r/onednd • • Sep 09 '23

Discussion If OneDnD comes out in the direction its going...their is no reason to really not play it, its a better 5e.

17 Upvotes

Currently 1DnD is just straight up becoming a better version of 5e with just more features, options and mechanics then core 5e. Its the same game just with more, and all of those tasha's changes rolled into one.

You dont even have to buy it since they are releasing an SRD for it for free as an update to the old 5e SRD.

I just dont really see a reason to stick with 5e when OneDnD is just better, almost entirely backwards compatible, and most classes and features with the current direction they are going in are just better.

Its like sticking with 3e rather then playing 3.5, theirs no reason, honestly.

Did it address every issue i had with 5e from the jump? Nah, but its just a better more feature rich version of the same game we are playing. That addressed some of the issues i had.

It has some issues and kinks still, but i feel most of these will be ironed out, and the game will despite not being a radical reimagining we had hope, Just a better 5e, and honestly...

Im kinda starting to be okay with that.


r/onednd • • Aug 24 '24

Discussion I don't think it's very reasonable to be upset about the automatic spell updates on d&d beyond

0 Upvotes

I'm sure most of us have played video games that get patched. I guess there's always some griping about this or that patch especially in competitive games when it nerfs a character that you played. Most of the time patch drops are these really exciting things that people just get hyped for.

Overall people just kind of accept it and adapt to the way the game is changed. I don't see how this is any different at all. You just need to change the way you're relating to it instead of being upset. I think it's kind of cool that you're getting some of the updated 2024 stuff for free


r/onednd • • Sep 01 '23

Discussion Multiclassing should just be removed, its handled poorly and its the worst of both worlds.

43 Upvotes

Im slowly realizing that multiclassing in 5e is just terrible.Not only is it hard to balance for it waters down every class, because at early levels classes cant get powerful cool thematic features because of dips, making some features just feel terrible and the early class fantasy feel so weak and lame.It also at higher levels leads to balancing issues where some classes feel like they can just break the gaming doing this stuff, and devalues the fantasy/ideas full classes itself.So we get the worst of both worlds.Full class fantasy's that feel worse early on, and Multiclassing either feeling terrible or breaking the game. Its just sucks man.We have better solutions in the game between Feat Chains, and Subclasses, this extra thing just make classes feel entirely worse for little benefit, since their is better ways of pushing forward customization honestly. I just over it at this point, let it die. I dont even think it should be optional, it should be not an option entirely.The game is not built around it well enough, but wants to have it anyway, we just get the worst of both worlds, just let it go. The Customization options dont feel meaningful and it feels like crap or is too broke.

Like you cant meaningfully give classes super unique mechanics since any pc can just bite it at any level, like you have to water down every archetype, class and mechanics because since a PC with enough levels can bite it, and break it, its just impossible to consider for. So instead of classes getting cool flavorful and unique mechanics, we get watered down goop because multiclassing exists.

It just makes the full classes less unique and fun, and multiclassing lame as well.


r/onednd • • Mar 09 '23

Discussion Can we stop trying to “fix” Wildshape (and Druid)

31 Upvotes

Hot take but I’ve seen many ppl post fixes and even whole rewrites on the class and I have to just say.. please stop. I’ve yet to see a single one that doesn’t push the Druid from where it is now (strong class but missing some flavour and maybe a bit of tanking in ws) to “I’m going to kill everyone and win the game”

Over the last week alone if seen the following suggestions

  1. bring back Hp pools and give Druids unlimited WS at lv14.. like if invincibility is good for the game

  2. class options to allow up to 40d8 AoE option instead of wildshaping

  3. adding insane buffs to WS to make them out damage a fighter w things like pack tactics, adding damage dice to attacks or giving insane alternative attacks that restrain or poison w more damage than bestial strikes (both hits!)

For 1 - HP pools are bad for the game. Hard to track and allows healing better than any spell in the game. It has to go. Same for unlimited WS. Never gunna be a thing again.

For 2 - I’m all for adding something for non-WS Druids and healing blossoms is actually pretty nice. I’d just prefer MINOR scaling and the ability to damage as well. That’s all. Druids don’t need a massive damage option they already have spells

For 3 - this one will be a bit more subjective but the moon Druid does good damage and needs zero buffs to damage. Any ability that adds to this will out shadow martials very quickly especially when you have full spell slots. They are supposed to do less than a fighter (1d8+mod+weapons?) and the moon Druid currently does 1d8+mod+d6 so that’s more than enough w the compliment of again full spell casting that’s prolly more than any martial will do already

Pack tactics is something that’s also thrown around a lot. The forms that got this only had 1 attack and like wolves it did on avg 7dmg. You can’t add this to a multi attacking template w same damage to fighters unless you give every martial pack tactics to balance it out.

I’m not trying to be negative but we need to be honest in the feedback we give them if we wanna see an actual usual improvement. These suggestions allow them to shrug off anything we say as “they don’t know any better” and honestly from the foxes I’ve seen they’re not wrong.

The new Druid as it stands now is FAR more balanced and 5e to martials and again only small tweaks are needed please.

Thank you for coming to my TED talk Sorry if I sounded negative I’m not trying to be rude but also trying to give the best feedback possible to a lot of options that put us right back to caster>>>martial

Edit: it seems the community is very passionate about this topic and I’ve received everything from threats to accusations that I’m not a player of the game. I think ppl are reading my post as STOP! 6e druid is awesome and your opinions are bad” when I’m reality I have many problems w 6e Druid but damage isn’t one. I it lacks flavour and utility yes but buffing damage and rewriting the whole class generally isn’t what is useful discussion as they are likely sticking to this template w maybe some tweaks


r/onednd • • Oct 27 '23

Other Should One D&D remove Multiclassing?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
6 Upvotes

r/onednd • • Dec 20 '23

Feedback Honestly, why people don't go off this sub if they aren't interested?

0 Upvotes

Like, every once and then when these trying times come i see lots of people commenting "no i don't plan to buy anything, this is bad, this does not deserve to be bought" and so on.

EDIT: just to make it clearer I do not talk about complaints concerning the playtest, I talk about external behaviours. See, Hasbro.

Like. Sure, understandable, but why the hell are you here then? Even more, why bother to complaint? There are better subs for that.

I don't think this sub needs to be complaint free, but these kinds of points don't make sense and only creates another echo chamber.


r/onednd • • Nov 05 '24

Discussion Is it just me who have found the girlies in the new phb gorg af

0 Upvotes

No cuz like every time I go to the warlocks page and just find my self staring at the fey warlock I'm always like how can they be this beautiful!?

Oh and don't even let me start at the GOO's fashion! IM IN LOVE!

