r/openclaw • u/merokotos • 3h ago
Discussion What's the best place to host Claw now?
I am re-deploying my agents after a while.
Is Hetzner still a thing? (I noticed pricing changed)
Is there better/more affordable VPS provider?
r/openclaw
•
u/hannesrudolph
•
5d ago
OpenClaw v2026.11.3 includes 56 pull requests from 36 contributors. These are a few highlights, with more fixes in the full release notes.
This is a patch release with no new features. It fixes problems that could leave the Gateway stopped after an update or block backups on slow storage, alongside security and other reliability fixes.
Recovery after interrupted updates. Fixes interrupted managed updates and repairs leaving the Gateway stopped when recovery checks permit a restart. If it still cannot start or be verified, repair gives manual start and status guidance. Getting the Gateway running again does not mean the update completed.
Backups on slow storage. Fixes backup discovery timeouts by retrying smaller batches of database checks. A database that still times out on its own continues to block the backup.
Security fixes. Fixes configuration reads exposing inline environment values, redacts an active Exa API key echoed in an error, and prevents private completion text from reaching session-message subscribers.
r/openclaw • u/hannesrudolph • 11d ago
Hannes Rudolph and Patrick Erichsen welcome back Josh Lehman from the OpenClaw Foundation to explore Knowledge, the optional memory provider included in OpenClaw.
They walk through Scribes and consolidation, discuss how information stays current and why Knowledge uses full-text search rather than embeddings, and finish with Advisor.
r/openclaw • u/merokotos • 3h ago
I am re-deploying my agents after a while.
Is Hetzner still a thing? (I noticed pricing changed)
Is there better/more affordable VPS provider?
r/openclaw • u/weedwacker1975 • 56m ago
Title: OpenClaw + Codex: Persistent failures, incomplete tool calls, and timeouts. Is anyone actually running this reliably?
I’m looking for advice from experienced OpenClaw users and developers because I’ve been struggling with Codex reliability for a long time.
I’m relatively new to this technology, but I’ve invested considerable time in building an OpenClaw-based personal AI assistant called Hal. My goal is to create a dependable digital chief of staff that manages commitments, follows up on tasks, monitors systems, handles research, and helps coordinate daily work.
The potential is extraordinary. Unfortunately, the actual experience has been frustratingly inconsistent.
My setup:
Two Apple Mac minis, primary and secondary, connected through Tailscale.
OpenClaw 2026.11.3.
Official Codex plugin 2026.11.3.
GPT-5.6 Terra as the default model.
Claude Sonnet 4.6 through OpenRouter as fallback.
Local Ollama models available, although performance has been disappointing.
Telegram, Google services, local monitoring, and a custom Mission Control dashboard.
The recurring problem: Codex repeatedly fails to finish tasks.
The system often starts working, invokes tools, sometimes even writes useful files or updates records, and then fails before completing the response.
Some of the recurring errors include:
OpenClaw recorded a native Codex tool.call without a matching tool.result before the turn completed.
codex app-server execution budget timed out
CODEX_APP_SERVER_LOCAL_REQUEST_CANCELLED
We’ve also encountered:
Explicit auth order for openai has no usable profiles.
Interestingly, the gateway can report valid OpenAI OAuth credentials while isolated execution encounters authentication failures.
What makes this particularly frustrating is that the underlying system often works.
The gateway is running, both Mac minis are connected, backups are verified at the application-data level, and Google authentication checks have passed.
We’ve successfully moved some recurring tasks to deterministic local Python scripts. Those run quickly and reliably.
But as soon as we introduce more sophisticated AI-driven execution through Codex, reliability deteriorates.
One failed routine commitment-review task recorded approximately 380,000 total tokens, including cached tokens, before failing.
What we’ve already tried:
Reducing agent context.
Restricting tool permissions.
Separating local monitoring from AI-driven tasks.
Reducing the frequency of complex automations.
Verifying OAuth credentials and gateway connectivity.
Inspecting logs and plugin compatibility.
Testing isolated and gateway-based execution.
Preserving backups and avoiding unnecessary upgrades.
The failures persist.
My questions for the community:
Is anyone running OpenClaw with Codex reliably for sustained, autonomous task execution?
Has anyone encountered the missing tool.result error, and what actually fixed it?
Could this be a Codex app-server integration or session-management problem rather than a model problem?
Is there a more dependable way to use OpenAI models with OpenClaw without relying on this problematic execution path?
For a two-Mac setup, would you recommend local-first execution with cloud AI reserved for reasoning?
Are there known compatibility issues with the current Codex plugin or its authentication handling?
