Kids are cruel. And teens? Teens are monsters. Gather a large group of them, put them in a building from 7:00 AM to 3:00 PM for five days a week, and you have a hotbed for chaos.
And then you have Tyler.
Tyler was a model student. He was at the top of several classes, handsome, friendly, a skilled athlete despite not being on any sports teams. He was frequently sticking up for freshmen and sophomores who got bullied or helping them with schoolwork they had a problem with, and overall, he was a great guy.
I should emphasize he was a “great” guy; Tyler was not a “good” guy. Tyler was a bona fide psychopath.
In 2009, when Tyler transferred to our school, he noticed that the place had a very serious bullying problem. Instead of his brilliance making him a target or a problem-solver, he decided to turn the bullies and the victims alike into his personal playthings. If he helped you out against a bully, there was always a catch. Once, he helped David, a chemistry student being picked on. He approached him outside school away from prying eyes and ears.
“Hey, David,” Tyler greeted him in his usual disarming, friendly manner.
David responded in kind and thanked him for the help he gave him before, and said that if there was anything he could do to repay Tyler, all he had to do was ask.
“Well, there is one thing, actually,” Tyler said placidly, smoothing back his hair. “I want you to start a fire.”
David stood still, looking at Tyler, then laughed nervously, thinking—and hoping—it was a joke.
It wasn’t.
“In the chemistry lab,” Tyler continued, almost sounding bored. “Any time before Thursday.”
David looked at Tyler like he’d sprouted two heads. “T-Tyler…you— I can’t just—”
“You owe me, remember?” Tyler said, sounding more reproachful than anything. “Before Thursday, or I’ll give a concerned report to the principal about how you tried to drug Lacey for not going out with you.”
David had never tried to drug anyone, but it had become an unspoken secret that it didn’t matter what the truth was; Tyler could turn it into his truth.
David started the fire on Wednesday. Nobody was hurt, but David was expelled and went to juvie. All of his prospects for graduating from our school and furthering his chemistry studies at the college of his choice went up in smoke, quite literally.
Many of us didn’t believe David had done it for a second. In fact, we knew it. David had been pretty damn upset when his crush, Lacey, had rejected him, but he was a good kid; arson just wasn’t in his nature. But what could we do? The older students had a hunch that Tyler was a manipulative, charming psychopath. People had tried to report him to school authorities, and to their credit, they weren't dismissive of our concerns; Tyler was just good at hiding proof, faking empathy, and punishing people for trying to report him.
So where do I fit into all of this? I was Tyler’s friend. When I first met him, he didn't seem all that bad. He was friendly, had a good sense of humor, and always made time for me. We would spend time together hanging out at the bleachers of our school’s baseball field late at night, him smoking cigarettes and offering them to me, which I always refused. We just talked, never really had a particular topic in mind; we just said whatever we were thinking of.
“Y'know, Matt,” he once said to me during the early weeks of our friendship and before his manipulative tendencies surfaced, “I’m new to all this.”
“To what, Tyler?”
He gestured between us.
“This. You, me, just shooting the breeze like this. Never…never really had this at my old school. Even back in middle school, hell, even before that. Not anyone I could really call a friend, y'know?”
His voice was lower, almost vulnerable.
“Oh.” It was the only thing I could think to say.
“Am I…” he paused, seeming to weigh his words. “Am I doing all of this right, man? Are we friends? Like, real friends?”
“…Yeah. Yeah, man. We’re friends.”
He seemed to brighten up, then nodded.
“Thanks, Matt. Just wanted to make sure, that’s all.”
It was a weird question, and in hindsight, I think his apparent sincerity made me overlook his red flags. Teenagers can be stupid like that. It took me a few months to realize what he was, and by then, I knew what he was capable of. But what complicated matters was this: of all the students, Tyler seemed to take a sort of interest in me. It wasn't romantic or even obsessive; he just always looked at me like breaking or putting strings on me was a waste. He viewed me as a confidant, telling me all of his misdeeds openly, casually. That was always one thing that seemed constant with him: he never lied to me. Anyone else, he would spin a story, but when talking to me, he was opening up. And me? I had seen some of what he was capable of, and if what he told me was true, all of that was the tip of the iceberg. In short, I was his “favorite.” His favorite what, exactly, I don’t know, but I don’t think I want to.
