a Black trans woman, I believe in gendered categories.

Post image
36 Upvotes

Im a 21F from East coast and I saw a lotttt of discourse on a post talking about gendered categories yesterday. And I wanted to provide my own thoughts on this… I feel and many women like me feel like the trans conversation has been somewhat hijacked by White non binary people (as I believe someone rightly pointed out)… and everything somehow has started to be catered to them from the spirit awards and a critic award.. and no one is really asking us what we think…

I can’t speak for the entirety of trans female actresses (hopefuls) everywhere. But I can say this… for me… I want Best Actress and Best Supporting Actress to stay! When we say we wanted a level playing field, we meant we wanted to be included. We wanted to be able to be next to and compete against our cis female friends and female adjacent friends. Getting rid of the category not only does damage to cis female visibility, but totally would wipe our chance out. Plus… we are women… We’re actresses, we want to win best actress too. That’s all- getting rid of the category doesn’t help us, only makes it harder to win as we’d have to go up against everyone* when we put on a phenomenal performance. That could be favored for a male or even a non-binary person.

It isn’t fair… and I’m not meaning to come off terfy** or whatever word some ultra liberal, will call me. But as a progressive, this seems very counter productive. I’m happy to hear everyone’s thoughts on this, but I think we all agree, gendered categories are fine. If you are trans- you accept the existence of gender. Example: I’m a trans woman. I accept the existence of women and men vice versa. Non binary people shouldn’t always be grouped in and get to speak for us because truly… they’re not speaking for us. Getting rid of the category is essentially like erasing trans women and our acceptance of the word itself “actress” or gendered categories as a whole. We should find a solution for them without affecting everybody.

What are all of your thoughts?


r/oscarrace • • Dec 12 '23

Finally saw KOTFL for the second time, and Gladstone’s performance is legitimately underwhelming at best. Genuinely surprised she’s getting such disproportionate praise.

3 Upvotes

She’s fine, not bad. I would never say mediocre at all, but a passionless and timid performance. I also realize that she could very well have been strictly following Scorsese’s direction.

By this I mean that as a relative newcomer, with absolutely none of the gravitas of DeNiro and DiCaprio, she might not have been able to flex her thespian muscles more and be given more freedom in how she portrayed her character.

I can imagine being her, being directed by probably the greatest living film director, co-starring with two of the most iconic movie stars ever, men of titanic Hollywood power and reputation, and not fully being able to call her own shots. Or feeling like she couldn’t.

It is mostly a one note performance. Mollie suffers a lot and internalizes it. Mollie feels melancholy and keeps it to herself - and the camera. Mollie rests her head on her husband’s shoulder. Mollie loses loved ones. Molly is sad.

I honestly never got the feeling of a multi dimensional person with various shades of good, bad, high and low. An alive personality with charm and a winning style to make me want to care about what was happening to her. We know it’s a quiet performance, but that’s not it.

One of the finest best actress winners ever is Jodie Foster in The Silence of the Lambs A truly quiet performance, except when a sparkle in Clarice’s eyes, tears with too much pride to fully manifest themselves, or a quick look of terror on her face create a woman with hundreds of thoughts and emotions and life struggles that we take on as our own.

We want to accompany her on this scary journey and watch her triumph in the end. A subtle performance that in the hands of a brilliant actress wins us over even when she’s sharing the screen with the most spooky movie monster ever, one that tries to chew the scenery and steal the spotlight. He does a remarkable job, but Clarice is still never overshadowed by him. She’s too strong - yes, quietly so - to let Lecter make us forget her.

In this film, Mollie rests her head in a perpetual state of sullenness and Gladstone attempts to make us feel awful for her. And we do. And then that’s it.

She’s the woman that is suffering, and that seems to be the totality of her character. Gladstone provides no further depth to her Mollie other than, quite frankly, wanting us to feel terrible for her. We do, but it gets to a point where she’s no longer an interesting investment in our pity. We can feel sorry for her, but she’s not someone we’d like to be around much longer.

This is ultimately on Gladstone, and for that reason the laurels and lavish praise are surprising. Subtle performances can be superb, but we must have more than sympathy for the character and a much more fully realized human being to feel for.

The Oscar for 2023’s best actress must be far more deserving than this.


r/oscarrace • • Feb 27 '25

Opinion If Anora wins BP it will be one of the most deserving and interesting BP winners in a long time

8 Upvotes

This movie reminds me so much of the 'New Hollywood' movement of the 70s.

Taboo subject matter, small budget, all on location shoots, mostly unknown actors, strong ensemble, dark humor, realistic cinematography, unresolved ending.

I think most people have missed these types of movies judging by the overwhelming reception this movie has gotten. I also think academy voters really appreciate the callbacks to this type of grounded film making. The shocking DGA win for Baker doesn't seem so shocking in retrospect when you consider that most directors working today grew up and adore these types of films and have a genuine admiration for this type of film making. Of course this movie also subverts expectation that keeps things fresh and modern. It's this combination that's really appealing to cinephiles I think.

