Simple, the mta has receives around 6 billion dollars a year via tax money, this has been upped to 60 some billion over the next five years. They receive over 2 million a year (which I think is a very very low estimate, the costs for a e banner add in penn station alone are a 750k a month). They have another some 10 billion dollars they receive through donations and museums and fares make up 23% of the total budget so probably another few billion. Not to mention all fines related to the train pay a portion the the mta and there are billions in fines each year in stations.
Where does all this money go? Walk through a station in Manhattan, it will be covered in pee and a thick grime. The infrastructure is all from the 80s, barely any seats, bo charging ports or air conditioning or even public restrooms or drinking fountains at 99% of the stations.
Walk through the tunnels and see some of the most slip shod halfhazardly thrown together electrical and metal work you will ever see. Damage from sandy 13 years ago still being used to justify massive construction and repair projects but instead of even replacing wiring they duct tape and zip tie things back together.
Why are stairways always under construction? With budgets in the hundreds of millions yet when they reopen they are still just the same exact concrete staircases down to the grime and gum stuck onto the stairs.
What do you think? Is it fat cats stealing our taxes or is. 60 billlion just not enough to keep trains running?