While there are many complaints and issues people have with the current One D&D Warlock, it seems like there is a lot of talking over each other. People seem to not understand why there is the shift from pact magic, arguing warlock has fewer spells to cast, and trying to find various ways to keep pact magic such as making it a 10 minute ritual twice per day. While the change to traditional spell slots seems like a loss on paper, it is really a net gain and should not be reverted to its previous state.
The Problem of Pact Magic
As a concept, Pact Magic is unique in every sense of the word. Instead of gaining a normal spell slot progression, Warlock gets 2 “pact slots” they can cast of their highest available spell level that refresh on a short rest. Every spell they cast uses these slots. For example, a level 9 warlock will have two 5th level pact slots. Even if they cast a 1st level hex, it is done using a 5th level pact slot.
However, while it is unique, that does not mean it is good. This style of magic means the Warlock is severely restricted in terms of what spells they could be casting and when they can cast them:
Pumping a lower level spell into a higher level slot almost always feels bad. With some minor exceptions Warlock doesn’t have access to (namely Spirit Guardians), upcasting lower level spells into higher level slots will always be considerably worse than just casting a spell of that level. This leads to the issue of warlocks either not wanting to use the spells they have access to with the exception of the small handful of higher level spells or trying to cast low level spells and not seeing much of an improvement.
Warlocks can only use a small handful of spells during a fight. For example, first level spells like shield and absorb elements are cornerstones for self defense that you would not want to have access to only twice. Even the 3rd and 4th pact slots at 11 and 17 do not help. While you’re capable of recovering these slots after a short rest, during a single combat you are not casting the hypothetical 16 spells assuming 4 short rests but just the 4 pact spells. Access to spells of all levels is important and you can’t use your casting to its fullest potential if you are limited in slot count per encounter.
Warlock’s lower pact slot count also means they want to maximize the effectiveness of each spell, which can lead to them waiting until the very very last moment to actually expend them. This leads to Warlocks simply…not casting spells, whether in or out of combat. After all, why risk a Charm Person on the guard when you could use the same slot for a Fireball? You ever have a consumable in a video game, say you’ll “save it for when you need it”, and then never actually use it even after beating the game 100%? That’s more or less what happens a lot of the time.
This leaves warlocks in a position where they are casting significantly less spells than the other casters. Even if their spells are of higher level, players are stuck throwing them out then relegating themselves to cantrips (namely Eldritch Blast) and that’s it. While I do not deny the power of Eldritch Blast, warlocks currently blast during most rounds not because they want to but because they have to.
Short Rests and the Adventuring Day
While changing a short rest to 10 minutes could potentially increase the encounters per day Warlocks go through, it won’t change the fact that your pact slots are hampering you more than helping. Though even then, the recovery method of these slots is just as much an issue as their limited count. The DMG highly recommends 6-8 medium encounters per day with 2 short rests. However, most players only really see anywhere from 0-1 the majority of the time. This is not because the DMs are bad or that the system from the DMG needs to be enforced but because of the shift in game culture from a more dungeon crawling focus to a narrative one. DMs will throw you into single big encounters for the day to have an epic boss fights or throw you into a roleplay focused session with only two or three fights. Whether it’s 1 hour or 10 minutes, these sorts of days will still have a short rest problem.
Is that a bad thing? No. The DM should set the pace of the adventuring day and characters should have access to all their resources at the start of each day. If all classes have their primary resources recharge on long rest, then the DM has the flexibility to challenge you to spend those resources at their own pace rather than having to follow a strict guideline because of the absolute necessity of short rests. That isn’t to say short rests should go away or are being destroyed or what have you. Instead, they are there to supplement or extend these adventuring days. If the party ends an encounter slightly battered and bruised and need to recover a few resources, short rests will be there to help you last a little longer during the day. However if you take a major hit and are running on fumes, a long rest is what you need. Basically, this is one of those cases where the system's assumptions are the thing that need to change due to the practical realities of how the game is played today.
New Warlock: A Half Caster?
When the new warlock was revealed to the world, everyone was baffled when they saw the half caster progression on the class chart. On paper, Warlock switched from its unique pact magic system to the same spellcasting progression Ranger and Paladin have. If that were truly the case, it would have been horrible and a loss of identity and flavor. However, the class table is extremely deceptive in both the spells known and the spell “slots” you have.
This new Warlock’s spell power comes from a mix of its half casting progression and its new Mystic Arcanum invocation. At the cost of an invocation, you get a single spell of any level a full caster can cast. You can even take this invocation multiple times: one for each spell level. In theory, this means you can take Mystic Arcanum 9 times and get an extra spell slot of 1st-9th level. While this is a massive change, there’s a lot of good here. All in all, I think it makes the warlock stand out as an extremely unique caster regardless of losing their short rest dependency.