Sometimes I even wonder if they could turn me bi like frfr but dunno so I always just give up on that thought.

Like every girlie, boss girl or girlie girl as soo drop dead gorgeous, I can't (looking at wizard and life cleric)

Oh and ofc I didn't forget the fighter or the monk girlies too or any other material atrs class girly I'm just simply more in to slender man and I think that effects that I'm mor into feminim bodies but whatever my preference is I can say tagt all of them are serving

Oh and I almost forgot!! THE STARS DRUID! her art Is open of the most captivating and eye catching (for me) if not the most!

I'm really really down on my knees in front of the artists, they always do amazing and I can't thank them enough for that


r/onednd • • May 12 '23

Discussion One D&D Warlock: An Eldritch Masterstroke

9 Upvotes

While there are many complaints and issues people have with the current One D&D Warlock, it seems like there is a lot of talking over each other. People seem to not understand why there is the shift from pact magic, arguing warlock has fewer spells to cast, and trying to find various ways to keep pact magic such as making it a 10 minute ritual twice per day. While the change to traditional spell slots seems like a loss on paper, it is really a net gain and should not be reverted to its previous state.

The Problem of Pact Magic

As a concept, Pact Magic is unique in every sense of the word. Instead of gaining a normal spell slot progression, Warlock gets 2 “pact slots” they can cast of their highest available spell level that refresh on a short rest. Every spell they cast uses these slots. For example, a level 9 warlock will have two 5th level pact slots. Even if they cast a 1st level hex, it is done using a 5th level pact slot.

However, while it is unique, that does not mean it is good. This style of magic means the Warlock is severely restricted in terms of what spells they could be casting and when they can cast them:

  • Pumping a lower level spell into a higher level slot almost always feels bad. With some minor exceptions Warlock doesn’t have access to (namely Spirit Guardians), upcasting lower level spells into higher level slots will always be considerably worse than just casting a spell of that level. This leads to the issue of warlocks either not wanting to use the spells they have access to with the exception of the small handful of higher level spells or trying to cast low level spells and not seeing much of an improvement.

  • Warlocks can only use a small handful of spells during a fight. For example, first level spells like shield and absorb elements are cornerstones for self defense that you would not want to have access to only twice. Even the 3rd and 4th pact slots at 11 and 17 do not help. While you’re capable of recovering these slots after a short rest, during a single combat you are not casting the hypothetical 16 spells assuming 4 short rests but just the 4 pact spells. Access to spells of all levels is important and you can’t use your casting to its fullest potential if you are limited in slot count per encounter.

  • Warlock’s lower pact slot count also means they want to maximize the effectiveness of each spell, which can lead to them waiting until the very very last moment to actually expend them. This leads to Warlocks simply…not casting spells, whether in or out of combat. After all, why risk a Charm Person on the guard when you could use the same slot for a Fireball? You ever have a consumable in a video game, say you’ll “save it for when you need it”, and then never actually use it even after beating the game 100%? That’s more or less what happens a lot of the time.

This leaves warlocks in a position where they are casting significantly less spells than the other casters. Even if their spells are of higher level, players are stuck throwing them out then relegating themselves to cantrips (namely Eldritch Blast) and that’s it. While I do not deny the power of Eldritch Blast, warlocks currently blast during most rounds not because they want to but because they have to.

Short Rests and the Adventuring Day

While changing a short rest to 10 minutes could potentially increase the encounters per day Warlocks go through, it won’t change the fact that your pact slots are hampering you more than helping. Though even then, the recovery method of these slots is just as much an issue as their limited count. The DMG highly recommends 6-8 medium encounters per day with 2 short rests. However, most players only really see anywhere from 0-1 the majority of the time. This is not because the DMs are bad or that the system from the DMG needs to be enforced but because of the shift in game culture from a more dungeon crawling focus to a narrative one. DMs will throw you into single big encounters for the day to have an epic boss fights or throw you into a roleplay focused session with only two or three fights. Whether it’s 1 hour or 10 minutes, these sorts of days will still have a short rest problem.

Is that a bad thing? No. The DM should set the pace of the adventuring day and characters should have access to all their resources at the start of each day. If all classes have their primary resources recharge on long rest, then the DM has the flexibility to challenge you to spend those resources at their own pace rather than having to follow a strict guideline because of the absolute necessity of short rests. That isn’t to say short rests should go away or are being destroyed or what have you. Instead, they are there to supplement or extend these adventuring days. If the party ends an encounter slightly battered and bruised and need to recover a few resources, short rests will be there to help you last a little longer during the day. However if you take a major hit and are running on fumes, a long rest is what you need. Basically, this is one of those cases where the system's assumptions are the thing that need to change due to the practical realities of how the game is played today.

New Warlock: A Half Caster?

When the new warlock was revealed to the world, everyone was baffled when they saw the half caster progression on the class chart. On paper, Warlock switched from its unique pact magic system to the same spellcasting progression Ranger and Paladin have. If that were truly the case, it would have been horrible and a loss of identity and flavor. However, the class table is extremely deceptive in both the spells known and the spell “slots” you have.

This new Warlock’s spell power comes from a mix of its half casting progression and its new Mystic Arcanum invocation. At the cost of an invocation, you get a single spell of any level a full caster can cast. You can even take this invocation multiple times: one for each spell level. In theory, this means you can take Mystic Arcanum 9 times and get an extra spell slot of 1st-9th level. While this is a massive change, there’s a lot of good here. All in all, I think it makes the warlock stand out as an extremely unique caster regardless of losing their short rest dependency.

The Bad

I want to start with the issues of this new arcanum-casting design:

  1. The other invocations feel weak by comparison. Eyes of the Runekeeper, Beast Speech, and other picks do not keep up with just...getting a spell of your choice. While there used to be other invocations that gave you a spell once per day and a lot of them were seen as bad, they were limited to specific spells. Now having access to the entire Arcane list for invocation choices, warlocks can take hypnotic pattern, fear, slow, fireball, counterspell, and other potent magic at the cost of an invocation. Why use invocations to get 6-9 temp hp when you can do 8d6 fire damage in a 20 foot radius sphere instead?

  2. Arcanum levels 6-9 are a non-choice. Not even the 15th level arcanums in this UA hold up to getting a 6th, 7th, 8th, or 9th level spell slot. The arcanum from 6-9 should be reverted to class features or else they are just an unnecessary invocation tax.

This being said, the solution to the problems with mystic arcanum is simple: Buff the weaker invocations! For a few examples: merge Eyes of the Runekeeper with Eldritch Sight, give Beast Speech more than just speak with animals at will, have armor of shadows let you cast mage armor on other people too (reminder the spell has a range of touch)! If you want mystic arcanum not to be an automatic pick, don’t remove it or bake all of it into the class (like I said 6-9 I could see baking back in). Make it so there is an actual choice!