In hindsight, I should have reported him, but at the time, all I could think was, “What then?” He would find a way to ruin me, to make my life Hell. For the record, I never helped him do what he did; hell, there were times that I tried to suggest that he lay off, but he would always laugh and pat my shoulder and give a squeeze that went on just a bit too long—his way of saying, Tell anyone and you’re finished.
But one evening, he said the six words that would forever change my life. He sat down next to me in our usual spot on the bleachers of the school’s empty baseball field, took out a cigarette, lit it, then blew a column of smoke in the air before saying, “I killed someone this weekend, Matt.”
I did a double take. The way he said it, it was like somebody mentioning an anecdote about meeting someone strange or something weird happening to them.
I looked at him. He hadn’t made eye contact with me when he said it. And as it dawned on me, I was shocked, but I thought he was just yanking my chain. After almost thirty seconds of silence, of trying to find the right thing to say, I managed to stammer out, “Wh-who?”
He sighed and shrugged. “I dunno. Just some old drunk on the side of the road. He was singing loudly; I got annoyed. I kicked him. He kept singing. Kicked him several more times; no dice. So I broke his bottle and stabbed him in the carotid artery, and that was that.”
He looked at his smooth, deft hands, as if checking for any dried blood beneath his nails.
“It was weird, man. Like, I knew it was wrong, I knew I could get arrested. But still…it felt kinda nice. At least, I think it did? It was like… I dunno, like being on a roller coaster. I kicked the guy; it felt like I was going up slowly, then I stabbed him, and it felt like I went down, full speed, adrenaline pumping through me. Then he stopped breathing and… Well, I felt disappointed… I…I really don’t know how else to describe it. And I’ll be honest, Matt: I didn’t do it because he annoyed me. That was just part of it. The excuse. I just kinda wanted to give it a try. I’m not sure if I’ll do it again or not. Maybe not. Seems like more trouble than it’s worth.”
I looked at him, unable to comprehend what I was hearing. Tyler, unrepentant psychopath and manipulator, had just casually confessed to a murder. I knew he was crafty, but this was different. He’s lying, I thought. Please, God, let him be lying.
He looked at me, and he laughed lightly. “Don’t worry, Matt, I’m not gonna kill you. We’re friends.” He patted my shoulder, giving the usual squeeze, but holding it just a bit longer, and he left, just like that.
Even with the knowledge that he didn't lie to me about other things, I didn't fully believe him. I didn't want to believe him. He was messing with me. He had to be. Then the school newspaper came out with details of a body that had been discovered by a railroad, stabbed to death. From what the police could determine, the man—Bill—had come to town from about three states over, hitching a ride on a train. How he had gotten drunk was anyone’s guess. The murder weapon hadn’t been found yet, and police had cordoned off the crime scene. This was a small town, so there were occasional robberies and gang violence, but the nature of Bill’s death was different. We didn’t see cold-blooded murder around here often, if ever. Everyone was on edge. Everyone, of course, except Tyler. He just read the newspaper. To everyone, he just appeared like his usual self. But I could see a particular expression on his face, one he usually kept well hidden: a look of accomplishment and surprise, like a rookie football player scoring a touchdown during his first game without even realizing it.
He’s just interested, I told myself*. He’s weird. Fucked up, even. But there’s no way he did it.* Part of me knew I was lying to myself, though, but the idea that I had been friends with a murderer was unthinkable.
After that, I kept hanging around with him, but more warily. I initially considered reporting him to the police, but as I said, what then? I had no tangible proof; I was going off a hunch, and Tyler was good at lying and putting on an act, even if we juniors and seniors knew better. And even if he was taken in and questioned, he wouldn’t be held long, if at all, and the second he’d be released, he would make a beeline for me. Whether he would murder me or just turn my life into a living hell, the jury was out at the time.
If I’d known how far things were going to go, I would have turned him in.
As we were headed to our usual spot another night, I heard something: an odd clinking in Tyler’s school bag. He made no mention of it, and I didn't ask. When we sat down, all Tyler could talk about was murder. From little-known one-off killers to the likes of Bundy and the Zodiac Killer, he sounded like a living true-crime podcast before they became all the rage. I just contributed with the occasional “Yeah”, “No way”, “Seriously?” and other taciturn answers. What was I supposed to say? What does one say to their friend who’s suddenly obsessed with murder? The thing that scared me most, though, was that he wasn't acting like a bloodthirsty serial killer. If I had to put a description to it, he seemed more like he had discovered a new fad, a fascination. He talked about serial killers and their actions like he was describing a collection of antique coins. I had never seen him so pumped with energy as when he was talking about murder.