The Bad
I want to start with the issues of this new arcanum-casting design:
The other invocations feel weak by comparison. Eyes of the Runekeeper, Beast Speech, and other picks do not keep up with just...getting a spell of your choice. While there used to be other invocations that gave you a spell once per day and a lot of them were seen as bad, they were limited to specific spells. Now having access to the entire Arcane list for invocation choices, warlocks can take hypnotic pattern, fear, slow, fireball, counterspell, and other potent magic at the cost of an invocation. Why use invocations to get 6-9 temp hp when you can do 8d6 fire damage in a 20 foot radius sphere instead?
Arcanum levels 6-9 are a non-choice. Not even the 15th level arcanums in this UA hold up to getting a 6th, 7th, 8th, or 9th level spell slot. The arcanum from 6-9 should be reverted to class features or else they are just an unnecessary invocation tax.
This being said, the solution to the problems with mystic arcanum is simple: Buff the weaker invocations! For a few examples: merge Eyes of the Runekeeper with Eldritch Sight, give Beast Speech more than just speak with animals at will, have armor of shadows let you cast mage armor on other people too (reminder the spell has a range of touch)! If you want mystic arcanum not to be an automatic pick, don’t remove it or bake all of it into the class (like I said 6-9 I could see baking back in). Make it so there is an actual choice!
The Good
Warlock got massive quality of life love in this UA. The class was given three big things that make it overall feel more satisfying to play: better spells to know, more spells known to learn them, more slots to cast them with!
Quality
Let’s start with the first thing: better spells known. The old Warlock spell list was, in a word, bad. Warlock went from having one of the worst spell lists in the game to having the best. The Arcane list combines all spells from wizard, sorcerer, warlock, and bard. While warlock may be losing exclusivity on Armor of Agathys, they are getting so so much more in return: shield, fireball, faerie fire, sleep, cone of cold, wall of force, simulacrum, wish. This is just the tip of the iceberg. Warlock in total gained over 100 spells to their spell list, giving them quality…but what about quantity?
…and Quantity
To start the comparison, let’s look at 5e. Old Warlock has a total spells known count of 21: 15 pact spells and 4 mystic arcanum. You’re probably wondering about old warlock’s subclass spells, and if so I would like to remind you that those are not subclass spells. They are an expanded spell list which means you have to use spells known as old warlock to take your subclass spells. New Warlock, assuming you take 0 mystic arcanum, gets a total of 27 spells known: 15 spells known from their prepared spells, 10 known from their subclass, 1 for Hex at level 1, and 1 for Contact Other Plane from their contact patron ability. From there, they get an additional spell known for every arcanum you choose to take. Assuming you spend every invocation on mystic arcanum (so one extra spell of each level), you have a total spell known count of 36. So, you have spells in spades. Now what? Are you going to just take a bunch of spells and let them sit and rot? Nope! Because you get multiple ways to put them to use!
Lots of Slots!
Before we get into the arcanum and spell slots, I want to point something out from the Experts UA: all spell casters get ritual casting. That includes the warlock. Since you now know so many spells, you can even afford to take rituals which gives you out of combat utility previously exclusive to spending a pact boon and an invocation.
Looking at spell slot count, the math is tricky because it depends on short rest count (See: Short Rests and the Adventuring Day). So, we will look at a warlock at levels 5, 11, and 17. For the new warlock, I will be assuming you only take mystic arcanum of spell levels you don’t have slots for and swap them out once you can use their slots. After all, you can overload on casting if you want to, but it is not necessary to enjoy the class!
Level 5
Old Warlock
2 3rd level Pact Slots per short rest.
Total: Anywhere from 2-6 slots per long rest spread between 1-3 encounters at minimum.
New Warlock
4 1st level slots 2 2nd level slots 1 free subclass spell (2nd level max) 1 3rd level arcanum
Total: 8 slots per long rest to be cast whenever you’d like.
Level 11
Old Warlock
3 5th level pact slots 1 6th level arcanum
Total: Anywhere from 4-10 slots, 3-9 of which must be spread out between 1-3 encounters minimum
New Warlock
4 1st level slots 3 2nd level slots 3 3rd level slots 1 free subclass spell (3rd level max) 1 4th level arcanum 1 5th level arcanum 1 6th level arcanum (Also there’s 1 Contact Patron casting but I’m not counting that)
Total: 14 spells to cast whenever you’d like
Level 17
Old Warlock
4 5th level pact slots 1 6th level arcanum 1 7th level arcanum 1 8th level arcanum 1 9th level arcanum
Total: 8-16 spells, 4-12 of which must be spread between at minimum 1-3 encounters.
New Warlock
4 1st level slots 3 2nd level slots 3 3rd level slots 3 4th level slots 1 5th level slot 1 free subclass spell (5th level max) 1 6th level arcanum 1 7th level arcanum 1 8th level arcanum 1 9th level arcanum (Also there’s 1 Contact Patron casting but I’m not counting that)
Total: 19 slots to spend whenever you’d like
Overall, you are getting more spell slots than ever before and aren’t restricted on when you can cast them. You know more spells than before, letting you prepare rituals that you can actually ritual cast now, and your spell list is the best in the game!
