r/opensource • • Jan 21 '11

Oops: Android contains directly copied Java code, strengthening Oracle's case

http://www.engadget.com/2011/01/21/oops-android-contains-directly-copied-java-code-strengthening/
0 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

View all comments

0

u/[deleted] Jan 21 '11

[deleted]

-3

u/omgwtfchill Jan 21 '11

Even the author of this article admits the sources files were there for 2.2 and 2.3, they just aren't there anymore (removed January 14th).

As far as his second argument goes, the Judges aren't going to care that the code isn't built into the resulting binary or not, because that's irrelevant. What matters is source code files that are not allowed to be redistributed (as stated in their license) are being redistributed (via git and tarballs of the Android sources). That alone is a copyright violation.

2

u/mycall Jan 21 '11

Easily corrected, especially with INSTALL_ASSET capabilities.

2

u/omgwtfchill Jan 21 '11

I'm not familiar with INSTALL_ASSET. Is that something to do with git? Or is that some automake variable?

1

u/mycall Jan 22 '11

It allows Google to install whatever they want onto all Android phones remotely. They could, using that, remove any java code present on the phones.

1

u/omgwtfchill Jan 22 '11 edited Jan 22 '11

Okay, but as has already been determined, it doesn't look like this code was shipped on any devices, so that doesn't matter.

What matters is whether or not there is a copyright violation by Google - unit test source files or not, if they decompiled those from Java 1.5 (or just copied the source code manually), then that suggests there is a copyright violation. It doesn't have to ship on a handset before the copyright violation kicks in.

I guess we'll find out how the judges rule on this eventually. That said, I'd imagine that the copyright infringement is the less significant part of the lawsuit. The patents will be the deciding factor, I think, and there's been no news on that yet.