“I’m telling you, Matt,” he said one night, “Ed Gein was caught because he was obsessed with making furniture out of his victims. Why would you do that? You’re just creating evidence against yourself.”
“Weren’t most of the parts he used from graves he robbed?” I asked, immediately wondering why the hell I asked.
He looked at me disapprovingly.
“Yeah, they were, but Matt, come on, you know what I meant. If he wanted parts for furniture, he should have just stuck to digging graves. Like, be a grave robber or a killer. Pick one. Take trophies from people you killed, not from people who are already dead. And then there was the whole ‘woman suit’ thing. That— Ugh. That guy was just a weirdo.”
If I could give Tyler credit for one thing, it was his genuine disgust at that. But it didn't seem to be a moral standard; it was more of a look someone gives to a guest who tracks mud on a freshly washed carpet.
Eventually, the conversation did turn away from murder, and at some point, Tyler left for a restroom break. I knew then that I had to take a look at whatever was in Tyler’s bag, whatever was making that noise.
I really did hope that he was just messing with me this whole time, that the talk about murder and the claim that he was a killer himself was all some attempt to scare me. But when I surreptitiously lifted the flap of his bag and peered in, I knew I couldn’t keep lying to myself.
In the bag, resting between the textbooks and pens, was a broken bottle of whiskey with dried-out blood on the jagged edges.
I didn't touch it. I’d seen enough crime movies and shows to know that it was evidence, and touching it would contaminate it. I just closed the bag as quickly as I had opened it and scooted away, trying to act casual as thoughts raced through my head. I thought about how the newspaper said the murder weapon hadn’t been found. I thought about why he would carry it with him, let alone leave it there for me to find. Surely he knew I heard it. Was it some screwed-up test? Was he keeping it there to make sure that I knew the consequences of letting his secret out? Or in his own way, did he trust me not to look? Did he genuinely believe all of this stuff was just normal, and that bottle was just a prize? Take trophies from people you killed. The Gein rant hit me: a trophy. That bottle wasn’t a murder weapon to him, and it wasn't even evidence of a crime; it was a trophy.
When Tyler came back, we just sat and talked for a little while longer. I did my best to stay calm despite my instincts wailing at me to run. Eventually, though, I had to head off.
“Matt?” he said, causing me to freeze and turn stiffly.
“Yeah, Tyler?”
“What’s up?”
“What do you mean, Tyler?”
“You’re not looking so good. You sick or something?”
Are you? I thought, but I didn't say it. “Y'know how the cafeteria food is,” I lied. “Gotta start bringing my own lunches.”
“Matt, come on. We’re friends. I’ve never lied to you.”
I stiffened. I knew that tone. It was the same charm he used to get his way out of trouble, the same tone he’d used to tell David to set fire to the lab. His puppetmaster’s voice.
“I… Well, a-after… Y’know, Bill…”
His face darkened slightly.
“Yeah? What about him?”
“Well…you’ve…been on a kick lately. I-I promise, I haven’t said anything. I just… L-look, man, I just don’t get it. You’ve never been this… I dunno, excited. And you’re excited about goddamn serial killers.”
He was quiet.
“What’s wrong with that?” he asked. His tone was earnest, like I’d objected to a new hobby.
“Tyler, you… You told me you killed someone. You fucking killed someone. And I don’t know if you’re just screwing with me here or what, but now you’re all excited and chatty about it, and… I just… I… You’re scaring me, Tyler.”
He looked incredulous.
“Why?” he asked. “I said I wouldn’t kill you, right? We’re friends.”
“Yeah, we are,” I said aloud, “but…well, what if you go to jail?”
There was a pause as his face darkened.
“Why would I go to jail, Matt?” he asked blankly as I realized the implications of my words.
“W-well, y'know, cops might find something to link you back to Bill’s murder. It was your first time, right? Nobody does it perfectly the first time.”
I couldn’t believe I was talking like this, but he seemed to buy my act, or if he didn’t, he seemed to value our “friendship” too much to pursue it.