So, you are neither a full caster nor a half caster. Full casters beat out both warlocks in terms of slot count. Half casters never access 6th-9th level spell slots. What are you then? You are whatever you want to be in between. At maximum you’re like a 95% caster and at minimum you’re a half caster. How much casting you want your warlock to have, though, is up to you. The more and better invocations WotC pumps out, the more competition mystic arcanum has. That’s the beauty of making arcanum invocations: the choice is in your hands.
The Same-ish
Despite getting the amazing ability to cast as described above, there were a lot of things about the warlock that was kept the same-ish. Its hit dice, armor, pact boons, and the most consistent damage tool in the game: Eldritch blast.
These are what you get for compensation for not being a full caster. If you were an arcane full caster, you would have a d6 hit dice and no armor much like our Wizard and Sorcerer friends.
Why same-ish? Because there were tweaks here that actually make the class even stronger. Armor was bumped to medium instead of light, giving you higher AC. Pact boons now come at level 1 making them more flavorful and tie into the warlock themselves more. While they are cantrips now, I think that is a bit awkward and should be made as class features. The pact boons also have an invocation each baked into them now, making them much stronger if you stick with warlock. Eldritch blast also now scales off warlock level which entirely invalidates the old sorlock: good riddance.
Side Note: Multiclass Mayhem
Speaking of Sorlock, I would argue the change to Eldritch blast is a warlock buff because people would take Eldritch blast, agonizing blast, repelling blast, and 2 short rest pact slots for shield (Hexblade expanded spell list) then take sorcerer for the rest of their lives. Warlock 2/Sorcerer X isn’t a warlock, it’s a sorcerer with Eldritch blast. Though, it does raise the question: why did people build sorlocks? Because you got more spell slots than if you played warlock but you also got all the goodies associated with the class.
Invocation Starvation?
Another common complaint I see with new warlock is the claim that they are invocation starved. While I do think arcanum 6-9 should be baked into the class because they are non-choices, even right now you get more than enough invocations for both spellcasting and cool warlock stuff.
I made a warlock build, Tomes of Fun, that you can find here: https://docs.google.com/document/d/12JM2VOIYVrDvBZyc87HuGE05MmIZ13REC90qPZ7OTOo/view
In the build, I have plenty of invocations that are not arcanum by using the following progression:
Level 5: 1 arcanum, 2 other Level 7: 2 arcanum, 2 other Level 9: 2 arcanum, 3 other Level 11: 3 arcanum, 3 other Level 13: 3 arcanum, 4 other Level 15: 4 arcanum, 4 other Level 17: 4 arcanum, 5 other
While 5 is definitely less than the 8 an old warlock would have...I didn’t really see it as a big deal when making the build. I had enough invocations to pack in all the goodies I wanted for my warlock: Repelling blast for at-will control, gaze of two minds for party splitting, gift of the protectors to save my friends from dying, Lessons of the first ones for a free feat, and witch sight for 30 feet of true sight (reminder there is an epic boon which gives you 60 and you get this 5 levels earlier).
There’s not really much else I would ask for. Are any of these invocations mandatory? No. You could grab cool ones like Mask of Many Faces, Devil’s Sight, Visions of Distant Realms, etc. Of course there are stinkers like Eyes of the Runekeeper, Eldritch Sight (you can ritual cast now), Master of Myriad Forms, and Beast Speech. I think these need to be boosted to be either more interesting, more powerful, or both. Regardless, I’m not too upset at my invocation selections and felt like it was more than enough.
A Crappy Capstone
I should mention the elephant in the room before I wrap up. Yes, Hex Master is bad. There are a ton of ways you could make a better warlock capstone. I think allowing the at-will version of the spell to be upcast to 5th level would be a good start then also add something on top. Either that it’s not concentration or that it imposes disadvantage on d20 tests rather than ability checks for the selected ability. You’re level 18, you can cast WISH for God’s sake. All this being said, the crappy capstone just needs fixing, not a reason to give the class as a whole the thumbs down.
Conclusion
I hope I explained the draw of this new version of the warlock to you all: it is a highly customizable class with the ability to opt into spellcasting and is neatly balanced through the invocation system. It is both mechanically stronger and more engaging to play due to the fact you can cast spells when you want rather than needing to take a nap every 2 castings while having a much more interesting selection of spells to choose from. If you don’t agree with me, that’s fine, but remember that the 5e warlock will still exist after this. Your 2014 PHB isn’t going anywhere and they are still insisting on ‘backwards compatibility’. One DnD Warlock can be something entirely unique and not just a rehash of what you already got.