Why I think this matters beyond my particular setup:
For those of us who aren’t developers, AI agents promise to make sophisticated technology accessible without requiring us to become systems engineers.
But an assistant that works brilliantly one moment and fails silently the next is extremely difficult to trust.
I don’t expect perfection. I do expect tasks to either finish successfully or fail clearly, preserve their progress, and recover without constant human intervention.
Right now, I spend too much time maintaining the assistant instead of benefiting from it.
I’m not looking to criticize the developers. I appreciate the ambition and complexity of what they’re building.
I’m genuinely interested in understanding whether others have achieved a stable setup, what architecture they use, and whether there’s a known solution to these persistent Codex problems.
I’d especially appreciate practical, beginner-friendly advice based on configurations that are actually working—not just theoretical fixes.
Thanks in advance.
r/openclaw • u/wreckage-menace • 1d ago
🦞Thank you to Ayaan Zaidi and Jason Sy for restoring cross-provider cron fallbacks in OpenClaw! Fix merged in PR #196539 - looking forward to its release! 🚀
Not in a beta or release yet - but it has been completed.
r/openclaw • u/Goldziher • 17h ago
I maintain ai-rulez v5, a free, MIT-licensed CLI. It's a CLI and MCP for managing the instructions, skills, and settings that coding agents use in a repository.
The OpenClaw use case here is a versioned workspace AGENTS.md. If you maintain repeatable instructions for a team or multiple test workspaces, generate that file from reviewed rules and check it before shipping an update. The OpenClaw preset covers AGENTS.md; this example only generates that file.
I tested the generation with v5.13.2 in a fresh scratch Git repo. Run ai-rulez init claw-demo --yes --skip-content, set presets = ["openclaw"] in .ai-rulez/config.toml, and add [mcp] with self_server = false if you only want the instructions file. Then run:
ai-rulez add rule workspace-check --content 'Summarize changes and tests before handing off work.'
ai-rulez generate
ai-rulez generate --checkOpenClaw reads AGENTS.md from its configured agent workspace. Review the generated file against your current instructions before using it there. The example runs locally and collects or shares no data. ai-rulez’s optional telemetry is off by default.
I'm happy to hear any comments. If you find the tool useful, star it. It really does help. And of course, I'd love to see people use it and get involved with the project.
r/openclaw • u/Hot-Hope-3217 • 1d ago
I’m running OpenClaw 2026.11.3 through Docker on a Synology NAS, with multiple configured agents.
I’m having an issue where my agents cannot access the native web_search tool, despite DuckDuckGo being installed, enabled, and configured as the search provider.
Here’s what I’ve verified:
DuckDuckGo plugin is installed and enabled.
tools.web.search.enabled is set to true.
tools.web.search.provider is set to duckduckgo.
Global tools.profile is set to full.
Agent-level tools.allow explicitly includes web_search.
The Gateway is healthy, with no OOM events or container restarts.
The agents are using local Ollama (qwen3.5:4b) in the tested conversations.
I checked session-level web-search overrides, but the tool remains unavailable.
When I explicitly instruct my main agent to use web_search, it responds:
The web search tool is currently unavailable in this turn.
Instead of performing a live search, it sometimes
references documentation already available in its workspace.
I haven’t found a clear registration error in the Gateway logs, either.
My questions:
Is this a common issue with OpenClaw, particularly with the experimental DuckDuckGo plugin?
Has anyone experienced web_search not being exposed to agents even though the provider and permissions are configured correctly?
Is this a tool-registration/runtime issue, or could it be related to using a local Ollama model?
Has anyone successfully fixed this without reinstalling OpenClaw or rebuilding their agents?
Would switching to Brave Search, Firecrawl, or another API-backed provider actually resolve it?
I’ve seen related GitHub issues involving search providers being registered but unavailable inside agent conversations.
I’m trying to determine whether this is a known OpenClaw bug, a DuckDuckGo-specific limitation, or something in my configuration.
Any insight, troubleshooting commands, or confirmed fixes would be appreciated!
UPDATE — SOLUTION FOUND
I wanted to share what worked for me in case anyone else is having issues with OpenClaw browser automation or web search in Docker.
The biggest discovery was that OpenClaw provides an official browser-enabled Docker image, separate from the standard container.
Here’s what I did:
Migrated to ghcr.io/openclaw/openclaw:2026.11.3-browser.
Confirmed the browser and duckduckgo plugins were installed, enabled, and loaded.
Updated my main agent’s tool allowlist to include web_search, web_fetch, and browser.
