r/opensource • u/tofino_dreaming • Mar 26 '25
Google will develop Android OS entirely behind closed doors starting next week
https://9to5google.com/2025/03/26/google-android-aosp-developement-private/18
u/Bachihani Mar 26 '25
While it's possible to somehow switch aosp to a close source licence ... It s very unlikely, google is the n1 beneficiary from keeping it oss and they sure know it, even if they did then i m optimistic that will prompt some exciting projects to surface
31
u/Infamous_Prompt_6126 Mar 26 '25
China is so closed to the world.... Oh, wait... What?
9
u/A_Light_Spark Mar 27 '25
We are seeing the shift in culture in real time. Exciting... Almost too exciting...
4
u/almbfsek Mar 27 '25
isn't this already the case. AOSP was released most of the time when it's ready?
4
2
2
u/healer-peacekeeper Mar 28 '25
A relevant and helpful read, for those looking to de-google their smart phones.
1
u/TheCancerMan Mar 27 '25
Most of Android new and shiny things, but also old deemed crucial and useful, were moved from AOSP to Google services over time.
1
u/Dexterus Mar 27 '25
Oh, it's not closed sourcing it, it just goes closed dev, so you see either only releases if google bothers or you go beg the phone vendor for the sources.
1
1
1
u/Diuranos Mar 29 '25
Finally, android OS and no more shity chrome OS. I tried Chrome OS and nope, for using web-browser was okish, anything else, sucks.
I was thinking recently to buy one of the Motorola phone to have motorola connect PC mode l or Samsung phone to have Dex. OR install on a small pc, one of the pc android ver.
Now I can wait for official Android PC OS yep.
1
1
1
1
1
u/JG_2006_C Apr 06 '25
So Fork with feature comaptibty but free of google nonsese plese cn we make cominity android real but we could still red the google aosp codefor patches so feures work acoss the board
1
1
Jun 15 '25
Y'all are getting heated over nothing, the article says the full Android builds and components are going to still be on AOSP. The only difference is you won't get to see every step and change Google does, not a big deal. It's like with Third Party ROMs having Nightly builds and then removing them. Plus, Google knows they can't close source it and it'd also remove Googles ability to allow third party patches and White Hat hackers to snoop the code, that's a detriment to Google and their distributors/Partners.
1
u/WildKarrdesEmporium Sep 01 '25
So, what's the alternative? Cuz if Android is gonna be just like Apple, I'm switching back to Apple.
1
u/xgui4 Sep 03 '25
as a foss lover, i am really dissapointed ... why does google want to make Android like iOS??? i buy an android for freeedom not for an cheap iphone ...
-7
u/voidvector Mar 27 '25
I think the problem is their version control system. They don't use Git internally, have to effective "sync".
3
u/yatsokostya Mar 27 '25
What do you mean? Repo is a bunch of python scripts that invoke git in the end.
0
Mar 26 '25
[deleted]
10
u/GNUGradyn Mar 27 '25
??? It's an OS called Android. "Android OS" is said all the time, generally when referring to the actual operating system code itself not the ecosystem or whatever
0
Mar 27 '25
[deleted]
5
u/GNUGradyn Mar 27 '25
Yes. We are talking about the android operating system or OS for short. Frankly I work in tech and I hear "android OS" regularly so you're just wrong and I'm not gonna spend a day watching keynotes to prove it
3
314
Mar 26 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
153
u/MrPureinstinct Mar 26 '25
I'm pretty sure the licensing of Google/Linux would prevent that wouldn't it?
12
u/onthefence928 Mar 26 '25
Not if they rebase it into something other than Linux
9
4
2
u/RadiantLimes Mar 27 '25
I assumed most of it was under permissive licenses. I am sure they will find a way to close source it.
1
u/hishnash Mar 27 '25
The existing license only prohibits them on items they do not have copywriter controle over.
Sure they will need to open source libraries and packages that others have contributed and google has not got them to sign a waver. But most of the core android parts when you contribute to them google have required you for years to sign a waver that in effect will enable tool etc re-liense them. The result of that will be that all new changes after the re-licensing will be under whatever license google want.
1
1
u/QliXeD Mar 26 '25
Yes. Unless they change the license. The old code will be under oss license but new one not.
