47
u/Syrigan 13d ago
they're actually just really really drunk. https://x.com/jayair/status/2117810542329184269
1
145
u/BuffMcBigHuge 13d ago
$5.99 for mistral.ai student plan, 165$ worth of deepseek v4.1 1017, just saying
43
u/PhoenixtheII 12d ago
That's misleading, that's the yearly plan, NEVER in the current day commit a yearly plan to AI subs right now. Scene moves too fast.
4
u/jaster_ba 12d ago
This is what were people saying last December when I subscribed for yearly GLM coding plan for 120€. The legacy v1 plan has no weekly quota and I have reached the 5h quota maybe once or twice.
2
u/candraa6 12d ago
GLM is outlier,
most yearly plan became shit after a while, but that's because few months ago the model pricing tends to go up, but now the trend became the opposite, providers race to the bottom, this is the efficiency era I guess, so yearly plan might be worth it
2
u/CloudNine3282 11d ago
If we really are in an efficiency era and a race to the bottom, a yearly plan is the worst move. Whatever you lock into today will be obsolete and overpriced in six months. The only exception is when a lab (GLM, DeepSeek) sells heavily subsidized access at a pure loss to buy market share
1
u/candraa6 11d ago
hmm make sense. I use opencode go where they always give updated discounted price / usage allowance. so my assesment above indeed a bit biased and wrong. most providers wouldn't do such thing.
1
u/Standard-Goose-3958 6d ago
Its efficiency era because the new hardware is not out yet or installed. So they have a choice, die or adapt.
1
u/Victorbar974 10d ago
I did exactly that and I deplete the pro 5h quota in half the time , now I am not sure if to u0grade to GLM max or switch to the expensive Anthropic
1
1
u/EagleNait 9d ago
The one exception was copilot. Damn I generated hundreds on millions of tokens of opus 4.8 a day for a year with that for 40 bucks a month
1
1
u/censor_this 9d ago
I don't know... My OG glm subscription from last year gets me about 10x what I could get on their new subscription style plan... I won't be renewing in January to the new subscription format, but for $120 for the year, I got waaayyyy more than my money's worth.
2
u/CraaazyPizza 9d ago
At this point buying a yearly sub is like an option market at the stock market. I'm bullish on Mistral being a good deal
1
u/Fit-Produce420 9d ago
My 75% off grandfathered plan for z.ai begs to differ. It was extremely cheap for billions of tokens a month, I'm not saying everyone will come out ahead, but you could.
Specifically I scheduled new or continued work at each 5 hour window, if you only used in when you were at work/home/awake you couldn't farm that many tokens.
1
1
u/zenerbufen 8d ago
No, it's NOT misleading. $4.79 / month is the annual plan, $5.99 is the full month to month student price. Please don't spread disinfo.
10
u/Nokushi 12d ago
how do you calculate 165$? pricing page says for the student plan you get 15$ of api credits
6
u/Low-Gold5909 12d ago
For use with the API. The subscription usage is separate. On the €18 plan it's €255 of usage and €25 of API credits. The wording is just not very good.
1
u/Nokushi 12d ago
okok thanks for clarifying, ngl i find it quite odd they're not stating this in their docs nor pricing page, it's really confusing
and i guess you can't use your mistral sub in opencode, as they keep a separate api credits allowance?
1
u/Low-Gold5909 12d ago
I haven't tried but I think you can use it in Opencode with the sub. Someone else in here has said you can.
1
u/tactic-impress-55 12d ago
source?
2
u/Low-Gold5909 12d ago
I use it...
4
u/ArgenEgo 12d ago
Do you use it in the Vibe CLI? Or in another place? Do you get $165 un usage? I don't see anything in the docs :/
2
u/Helpful_Jelly5486 12d ago
Vibe cli draws from subscription instead of api. API is for other apps and harnesses. Source: I asked vibe. Also vibe cli is somehow linked with vibe code web. I can start a session and /teleport and it’s sent to vibe code web.
