r/nycrail • • Sep 01 '24

Question Fare Evasion Solution

13 Upvotes

Rather than spend $ on security, cops, maintaining turnstiles, inventing new turnstiles, OMNY readers, OMNY/MetroCard machines, EAGLE, administrating fair fares, reconfiguring emergency exits to delay opening, increasing dwell time on buses by having the back door closed, why not just make the fare free?

Before commenting on how we’d afford it, please explain how we can afford war, corporate welfare, subsidizing agriculture, cop cities, and tax breaks for the wealthy and how this would be the one item to break the bank


r/nycrail • • Oct 14 '24

Question What can we all agree that the best seat on a r68/R46 is

47 Upvotes

Seat no1 is the one right behind the operator Seat no2 is the one next to the door Seat no3 I'd the one in the middle in those 3 seats between the window and the door Seat no 4 is the one in front of the window Seat with nothing Seat no 5 is the window Seat with the cramped up leg room Seat no 6 is the 2 lonely seats at the back if there's no cab over there by that 1 small window


r/nycrail • • Apr 03 '24

News Congestion fees coming for the street races too

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/nycrail • • May 05 '24

News Panhandlers on Metro North

1 Upvotes

I've seen 2 panhandlers on Metro North (new haven line) between Grand Central and Mount Vernon East in the last week. I'm not trying to be a Karen here, but checking tickets before allowing access to platform at stations between 125th and New Rochelle can't come soon enough.


r/nycrail • • Oct 14 '24

Question Why cant the MTA just install these as the permanent faregates at every station ive never seen someone try to fare evade these

1 Upvotes

r/nycrail • • Mar 20 '24

News An enforced ban on people riding the subway with bikes needs to be put in place

0 Upvotes

It’s insane how frequently I go to get on a train at rush hour or at a generally busy station, and see people struggling to get both on and off the train because some bike delivery guy is blocking basically the entire entrance with their bike (sometimes electric which is an uncomfortable fire hazard to have to be on a train with) and their massive insulated backpacks.

This is annoying when it happens on a quieter train but not the end of the world, but when you have a crowded platform of people trying to get on the train or a crowded train car trying to exit before the doors close that all get blocked by a dickhead with a bike, it’s unacceptable.

If there’s already a policy in place that prohibits this then I’m not aware of it, and it’s certainly not enforced regardless. Anyway, that’s my rant. Others that ride the 2 train regularly can probably empathize.


r/nycrail • • Sep 10 '23

Dear MTA: it's pronounced 'rear', not 'rare'

4 Upvotes

I know the MTA possibly has more important issues to sort out, but: "the elevator is located at the rear of the platform". It rhymes with 'ear'- there is no rare of a platform.


r/nycrail • • Mar 12 '23

Homeless people on the R211 already

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

They already getting dirty 💀


r/nycrail • • Mar 22 '26

❓ Question What do you think of this?

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/nycrail • • Nov 01 '24

News Daniel Penny

0 Upvotes

Daniel Penny is innocent and any person who believes he should be in jail, I pray to god nobody helps you in the subway when a homeless dude, junkie, crack head or any hoodlum attacks you 🤷‍♂️


r/nycrail • • Aug 30 '26

🗞️ News This is coming up for 25th Anniversary for 9/11, if anyone is interested to pay respects or see something unique and positive from that day, check them out

Post image
37 Upvotes

r/nycrail • • Mar 22 '24

Question At this point, it's safe to say: MTA service has become unacceptable

1 Upvotes

I regularly take the 8th Ave lines and the F.

I follow the NYCT alerts on Twitter and the amount of brakes going off, mechanical failures, disruptive passengers. COMBINED with the fact you can't a ride without the train stopping in the tunnel 600 time, sudden service changes, crawling speeds (I have a video of my express A taking 2+ mins to pass 72nd st. That trip my train crawled from 125 to 59th. May as well have been local. I rarely ride the A express without there being a distruption).

Everything is slow. It seems that mechanical problems are the norm now.

What is going on behind the scenes? Why am I waiting 20+ mins for an F train during rush hour (that definitely won't be a smooth trip. It'll stop in the tunnel multiple times and it'll crawl of course).

This seemed to start right after the new year.


r/nycrail • • Oct 11 '24

Video Don't lean on doors please

0 Upvotes

r/nycrail • • Oct 22 '24

Fantasy map I made another fantasy map!!

Post image
0 Upvotes

Now, along with the 4 and 5 being gone, the 2 train is also gone!! :D


r/nycrail • • Apr 29 '24

Art An R68 in my recent art, thought I’d share it here too! (Furry related) Spoiler

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/nycrail • • Oct 30 '25

Discussion Rant: I am irrationally bothered by all the announcements on the 7 train

0 Upvotes
  • Hey I'm Cardi B, --

Noone cares.

  • What's up New York? 3 kids have been killed due to Subway surfing this year

Yikes! OK but why are you telling me this when I just want to go to work.

  • ...Ride inside, stay alive

Do you really need to spell this out? Obviously the kids that are doing this will not listen. It's a futile ad campaign.

