From Norwegian Orca Survey via their Instagram:
9 killer whales. 34 boats and snorkellers. How can this be acceptable?
Today, instead of studying killer whales, we documented the boats surrounding them.
A small group of just 9 killer whales was first found in Jøkkelfjord this morning. News of their presence spread quickly. By the time our research team arrived at 10:35, 34 whale-watching and snorkelling boats had already gathered around them. Throughout the entire daylight period, the whales were continuously surrounded by boats, with a staggering total of 72 boats visiting the whales by the end of the day.
What shocked us most was that snorkellers were still being put into the water. Even some of the longest-established operators, who should be setting an example for newcomers to the industry, were participating.
We also understand the challenges operators are facing this season. Changes in herring distribution mean that fewer killer whales are currently available in the traditional winter whale-watching grounds.
Here is what we believe responsible operators should do when faced with such conditions:
Say NO to snorkelling. When dozens of boats surround a handful of whales, putting people in the water is neither appropriate nor responsible. Explain the situation to your guests.
Give the whales more space, not less. Without the pressure to put snorkellers directly in the whales' path, there is less reason for repeated close approaches.
Limit your observation time. When many boats are waiting, consider a maximum of 30 minutes before moving away. Everyone deserves a chance to observe wildlife, but not at the expense of the animals themselves.
Adapt your operations to the conditions. The number of boats, the number of whales, their behaviour and the surrounding environment must determine what is acceptable. What might be manageable with many dispersed whale groups becomes unacceptable when 35 boats converge on just nine animals!
Responsible whale watching means knowing when to keep your distance. And knowing when enough is enough. The whales cannot speak for themselves. It is up to all of us to make better choices.
To be honest, I'm a bit upset right now :( There are many comments on the original post decrying these orcas being harassed, but when you click on the commenters' profiles, you see several of them promoting their "once in a lifetime" shots of whales they took while swimming just feet from them with no scientists present. It seems to me that the enormity of our community's love for orcas in combination with FOMO has created a situation in which people will loudly claim to be against any harm coming to these animals but then go contribute to their exploitation in other ways. It's hypocritical to preach about saving the Southern Residents or the Iberian orcas and bemoan the lack of action governments have taken on their behalf while spending thousands of dollars to fly to a country with almost zero cetacean protections so that you can participate in an activity that would unequivocally be considered "take" under the Marine Mammal Protection Act. Norwegian orcas are just as sensitive, astonishing, brilliant, and deserving of respect as orcas in any other part of the world; just because it's been normalized to make them into our photo props doesn't mean they're fine with that. There are a few brave people who have spoken out, but videos of people leaping off still-moving boats directly in front of orcas with vulnerable calves still go viral with captions like "the ocean chose me today🥹." I also once saw a video captioned "DITCH SeaWorld and come swim with wild orcas in the Arctic!" As if our only two options are supporting a massive capitalist company that prioritizes profit over animal welfare or a smaller network of companies that also (perhaps unwittingly) prioritize profit over animal welfare, but are better at greenwashing. Whale-watching doesn't have to be like this. We can do better. I am no ally of the people who insist that the only ethical way to observe wild cetaceans is from shore; I have experienced ethical, respectful boat-based whale watching and know it can be done. The only way to get there is by eliminating the social-media-fueled expectation that everyone will get a "magical" up-close-and-personal wildlife encounter and bring the focus back to these nonhuman persons' autonomy.
P.S. Orcas travel to these areas because they have been taught by their matriarchs over decades that these areas provide them with a consistent source of food in an ever-more-unreliable ocean, so the argument "if the orcas were bothered by us, they would leave!" holds no water. If paparazzi swarmed you whenever you were in your pantry, yeah, you could retreat to another part of your house, but then you wouldn't eat.