2
u/Low-Gold5909 12d ago
I use it in the CLI and in Vibe Code web. But afaik you can use your subscription API key in any harness.
1
u/MadOff33_real_one 11d ago
Sauf si ton harness est rattaché à un tiers comme zoo par exemple. La c’est motif de ban !
6
6
8
u/AcrobaticOutcome7895 12d ago
I can't find any reference of ds v4.1 usage on the mistral site. How did u get $165 number ?
12
u/co-lor-less 12d ago
He's right, and if you pick the pro plan at 18€ then you get 255€ of credit, and as you can see here you can pick deepseek, glm 5.3 and flash. Also the t/s output is much higher than opencode go.
3
u/iForgotso 12d ago
255? It's 25,5$ of credit... How does that add up?
1
u/co-lor-less 12d ago
Because the API credit and the vibe credit are different, I posted a screenshot of my usage in another comment. You can just see for yourself.
5
u/butterfly_labs 12d ago
Noob here, could you explain the difference in API credit and vibe credit?
I assume API credit means you can use with the agent/client of your choosing, while the vibe credit must be consumed in their proprietary agent?
I don't understand why such a big gap, or even why there's a gap at all. Compute is compute, it costs them the same no matter the client you use, no?
1
u/MorganProtuberances 10d ago
subscription ("vibe"?) is flat rate. some people use it all, some don't. you get a better deal
API credit is the cost as if you used their API directly, like if you built a product that talked to their AI on behalf of your users. This is charged at a premium rate that is profitable for the ai business.
example: $100/mo claude subscription, when 'maxed', spends the equivalent of like $2000 in api credits (which in reality costed anthropic much much less than that).
2
u/iForgotso 12d ago
Interesting, it directly contradicts what the website says, but good to know. Ever tried it in other harnesses?
2
u/co-lor-less 12d ago
I use it in opencode, I never tried their vibe cli tbh. It somehow doesn't work with pi though, I'm not sure why.
1
2
u/Low-Gold5909 12d ago
I don't think it contradicts, it's just not worded very well. The API credits are for you to use in the API directly.
1
u/iForgotso 12d ago
Not worded very well is an euphemism, I still couldn't find any indication of the vibe usage available, I'd still have no idea they had separate usage pools if it wasn't for reddit.
1
u/Low-Gold5909 12d ago
Yeah, I feel like it was recently changed because I'm sure it was a bit clearer when I signed up a week ago. Still didn't explicitly mention the €255 of usage but it did seem more obvious...
1
7
u/mystic_node 12d ago
I think he's referring to vibe-cli allowance, they do provide a monthly vibe coding allowance if using their cli ig, not sure tbh, never used it, would like to know more about it
8
u/co-lor-less 12d ago
You can use it with any coding harness, it's not limited to their own.
4
u/mystic_node 12d ago
Damn that's really a steal at that price
4
u/co-lor-less 12d ago
It really is credit usage
2
u/JosephDEWS 12d ago
how you connect to open code the api key ? i mean the api key in my account shows 15 dollars? while the vibe code shows 150 dollars so how this work with open code?
1
3
6
u/Motor-Ground4594 13d ago
question, does mistral allow to use another harness like opencode go ?
2
2
2
u/Wanderspor 10d ago
Wait what I thought mistral was just a model
1
u/duboispourlhiver 10d ago
They slowed down on model training and pivoted to more of an inference provider and AI consulting firm
3
2
1
1
1
1
1
u/kelvinwop 11d ago
the only downside to mistral ai is that its digital and not physical or i would use it as toilet paper
1
u/NotARedditUser3 9d ago
I am on a 5 person development team and our entire monthly retail API rate usage on openrouter does not exceed $165. I'm serious. We're at $152 in the last 30d.
0
25
u/Square_Confection_62 13d ago
What I dont understand is, why peak pricing still applies?
9
u/qqYn7PIE57zkf6kn 12d ago
flattening the curve is always good for providers, be it llm inference, electricity, medical services what have you. having peak pricing put the invisible hand at work to flatten the curve.