The Good

Warlock got massive quality of life love in this UA. The class was given three big things that make it overall feel more satisfying to play: better spells to know, more spells known to learn them, more slots to cast them with!

Quality

Let’s start with the first thing: better spells known. The old Warlock spell list was, in a word, bad. Warlock went from having one of the worst spell lists in the game to having the best. The Arcane list combines all spells from wizard, sorcerer, warlock, and bard. While warlock may be losing exclusivity on Armor of Agathys, they are getting so so much more in return: shield, fireball, faerie fire, sleep, cone of cold, wall of force, simulacrum, wish. This is just the tip of the iceberg. Warlock in total gained over 100 spells to their spell list, giving them quality…but what about quantity?

…and Quantity

To start the comparison, let’s look at 5e. Old Warlock has a total spells known count of 21: 15 pact spells and 4 mystic arcanum. You’re probably wondering about old warlock’s subclass spells, and if so I would like to remind you that those are not subclass spells. They are an expanded spell list which means you have to use spells known as old warlock to take your subclass spells. New Warlock, assuming you take 0 mystic arcanum, gets a total of 27 spells known: 15 spells known from their prepared spells, 10 known from their subclass, 1 for Hex at level 1, and 1 for Contact Other Plane from their contact patron ability. From there, they get an additional spell known for every arcanum you choose to take. Assuming you spend every invocation on mystic arcanum (so one extra spell of each level), you have a total spell known count of 36. So, you have spells in spades. Now what? Are you going to just take a bunch of spells and let them sit and rot? Nope! Because you get multiple ways to put them to use!

Lots of Slots!

Before we get into the arcanum and spell slots, I want to point something out from the Experts UA: all spell casters get ritual casting. That includes the warlock. Since you now know so many spells, you can even afford to take rituals which gives you out of combat utility previously exclusive to spending a pact boon and an invocation.

Looking at spell slot count, the math is tricky because it depends on short rest count (See: Short Rests and the Adventuring Day). So, we will look at a warlock at levels 5, 11, and 17. For the new warlock, I will be assuming you only take mystic arcanum of spell levels you don’t have slots for and swap them out once you can use their slots. After all, you can overload on casting if you want to, but it is not necessary to enjoy the class!

Level 5

Old Warlock

2 3rd level Pact Slots per short rest.

Total: Anywhere from 2-6 slots per long rest spread between 1-3 encounters at minimum.

New Warlock

4 1st level slots 2 2nd level slots 1 free subclass spell (2nd level max) 1 3rd level arcanum

Total: 8 slots per long rest to be cast whenever you’d like.

Level 11

Old Warlock

3 5th level pact slots 1 6th level arcanum

Total: Anywhere from 4-10 slots, 3-9 of which must be spread out between 1-3 encounters minimum

New Warlock

4 1st level slots 3 2nd level slots 3 3rd level slots 1 free subclass spell (3rd level max) 1 4th level arcanum 1 5th level arcanum 1 6th level arcanum (Also there’s 1 Contact Patron casting but I’m not counting that)

Total: 14 spells to cast whenever you’d like

Level 17

Old Warlock

4 5th level pact slots 1 6th level arcanum 1 7th level arcanum 1 8th level arcanum 1 9th level arcanum

Total: 8-16 spells, 4-12 of which must be spread between at minimum 1-3 encounters.

New Warlock

4 1st level slots 3 2nd level slots 3 3rd level slots 3 4th level slots 1 5th level slot 1 free subclass spell (5th level max) 1 6th level arcanum 1 7th level arcanum 1 8th level arcanum 1 9th level arcanum (Also there’s 1 Contact Patron casting but I’m not counting that)

Total: 19 slots to spend whenever you’d like

Overall, you are getting more spell slots than ever before and aren’t restricted on when you can cast them. You know more spells than before, letting you prepare rituals that you can actually ritual cast now, and your spell list is the best in the game!

So, you are neither a full caster nor a half caster. Full casters beat out both warlocks in terms of slot count. Half casters never access 6th-9th level spell slots. What are you then? You are whatever you want to be in between. At maximum you’re like a 95% caster and at minimum you’re a half caster. How much casting you want your warlock to have, though, is up to you. The more and better invocations WotC pumps out, the more competition mystic arcanum has. That’s the beauty of making arcanum invocations: the choice is in your hands.

The Same-ish

Despite getting the amazing ability to cast as described above, there were a lot of things about the warlock that was kept the same-ish. Its hit dice, armor, pact boons, and the most consistent damage tool in the game: Eldritch blast.

These are what you get for compensation for not being a full caster. If you were an arcane full caster, you would have a d6 hit dice and no armor much like our Wizard and Sorcerer friends.

Why same-ish? Because there were tweaks here that actually make the class even stronger. Armor was bumped to medium instead of light, giving you higher AC. Pact boons now come at level 1 making them more flavorful and tie into the warlock themselves more. While they are cantrips now, I think that is a bit awkward and should be made as class features. The pact boons also have an invocation each baked into them now, making them much stronger if you stick with warlock. Eldritch blast also now scales off warlock level which entirely invalidates the old sorlock: good riddance.

Side Note: Multiclass Mayhem

Speaking of Sorlock, I would argue the change to Eldritch blast is a warlock buff because people would take Eldritch blast, agonizing blast, repelling blast, and 2 short rest pact slots for shield (Hexblade expanded spell list) then take sorcerer for the rest of their lives. Warlock 2/Sorcerer X isn’t a warlock, it’s a sorcerer with Eldritch blast. Though, it does raise the question: why did people build sorlocks? Because you got more spell slots than if you played warlock but you also got all the goodies associated with the class.

Invocation Starvation?

Another common complaint I see with new warlock is the claim that they are invocation starved. While I do think arcanum 6-9 should be baked into the class because they are non-choices, even right now you get more than enough invocations for both spellcasting and cool warlock stuff.

I made a warlock build, Tomes of Fun, that you can find here: https://docs.google.com/document/d/12JM2VOIYVrDvBZyc87HuGE05MmIZ13REC90qPZ7OTOo/view

In the build, I have plenty of invocations that are not arcanum by using the following progression:

Level 5: 1 arcanum, 2 other Level 7: 2 arcanum, 2 other Level 9: 2 arcanum, 3 other Level 11: 3 arcanum, 3 other Level 13: 3 arcanum, 4 other Level 15: 4 arcanum, 4 other Level 17: 4 arcanum, 5 other

While 5 is definitely less than the 8 an old warlock would have...I didn’t really see it as a big deal when making the build. I had enough invocations to pack in all the goodies I wanted for my warlock: Repelling blast for at-will control, gaze of two minds for party splitting, gift of the protectors to save my friends from dying, Lessons of the first ones for a free feat, and witch sight for 30 feet of true sight (reminder there is an epic boon which gives you 60 and you get this 5 levels earlier).

