r/oneringrpg • • Jan 02 '25

Solo with ChatGPT

0 Upvotes

So just completed a full scenario with the AI as the loremaster. Overall it was pretty fun, the AI used Tolkien lore fairly accurately, and when it wasn’t accurate, my character was able to guide the Ai in the appropriate direction (the palantir at Amon Sul needed saving, and when i reminded it of the lore, the loremaster basically came back with “no, this is a lesser palantir” and kept on going with it). I found with the rules that frequently i had to correct it regarding mechanics like inspiration and hope, as well as some strange rules during the fellowship phase that must have been from the 1st edition of the game (which i have never read). But once i said “it doesn’t work that way can you review the rules in the 2nd edition the one ring”, it would reply with corrections. The AI came up with some clever lore based traps as i discovered a secret room hidden beneath Amon Sul, accessed by an ancient cistern, whilst agents of Sauron above seemed to be digging into weathertop trying to find the buried treasure. There was a sense of urgency. Then on the escape with the lesser palantir in my pack, i had a series of eye of Sauron rolls on the feat die (i rolled my own physical dice and input the results), and it beautifully interpreted this as the pull of the lesser palantir and the eye being upon me. Shadow points were missing. The role of eye awareness was not really there unless it was keeping track of it in the background the way a real loremaster would. Didn’t have any combat at all, which seems appropriate for a TOR scenario, so can’t comment on how that would work. All of this on my iPad, using ChatGPT app. Played for several hours and almost finished the fellowship phase before i ran out of free responses. I downloaded the chat and the game took up 42 printed pages.

Anyway thought it would be interesting to report, though I’m sure many others have done this before me. The most impressive thing i think was how it would create lore the was adjacent to existing lore and mostly still convincing. A lot of what happened surrounded my character as a Ranger and Warden, my distinctive features, and some very cool problem solving surrounding the stars of Elendil.

Overall it was fun and a little weird knowing that there was nothing on the other side of my interaction. Some uncomfortable ethical stuff underlies this maybe…but without a group to play with, there is no way playing strider mode alone i would have come up with the scenario as it unfolded.

Interested in others thoughts and opinions.


r/oneringrpg • • Mar 04 '21

Who else is not excited by the direction of 2E?

0 Upvotes

I've been following the development and comments on the Fria Ligans board for the 2nd Edition of The One Ring...excuse me.....for The Lord of the Rings: The One Ring.........and I'm not impressed.

They claim it is usable with 1e, but there are a lot of changes. I don't like that Hope will now be spent BEFORE the die rolls, and will only give you an additional success die to roll. I don't like that TN's are now lower. I don't like the art style of the new books. I don't like the increased use of "Advantage/Disadvantage" with the Feat die.

How are all you feeling about 2E?


r/oneringrpg • • Sep 07 '26

Skill roll mechanics are not intuitive

0 Upvotes

Reading through The One Ring 2nd edition rules.

The dice pooling mechanics are very strange - have had to reread several times. I'm used to players rolling a die or dice, adding modifiers, then compare to a target number equal to the difficulty. Simple.

Do skill and combat checks flow smoothly during gameplay? Can tell there's going to be some grumbling in my game group until we get used to it.


r/oneringrpg • • Sep 09 '25

Best virtues

0 Upvotes

Not all Virtues are created equal. Which culture virtues is it best for PCs to take first? There are some team player virtues that help the whole party, others that are straight up hax on entire mechanics.


r/oneringrpg • • Jul 06 '26

Help!

0 Upvotes

Is there a complete list of books, cultures, and classes for 1e and 2e? Thank you!


r/oneringrpg • • Jun 19 '23

Is there a character creator for this game which from my understanding may or may not even be based on middle-earth?

0 Upvotes

Originally I was gonna ask this sort of question about the adventures in middle earth but I thought it best if I go for this one first.

Besides I'm only asking for the one ring rpg first so only that one and nothing more that's for a different subreddit for another time and another day if I feel like it.


r/oneringrpg • • Jun 15 '26

Has anyone made a game rule that would allow me and my fellow players to play as Orcs? Or other 'evil' creatures?

2 Upvotes

r/oneringrpg • • Sep 20 '26

Elven musicians in the court of King Thranduil

Post image
0 Upvotes

On our way from Erebor to Moria our dwarven group stopped at Brother Day's court. We were to ask for King Thranduil's permission for King Dain's army to pass through the Greenwood on the way Moria. Our Lore Master can be a bit cheeky with NPC names.

The year is 2989, and as far as we know, no dwarf has set their foot in Moria for a thousand years.


r/oneringrpg • • Feb 01 '25

Playing evil characters

1 Upvotes

Hey All!