2
u/Big_Law_3080 12d ago
Maybe, but that helps them, doesn't help me. Peak is 2x the price. China time starts around 9pm EST my time. So I can work 9am to 9pm for offpeak. If that time went to peak instead, I would not use that provider.
Deepseek Harness can be configured to show all models rate card at the time of interrence. It goes red, I nope out. Easy as.
47
u/AdFun4897 13d ago
Holy fk.
We just need DS 4.1 to match Opus 5.5 in a couple of months, and i will cancel all my subscriptions with these closed source companies
18
u/Ecstatic-Diet-1375 12d ago
You said this 4 months ago
24
u/Takeoded 12d ago
You said this 17 minutes ago
8
u/OnyxMonolith 12d ago
I said it now. Jk
I dont think people understand how far ds 4.1 is from opus 5.5 max
6
u/FortheredditLOLz 12d ago
The gap between these two is like the best basketball player in a friends group going up against the great (LeBron/Kareem/Michael/etc…)…..while the numbers look somewhat close. The actual performance difference is massive and a HUGE hurdle to overcome
1
u/JLongTom 9d ago
I think people's point is that if all you need is to drop a ball in a waist-high hoop, why not go with your friend (who probably eats less too)
10
u/Illustrious-Many-782 12d ago
Fable 5.5 is coming soon. So is 6.1 Astra, and then Opus 6 after that. All probably before DS v4.1 Pro, meaning that it will still be 4-6 months behind, and most people will pay the extra money for the extra intelligence.
The demand for the highest intelligence possible is almost unlimited. "Good enough" certainly has a market, but it is not infinite.
5
u/Itchy_Tiger2497 10d ago
You’re vastly underestimating the utility of much much cheaper inference at roughly current levels of intelligence.
Every task has a ceiling for required intelligence.
1
u/Altruistic-Wolf-3938 9d ago
Well, I can work toward a goal, but it is been 3 months already, with significant advances and milestones attained. But I can see how a more intelligent model could need less guidance , make less mistakes , and reach the goal a lot quicker. The intelligence here not being intelligence I guess but ability to plan further in advance and to keep all the elements of the project in mind , not dropping random 600 documents of a dataset of 5000, before the main training of 49 hours of max gpu use. It is actually not intelligence. Intelligence is weird. I would say in these models , being intelligent is mainly being able to forecast further while being closer to reality
1
1
u/anengineerandacat 9d ago
Opus 5.5 to me is "genuinely good" for my tasks, I think their comment around intelligence requirements is quite true and these models are reaching levels where you don't need the latest and greatest any longer.
For coding and such latest models produce average to above average output, whatever comes next might push it to above average which means whatever comes after just needs to be cheaper and more efficient.
Considering how this last year went, that would likely mean by September next year this might actually be the case.
1
u/macronancer 9d ago
The thing with building intelligence is its not like building a higher and higher building, its more like building a ball thats more and more round.
Aftet a while it will be round enough and improvements will be marginal.
3
u/Significant_Spring87 12d ago
I use opus 5.5 as director for ds 4.1 workers, with red team fable. I wish ds 4.x could run with them. I'll be honest after working with Astra it was only good for review and security still. I wanted it to be a daily driver but just was a token drain and didn't get it done.
2
u/davidagnome 12d ago
This. Eventually it’ll be like the difference 4K vs 8k. I can’t tell the difference. Not on a 27” monitor. The quality of the open model and their price will exceed good quality frontiers today.
1
1
u/KrydanX 9d ago
Yeah and when DS is on level of opus 5.5 we have opus 6 which massively outclasses DS. This play of catch won’t be going on forever, once one of the big player figures out RSI it’s over with. DS can’t distill fast enough to catch up, and even if they do so - they can’t match the compute or bring a model that runs on affordable hardware. No idea where this cope comes from.
15
u/azadkashur 12d ago
I don't know what's happening behing the scenes, but I gave same task to OpenCode and Cline with same backend provider, using DeepSeek-flash-1701.