There’s not really much else I would ask for. Are any of these invocations mandatory? No. You could grab cool ones like Mask of Many Faces, Devil’s Sight, Visions of Distant Realms, etc. Of course there are stinkers like Eyes of the Runekeeper, Eldritch Sight (you can ritual cast now), Master of Myriad Forms, and Beast Speech. I think these need to be boosted to be either more interesting, more powerful, or both. Regardless, I’m not too upset at my invocation selections and felt like it was more than enough.

A Crappy Capstone

I should mention the elephant in the room before I wrap up. Yes, Hex Master is bad. There are a ton of ways you could make a better warlock capstone. I think allowing the at-will version of the spell to be upcast to 5th level would be a good start then also add something on top. Either that it’s not concentration or that it imposes disadvantage on d20 tests rather than ability checks for the selected ability. You’re level 18, you can cast WISH for God’s sake. All this being said, the crappy capstone just needs fixing, not a reason to give the class as a whole the thumbs down.

Conclusion

I hope I explained the draw of this new version of the warlock to you all: it is a highly customizable class with the ability to opt into spellcasting and is neatly balanced through the invocation system. It is both mechanically stronger and more engaging to play due to the fact you can cast spells when you want rather than needing to take a nap every 2 castings while having a much more interesting selection of spells to choose from. If you don’t agree with me, that’s fine, but remember that the 5e warlock will still exist after this. Your 2014 PHB isn’t going anywhere and they are still insisting on ‘backwards compatibility’. One DnD Warlock can be something entirely unique and not just a rehash of what you already got.


r/onednd • • Nov 24 '24

Discussion 2024 backgrounds are annoying me.

10 Upvotes

I spend a lot of time making characters, and it used to be fun. However, the latest rule set is causing me depression. Specifically how limiting the backgrounds are. I know it was talked to death when the book came out, but I'm wondering if this still bothers anyone or is it just me?


r/onednd • • Jul 06 '24

Discussion Nerfed Classes are a Good Thing

133 Upvotes

Classes is 5e are too powerful in my experience as a DM. Once the party hits 6th level, things just aren't as challenging to the party anymore. The party can fly, mass hypnotize enemies, make three attacks every turn, do good area of effect damage, teleport, give themselves 20+ ACs, and so many other things that designing combats that are interesting and challenging becomes really difficult. I'm glad rogues can only sneak attack once per turn. I'm glad divine smite is nerfed. I'm glad wildshape isn't totally broken anymore. I hope that spells are nerfed heavily. I want to see a party that grows in power slowly over time, coming up with creative solutions to difficult situations, and accepting their limitations. That's way more interesting to me as a DM than a team of superheroes who can do anything they want at any time.


r/onednd • • Jul 09 '23

Discussion Unpopular opinions: bards picking their spell list origin is not good

3 Upvotes

Obviously gonna get downvotes into oblivion, but I’m not a fan of this change in the UA and hope it doesn’t stay.

  1. Spell lists are core to a classes power and identify and handing them out left and right causes, for me, a lack of niche protection.

  2. This new change might end up (once the dust settles) hanging bards be better “clerics” than the cleric class, Druid’s than the Druid class, and/or overshadowing one of the arcane casters at their roll.

  3. It feels really unthematic to get a bard to be casting thunderstep, fireball and wall of force just as good as a wizard.

*what would I like instead? Give bards access to the illusion/divination/abjuration/enchantment spells from the divine/primal/arcane lists from level 1. Now they’d have their “own” spell list that fits with the concept of bards.


r/onednd • • Sep 12 '23

Discussion The designers are not stupid or incompetent they're just not designing for you.

116 Upvotes

There's constant posts here that are pretty much nothing else but shit talking on the designers of this game. It's usually followed or preceded by some half-baked homebrew that if we're being honest sucks total shit and the poster doesn't even understand why.

The designers of this game are not always designing for you. You might disagree with the design, who it's for etc, but it's not designed for you. I'm so tired of hearing "their reason is bullshit111!" it's not bullshit it's just not for you.

Most players at a table are not minmaxers, aren't crunching numbers, many don't **want** a million abilities including new playersm, and 'low-engagement' players. The designers have to design things to play and on-ramps for these players. "Just make there be default options!" there's already a ton of shit for people like this to think about learning the game and throwing them on a low decision class/subclass like Champion Fighter, Thief Rogue, or a simple Barbarian can help them focus on roleplay > rollplay because they're not constantly thinking about their features and they can think about who they are.

You might not believe that there exists a reason not to push to maximum complexity on every class, but there is and they're at people's tables. I played with a player like this for years and he struggled on Druid, etc. It was actually only when they started playing Barbarian and their decision tree was much smaller that they felt comfortable. His Barbarian quickly became a memorable roleplay character in a way none of his previous characters did. The simplicity of the class/subclass let him focus on what's important at our table: telling a good story.


r/onednd • • Jun 03 '23

Discussion One DnD just BROKE Thunderclap for Sorcerers, and I'm totally here for it!

1 Upvotes

Okay so basically, as a 2nd level sorcerer you can nuke the entire field with thunder damage now (Yay for Thunderclap becoming relevant, but DANG! Maybe not this way? Lol)

Correct me if I'm wrong but you take the following CANTRIP

Thunderclap (Cantrip) Evocation Cantrip Casting Time: 1 action Range/Area: 5 ft. Components: S Duration: Instantaneous Attack/Save: CON

You create a burst of thunderous sound that can be heard up to 100 feet away. Each creature within range, other than you, must succeed on a Constitution saving throw or take 1 d6 thunder damage.

The spell's damage increases by 1 d6 when you reach 5th level (2d6), 11th level (3d6), and 17th level (4d6)

THEN you take the following METAMAGIC, available at level 2:

DISTANT SPELL Cost: 1 Sorcery Point When you cast a spell that has a range of at least 5 feet, you can spend 1 Sorcery Point to increase the spell's range by a number of feet equal to 30 times your Sorcerer level.