I'm preparing to run a duet campaign for a friend, and I'm currently reading through the books I own. (core, tales, shire suppl.)
He will def. play a hobbit, but I was wondering if one could run a game, either campaign or one-shot, for an evil character? I know this is not the point of the game, or the setting even, but maybe his character could get corrupted?
For example, he would start his journey being cheerful and hobbit-y, but during his encounters he becomes greedy. That would change the focus of his adventures to him seeking out treasures and generally being drawn to the evil artifacts of old instead of growing all what is beautiful. Something like Gollum or Thorin in the end?

Other examples would be leading a party of orcs (something like the solo in the Moria suppl.) or playing through events as a powerful enemy, like a nazgul or balrog. This would be an interesting solo adventure to be honest. :)

Perhaps these topics are mentioned in the books I just haven't noticed. Regardless, I'd be interested in your opinion and how would you pull off such a thing?


r/oneringrpg • • Aug 30 '26

Is the new LOTR 5E campaign the first actual full campaign?

1 Upvotes

I’m a little confused about how the adventure books for The Lord of the Rings Roleplaying 5E work.

I know there are already books like Tales From Eriador, Ruins of Eriador, Shire Adventures, etc., but from what I understand these are mostly collections of adventures, locations, or campaign frameworks rather than a traditional prewritten D&D campaign.

I saw the upcoming The White Towers / Halls of the Kings products described as including a campaign. Is this going to be the first actual full-length prewritten campaign for LOTR 5E, similar to how a D&D campaign book works? Or is it expanding/continuing a campaign that already exists in one of the previous books?

Basically, if I wanted to DM LOTR 5E and run one continuous prewritten campaign from beginning to end, what book(s) would I use?


r/oneringrpg • • Feb 04 '26

Advice on character creation

2 Upvotes

I almost always play elves in fantasy settings. In the context of Tolkein, I want the character to feel powerful, a Noldorian elf that has seen the light of Aman. However, I worry that with the need for balance they'll be little different to a man from Bree. We only have the core rules, so it's just the Elves of Lindon available. I can see a decent Archer build in there but that seems a bit too much like a Silvan elf, rather than say one that came back to Middle Earth and has "stature" like Glorfindel (I am quite attacked to awe in that context). in terms of attributes I like the idea of a powerful character (high strength and wits) and the reason they have low hope is they are weary of middle earth. But does that work with their main ability using hope points to get magical successes?


r/oneringrpg • • Apr 03 '26

Detecting Lies and Deception

0 Upvotes

So I've played The One Ring for a few months now and it seems to me that lying NPCs are a significant weakness in the system.

Let us consider the following scenario in D&D and TOR.

An NPC approaches the players and bequeaths them to help their friends who are deep in a bandit cave. The 'lie' is that the bandits are the NPC's friends and they're going to ambush the party for their gear.

In D&D, if the players seem suspicious of the NPC, they can roll insight and catch the lie if they succeed.

In TOR however insight would only tell you the NPC wants to help their friends, and the players really have no recourse in catching the deception.

Alright, so you have to rely on real world lie detection. Now obv in real life we don't determine lies through dice rolls (much simpler if we could :D), and instead have to rely on intuition, body language, and cross checking information. Of these, only cross checking is available to TTRPG players, since they can't see the NPC, which is one, boring (to me at least), and two heavily dependent on a GM sufficiently cluing the players into the deception.

Considering how easy it is for players to focus on the wrong thing the GM is trying to direct them to and how difficult it actually is to describe a character lying without outright saying it, it makes total sense to me that this is best resolved mechanically with a skill check in D&D.

That TOR doesn't have mechanical way of detecting lies, something the players have little ability to determine independently due to the game genre, seems to me a HUGE oversight.

Has anyone else encountered this problem?


r/oneringrpg • • Aug 15 '26

09 Aventuras de la Compañía de Bree. El Prisionero de Monte Gram (Actual Roleplaying in Spanish)

Post image
2 Upvotes

Here you have the last episode of this season 2026. https://youtu.be/lykBhe49Ltw


r/oneringrpg • • Jan 01 '26

I struggle with the limitations of Middle Earth

22 Upvotes

Hi,

I have run games in other settings before but I struggle coming up with stories in Middle Earth due to a few reasons.

  1. The pre-established world

The world of Middle Earth is already so established and the story of the ring so well known that it seems very difficult to have characters that can truly change the world without breaking the cannon.

Also, I can’t really have my stories set after the defeat of Sauron because the elves leave for the undying lands.

I’d like to create a big bad but I don’t see the gaps in the world that I could fill in.

2. The barren landscape.

I know things can be be done with wilderness exploration and ruins but the lack of towns in Eriador make me think that this would get boring relatively quickly with few new NPC’s to meet and no large human cities.

