1) getting shit on by vets
easily the most unfun thing about ns2 is the skill gap between fresh blood and experienced players. it's exceptionally hard to appreciate the positive qualities of the game when every round is a steamroll. this problem is likely the biggest contributor to new players not sticking with the game.
as such, there's already a lot of discussion on the topic, mainly on stuff like intelligent matchmaking. personally, I don't feel matchmaking is the way to go unless the player base grows explosively. additionally, I'm going to make a bold claim and say that this kind of skill gap is not a problem, but instead it highlights a multitude of other problems. yes, a team of vets should shit on a team of rookies. but the rookies should still a) have some way to create team momentum b) learn and understand why they're losing and c) HAVE FUN PLAYING.
possible solution: here's a quick list of some that could possibly smooth out the skill gap problems:
offer players more feedback, better feedback, and clearer feedback on the current state of the game and their performance.
checking the map is a massive burden and a lot of important information can be given to players without forcing them into the map every 2 seconds. (example: the waypoint breadcrumbs are often either hard to notice or hard to follow optimally)
dimishing combat effectiveness past a certain point. if a player's K:D passes a certain point, reduce damage dealt and increase damage received by some %.
fix the other stuff in this thread
2) lack of personal customization/strategic decision making
aliens get a particularly interesting mechanic in the form of personal upgrades. this mechanic allows aliens to choose a loadout that will either compliment their playstyle or somewhat counteract the enemy's playstyle. the problems here are a) marines don't get a comparable mechanic and b) the loadout options are fairly shallow, stiff, and limited
possible solution: introduce a "true" loadout system that allows for more strategy and variation. interestingly, combat mode has something kind of like this, but your choices persist for the duration of a round instead of a single life, which strips most of the strategic potential from the system. games that do this well: tf2, cod, lol
3) early game too short, late game too long
I forget where I read this, but someone succinctly described the ns2 victory conditions as, "whichever team can creative a positive feedback loop most efficiently wins". unfortunately, your team's efficiency is usually set and solidified within the first 5-10 minutes of a match. whats worse is, once the snowball is established, it takes wayyyy to long to play out to completion.
possible solution: finding ways to extend the early game could ease this pain. here are a couple thoughts.
add an on-hit DoT to RTs (damage over time applied to a person damaging the rt). this will introduce some mild fortification to rooms that have been successfully claimed and will make it harder to topple a team's entire economy early on
make resource nodes in the middle of the map worth half as much as those located near main bases. shifting the bulk of a team's economy to more defensible positions will make it easier for teams to fortify after unfortunate fights and will also somewhat reduce snowballing in situations where one team locks down a significant majority of the map
room buffs! allow commanders to drop a temporary buff in a specific room. stuff like scans and med/ammo spamming are super interesting because a) it enables the commander to turn a fight on it's head b) there's some pretty interesting cost vs reward analysis to it and c) its a cool interaction between soldiers and commander. extending this mechanic to allow a commander to drop a temporary buff (+fire speed, +armor, +heat vision, etc) on an engagement zone allows for more zone control and more interesting struggles for control. buffable rooms can also be limited to 'friendly' rooms only, to focus buffs on fortification
4) don't call it a comeback
because there's no such thing in ns2. there needs to be more blue shells in ns2, meaning there needs to be some ways for underdogs to get back into the race
possible solution: although resource control dictates the direction of momentum in a game, tech is the immediate realization of that momentum. unfortunately, getting at the enemy crag or proto lab usually means strolling into a heavily fortified enemy base. making tech more vulnerable would create more opportunity to knock your opponent off balance. however, I don't have a solid idea on how to approach this