This type of fun, spontaneous and adventurous energy is not present in any of the other BP nominees. This is 100% Baker's moment to shine and I hope the academy recognizes this special achievement.


r/oscarrace • • Aug 03 '26

Opinion Four months left and Zendaya is still Best Actress with her performance in The Drama

Thumbnail
gallery
36 Upvotes

Zendaya’s performance was playful, dainty, on guard, crude, mature and honest. She played Emma with a fine line between confidence and doubt. The line deliveries of how she would ask questions to Charlie as well as her actions when she would challenge his thoughts (ex. knife scene) were superb. Zendaya made Emma sincere in most encounters however she made Emma hold frame, it wasn’t necessarily arrogant but it allowed her to not be this “full frantic/trouble pushover.”

Maybe it’s coupled with the fact that Zendaya has a lot natural charisma IRL, but it happen to pour into the role really well and didn’t make it one dimensional when it could’ve been.

To put it together, her performance was like seeing
“Adult Angst” if that’s even a term said around. She was multi faceted and had an internal teen-adult clash going on, making her be my vote for the awards.

Side note loved how quirky she was with the opening meeting with Emma and Charlie, drove it close to the idea of her being arromantic but hinting enough to her attraction to Charlie as this is sort of her first go around at this “romance” thing.


r/oscarrace • • Jan 22 '24

Is there a place to put Oppenheimer negativity?

0 Upvotes

I enjoyed Oppenheimer, but I think there were better movies in 2023. Everything seems pretty unanimous on this sub. Feel free to put any Oppenheimer critiques or cynicism below. Would love to know I'm not the only one.

E: Guess I'll put mine.

I'm pretty cynical towards Nolan's recent work. I think he's less focused on making entertaining movies than he is on making "important" ones. I was hoping for something a little more procedural when it came to the nuts and bolts of the project but every scene instead is about how monumental the decisions being made are. Ultimately I think everything comes down to how much of the "tortured genius" he makes Oppenheimer you think Nolan sees in himself. Makes the movie kind of shallow to me. Still had a good time with it and really enjoyed the whole ensemble.


r/oscarrace • • Dec 02 '24

Timothée Chalamet Says He Prepared to Play Bob Dylan for 5 Years, It Affected Him 'Psychologically'

Thumbnail
people.com
1 Upvotes

r/oscarrace • • Apr 10 '24

I don't really understand why people hate Jaime Lee Curtis' win so much.

5 Upvotes

It may have been a career Oscar, but it's a wonderful comic performance. She was the least best of the nominees, but it was a stacked year. She 100% deserved the nomination. Personally, I would've given the win to Kerry Condon, but I was not at all mad when JLC's name was announced.


r/oscarrace • • Aug 24 '26

Prediction End of August predictions for acting categories

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

• I dropped The Debut from both the categories that it is contending in. Something about the trailer screams "TIFF film that immediately crashes and burns" to me

• I put Morton in. The goodwill over her and her comback narrative is snowballing.

• Hüller for Rose is pretty much the only contender to me who seems likely to win the Drama Globe, so of course she's in.

• La Bola Negra is getting 2 acting nominations and neither will be Penélope Cruz.


r/oscarrace • • Mar 06 '26

Discussion Michael B Jordan doesn't deserve the oscar

8 Upvotes

Compared to the other nominated performances, I honestly feel like Michael B. Jordan falls a bit short in the Oscar conversation. In Sinners, he gives a solid performance and brings a lot of energy to the role, but it mostly leans on his natural charisma and intensity rather than a real transformation. When you look at someone like Leonardo DiCaprio in One Battle After Another, the performance just feels more layered. There’s vulnerability, desperation, even some dark humor, and he moves between those emotions really naturally. It feels like a much broader and more complex performance overall. Ethan Hawke has always been great at subtle, introspective acting. His performances usually feel very lived-in and natural, and he can elevate a scene with small details rather than big dramatic moments. Then there’s Timothée Chalamet in Marty Supreme. From what we’ve seen and heard, he really throws himself into the role, changing his mannerisms and fully disappearing into the character. Don’t get me wrong—Jordan still did a good job in Sinners, especially playing the twins and making them feel slightly different from each other. But compared to the others, the performance just feels a bit more straightforward. Considering some people are calling him the main contender, I just don’t think it reaches the same level as the others this year.(This is completely my opinion feel free to disagree 🙂)


r/oscarrace • • Jan 17 '25

I want Bailey to get in

Post image
3 Upvotes

the supporting actor race for this year is one of the most dull and sad races ever. It feels so boring and predictable compared to the 3 other races. It was also like this last year with rdj sweeping. Jonathan is actually supporting, his 10 minute scenes were memorable and fun. Also wicked finally having a male actor get in at award shows when it’s just elphaba and glinda every time would spice things up. it is possible to get in with just sag nom it has happened before


r/oscarrace • • May 05 '25

Discussion Is the Sinners hype being overhyped?