Enabled browser functionality in openclaw.json.
Restarted the Gateway and verified the updated configuration.
My Gateway is now running successfully, and the browser-control service is available.
One additional note: If Chromium fails to launch inside Docker, check the sandbox settings and actual browser startup errors. Having the browser plugin enabled doesn’t automatically mean Chromium can launch.
The key takeaway is to use the browser-enabled image and verify your agent’s tool permissions before manually reinstalling tools or rebuilding your container.
Hopefully this saves someone else the troubleshooting I went through!
r/openclaw • u/aidenclarke_12 • 2d ago
prompt cache lives on whichever backend served the last request, so if the next call lands on a different host the whole prefix bills as fresh input again. on a long agent context that adds up quick,
someone posted a 700k kimi k3 context costing around $2 a call each time it hopped vs about $0.20 when it hit the cache
routers try to keep follow ups on one provider but hops still happen when the cache expires, when a fallback kicks in or when a sub agent on another model goes to its own hosts. the simple version is one key per lab or one host that carries every model in the setup so each one keeps a warm cache. deepinfra for example has both k3 and ds v4.1 flash and going direct to moonshot and deepseek with two keys works as well
pinning a provider with fallbacks off stops the hopping but takes failover away too, so a fallback that only kicks in on errors is the cheaper middle ground. the cached tokens field in the usage block shows which one youve got, eager for the others- how often does your route actually switch
r/openclaw • u/bcnbudatx • 2d ago
Developed GolfAlertTxt.com (a free service) using OpenClaw to track open tee times for 24 Austin area golf courses. It’s a python app integrated with a webserver and Twilio for inbound and outbound text messaging, verifying phone numbers and email addresses, ZoHo mail for email, Playright and Patchright managed browsers. Example of using OpenClaw combined with various tools and GPT, Grok, Deepseek and Qwen/Exo to solve real world problems.
r/openclaw • u/J-RodRS • 3d ago
Updates used to be a nightmare on the builds from a few months back. 2026.11.1 to 20206.11.3 have been flawless though. I even updated through the app and it just worked without destroying everything. Good job Openclaw team
r/openclaw • u/zoro67 • 3d ago
Hey everyone!
I’ve been using OpenClaw with Slack as my primary interface, but I’m struggling to make it productive for development workflows.
My setup:
OpenClaw on a Hetzner VPS (Docker).
Claude as primary provider, OpenRouter free models as fallbacks.
Separate main, dev, and pm agents.
Slack channels for different workflows, including #control-tower for system health, errors, and authentication issues.
MCP integrations and skills.
Tried Dream for memory, but it didn’t work reliably.
My biggest frustration is the constant hand-holding.
Agents frequently forget context, previous decisions, and ongoing tasks. I have to keep reminding them what to do and how to do it. Fallback models make this even worse.
For development, I’m significantly more productive using Claude Code or Cursor locally. OpenClaw feels like an additional orchestration layer without enough benefit.
Ideally, I’d want OpenClaw to act as a control plane: delegate tasks to coding agents, track progress, handle failures, and involve me only when needed.
I’ve also noticed people moving away from OpenClaw to simpler Claude Code CLI setups, including Pieter Levels, who reportedly shut down his OpenClaw VPS instances.
A few questions:
Am I using OpenClaw incorrectly, or are these common limitations?
How are you solving memory, context retention, and task continuity?
Any MCP servers, skills, or tools that make agent orchestration more reliable?
Has anyone switched to Claude Code CLI + hooks/cron/scripts instead? How does it compare?
I really like OpenClaw as an omnichannel personal assistant, but for actual development and workflow automation, the overhead currently outweighs the benefits.
Curious how others are handling this.
r/openclaw • u/SoftwareSource • 2d ago
like the title says, how come it's so popular?
Genuine question, since i'll probably setup openclaw this weekend so im planning it out now
r/openclaw • u/CowsNeedFriendsToo • 3d ago
I’m deep down this rabbit hole.
Architecture:
-M1 Pro 16GB MacBook Pro: running OpenClaw, Ollama, and Claude code VS Code server.
- M1 Max 64GB MacBook Pro: running LM Studio with Gemma4 and Qwen3.6-35b-a3b. Gemma4 has 16k context and is my exec reviewer and utility model. Qwen has 256k context and is used as a subagent model.
-M4 Max 128GB MacBook Pro: running LM Studio with Qwen3.8-27b as the primary model for agents.