3. I really wish there was a way to measure distances in combat (bonus)

I really love miniatures and especially ones from the LOTR SBG and would love to use them along with terrain for the battles but there isn’t a way to do that as written. Any homebrew suggestions would be very appreciated.

——

Thanks, I’d love to know your thoughts!!!


r/oneringrpg • • Oct 18 '26

Ruling advice: Got a big pushback for ruling slaying fleeing goblins as a misdeed

7 Upvotes

The Book (5e) says:

"Misdeed: Torment or torture: Killing/crippling a surrendered/harmless foe: 4 Shadow Points"

And

"Merely attempting to do something despicable is a Misdeed."

Company Warden OHKO'd a goblin archer, who had just started it's retreat from battle, as an opportunity attack reaction to it fleeing their combat zone, I decided to warn them it would be a misdeed, and they went "...are you serious? It's of orc-kind!", and I backed off.

Not sure who's in the right here.


r/oneringrpg • • Dec 02 '25

Would i be better running the 5e version if my party is more familiar with the films than the books?

6 Upvotes

The One Ring sounds great but I fear my party will be expecting to slay dozens of orcs with ease like aragorn and co do in the films, would I be better running 5e to capture the action of the films or do you think we'll get by with the One Ring system? (I do realise this sub will probably be biased to the One Ring but I figured it was the best place to ask).


r/oneringrpg • • Feb 05 '26

Thinking into convert The One Ring to the PbtA engine.

0 Upvotes

I think that mixing The One Ring and Fellowship, it could be easily achieved a PbtA ttrpg.
Strength, Heart, Wits, Valour and Wisdom could be the attributes.
The six Callings could be the playbooks.
Hope, Shadow, Fellowship mechanic and theme should be preserved.
The Loremaster could be the Dark Lord, in a similat way as it is the Overlord in Fellowship.
I don’t know, ideas, thoughts?


r/oneringrpg • • Sep 19 '26

Need help with a homebrew

2 Upvotes

I'm gonna run a oneshot set in the world of Legend of Zelda and using one ring (1st edition) as the system (because I quite like its mechanics and think they git nicely for what I have in mind). I'mmostly rearranging skill points for the cultures of Hyrule and reskinning the things already in the system (for example, Gorons get the cultural benefit of the lonely mountain dwarves).

What I need help with is adding a third stat alongside wisdom and courage (that being power). It just makes sense for the world of Zelda to have the whole trinity of the triforce. However, I'm not so sure what investing into power could give since wisdom already grants abilities and courage items.

So, if any people more experienced with the system or familiar with Zelda could lend me a hand I'd be grateful!


r/oneringrpg • • Jan 21 '23

On The Fence

2 Upvotes

With everything going with Wizards of the Coast and this new OGL scam they are doing . . . it has caused me to search for other game systems (if the OGL final version goes bad). At one point in time I almost moved over to AiMe even before this OGL scandal started but I didn't.

The reasoning for this was where my beloved Middle-earth is concerned, the surprise factor is gone since we all basically know the history of Middle-earth. I've always like running campaigns that had an EPIC middle/ending like a long lasting campaign that slowly built up to a massive war, but with AiMe/TOR that just won't happen, everything would be on a smaller scale.

Don't get me wrong, I 100% LOVE LOVE LOVE everything Middle-earth. I love it so much I did not even watch this new Rings of Power crap on Amazon because it's just not Middle-earth. But, as this post title says, I am on the fence on if I WERE to move away from WotC and D&D where would I go. It would have to be a rules set that was not D&D and Middle-earth is on the list only not AiMe since it uses 5e. I can't explain it, even though I adore this universe with all my heart, I simply have not gotten excited about the prospect of possibly relocating to TOR.

Maybe this post makes sense and some might see where my head is at on this lol.


r/oneringrpg • • Aug 20 '24

What are your opinions?

0 Upvotes

Hi, I've been playing RPGs for a few years now. I've been exposed to a few systems, I'd like to talk about OneRing and your impressions. I don't know how much of my perceptions are due to the mechanics of the system and how much are due to the way Game Master run this (I play OneRing as a player, I've mainly run games so far) but I feel that this system is very much infantile.

Even the first adventures are designed in a very childish way, not too much anticipating other approaches to solving the problem than those proposed by the author. These adventures made me hate hobbits, seriously. In a system where even ‘wrong thinking’ can bring us shadow, it sends us on a mission to steal Bilbo's memento, which wasn't even taken from him unlawfully.

Acutally, in our game we did not play hobbits, but creatures that we want to continue. The team split into two camps during this adventure, one went to investigate the museum, the others went to the inn. The adventure immediately assumed that if something bad was happening in the town, strangers would be blamed. Even though we sat in the inn the whole time. What else to call this but racism?