“True. It was pretty sloppy, looking back. He bled more than I thought he would. And turns out, bottles aren’t very efficient for murder weapons. Thank God he was drunk, or he might have killed me.”
He drew a knife from his pocket and I pulled away. He looked at me and laughed.
“Relax, Matt, it’s not for you,” he reassured me.
“Wh-who’s it for, then?”
“Nobody in particular right now. I’m just keeping it with me. You know, in case I get another urge.”
He was as sickeningly casual as always, like he was talking about an asthma inhaler.
“Yeah, I should have used it on Bill, in hindsight.”
Conceding that he had been sloppy on his first murder (and I was regretting using the word “first”, like I was expecting that he would commit more murders) as easily as admitting that he botched a recipe, carrying the murder weapon as a trophy, and admitting that he might want to kill someone again—I could have puked.
Eventually, the time came for us to part ways. As always, he squeezed my shoulder before he left.
I knew I had to tell someone.
The following Monday, I triple-checked to make sure Tyler wasn’t watching me when I went to the school counselor. I was almost relieved when he texted me that he was helping out a freshman named Ben who had been harassed by one of the school’s star players for our baseball team, Jack. I didn’t like the phrase he used when he said he was “helping Ben grow some backbone.” When I was there, she asked me standard questions; I gave her general answers. Then I asked her what I should do if hypothetically, a classmate was expressing an unhealthy fascination with murder cases. Instantly, she stopped writing on her clipboard, and her face became pale. Bill’s murder was still fresh on everyone’s minds, so naturally, she asked if I believed this classmate was responsible for Bill’s death. I lied, saying that the classmate was just a little too interested in the act of murder, what the police may have been keeping from the public, and telling her that I thought this classmate had visited the crime scene after the event. She didn't buy it, but she didn’t push me. She told me that, since this was a murder case, it would be best to notify the police. She had just asked if I would give this classmate’s name.
“No!” I whispered frantically, startling her. I looked at the door, imagining Tyler opening it, his blank face peering in through the crack.
Why would I go to jail, Matt?
She furrowed her eyebrows in suspicion and concern.
“Is it that Tyler boy?” she asked quietly, and my heart sank. “Has he threatened you?”
I was quiet. As I mentioned before, Tyler’s masquerade worked best with freshmen and sophomores. Most juniors and seniors knew he was a calculating psychopath, but again, they were too afraid to confront him. Clearly, she had heard the rumors.
“Matt?” she said, her tone quiet but serious. “Matt, if this boy is responsible for a murder—”
“…He told me,” I muttered. I explained everything to her, from the confession to finding the bottle. “I-I don’t know if he was hoping I would find it or something. I just…” I looked at her, and from the look in her eyes, I must have looked like I was on the verge of a panic attack, and I whispered, “You don’t know Tyler the way I do. You don’t. I don’t know why, but I’m the only person he ever talks to about this. He thinks I’m his friend, or something. But if he found out I told anybody about all of this—”
I shook my head, my voice breaking at this point as I covered my face. “I’m a goddamn coward,” I whispered. I could feel her eyes on me. I knew it was the truth: I was scared of Tyler. Scared of him smearing my name, of being manipulated into doing something terrible, or being murdered—I just didn’t know.
“No, Matt,” she said. “You’re not a coward. Being afraid and being a coward aren’t the same. Cowards are selfish. If you were a coward, you never would have come forward with this. If anything, telling me this despite being afraid of Tyler—”
She was interrupted by commotion in the hallways. We both turned to the doorway. Down the hall, there was what sounded like a struggle. I hastily wiped my eyes and ran out of the room, followed by Ms. Jennings. A crowd of students was gathered around Ben and Jack. Jack had the skinny Ben pinned up against a locker, rage in his eyes. As he punched Ben in the gut, he was growling something about whether Ben thought he was cute, writing “Jack-Off” on his prized baseball bat in Sharpie. There was fear and pain in Ben’s eyes as he stammered, and he looked from one side of the crowd to the other. But the fear was replaced by an anger that someone as small as he was shouldn't have been able to muster. Even Jack hesitated, caught off-guard by the sudden shift.
“Leave me alone! Ben yelled.