10
u/kohuept Mar 26 '25
you can't just change the license without all contributors agreeing (unless google uses a CLA or something)
2
u/fromYYZtoSEA Mar 27 '25
What you can do is fork the previous codebase into a new one. The new one will use the old code with its old license, and new code will be released under the new license (as long as compatible). Then rename the fork as the original.
Also, Google does use CLAs or equivalent.
1
u/hishnash Mar 27 '25
Goole have been very careful to ensure all contributions to the android parts of android required devs to sign over copywrite.
1
u/kohuept Mar 27 '25
In that case they can probably do whatever they want
1
u/hishnash Mar 27 '25
All large companies that controle a code base ensure all contributions have attached legal paperwork. Even if they never intend to change the license they need this paper trail to protect themselves should the original contributor want to claim thier copywrite on those lines of now critical code.
-3
u/QliXeD Mar 26 '25
Yeah, but at google-scale, that's just semantics. They have enough power to help you to get to the 'right decision'
2
u/Desperate-Island8461 Mar 27 '25
That doesn't make it right or even legal.
1
u/QliXeD Mar 27 '25
Absolutelly, but sadly that don't meam that it could not happen. When you have power legality is flexible 😭
-6
u/QliXeD Mar 26 '25
Yeah, but at google-scale, that's just semantics. They have enough power to help you to get to the 'right decision'
71
Mar 26 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
11
u/Potential_Drawing_80 Mar 26 '25
RHEL source code is still available.
1
u/adevland Apr 22 '25
RHEL source code is still available.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Hat_Enterprise_Linux
In 2023, Red Hat decided to stop making the source code of Red Hat Enterprise Linux available to the public. The code is still available to Red Hat customers, as well as developers using free accounts, though under conditions that forbid redistribution of the source code.
1
Mar 26 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/Potential_Drawing_80 Mar 26 '25
Have you met Rocky/Alma?
2
u/catskilled Mar 27 '25
SUSE launched multi-Linux support. It's another shot (mainly) across Red Hat's bow.
6
Mar 26 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
-4
u/ConfusionSecure487 Mar 27 '25
Which is completely unnecessary after all
3
Mar 27 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/ConfusionSecure487 Mar 27 '25
The binary "bit for bit" compatibility and no that must never be required otherwise you do something wrong
→ More replies (0)1
u/TheRealLazloFalconi Mar 27 '25
RedHat is not obligated to distribute its source to non-customers. But if you are a customer, you are allowed to edit the source all you want, and you are allowed to redistribute that source, or your own binaries. But RedHat is not obligated to keep you as customer, and if you're not a customer, they don't need to give you anything.
It's icky, but it's not closed source.
1
Mar 27 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/TheRealLazloFalconi Mar 27 '25
No, it is exact. They can't legally stop you from distributing what you have. But they can decide they don't want to distribute to you for any reason, including that you distributed it. They can also decide they don't want to distribute to you because they don't like the number 6507. They are under no obligation to give their distribution to anybody they don't want to.
1
u/ArmNo7463 Mar 28 '25
I'd argue if you can pick and choose who has access. That's not "open" source tbh.
The whole point of open source is that it's freely available. - Restrictions like the one mentioned are proprietary in all but name.
1
u/TheRealLazloFalconi Mar 28 '25
That is why we have the distinction between free software and open source. See What is Free Software? and Why Open Source Misses the Point of Free Software.
5
1
1
u/roflfalafel Mar 30 '25
They didn't close the source. They closed access to their commit history to make it harder to do 1:1 rebuilds lockstep with RHEL. They also changed the access mechanism to requiring a RHEL account, which requires you to agree to some terms. GPL wasn't violated by doing this. You can still download all the RHEL source to your hearts content today.
1
u/carlwgeorge Mar 30 '25
They closed access to their commit history to make it harder to do 1:1 rebuilds lockstep with RHEL.
Not exactly.
Originally RHEL only published source RPMs on a file server. These contain the sources and build instructions to create a binary RPM (the one you actually install), but no commit history. Later this process was modified slightly and the extracted source RPM content was exported to git repos. This had commits, but it wasn't the real commit history of the package, just a history of exports. The diffs were way larger (many commits between export pushes all combined) and commit messages were completely lost.