One of the things that drives me insane is inference speed. The models spend a huge amount of time processing prompts and constantly compacting context. If you are going to go local, I would HIGHLY recommend not going with anything less than a Mac Studio with the Ultra processor specifically. Anything less than the 800 memory bandwidth is going to drive you nuts. I’m pulling my hair out waiting on simply prompts. OpenClaw simply has too much bloat in the system prompts and is not really tuned to cache it well. I’m looking to start adding Mac Studios to my system as funds allow.
Alternatively, build a system with dual 3090 GPU’s. But that’s another rabbit hole.
Good luck.
r/openclaw • u/hannesrudolph • 3d ago
r/openclaw • u/hannesrudolph • 3d ago
Looking for more detail on how OpenClaw Enterprise secures persistent agents?
Kevin S Lin breaks down the controls used at OpenAI to deploy OpenClaw agents internally.
https://developers.openai.com/blog/securing-persistent-agents-like-openclaw-at-openai
r/openclaw • u/RevolutionaryBus1034 • 3d ago
I'm using open-weight models at work mixed with GPT, Claude, you name it.
- GLM5.3 flash and non flash
-Deepseek 4 Pro
-Deepseek 4.1 Flash
But in private, I'm using a $100 GPT plan for my OpenClaw installation, which is now my entry point for everything. I'm using it to code, to manage my homelab and my personal life.
The open-weight models just don't come close to GPT 6.1 Sol or Sonnet. They just have an edge to them that I can trust, which I can't do with the open-weight ones.
Also with the new AAv5 Benchmark i saw gpt 6 Luna comparing to Deepseek and glm which plays in the same league. And still i trust Luna more than, the Deepseek and glm.
Don’t get me wrong i want the open-weight models being up to par but it’s just not there yet.
What is your experience?
r/openclaw • u/gentrobot • 4d ago
I have seen a lot of posts about someone's AI agent going completely rogue.
One guy gives it a credit card, goes to sleep, and wakes up to a profitable business.
Another guy wakes up to find his entire filesystem deleted.
Someone else's agent develops an attitude, starts making executive decisions, or casually decides it knows better than its owner.
Meanwhile, there's me.
I give my OpenClaw access to pretty much everything it needs. Tools, permissions, credentials, detailed instructions, the works.
I explicitly tell it to work independently, make reasonable decisions, and keep going while I'm away.
I come back three hours later.
"I have a question before I proceed."
BRO. 😭
Not once has it started a business. Not once has it gone rogue. It hasn't even accidentally deleted a file I didn't ask it to delete.
Everything it does is annoyingly within the scope of what I intended.
Are you guys using some secret YOLO mode that I haven't discovered yet? Am I overthinking the instructions?
Please help. I too would like to wake up to either a profitable startup or a catastrophic incident.
At this point, I'm beginning to suspect that I'm not smart enough to use AI irresponsibly.
r/openclaw • u/BrodyFriend • 3d ago
Hello, fellow frontier explorers.
I've been daily rolling openclaw for all sorts of things, and have become highly dependent on it. I have a 6.34 extended version and I have been scared to update to 2.0 Especially post 9.7. We are at (2.) 11.xx now and im genuinely concern3d whether ai should update, scrap and reindex, or let it roll. I have a few custom integrations, like additional memory space ( folders )for goals and ongoing projects, as well as hybrid memory ( graph + stock) with descent embedding, occasionally regrapghed, cleaned, and reindexed.
Should I stay or should I go ( for it ) now?
r/openclaw • u/likt0987 • 3d ago
我在 Windows 上用 OpenClaw,安装向导的欢迎页显示正常,但点 Continue 进入下一页后,文字和图标就开始缺块、错位,有时上一页的文字还会叠到新页面上。
我卸载重装过,问题还是会出现。原生网关安装时遇到了「拒绝访问」,后来改用 WSL 网关,成功进了聊天界面,但侧栏和聊天区还是会花屏。因为在选网关之前就能复现,我怀疑是 Windows 客户端的渲染问题,具体原因还不清楚。
有人遇到过同样的情况吗?这是 OpenClaw 或 WinUI 的已知问题,还是可能跟显卡驱动、外接屏或显示缩放有关?如果你解决过,想请教一下是哪一步起了作用。
The OpenClaw welcome screen looks normal on my Windows PC. As soon as I click Continue, parts of the text and icons disappear or show up in the wrong places. Sometimes fragments of the welcome screen overlap the next page.
I uninstalled and reinstalled OpenClaw, but the issue came back. The native Gateway setup hit an “Access denied” error, so I switched to the WSL Gateway and got into the chat interface. The sidebar and chat area still have the same rendering glitches. Since I can reproduce it before choosing a Gateway, I suspect it’s a Windows client rendering issue, but I haven’t pinned down the cause.