When you cast a spell that has a range of Touch, you can spend 1 Sorcery Point to make the range of the spell 30 feet

Now all of a sudden at level 2, mind you, you can BOOM a 65ft radius sphere for 1d6 thunder damage. Now take that same character at lvl. 5 with who took one level in tempest cleric. Automatic 12 damage to anyone within 155ft of you. That's bigger than a football field. A 5th level evil-doer could literally show up in the middle of a football game and merc ALL of us little 4 HP commoners with a single clap, 1 Sorcery Point and a brief entreaty to their demented storm god. Lol

Please tell me if I'm reading that wrong.


r/onednd • • Oct 15 '24

Discussion DnD 2024 Dungeon Master’s Guide review

Thumbnail
wargamer.com
0 Upvotes

r/onednd • • May 18 '24

Discussion Are they going to change terminology so that we don't have Spell LEVEL and Character LEVEL?

10 Upvotes

Has there been any indication that they are going to change one of the uses of "Level" so there isnt the confusing "Congratulations! you have reached 5th level! you can now cast 3rd level spells!"

its kind of a travesty that a game released in 2014 had such poor use of overlapping terminology - but it will be REALLY bad if they do it again in 2025!

What would your choice of terminology be?

I think i would like "Character Rank".

if druids hadnt already used the term, i would like "Spell Circles"


r/onednd • • Aug 24 '24

Discussion WotC just lets us in on normal development processes; that's why we get mad

119 Upvotes

!UPDATE! WotC announced at ~9p PST Sunday night that they've decided not to update all DNDBeyond character sheets to reflect 2024 spell/item content. Cheers all.

Original post below:

Other companies that develop game products just show you, 1-4 times a year, what they decided to do behind closed doors.

The back-n-forth we see on WotC decisions, the unclear language, the misjudged press releases—these all normally consitute the unseen in-house drama most companies go through, without inviting us to see, let alone give feedback on.

Know how most office environments or design jobs you've had are to some degree annoying, at most a hellhole? Where emails don't make sense, no one knows how to talk to other departments, and time gets wasted while resources are misallocated? That's normal in a development space to varying degrees, and we all joke about it. There are sitcoms and comic strips about it.

The difference with WotC is they inexplicably show us the sausage being made, and ask us for feedback. There's not additional drama specific to WotC; they simply tell us what's going on, vs. Nintendo or CD Projekt Red or Nike before they drop a horrific shoe.

I see the kinda fangless terms 'dumpster fire' and 'boycott' and a lot of personal and moral judgement, and I just wanna say clearly once, that especially since Spelljammer backlash, and then the NDA (standard part of beginning a development relationship), WotC has gone out of their way to simply open their blinds so we can see into their normal process.

When we get mad, it's at normal processes, and they've pretty much always acknowledged our reactions and worked to give us what we ask, actually quickly given what we ask, during the development of 5.5.

Just gotta say this coz when I see the usual drama meme terms trying to spread anger in this usually fun positive space, I just think, "Your reaction right now is what a dozen workers have already brought up, and we've been doing this long enough to know WotC will respond, try to change, give us advice if they can't, and it's already insane that they're even asking for help."

We've been through this for years and we always end up appreciating what we like and dropping what we don't. This is the process, and we're a part of it, and it's cool.

Coz they could just close WotC, stop Sage Advice, and we only know about changes when Hasbro itself drops a gatekeepy, mandatory-purchase book twice a year.


r/onednd • • Jan 04 '24

Discussion Rogue damage is right where it needs to be with blade cantrips.

0 Upvotes

It's no secret that the Rogue is one of the best classes for the blade cantrips. Trading the attack action for a spell that offers level scaling damage that ALSO works with Sneak Attack is a no-brainer buff.

While it is not difficult to get a cantrip, especially in OneDND, I think that something equivalent should be either built into the base class or (would be really neat but unlikely) included in the sub class. (Yay to Arcane Tricksters for having this already built in.)

Basically, my point is Rogue's should get something like an extra D8 at levels 5, 11 and 17 (something that doesn't over-tune and stack with existing blade cantrips). If this will stay limited to forcing players to build into cantrips then fine but IMO there should be alternatives to using these spells.


r/onednd • • Aug 12 '23

Discussion How I think we can get the 3 universal spell lists back.

0 Upvotes

Intilted wizards players took away spells from other classes and any chance of getting more classes instead of a bunch of half backed sub classes.

Let's give all the spell lists in the next UA extremely dissatisfied and demand universal lists back. Don't think Jermey Crawford in his bone headed flex is mathematically the best weapon mastery and class abilities scored higher then whole class so they must really not want complexity might miss interept it.


r/onednd • • Oct 19 '23

Discussion Complexity, Martials, and a non-Compete Clause

36 Upvotes

So, this is inspired from another thread...

What is D&D?

This is a complex answer because D&D is many things. It is a war game, a storytelling game, an improv game, and everything in between. There are a million ways to play, and all of them are valid.

I think some people, however, don't care about what D&D is and focus too much on what they wish it were.

Classes in D&D range from the super simple (Champion Fighter, Berserker Barbarian, etc.) to the moderately complex (Warlock, Eldritch Knight, Battlemaster, Monk, Rogue, etc.) to the supremely complex (Wizard, Cleric, etc.)

The above is not an exhaustive list.

I want you to think, however, not of the "WotC won't give us more for Martials!" As much as the vast majority of Martial Players don't want more.

I've been a DM for 35 years. I've run a lot of games for a ton of different groups. I've run many systems including every iteration of D&D from the red box to 5e. The following is what I have observed...

Some players just want to hit something.

These guys get their dopamine hit by rolling damage dice. They don't frankly care what the guy in the dress with the stick, the person wearing leaves, the guy prostalitizing, or the weird dragon-blooded guy do. Such players can play for years saying, "I hit them with my axe!" and absolutely love the game.

They like simple, straightforward, linear gameplay.

D&D Redditors are absolutely not a good representation of the greater D&D consumer. We are 1% of the 1% and for every one guy who posts about the "disparity" there are 50 people who don't care.

I've professionally worked in game design, in one form or another, for the majority of my 43 years. I got my first job in the industry as an in-house playtester at age 17 back in 1997.

Designers rarely care about us.

That's not them being callous, but this is a business. If 100 people like the product as-is, and 1 person doesn't, they're not going to change the product to suit the 1 if it would cause them to lose 2 of the 100.

Simple Martials work in D&D. From red box to 3.5 Fighters were simple. There were always complaints about overpowered casters. They have complained about us since 1973. Before the internet.

4e changed that, and gave us complex martials. 4e was the highest selling WotC RPG of all time, at the time. Why do people, and WotC, consider 4e a failure? You're not going to like this, but it is called "player retention."

A lot of people bought 4e. Played 4e. Didn't like 4e. Then went to something else.