4 Upvotes

This is not me calling the movie Sinners overhyped. It is not!

But am I the only one feeling like people are overplaying the hype and enthusiasm around it? I keep seeing people compare the love for the film to the love EEAAO or Oppenheimer got and are we sure? The love for the film is obviously very real and very very positive, but these are extreme comparisons and I don’t think it’s that same over the moon hype so many are claiming it to have. Just a few weeks out from the release of the film and things seem to be simmering down for it already, as opposed to EEAAO, Oppenheimer, or even The Substance where it felt like the hype was getting bigger and bigger every passing day for months.

This is not me saying the film isn’t widely beloved because it very clearly is and please don’t read this as me calling it overrated either- that’s not what I’m saying. Im saying I don’t think I’m seeing the same insane passion so many people are claiming it has. It seems to be universally agreed upon as great but the conversation around it is a little too normal for me to feel the EEAAO, Oppenheimer, Substance, hype comparisons. It’s just a step below that, which is still a great place to be!

I’m not sure if I explained these thoughts well but does this make any sense? Is anyone else feeling the same thing?


r/oscarrace • • Oct 21 '23

Why is everyone hyping up RDJ in Oppenheimer?

33 Upvotes

The dude did one of the most generic jobs. Nothing screamed oscar worthy other than the fact that he’s a big name in a big movie. there are so many actors who could’ve done that role better and more believably. I’m so confused why people think he should win


r/oscarrace • • Nov 18 '24

More “real” critics loving Wicked

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

I saw it last week! It’s SOOO GOOD! I’m so excited for everyone to see it this week. This will be a fun awards season


r/oscarrace • • Jan 30 '26 Bravo

Discussion Why is OBAA so dominant?

11 Upvotes

Is there some awards politics involved or am I just missing the appeal? It’s obviously been sweeping the awards and is the favourite to win best picture. I’ve seen several of the other nominees and they’re fantastic. OBAA was just alright to me, nothing revolutionary (ironically). Is there something else behind the hype? (Eg long overdue award for PTA) or do I just have bad taste?


r/oscarrace • • Jan 12 '25

Jamie Lee Curtis is worthy of a BSA nomination.

Post image
2 Upvotes

After watching The Last Showgirl, I am not opposed to her nomination. Her character is a highlight of the movie. Tragic, funny, sincere, and bold. Her "Total Eclipse of the Heart" moment has stayed in my mind.

Thoughts?


r/oscarrace • • Nov 29 '24

How 'Wicked' Could Shock Everyone and Win Best Picture

Thumbnail
hollywoodreporter.com
0 Upvotes

r/oscarrace • • Feb 25 '26

Discussion The Path to Best Picture for Sinners

0 Upvotes

With PGA and SAG around the corner, if the tide is ever going to turn toward Sinners, this feels like the last opportunity, and I actually think it’s quite strong in both places.

PGA

At the PGA especially, I think there’s a very reasonable argument to be made. Producers are the ones voting, and while they absolutely vote for the films they love, they’re also uniquely aware of the business side. In a tight race, it’s not crazy to think some might lean toward the film that was a major box office success rather than one that struggled commercially. If any voting body were to be swayed by that logic, it would probably be producers.

But to be fair, what OBAA lacks commercially, it doesn’t lack in industry visibility. There are no awareness issues there, which is often the real danger when a film underperforms. People have seen it. People are talking about it. So the “box office bomb” label doesn’t necessarily hurt it in the way it might hurt a smaller, less visible film.

SAG

In the last 10 years, when a film has won both SAG Ensemble and an individual acting award, it has gone on to win Best Picture 3 out of 4 times.

Right now, Sinners is widely predicted to win Ensemble, and Musaku/Jordan are competitive in their respective acting categories. If that double win happens, that’s a huge signal.


r/oscarrace • • Dec 12 '24

When you see a movie like Wicked being nominated for Visual Effects…

3 Upvotes

This is why they leave Oscar voting to actual professionals.


r/oscarrace • • Jan 11 '25

He should be winning Best Actor and Best Supporting Actor this year. Will go down in history as one of the worst snubs

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/oscarrace • • Aug 01 '23

I’m not trying to be rude, but can we please stop with Barbie winning best picture.

0 Upvotes

It’s a great comedy, but in all honesty…I can’t imagine the backlash if a movie about a rich white plastic doll wins over let’s say a film showcasing a long horrible history of Americas original sin with the slaughter of the natives for their land. I understand gender roles and the hype are hot right now, but please be realistic.