I won't even write about the consequences of this in the next scenario, those who have played it know, and those who haven't will have no spoilers. The final plot twist with Bilbo is done by force, silly, not fitting the character of the cunning Hobbit who won the ring.

But enough about the opening scenarios. The other aspect that spoils it somewhat is the boss battle mechanics. In fact, the combat in general. I don't know what this system is supposed to be used for, whether we are playing here as inhabitants of Middle-earth who happen to encounter dangers, or perhaps as aspiring heroes who want to help this world. After all, winning against any of the more powerful opponents is pretty unlikely, as they regain a lot of health if you don't make a piercing hit in a small window of time.

The mechanics of interrogations are little understood. But here I have the impression that it is acutely the fault of my group. We are incapable of switching to abstract and illogical thinking. We always try to use logical arguments to convince, and I don't think that's what this system is about.

And finally, are the inhabitants in Middle-earth in your games as indifferent to the evil going on around them? We won't go to any town if there is something bad going on there - a family has disappeared, someone has lost their crops and therefore their livelihood, there is a monster nearby that eats people - others don't give a damn. There is always the explanation ‘You know how it is, life is hard’. Nobody tries to do anything, nobody wants to help. Remember - this system punishes you with shadow for very similar behaviours, but somehow other people aren't affected. And again I point out, I don't know if this is not our GM's vision of the world, but he told us that this is how it is described in the One Ring manuals.

It came out a bit gruff, don't take it as an attack, I'd like to hear other people's opinions.


r/oneringrpg • • May 10 '24

The Star of the Mist - Broken Bridge Map Spoiler

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/oneringrpg • • Oct 12 '25

Cram

Post image
19 Upvotes

My Barding has the recipe for Cram which greatly helps our party recover endurance. Since we play online, I generated this meme for our game master.


r/oneringrpg • • 3d ago

Concerns about TOR 2e and whether I should pick it up

0 Upvotes

Im interested in getting into running and/or playing a TTRPG set in Middle-earth and I have seen a ton of praises for The One Ring 2nd edition and a lot of people recommending it to others. I don’t have any of the books yet and so I’ve been reading some reviews and trying to learn how it plays. From what *very little* I've read about The One Ring so far, I have some concerns about its systems versus my system and playstyle preferences. So I'm wondering if some here would be willing to address them?

  1. ⁠The Hope/Shadow thing concerns me. I strongly dislike systems that force characters to become evil/unplayable, especially if it is at the whim of the dice. From what I've read about the Shadow system, it seems like that could be the case in TOR 2e. Concerns about this can be mitigated if most or all of the control over how this progresses and whether a PC falls to evil/becomes unplayable is in the hands of the player in some way.

  2. ⁠I've read some things about TOR 2e that make me worry it cares/focuses too much on exactly what and how much PCs are carrying and cares about encumbrance. I can't stand all that bookkeeping, and I always house rule it out of any game I run that has it. Is this an actual concern with TOR 2e?

  3. ⁠I like games, especially when I'm a player, that have "Cool Powers or Abilities" that the PCs gain. It makes games feel more exciting and PCs feel more distinct from one another. I know there aren't really a lot of cool powers and magic and such in Tolkein's setting and I know that the various cultures get some kind of benefits. So, the question is, are these benefits interesting and cool enough in play to make players feel excited about having and using them? Do they have real impact in play?


r/oneringrpg • • Jan 20 '25

[2e] My journeys in Strider Mode + AI

15 Upvotes

I’ve had a really hard time doing Strider Mode, I think a lack of creativity or the ability to conceptualize the story made it difficult for me, but I’ve always wanted a LOTR sandbox to play around in.

I instead loaded the rules and some additional resources into a private GPT and then instructed it to play the role of lore master. I, of course, have to guide it and I do the combat encounters and some exchanges and dice rolls to propel the story as I’m starting to see it, BUT it’s made it a lot more accessible, interesting and descriptive.

I’m sure it’s not novel to have AI assist in a solo pen and paper GPT, but I figured I’d write about it (mostly for me), so I have a blog where I write about my characters and campaign:

https://traversenmiddleearth.blogspot.com

It’s early going at this point, just a few chapters in but playing two PCs. I’d be happy to talk more about my setup if this is interesting to anyone else struggling as I was with Strider mode but eager to play the game! Also happy to talk about the story if that catches anyone’s interest, though the writing is mostly for me. I’m trying to toe the line on lore. It’s in TA2965 and I want the players to thwart something meaningful, but don’t know where all that will take me. For now, it’s mostly around some lesser antagonists that seem to be stoking embers of a dormant Angmar. Perhaps that was inevitable playing a Ranger and using some of the prompting from the AI coupled with some lore table and core rule rolls.

Thanks for reading if you do! I hope you all have fun with the game as I have!