That something was Pathfinder. An unknown game, from a small developer, came in like a battering ram and beat WotC at its own game. Pathfinder out sold and had a higher player retention than D&D. That shouldn't have been possible.

D&D is the genre. It is the most recognized RPG in the world. When people say they play D&D they can, and often do, mean another RPG. Plenter of PF1 players referred to PF as D&D.

For D&D lose to PF is like Coca-Cola losing to Sam's Choice Cola. It's unthinkable, it shouldn't be possible, and it's incredibly embarrassing to WotC.

So, we look at 4e and we can see where the flaws were. The first and main one was how complicated everything was. Every class had a litany of class abilities to the point that many players needed cards to keep track of it and encounter design for DMs required a spreadsheet to actually make work properly.

I remember having to determine X number of enemies, this group of goblins were minions, the players had X, Y, Z so I had to space inions out like this and wave with real enemies after the first wave of per encounter abilities decimated the mooks. I hated it.

My players? One of them literally said, and I quote, "Why the (censored) do I need a deck of cards to swing my (censored) sword? (Censored) this, I want to play something else."

That player, let's call him Joe, is the LCD player. The lowest common denominator. He is the average D&D player. He doesn't know who Treantmonk or Laserllama are. He's never looked at a class optimization guide. He likes to roll a D20 and hit something with a sword.

Joe is actually a great player. He's basic, sure, but he always pays attention, he never gets mad at poor rolls, he's always on time, and he really gets into some fun character roleplay. He also always shows up with pizza and a 12 pack of coke.

He loves the story. He doesn't care if it is a railroad, a module, he doesn't really care for sandbox gameplay. He's got flaws, but he's welcome by most DMs because he's generally fun to be around.

Is Joe stupid? No. Joe has a degree in physics. He works in a laboratory. When he plays a game it's to get away from crunching numbers and doing formulae. He just wants to hang out with his friends and club a few Goblins.

Most players are like Joe.

You may not like to hear that, but it's true. I worked in this field. I worked on one of the most complicated RPGs I've ever played, Mage: The Ascension - Revised Edition. I know complicated games and I know how niche they are.

D&D isn't supposed to be complicated. It was never intended to be complicated. It was always straightforward and simple.

Those players who wanted more complex options have them. Yes, spellcasters, rogues, characters with situational or tactical requirements to be played optimally.

Modern D&D (meaning 5e/OD&D) is built off of a very simple framework. Classes have a base core of abilities and a handful of sub classes with a small number of alterations to enhance them in different ways. It's very hard to make a class both simple and complex and still be just as effective regardless of which way you choose.

Look at the Fighter: The simplest variant is the Champion. The medium complexity benchmark is the Battlemaster. The highly complex variant is the Eldritch Knight.

You then may say, "But that's a caster!"

"So?" I reply. "It's a Fighter."

"But I want to be as effective at narrative power as a Wizard!"

"... Play a Wizard?"

"No! I don't want to use magic!"

WotC can't, within the template they are using, do that. Not only that, but it would be radically different from every other version of D&D ever.

In my vast experience, the CMD doesn't effect most real tables. Optimizers aren't forced to, and don't, play non-casters; they think that everything else is too gimped. Most common players don't care if someone's character is "more powerful" than theirs. It only becomes an issue when the optimizer starts being an A-Hole.


r/onednd • • Sep 09 '25

5e (2024) The Shortcomings of Graze

1 Upvotes

TL;DR: Graze’s DPR increase is misleading. It fights most mechanics in the game. But it’s good if you want a passive effect.

In the debates surrounding one of the biggest additions in 5.5, masteries, there is a question that appears to be a common hot topic: Just how good is the graze mastery? Multiple calculations and builds will be tossed about arguing for its capability. I, personally, find them all to be lacking. I believe that graze is the worst mastery in the game. There is a main argument to the contrary, but allow me to attempt to debunk it. Of course, if you have an alternative reason, please let me know below. 

“Graze has the highest DPR out of any mastery.”

This is a common rebuttal to the critiques of graze. Assuming the standard optimization benchmark hit chance of 60%, graze can provide +2 to your average damage per round for every attack you make. This is then upheld as one of the highest virtues and something it can lord over the other masteries as a reason why you should consider it. 

However, this achievement has one hidden fault: In these comparisons, graze is winning a competition against opponents who aren’t competing.

Those who discuss optimization are loath to ever receive the response of “Well you can’t guarantee that…” Thus it’s common for anything even potentially presumptive to be removed from calculations. This leaves us with a theory craft space derided as the “white room.” This isn’t to say having a controlled scenario is wrong when considering a build. In fact, we have to make some concessions to controlled variables otherwise we wouldn’t be able to conceptualize anything. But I’d argue that worrying about being contested based on “You can’t guarantee that…” has often led us to a white room that is “too clean.” That is, a scenario so unlike actual play that the theoretical calculations done within aren’t transferable to the table.

Where does graze’s moniker of “highest DPR” factor into a “too clean” white room? If you’d argue for nearly any other masteries contribution to a fight, that loathsome response would inevitably creep back in. This means since we cannot guarantee that cleave would be usable in any given situation, the extra attack cannot be considered within damage calculations. Since we cannot easily calculate how consistently we will successfully topple an enemy, nor accurately calculate how much damage our party members either gain or lose from the enemy being prone, it cannot be considered. Since we cannot guarantee that push will be able to put an enemy into a hazardous space, such as something within the terrain of the fight; a magically created hazard such as web, cloud of daggers, or spike growth; or to be newly accessible by an ally, it cannot be considered. Thus, graze wins a race where all of its opponents have been disqualified. 

The DPR calculation argument also fails to realize what actually matters within a fight: Breakpoints. As an example, consider a twig blight. With its 7 health, a mastered great sword wielded by a level 1 barbarian with a standard 16 strength is guaranteed to kill the creature by its 3rd attack. However, a maul wielded by the same barbarian has a 94.6% chance of doing the same. This is without even considering reckless attack, but I’m getting ahead of myself. So in this situation where the maul has ~86% of the great sword's DPR, it performs on par 94.6% of the time. This begs the questions of just exactly how much we benefit from the DPR increase graze provides.

Without intending to rob respondents the joy of pointing out that I’ve carefully selected a situation to support my argument in a moment of hypocrisy, I will concede that this one instance doesn’t immediately mean that the additional damage from graze will almost never contribute to an enemy going down faster. We could add to this situation an allied caster with the spell firebolt on hand. After a single missed attack with graze, the chances of our ally dropping the enemy with their spell rises from 42% to 60%. My reasoning for bringing up breakpoints is that graze’s impact on a fight is truly just as incalculable as any other mastery. 