  • HELLO. The MTA is hiring. We are looking for talented individuals...

Is it really necessary to announce this kind of ad to a whole group of commuters? Why not just a poster instead? Never mind the fact that "talented" is overused here as is typically done in corporate speak. Most of the jobs in a transportation system don't require "talent" per se. You would not say that the sanitation department is looking for talented individuals.

  • HELLO. It is dangerous to hold the doors open. HELLO. Backpacks and other containers are subject to random search by the police. HELLO. ... HELLO. ....

This happens sometimes in the Queens - Manhattan tunnel. Just because you are bored, doesn't mean you should spam us with all the announcements you have available, back to back. HELLO - shut up for a bit!

Plus, all these superfluous announcements take away from more important announcements about services changes, that we should be listening to.

That is all. Semi-joking but also semi-serious. And yes I usually have my earbuds with me but not always!


r/nycrail • • Dec 26 '24

News Why nobody grabbed a fire extinguisher at the Coney Island station?

17 Upvotes

Please,someone help me understand, why the police did not use some readily available, easy-to-apply fire extinguishers during the recent Coney Island tragedy? Or billions of dollars were wasted building that station or no basic necessity fire extinguishers there were nowhere to be found?

Edit: I see that many are very protective of the police. I see your point. In fact, my confusion was not particularly about the NYPD's actions but about the absolute lack of easy access fire extinguishers at the station or on the train. Or why the MTA workers were not running over to hand them to the police? I looked up some articles from a few years ago, already then a commission found that MTA is not up to the fire code, they promised to improve it. Nothing.

Edit: as time goes on, I am even stronger holding the opinion that were there an extinguisher available in the train car, the woman would be alive and the society would be saved from seing this atrocious event. MTA should be held responsible and charged with public safety neglect.

https://ny1.com/nyc/all-boroughs/news/2022/05/11/audit-finds-severe-fire-safety-concerns-at-mta-train-yard

https://finance.yahoo.com/news/mta-still-faces-fire-sprinkler-120000660.html


r/nycrail • • Jun 14 '25

Photo Interesting

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/nycrail • • Apr 08 '26

Service Advisory Chaos at 96th Street (1 2 3)

Post image
5 Upvotes

Track switch issue at Jackson Avenue has affected 2 and 5 Train Bronx service SEVERELY. 2 Train riders were mad when they found out the last stop was 96th Street.


r/nycrail • • Jul 09 '26

❓ Question Is it possible to befriend a conductor and ride in the front of the train?

0 Upvotes

It's a dream of mine but I have a feeling it isn't possible..........I want to see the tunnel approaching from the conductors cabin so bad


r/nycrail • • Aug 21 '25

Question Why does the MTA pull from so many billion dollar revenue streams and still operate like crap and cost so much???

0 Upvotes

Simple, the mta has receives around 6 billion dollars a year via tax money, this has been upped to 60 some billion over the next five years. They receive over 2 million a year (which I think is a very very low estimate, the costs for a e banner add in penn station alone are a 750k a month). They have another some 10 billion dollars they receive through donations and museums and fares make up 23% of the total budget so probably another few billion. Not to mention all fines related to the train pay a portion the the mta and there are billions in fines each year in stations.

Where does all this money go? Walk through a station in Manhattan, it will be covered in pee and a thick grime. The infrastructure is all from the 80s, barely any seats, bo charging ports or air conditioning or even public restrooms or drinking fountains at 99% of the stations.

Walk through the tunnels and see some of the most slip shod halfhazardly thrown together electrical and metal work you will ever see. Damage from sandy 13 years ago still being used to justify massive construction and repair projects but instead of even replacing wiring they duct tape and zip tie things back together.

Why are stairways always under construction? With budgets in the hundreds of millions yet when they reopen they are still just the same exact concrete staircases down to the grime and gum stuck onto the stairs.

What do you think? Is it fat cats stealing our taxes or is. 60 billlion just not enough to keep trains running?


r/nycrail • • Jan 24 '25

Photo Woodside Station is a Joke

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/nycrail • • Oct 22 '24

Fantasy map i made ANOTHER fantasy map!!

Post image
1 Upvotes

thanks u/yuds2003 for the idea to remove the shuttles!

Removed:

2 train 4 train 5 train Every Shuttle

Next:

1 train Z train


r/nycrail • • Dec 01 '24

News E train at WTC filled with homeless

0 Upvotes

So Thanksgiving, came back to NYC from Exchange Place at midnight. Went to the E train at World Trade.

First seven cars were filled with the homeless. One other family and my wife and I found one bench free. A homeless guy came from another car and deliberately sat across from us. Crushed a soda can, tossed it and stared at us all. We got off at Canal and waited for an A.

Now as to the platform. Three MTA employees just standing around and two cops on their phones.

I mean you could make the first cars only for paying customers and put a cop in that car. That one homeless guy wanted to do something so I put my hand in my coat pocket and made it look like I had something to deter him. He grimaced and sat back down but glared at the 6 of us sitting across from him. FELT incredibly safe do nothing City employees.