In Opencode my API usage was ~$14 and in cline my API usage was ~$4.
Same model, same provider just different harness. For context, opencode session had 5X cache tokens
11
u/reybrujo 12d ago
Geez, that's insane, one task $14? That sounds like "Write a SNES emulator, make no mistakes" type of prompt.
3
u/azadkashur 12d ago
I build a multi-phase plans, as I work on a large backend system. I do a lot of testing per each phase, and make sure it's "green" before moving to next. So yeah. It's a make no mistakes kind of prompt.
4
2
u/Easy-Mad-740 11d ago
I do the same, with independent reviewers for every single PR and extensive testing, but never reached more than 1-2 dollars per task
1
u/azadkashur 11d ago
AI, is good to get the job done faster, but I'm yet to find a model which will execute anything flawless and without needing supervision/checks and balances
7
u/theresurrected99 12d ago
Cline does write less. That's a problem in cline. I watched it carefully saying I spent 0.90 cents. While the deepseek platform itself says $5. So cline isn't trusty on that
3
u/Dantzig 12d ago
But the harness litterally decides what to send to the model so is it surprising?
3
u/azadkashur 12d ago
Yes, that's why, I moved to Cline. OpenCode is starting to become Microsoft of harnesses. Too many things in the background.
3
2
0
u/Dantzig 12d ago
Claude code can be run with other LLM's than Anthropics afaik
1
u/No_Committee8392 12d ago
Yep. not sure of its “easy”/integrated yet though i think you still just need env vars for it
2
u/TimChr78 12d ago
They definitely has different default reasoning levels - if you set the reasoning level explicitly you should see much closer token usage on OpenCode and the official Deepseek api.
1
1
u/Upstairs-Version-400 10d ago
Try Pi, I would be very curious because I spend less than 50c on moderately heavy tasks
26
26
17
u/Early-Crazy-4246 12d ago
Can I be enlightened as to why people are so persistent on claiming OpenCode's DeepSeek is quantized? I mean literally yes it is quantized out of the factory (Base weights are MXFP4) but I assume they mean OpenCode is quantizing it further (Which makes little sense and doesn't provide any benefit to OC)
On top of that, they've also said several times that they do not quantize the (already quantized) weights?
4
3
u/LiteSoul 12d ago
People persist in that because a few times it seemed dumbed down in the past, and they invented the quantization rumor. In reality there was some technical issues that are being sorted out. Think about it, with the racks OC have, and how small the model is, it doesn't make sense whatsoever to quantize it further, but people is mostly ignorant technically
0
u/gugugaga_069 12d ago
It’s not dumbed down, but they routed most free-use requests to cheaper models to manage the load. it backfired and they reverted
1
u/jkflying 12d ago
There are also other things you can do to make serving cheaper at the expense of quality, like approximations during prefill
1
u/kagamiseki 10d ago
Seems OpenCode DSK model routes through 8 different suppliers, and 2 of them have smaller context windows or something so occasionally you have a longer task that lands on one of those suppliers and you exceed 100k tokens and see a drop in output quality.
Some of the suppliers are also much slower in tokens per second, so it will seem like the same model is struggling more, when it's really just moving the same tokens less quickly.
Finally OpenCode wasn't on 1017 checkpoint for a while. They are now, I think, but before they were literally on a dumber version than other brokers.
1
u/CandiceWoo 9d ago
pple benchmarked it to be worse. and well it could be buggy inference, could be quantization.
1
u/Early-Crazy-4246 7d ago
Won't be quantization (It's trained to be quantized already!), it could be many other things though, even the inference engine being different could be the difference.
My best guess is since their inference team is basically one guy and 2 guys who look over his shoulder, they got a lot of work to do
0
u/Drunkendrakon6 12d ago
Well money
4
u/Early-Crazy-4246 12d ago
In the case of money I'm sure they would've went for more conventional pricing (Starting at $20/month) and served the same from the start. OpenCode has their issues I've read all about it but having used their DeepSeek on Go before I swapped to just using DS API (And then GPT subscription) I couldn't tell you there was any trickery
4
u/rainpurplebow 12d ago
If you are using the model to write Python calculators of course you cannot tell the difference between OC's self hosted version versus the official DS API just like everyone else on this sub.