What happened next happened within the space of three seconds, but time seemed to slow. Ben's hand shot for his pocket, drawing something. There was a *click*and he brought his hand up and slammed it into Jack’s neck before pulling it away. A switchblade now drenched in crimson. There was a collective gasp, then stunned silence. Jack released Ben, seeming to be running on autopilot. Ben’s anger melted, replaced by wordless horror as he realized what he had just done. Jack held his hand to his neck, then began to choke. That was when the screams started. The students began clamoring in horror as Jack fell to the ground, convulsing. It all seemed to blur for me. Ben’s shocked and remorseful apologies to Jack, school security hauling him away, teachers instructing all of the students to stand back and make way for paramedics while they tried to staunch the bleeding. By the time medics got there, it was too late. Jack was gone. I had never been fond of the guy, but seeing them wheel away the limp, muscular body that had once won many baseball games for our school and simultaneously bullied anyone younger or weaker than him, a mean, dead kid, but a dead kid nonetheless… I had to look away.
And that was when I saw him.
On the other side of the crowd, the pool of Jack’s blood separating us, stood Tyler. Like everyone else, he was shocked. But I knew that look.
I’m helping Ben grow some backbone.
It wasn't horror he was feeling.
I’m helping Ben grow some backbone.
Amazement. He was—
Grow some backbone.
It was the expression of someone who had planted seeds and found an apple tree in their yard the very next day.
Backbone. Backbone. Backbone.
The words pulsed in my brain like a migraine, and I felt my veins running hot.
School was let out early, naturally. That evening, I sat in my bedroom. My parents had checked up on me to see if I was okay. I told them I just wanted to be alone for a little while, and I could see that they were trying not to push me after the day’s events, so they told me to let them know if I needed anything.
They were the best parents I could have asked for, but even they couldn't help with this. My mind was filled with so many emotions: guilt for not calling Tyler out on his suspicious behavior before, sorrow for Jack and Ben alike, and rage at my “friend’s” callous manipulation. What I did next was without a doubt the most reckless, stupid thing I’ve done before or since, regardless of the outcome. That night, when my parents went to sleep, I texted Tyler. It was much more blunt than my usual texts.
We need to talk. Usual spot.
After that, I began to sneak out as I usually did, but I paused. I looked through the back of my bookcase. When my grandfather had passed, he left me several things, including a K-bar knife he had used in Vietnam and an old Walkman recorder, the closest he ever got to accepting modern technology. I pondered the blade and the recorder. Maybe I wouldn’t need them. Maybe I could just leave them—
It then occurred to me what kind of situation I was going into: I was sneaking out, in the middle of the night, and going to an empty baseball field where a goddamn psychopath with a knife of his own who had shamelessly murdered a drunk but innocent old man, then manipulated an oppressed student into murdering his bully. Whatever he viewed me as, friend, confidant, pet, toy, things could go sideways in a heartbeat. And if worst came to worst, I would need something to defend myself physically and in court. I wrote a note to my parents, telling them I snuck out to the baseball field, and that if I wasn’t in bed in the morning, to call the police and send them to Tyler. A lump formed in my throat as I wrote that I loved them and I was sorry if something happened. Then I placed the sheathed knife on my jeans, concealing it, and the Walkman in my jacket pocket with my phone, and slipped out the window.
When I walked up the bleachers, Tyler was sitting there. I flicked the “Record” button on the Walkman in my pocket. When he saw me coming, he smiled and said, “There you are. I was starting to think you called me out here for nothing. What’s up?”
The fury from earlier coursed through me.
“What’s up?” I asked, bewilderment and rage in my voice. ”What’s up? Tyler, what— what did you do?”
He looked confused.
“Uh, dunno. What…did I do?”
“Ben, Tyler!” I snapped. “What the hell did you make him do?! What did you tell him?!”
“Oh, that,” he said as if recalling a long-forgotten anecdote. He seemed to think it over, then shrugged. “I just thought he could use a bit of encouragement, is all.”
“Encouragement, Tyler?! Encou— Someone is dead, Tyler! Dead! Because you told a bullied kid—”
“I didn’t tell him to kill Jack, Matt,” he replied nonchalantly. “Not in the school, anyway. I just told him he needed to think of ways to make him leave him alone. I figured humiliating him by vandalizing his bat was a good first step.”
“But you knew things would escalate.” It wasn’t a question.