Access to the real commit history didn't happen until CentOS Stream 9, when RHEL maintainers actually started doing their work in public. This workflow was later brought to CentOS Stream 8 as well. So it's going in the opposite direction, with RHEL development becoming more open.
https://gitlab.com/redhat/centos-stream/rpms
Once that started happening, the source RPM export wasn't necessary for Red Hat anymore. It kept going as an overlap for a while, but was eventually shut off. You're right that the main people affected by this were those trying to duplicate RHEL, it just wasn't about commit history, it was about duplicating with minimal effort.
They also changed the access mechanism to requiring a RHEL account, which requires you to agree to some terms.
What changed? Creating an account always required agreeing to terms of service. Those terms have always said that redistributing subscription resources (including source RPMs) was justification to terminate the subscription.
1
u/adevland Apr 22 '25
You can still download all the RHEL source to your hearts content today.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Hat_Enterprise_Linux
In 2023, Red Hat decided to stop making the source code of Red Hat Enterprise Linux available to the public. The code is still available to Red Hat customers, as well as developers using free accounts, though under conditions that forbid redistribution of the source code.
0
Mar 26 '25
[deleted]
38
u/BubblyMango Mar 26 '25
Since the gpl says the client is free to edit and re-publish the code, doesnt that mean anyone who pays for a RHEL copy can then just publish it publicly?
63
u/SirTwitchALot Mar 27 '25
Yes, but then Redhat will blacklist you and never allow you to buy from them again. You'll get the sources for the version you buy and nothing that comes after
9
7
u/hishnash Mar 27 '25
yes the code but the GPL does not cover copywriter so all the logos, text content etc and a load of other stuff is not part of GPL. GPL does not grant you the right to break copywrite and does not override copywrite law.
56
u/FalseRegister Mar 26 '25
This.
GPL never said that the code should be published or released, just that, if you distribute it (eg binaries) then you must make it available.
It doesn't even say how, so it could very well be printed and good luck making any use of it.
37
u/abotelho-cbn Mar 26 '25
It doesn't even say how, so it could very well be printed and good luck making any use of it.
It kinda does. Printing it would definitely not be a valid way of distribution.
0
Mar 27 '25
[deleted]
4
u/abotelho-cbn Mar 27 '25
GPL v2
3. You may copy and distribute the Program (or a work based on it, under Section 2) in object code or executable form under the terms of Sections 1 and 2 above provided that you also do one of the following:
a) Accompany it with the complete corresponding machine-readable source code, which must be distributed under the terms of Sections 1 and 2 above on a medium customarily used for software interchange; or,
Nobody would be able to argue that faxing is a "a medium customarily used for software interchange". It would fail in court as far as I understand (IANAL).
2
u/Comfortable_Plate467 Mar 31 '25
this has been litigated and companies were forced to either release the code or pull their product from the market. happened wit everal routers and the like at least.
0
5
u/glasket_ Mar 27 '25
It doesn't even say how
The license actually repeatedly uses the phrasing "a medium customarily used for software interchange" ("durable physical medium" in v3). You might be able to get away with punch cards if you want to be cheeky, but I doubt printed text would be considered customary.
1
u/FunkyFortuneNone Mar 27 '25
Just playing in the argument, but with the amount of OCR and paper paperwork being used across many industries, couldn’t one make an argument printed paper is in fact customarily used?
Again, just playing with the argument. It’s silly of course. :)
2
u/glasket_ Mar 28 '25
The key part is "customarily used for software interchange." Paperwork is customary in industry, but it's not customary to exchange software via text on paper.
1
u/FunkyFortuneNone Apr 01 '25
I feel you, but "software interchange" isn't really industry standard terminology (at least that I've encountered in my career). Is it defined explicitly as you are using it in the license? Otherwise I could imagine there's a possibility a 50-60 year old judge being convinced it had a more general definition under a plain reading.
Again, this is silly argument to try and make of course. I just enjoy language games and chatting with strangers on the internet.
1
3
u/drcforbin Mar 27 '25 edited Mar 27 '25
Afaik they publish the source online, it's just that plain raw source without binaries or anything else about how to turn that into an OS may as well be printed.Edit: never mind, I'm wrong
-13
Mar 26 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
26
u/Artoriuz Mar 26 '25
It doesn't break the GPL.
You're entitled to the sources of the binaries you've received, but if you do choose to share them in a way that goes against the rules imposed by RedHat, then they're free to terminate your contract which means you won't be getting newer binaries.