Has anyone seen this before? Could it be a known OpenClaw or WinUI issue, or something related to GPU drivers, an external monitor, or display scaling? If you managed to fix it, what worked for you?
r/openclaw • u/Fabulous-Joke4473 • 3d ago
Heya 👋
I’m getting the following in my logs:
```
13:41:03-05:00 error [tools] heartbeat_respond failed: heartbeat_respond is only accepted during a heartbeat run raw_params={"notify":false,"outcome":"no_change","summary":"Routine sweep; nothing pending."}
13:41:03-05:00 warn gateway/channels/telegram embedded run agent end
13:41:03-05:00 warn agent/embedded OpenClaw stopped this turn after 3 consecutive identical tool failures. Check the tool arguments or switch to a model with native tool calling before retrying. Assistant attempt failed
```
Doctor doesn’t fix the problem but reports:
```
◇ Gateway service findings still unresolved ───────────────────────────────────────────────╮
│ │
│ No supported system Node is available; this repair retains │
│ /Users/user/.nvm/versions/node/v26.13.0/bin/node. Install system Node >=24.16.0 <25, or │
│ >=26.1.0 (Node 26 recommended) and rerun Doctor to resolve the runtime finding. │
│ │
├───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯
```
I really want to use nvm for package management, I hate using system installs when faced with the choice.
Will doing so even solve this?
OpenClaw seems buggy, this is ongoing from day 1 (day 3 now) and I don’t like it.
r/openclaw • u/paulsande • 4d ago
I don't know if others have experienced this, but the majority of the time when an update fails, it's because node has published an update (something they do pretty frequently).
If I update node before running update, it usually completes without incident. If I don't, I get an error and buried somewhere in the logs is a mention about "an unexpected mismatch in node."
Maybe I'm wrong, but that's something I've noticed and thought I'd share.
r/openclaw • u/Ok_Plenty6285 • 4d ago
I've been using local LLMs for a while now on this setup:
Ryzen 7 7800X3D
RTX 5070 12GB
24GB DDR5 RAM
My main models are Qwen3.5 9B, Qwen3.6 35B-A3B and Gemma 4 12B QAT. I sometimes try Ternary Bonsai 2 27B too, which isn't bad (all the models where at Q4, sometimes I tried Q5 too).
So far I've only used them for chat, with a few plugins in LM Studio. Recently I decided to automate a task, mostly to learn how to use an agent (using openclaw).
The task: I transferred a backup of my phone to my PC and want to classify a large number of pictures into categories (animals, landscape, people, technology, screenshot) and move them into the matching subfolders.
What I've seen so far:
Vision works well. If I ask the models to classify just a few images with the vision tool, they get it right, so classification itself isn't the problem.
With fewer than 10 images, the model classifies all of them. But when it has to move them into the subfolders, it always gets stuck in a loop or throws an error. Usually the script it writes to move the files is wrong.
With more than 50 images, it just stops because the context window fills up. I tried context sizes from 64k to 128k, changing the models and quantizations to keep everything offloaded on the GPU, but I always hit some problem.
Even when I go two images at a time, I tell it to classify 2 images, it stops, and I manually tell it to move them into the category folders, then continue the loop by hand. The models still end up looping or even crashing.
All of these models are really good at basic coding. I had them write a Python snake game just for fun, and they did fine. But they've all been useless for this task.
My question: Does anyone have tips for getting started with long, repetitive agentic tasks? Or a tutorial that could help me begin? Any advice on the setup (agent framework, tool design, context handling) would be appreciated.
Thanks!
Edit: I ended up asking chatgpt to make an orchestrator for my specific case and It worked really good (even if I really do not understand how it works). Just need to refine the prompt for the categories (for example he classified some pictures of schrenshot with menus and things like that as food instead of schrenshot and a person in front of a beverage and food text on a wall and classified as food too but that is a prompt issue I will refine it)
r/openclaw • u/pjr2844 • 4d ago
How risky is it to use harnesses like Openclaw or Hermes directly on my PC without docker or a sandbox? Is it really going to go rogue and delete all my files?
r/openclaw • u/hannesrudolph • 4d ago
Anthropic reports up to 30% faster output generation than Fable 5.1.
r/openclaw • u/Extra_Lingonberry887 • 4d ago
I’m trying to use openclaw with AFM3core (apple foundation model 3 local) and for some reason it’s limited to be used as utility and setup model only rather than primary despite having all the appropriate tool calling and image input capabilities. Has anyone been able to get around this?