I have but one final critique of graze before concluding with something I appreciate about the mastery.

Graze is anti-synergistic with most other game mechanics.

The vast majority of mechanics a weapon user would appreciate having either increase your chance to land your attack or rewards you for doing so. Whether it be advantage or bless, increasing your chance to hit will always be a damage increase even if using graze. This is before considering other effects you’d want to acquire to increase your damage on a hit such as a flame tongue weapon or a barbarian’s rage damage bonus. This means the game constantly encourages a situation that would lead to graze being as weak as possible. 

In consideration of increases to your chances to hit, I struggle to find many classes or subclasses which don’t actively nerf graze in their standard loop. Barbarians have reckless attack, the devotion paladin’s sacred weapon, ancient have nature’s wrath, vow of enmity for vengeance, and even studied attacks later on for fighter. It seems at every turn, you’re making the DPR advantage graze provides smaller.

The few synergies graze does have are extremely lacking. Yes, it can guarantee the application of poisons. However this fails to mention that poison is still extremely lacking. Yes, it synergizes with the mage slayer feat by forcing concentration checks, but casters that concentrate are already a slim number within the new monster manual. Of that already select group, a portion are at most CR 1 while others such as the ice devil and lich possess a constitution save of at least +9. This means graze cannot break their concentration as they cannot fail a base concentration check. 

So graze actively fights a significant portion of the game’s mechanics, and also doesn’t have many strong synergies of its own; unlike the other masteries’ plentiful synergies which I deemed to not further bloat my musings with.

When should you pick graze?

Despite all of my preceding derision, I do think there is still a place for graze. For those who do not think tactically, either due to lacking the desire/skill to do so or playing at a table where it is difficult to benefit from such as a theatre of the mind game, graze avoids the risk of griefing your team that is present with the other heavy weapon masteries. Pushing an enemy to safety or knocking an enemy prone only for them to benefit from higher defenses against your ranged allies are hazards you must make sure you avoid in order to have better party cohesion. Even cleave can fall behind if you’re not able to recognize or manifest situations in which you can use it. If you wish to simply empty your head and swing, you seldom can go wrong with using graze.

I believe I’ve done enough to certify my position as a certified yapper and look forward to why the comments believe I’m wrong.


r/onednd • • Dec 03 '22

Feedback The 1D&D Cleric really makes me concerned for the Paladin

0 Upvotes

The biggest source of my worries are the Divine spell list and how the Cleric has access to the whole thing. That list now includes all the various Smite spells that were previously Paladin-exclusive, as well as the big one, Find Steed.

With those now on the all-encompassing Divine list, the Paladin is clearly going to lose its identity. The Cleric can now do Smites just as well. And the steed has ALWAYS been a Paladin thing only (5e Bard Magical Secrets shenanigans aside), and the Cleric now getting it just as easily (or actually even MORE easily) is just wrong, wrong, wrong.

I can think of a solid solution for the steed part, at least: It should not be a spell. It should be made a Paladin-exclusive feature that uses spell slots and scales with higher-level ones.

The Smite spells solution, on the other hand, is harder to figure out. Maybe eliminate those entirely as well and instead add options to the Paladin exclusively that they can use to alter their Divine Smite to add effects at the cost of a d8 of damage?


r/onednd • • Jul 08 '24

Discussion I'm a bit worried about why play a Rogue instead of Monk in a Combat Oriented Campaign in the future if not looking for that specific flavor

4 Upvotes

The published version of Monk has not been nerfed, but even buffed further. They basically have every combat feature that a Rogue has, but much better.

Free BA Dash and Disengage, Better with costing.

Deflect Attack, purely better Uncanny Dodge. Uncanny Dodge would be only better when you're getting 30damage from one attack which is nearly impossible to meet for most campaigns, since most campaigns are around 3~9.

Evasive, exactly the same.

Buffed Stunning Strike, a much more better Cunning Strike even though it costs Focus Point. Failed Save≈You Died. Succeeded=You're Grounded. Legendary Resistance is not even working while facing to Monks now. Especially Monks have way more resources now with the help of Uncanny Metabolism, and this could stack when you have two Monks in the party.

And...Well, that's all for Rogue. They don't have much Combat features while these features are basically all they have.

From here, Monk is only going to be better like attack 5 times in a round, ignoring certain debuffs, reroll failed Saves, gaining Resistance of every damage.

Sure Rogue has "Skills" that I'm sure someone would start to argue, but that few skill proficiencies aren't making me feel fair compared to these classes, especially compared to Monks anymore.

This is just purely unfair for Rogue to be the worst combatant in the whole game only for "It has skills". No spells, worst damage, squishy, and WotC is still telling me that every other class is getting boosted in skills. Skill checks have already been easy to pass when you have a good team, or a Bard, or a Ranger, or just "Tactical Mind!/Rage!" when you need it, or even just a small piece of good luck. So is it really fair for Rogue to be this weak in combats just for Expertise and Reliable Talent?

To me, absolutely no. These gap's been far too big that I can't call it fair.

Let alone there's a whole bunch of campaigns and Official Adventures that Skills basically matters nothing or most parts of them are about Combats. Why should the Rogue must be the very one and only class that "not suitable for those adventures".

Even looking for that "specific flavor", Shadow Monk is what crush my heart the most. It has every feature that I'd imagine a Rogue or an Assassin would have, calling out shadows, turn invisible, dancing and flashing in shadows unpredicted like exactly what people would imagine an Assassin should be, while Assassin only gets "maybe a bonus 3~9 at first round, and a maybe better initiative", then you become a vanilla Rogue with blank subclass. Especially when Gloom Stalker has always been a better Assassin with better utility, combat, and similar functions.

Is this version really fair to Rogues?


r/onednd • • Oct 15 '22

Suggestion I think rolling for stats should be a removed option from the PHB.

68 Upvotes

I think rolling for stats should instead be an optional rule in the DMG for DM’s who still want it. As though I understand why DM’s want it, I personally hate rolling for stats. For newer Player’s/DM’s especially, it can cause issues in balancing, unfairness across party members, and making party members feel less viable. As a minor thing, it can also makes it a lot easier to come with a character a person has already made to the table. I think standard array should be the standard to make it easier for new players (also fits well with the name lol), with point buy of course also being there as an added option for those who want a more customizability.

I see people trying to counter with this unfairness and other problems by making additional rules that just makes it overly complex. One of my friends for instance added:

  • You can remove 1 point from 1 stat and apply it to another

  • You can reroll your lowest stats

  • If you don’t have as many points as you would in point buy (for all the scores added up) then you can add the remaining points

At that point, you might as well just use point buy or standard array. Same applies for others who like to add rules like that.


r/onednd • • Dec 02 '23

Discussion The UA Conjure Spells: Another Brick in the Wall between Crunch and Fluff

0 Upvotes

The UA Conjure Spells: Another Brick in the Wall between Crunch and Fluff

Conjure Animals has a lot of issues in 5e. Just for a start, rolling a bucket of dice for eight freaking wolves is a huge pain in the ass.

