The entire point of automatic gratuity on parties of six or more was to prevent servers from getting totally screwed over from giant groups that's often times will tip you very little or in some cases none at all.
Studies show that as the amount of people in the group gets higher the tip percentage gets lower. I think it's more of an and indifference when you've got 12 people versus three or four.
I read a memo which I suppose is some years or months old wherein the management had stated that they conferred with servers and decided to no longer do the automatic gratuity because they would not be able to get their tips at the end of their shift versus having them on your paycheck. I can speak for myself, I would have absolutely 0 hesitation with parties even if I were to have to wait for my pay once a week rather than risk an entire shift getting fucked up from a bad large party. Management also claimed that in spite of the automatic gratuity no longer existing, that the recommended tip amount was 20% on the ziosks. Sadly, it doesn't do a fucking thing in some cases. These ghetto parties that honest to goodness just do NOT care about knowingly screwing you over.
I'm not sure how much consideration was given to this point, but now when I have ghetto parties I do not upsell anything unless I am specifically asked for it by the guests. I don't offer them refills for their beers, second rounds of drinks, desserts, appetizers, or anything to go either. I used to do this that's all too often, but the tip share would just get greater and greater to the point whereby I would actually be hurting myself by upping the check total. I recommend you servers do this if you ever have to take a party that is in your best judgment not going to tip you. It is for that reason why the benefit to the restaurant is to also have automatic gratuity.
Moreover, how much money does it cost to train a new server every time one of us decides to quit because of this policy? Probably costs nearly $1000 in the end to train them. Not everything is easily put into dollars. For instance the new server will inevitably make mistakes, the loss of a veteran server is bad for morale and the restaurant in general, and it's just not a sound business decision. Restaurant operators should strive for clientele that do not knowingly staff their staff as it's bad for the business in many ways.
At my restaurant we have these giant parties I'm talking about 15 to 20 even 30 sometimes that completely ruined a server's shift. Oftentimes they don't come back and I don't necessarily blame them. Sometimes they will up and walk out right then right there depending on the party that we receive, putting tons of pressure on everybody else to pick up the slack. I loathe this, but do not necessarily blame them. I have seen servers simply walk out mid-shift when they're told that this loud and obnoxious group who has begun to arrive will be going in their section.
I cannot say that I have ever come across a person that I know who would knowingly avoid a restaurant because of the automatic gratuity being charged for a larger party. I just don't think it's really something that anyone would ever take into consideration when choosing where to go. Let me know if you feel differently here.
It should not be a possibility that as a server you will not only not make money but will in fact lose money by simply doing your job because of the tip out.
I am asking everyone here who agrees to sign this petition, and it will be forwarded to Darden. We must advocate for ourselves because very clearly nobody else will.
https://chng.it/B2hfm5mP9R