“Well, obviously,” he scoffed. “Jack was hot-tempered. I wanted to see what would happen, wanted to see if Ben would fight back, get tired of being picked on. The results were… Well, even I couldn’t have imagined it, Matt. I told him that when Jack grabbed him again, to kick him in the nads, punch him in the jaw, pick up something heavy and hit him. But I never guessed that he would have a-a switchblade. A switchblade! Little Ben stabbing Jack in the throat.” He whistled. “Just…just amazing. Fucking amazing.”
I shook my head, dumbfounded.
“Tyler…” I muttered, making sure the Walkman was catching this. “Tyler, this— You murdered Bill because he ‘annoyed’ you, and then you—you convinced a freshman to murder his bully just to see what happened. David was bad enough, but you didn’t just ruin people’s lives with this; you’re a murderer, and you made somebody else do the killing for you. What’s next, huh? You gonna send an anonymous letter to Ben’s parents, tell them about what they do to kids like him in prison? You—”
“That isn’t my style, Matt,” he sighed. “I’m not some pathetic troll, writing to people and harassing them to get a rise. I convince people to do things, then watch what happens. And if I need to plant a bit of phony evidence now and then, who cares? No such thing as too much leverage. The murder is just a hobby.”
I stared at him, mouth agape.
“Yeah?” I scoffed. “And how soon until you find leverage against me, huh? Or get bored of me and kill me next to a railroad track?”
He was astonished. “…We’re…we’re friends. I didn't hurt you. I…I always thought you understood…”
“Understood what?!” I demanded as I backed away down the bleachers. “What is there to understand except that you’re a goddamn murderer?!”
“I never hurt you. I didn't do anything bad to you. I never did anything bad to you. Why…why are you afraid of me?”
That caused something to break inside me. He really believes it, I thought. He thinks that makes it all okay. I couldn't do it anymore. I couldn’t get through to him. “You need help, Tyler,” I said, my voice almost breaking. I shook my head and turned to walk down the bleachers.
“What’s in your pocket?”
I froze.
“Matt, is that— You were recording me?”
Tyler didn't sound angry. If anything, he sounded betrayed.
“Yeah,” I muttered. “You were right, Tyler—you never lied to me. And I needed to make sure you didn’t lie to anyone else. I…I always wanted to believe you weren’t all bad, Tyler. So I put up with all the bullshit you did before. The blackmail, the manipulation, getting David to commit arson—that shit was bad enough. But two people are dead because of you. If I let you cover it up, you’ll find a third.”
The blank expression spread over his face.
“Matt,” he said with a tone like a parent trying to confiscate a grounded kid’s phone, “give it to me.”
“Fuck you.”
“I can’t let you tell anyone what I did.”
As he spoke, he calmly and slowly drew a knife of his own from a sheath on his waistband and walked down the bleachers.
“Tyler—” I spoke rapidly. “Tyler, don’t—”
“I don’t want to. But I can’t let you tell anyone. I never thought you would.”
We both reached the grass.
“Give me the Walkman. Now.”
It was the harshest tone he had ever used with me, so much that I felt a shiver creep down my spine.
“Get back!” I yelled, pulling out my knife. I was much less composed than he was, holding the handle with both hands, shaking.
Tyler blinked. “Hm…” His priorities began shifting; I could tell by his expression. The Walkman was secondary.
Without warning, Tyler lunged forward and stabbed at me. I just managed to avoid my gut being pierced by inches. Instinctively, I punched him in the face, no coordination, no skill, just a desperate swing of my fist. He stumbled a little, looking more surprised than pained. Then he slashed again and stabbed. I felt the opening in my jacket and shirt and the blood ran down my side before I felt the sting of an open knife wound. A surface wound at most.
I began to retaliate, slashing wildly with the desperation of a wild animal backed into a corner. I left a cut on his forehead and arm, then kneed him in the gut, which he followed up with an elbow to my jaw and an attempt to stab my throat. I fell back to avoid it, and he loomed over me, preparing to bring the knife down in a theatrical arc, which I rolled out of the way to avoid, dropping the Walkman, which thankfully didn't cause it to stop recording or break. He walked past it with little interest; I was more important in that moment. That was when I realized something. Tyler was as good as any athlete at Ruby High. If he wanted, he could have easily subdued me, even gutted me. But he didn't. He just left flesh wounds, and he used his athletic prowess to make sure I only landed the same on him.