The new version is simple and easy and does only one thing: it hurts enemies that move within range of it.

That’s why I hate it.

Let me explain why.

Effects vs. Results

When you cast a spell, what exactly are you doing in game terms? Is the focus doing a specific thing in the fiction of the game world (fluff) that is then translated into game mechanics (crunch), or are you getting a specific mechanical effect (crunch) that can then be flavored in fictional terms (fluff)? This might seem like hair splitting but it really matters and will shape the direction that D&D goes in the future.

Or to put it in other words: is the important thing the EFFECT (what the magic is doing, which can have any number of results depending on how it’s used) or the RESULT (what happens because of the magic).

Let me explain why this matters and matters deeply.

The Conjure Animals Example

In 5e Conjure Animals is an effect, by casting the spell you get some animals (or fey spirits that are identical to obedient animals, same difference). They have animal stats and can do everything that animals can do. Of course most of the time you’re just going to make the summoned animals attack, but that’s not the only thing they can do. Since they’re identical to animals, you can figure out all kinds of creative uses for Conjure Animals:

-Try to tempt hungry monsters to chase after a tasty conjured cow (yes, I know that the cow will disappear as soon as a monster kills it so the monster can’t actually eat it, but the monster doesn’t know that). It really matters if the animal you summoned looks tasty or not.

-Provide horses for the party to ride. It really matters if the animals you summoned are things you can ride or not.

-Use summoned snakes as improvised ropes or try to get a summoned spider to spin some webbing you can use as rope. This obviously won’t work if you try to do the same thing with a wolf.

-Have some summoned apes carry shit for you. It really matters if the animals you summoned have hands or not.

-Hell, try to trick a poor NPC into buying your summoned animals. This might be a good con if you need some cash in a pinch. For this what animal you summoned is going to massively impact what price you can get.

You get the idea. What I’m going on and on about is that what animal you choose in 5e for UA MATTERS. And it matters beyond the stat blocks of the various animals, the flavor of the various animals MATTERS since if you do stuff with the animals aside from attack enemies with them then the DM has to think “could X animal actually do that?” If the PCs are trying to climb in a window and are stepping on a summoned critter to get a boost, which animal can you actually do that with? Etc. etc. etc.

In the new OneD&D UA Conjure Animals has been changed to work completely differently.

In the UA Conjure animals is no longer an effect, it’s a mechanical result. You don’t actually summon an animal anymore, you don’t get a critter that uses animal stats, and your conjuration can no longer do anything whatsoever except provide a bit of damage. Most importantly, it no longer matters in the slightest what kind of animal you summon with Conjure Animals.

So, the UA takes a case in which flavor matters and removes that from the game. They’re building an increasingly high wall between fluff and crunch.

Now I’m not going to cry too many tears over this one specific spell, it’s overpowered, a bookkeeping nightmare, and really slows the game down. It’s not so important in and of itself but it is indicative of the direction that WotC is heading with OneD&D.

Why This Matters

One of my very favorite things to do in D&D is to figure out creative uses of spells, items, and abilities. Nothing makes me happier than MacGyvering a creative solution to a problem. My favorite item in D&D is the bag of holding. My favorite 5e subclass ability by a mile is the thief rogue’s fast hands, and I am utterly in love with the Command spell. So many of my favorite D&D memories are of the shenanigans I got up to with a Bag of Holding or things along those lines.

For me this is what “rulings not rules” is all about. The kind of abilities I love the best are the ones that can’t be nailed down entirely with rules but require some DM common sense to evaluate the workability of whatever harebrained scheme I’ve come up with this week. This does require some DM experience as there’s no one correct answer to “what happens if my rogue sprints away from owlbear leaving a trail of tossed steaks behind him?” like there is a clear definite answer nicely laid out in the rules to “what happens if I shoot an arrow at the owlbear?”

Having flavor matter in concrete ways (do owlbears even like steak, or should I have packed mice or honey instead?) also helps make the world feel more immerse to me. It’s a lot easier to care about flavor if it can mean the difference between a winning a fight and losing one. Stuff like cramming wax in my ears to avoid being hit by a Command spell or learning a few words or orcish so I can hit monolingual orcs with “climb!” Editions in which I can’t make up my own Commands (booo 3.5e!) or in which it doesn’t matter if the critter I’m casting command on can hear/understand me (booo 4e!) drive me nuts. In general the HARDER it is to reflavor a mechanic the more I like it.

In a lot of ways 5e is a compromise between different styles of play. 5e doesn’t really work for the style of D&D that I like best but its close enough that I put up with it. I’m worried that OneD&D is inching away from me enough that it won’t be a good compromise for me anymore. Although it was rolled back, one version of the OneD&D UAs utterly gutted my beloved Fast Hands ability and this change to Conjure Animals is concerning to me.

As I said above, 5e Conjure Animals is busted and needed to be fixed. But there are ways of fixing it that don’t remove all of the things that make it interesting, all of the things that make it actually Conjuring some freaking Animals and not a bland and uninteresting Generic Persistent AoE.

This change along with things like making Wildshape more boring with bland templates make me suspicious that WotC is going to continue to build up a wall between crunch and fluff so that fluff stops making a difference in the game, so that there’s less and less need for DM rulings, and I get increasingly blocked from getting up to the kind of shenanigans I love the most in favor of clearer and easier to adjudicate combat mechanics.

Now I realize that some people have different preferred ways of playing D&D than me. And I think that the reason 5e did so well despite it’s (many!) flaws is that it’s done a pretty good job of being a compromise edition that can bring a lot of people together. Going full-in for the kind of OSR “rulings not rules” that I like is going to turn off a lot of people so it makes sense that WotC isn’t going to give me what I want. But going too far in the other direction and making everything in a OneD&D fight cut and dry is going to turn off a whole lot of people too and I worry that that’s exactly what we’re going to get.

I hope that OneD&D can walk the same kind of compromise line that 5e did with enough small quality of life and balance tweaks to make it more enjoyable, but if WotC lays one finger on Command I’m out. That spell, as it exists in 5e, is just an encapsulation of everything I love about D&D. Yes, even the stupid juvenile shit that always crops up with that spell.

If WotC doesn’t get that, then it doesn’t get how I play D&D and OneD&D won’t be a decent enough compromise in the way that 5e is.