4
u/Drunkendrakon6 12d ago
All these AI providers are literally black boxes. They can say one thing and do another and as long as no one catches on they profit. I just wouldn't put it past them to screw over their customers silently.
12
u/Total-Management8023 13d ago
this is NOT a good sign
5
3
7
u/Johhaidiidiralla 13d ago
Its easy how. They just increase their own price per request 3 times and voilaa!
People still don't realize that their 10 for 100 was never an equivalent of ds api price.
If you don't believe me, dyor. I did. In best case its 3:1 ratio and on average its less than that.
3
u/letuslisp 12d ago
This was my suspicion. But also the problem is their short cache time. DS keeps the caching alive for hours.
4
1
u/LiteSoul 12d ago
What's the cache time for open code
1
u/letuslisp 12d ago
Really? Openrouter only 5 min or 10 min No opencode only that short. Only deepseek has so long caching
5
4
u/Mobile-Poem9164 12d ago
frank : "yea dax, we can now do ggufs like Q1_XS and nobody will notice !!"
xddddd good one
3
3
u/eXperience79 13d ago
More allowance is good, more quantization is not. At least, let us select the quant level.
3
3
u/Slow-Set-2856 13d ago
Please don't fuck up the quality even more it already is worse than official api on benchmarks
2
2
2
1
1
u/inscrutablemike 12d ago
Did Frank then proceed to tell him what's happening right now or is Frank a drama llama information hoardin' mfer?
1
1
1
1
1
u/dumbasPL 12d ago
How about keep it $100 but make it faster? 100 is already basically unlimited, speed would be much more welcome at this point.
edit: and their calculation almost certainly includes the fact that many users will never reach 100% usage. So the few that do, are paid by all the ones that don't.
1
u/warpaint_james 12d ago
I was using 4.1 flash last night and getting over 200tps and more. So something was cooking
1
u/Tall-Wasabi5030 12d ago
They figured out that half the shit people build is the same context / memory / orchestrator crap and they can just cache the outputs
1
u/gpt872323 11d ago
lol. that would be interesting thing to try send same message prefix as different user in different api key does the previous answer temperature and other params make a difference.
1
1
u/Conscious-Doctor-585 12d ago
To save the servers from potential overload, OC shall refrain from rolling out plans like $5 for $150 of ds, $2 for $60, $1 for $30
1
u/OpenSourceCVEs 10d ago
I have not felt like I lacked when using the Chinese models. Yes, they're rougher than frontier Western models but for my use case, I still do (and enjoy) the deep analytical work and so haven't felt the need of a 'genius' AI yet.
As an enthusiast, I'm excited about the capability coming out but I've seen diminishing returns in utility, especially when measured against the token consumption rate.
I just need a reliable enough AI, especially for parsing large amounts of data. Though I have an OAI sub, it's mostly to use as an orchestrator for my Chinese models.
I'm experimenting with local LM but until I get something better than 3070, it's not super practical for my use case.
1
u/CardiologistStock685 13d ago
What is this dark story telling us? And who will actually be the winner? We can't just have too many winner!
0
-1
u/the_foreigner63 12d ago
Okay bro, I wish 300 usd is not just a number. I exhausted opencode go monthly quota with around 9B dsv4.1 tokens when amplifier was 80usd of dsv4 for 10 bucks, so its around 4 times more tokens, i guess ~33B. Would be certainly enough for me, id even buy go plus if this would be true. And again thanks opencode for cheap access
0
u/MadOff33_real_one 11d ago
Pour un etudiant en ostéopathie en France vous pensez que cela fonctionne ? Je sais je fais aussi ma réponse : il n’y a qu’à leur demander ! 😜. Mais au cas où… Thanks
0
0
46
u/Cyvster 13d ago
1 bit quant?