Since you never received any of the newer binaries, by the GPL you're not eligible to request their sources.
It goes against the spirit of the GPL obviously, but it doesn't really break the actual license in any way whatsoever.
-9
Mar 26 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/syncdog Mar 27 '25
Rocky is definitely also violating the RHEL terms of service. They told everyone it's fine because they do it through a temporary cloud server instance, but it obviously isn't.
1
u/ConfusionSecure487 Mar 27 '25
Still the only way to use Nvidia cuda docker images in the el ecosystem, so I don't care at all what Redhat wants here
→ More replies (0)1
Mar 28 '25
This. RedHat was a test for the whole open source community of the whole GPL licensing. Now that it goes unchallenged and it’s working, many large open source corporate projects will do the same. I suspect Android is going to do exactly this too but it will take some transition time.
Effectively signup for a developer account, if you redistribute then your developer account is banned. It’s not “if” but “when” this is going to happen.
I’ve noticed a good few projects for this reason go AGPL on purpose to force source code distribution.
1
u/Thorboard Mar 31 '25
But don't you distribute the binaries with every phone that runs android? You would still have to distribute the source code to every customer of an android phone
1
u/Desperate-Island8461 Mar 27 '25
If they cannot redistribute it then IS NOT GPL compliant. So they are breaking the GPL.
4
u/glasket_ Mar 27 '25
They're still free to redistribute it, they just won't get any updates. The GPL only covers what you've actually received, but it doesn't obligate continued support. They've essentially created a second distinct contract alongside the GPL that states redistribution will result in terminating their subscription to future releases.
As stated it's against the spirit of GPL, but still valid.
13
u/skiwarz Mar 27 '25
No way. "Don't be evil," right?
4
u/AdreKiseque Mar 27 '25
Fun fact! They removed that slogan a while ago.
2
u/kvothe5688 Mar 27 '25
fun fact! they didn't. just read Google's code of conduct.
4
u/AdreKiseque Mar 27 '25
Well I read articles starting a few years back that they did but I just looked it up to double check and got no hits for "evil" on their official CoC page so
3
u/Maleficus Mar 28 '25
Still there, look at the last paragraph
And remember... don’t be evil, and if you see something that you think isn’t right – speak up!
1
u/AdreKiseque Mar 28 '25
I see. I'd been looking at this page.
Worth noting that while it does remain in the CoC, it still isn't as prominent as it used to be.
4
1
u/acarefulobserver Apr 14 '26
Says a lot about their ethics and morals if they deem their actions as "not evil".
2
u/Cracknel Mar 27 '25
The Android you are probably using every day is mostly proprietary software on top of AOSP. Even basic applications from AOSP are replaced with a proprietary one. Nobody ships a true vanilla Android experience. Not even Google.
1
u/acarefulobserver Apr 14 '26
I'm using GrapheneOS. It's open source software via an MIT License. So it's as open and free as it gets.
1
u/Additional-Sky-7436 Mar 27 '25
This is probably too get around the court rulings that decided that they have to be open to other stores and Apple doesn't.
1
u/pink33n Mar 28 '25 edited Mar 28 '25
Depends on whether all of the contributors signed a CLA. If yes then they can take any future versions closed source or dual-licensed.
PS It's also possible to get CLAs retroactively, but it needs to be from everybody.
Edit: I don't really know how android is licensed - I assumed it's GPL or similar.
1
Mar 29 '25
It’s absolutely a big thing to worry about. Look at what cutting Huawei off did to their cellphone business. It’s all the apps that have been built to work on the operating system.
0
u/Chogo82 Mar 30 '25
Likely. The Trump administration is very anti globalization and anti anything that helps China. Open-source is a form of globalization so not a surprise if it goes away.
133
u/GeneralFloofButt Mar 26 '25 edited Mar 26 '25
What's with the comment graveyard?
Anyway, sucks but hopefully this will spark some new opportunities. Hopefully Linux mobile OS improving and phones that will carry Linux mobile OS by default. Probably would be easier to develop Linux for specific phones, but idk I'm not a developer
Edit; I should have read the article first... Android remains open source. Only development will be behind doors, but after release it's still open sourced. Still think we could use some forks that are entirely independent from Google.