I was part of one of his productions, his “experiments”, or whatever they could be called. And he wanted to know what was going to happen, so he couldn’t murder me then and there. Not without seeing how I’d react. And now that I’d realized it, I knew that throwing my knife aside was out; he would just kill me or destroy the evidence and weave a yarn to implicate me. With a sick realization, I knew it was me or him.
He punched me in the face and cut my outer thigh, and I desperately stabbed at his side, which he used as a way to grab my arm and twist it behind my back. I cried out and dropped the knife, and he kneed me in the stomach as I had done, then he pinned me to the ground on my back. Tyler knelt over my body, bringing the blade to my throat.
An almost sorrowful expression crossed his face.
“I…” Tyler stammered, “I really did think you were my—”
My hand clenched around an anthill and I threw it in his face. He grunted as he stumbled off of me, attempting to regain his vision from the combination of dust and fire ants. This was my opening. I tackled him to the ground and began punching him in the face. I punched again and again until his nose was gushing blood and his face was covered in purple and red lumps. Then I saw it. My knife. Instinctively, I picked it up. I thought about David, Bill, Ben, everyone he had hurt. I could end it. I could finish this psychotic fuck once and for all.
Through his bruised face, I saw no fear, but I didn't see any gloating or taunts to make me kill him. It was the same look of fascination as when Ben murdered Jack: an unexpected outcome, but an interesting one. I looked from him to the knife, then back at him. He looked…puzzled. Making sure I kept him pinned, I threw away the knife. Now he just looked purely surprised.
“…Wh-why?” he rasped out.
And the answer came as easily and bitterly as anything.
“Because we’re friends.” There was no forgiveness in my tone, and there was no mocking triumph in his face. He just looked dumbstruck. With that, I pulled out my phone and called 911, continuing to pin him.
A lot of things happened after that. To sum it up, there was an extensive investigation. The Walkman helped prove that I acted in self-defense, at the very least. This was backed up by numerous interviews given to me, my classmates, and faculty including the counselor. For some reason, Tyler did not attempt to defend himself, going into detail about the sort of guy he had always been: a bona fide psychopath. It was incredible, seeing someone dismantle their own image as a model student in the way he did. I guess he figured the game was up. The coup de grâce was Tyler’s sick trophy—the broken bottle covered in blood and covered in Tyler’s fingerprints and matched the shards found at the scene of Bill’s murder. At the end of it, due to the seriousness of his crimes and using the evidence and testimony provided, the prosecution pursued the strongest possible sentence they could despite him being a teenager.
It wasn’t a triumph for me. A psychopath was now behind bars, but I had allowed him to get away with so much of his behavior. People like my parents, the counselor, and other classmates always said it wasn’t my fault, that Tyler did all of those horrible things. And maybe I wasn’t directly at fault. But it wouldn’t bring back Jack and Bill, erase Ben’s actions, or change the fact that I was friends with a monster, and I pretended he wasn't one until he decided to “try” murder.
I saw Tyler only once during his incarceration. We didn’t talk. I could barely look at him. At last, he cleared his throat and asked, “Hey, uh, Matt?”
“Yeah?” I muttered.
“Are…” he asked, sounding sheepish on the other side of the Plexiglass, “…are we still friends?”
I couldn’t answer. I just looked at him, dumbfounded.
“I-I know it’s different, and the whole fight thing made it…weird. But…well, if I get out, will we be friends?”
“…I don’t know,” I murmured, because I really had no idea what else to say.
“I’ll let you think about it. God knows I’ve got time.”
So casual and sincere, even after everything.
I didn't see him again, and I never found out if he was released or not.
The events of my junior year were a source of trauma for years, but trauma doesn’t stop time. And after the debacle involving Tyler, I moved on as best as I could with counseling and making better, healthier friendships. I graduated high school, went to college, got a job, got married, and I built a better life. My husband, Travis, knew about Tyler ever since we began dating.
Recently, he and I were just sitting on the sofa. He was talking about our plans for his mother’s birthday.
“So I’m thinking we could rent a boat, ride out on the lake,” he suggested. “How’s that? Do your mom and dad like boat rides?
I nodded. “Yeah, we always used to take rides out to watch 4th of July fireworks. I—”
I then trailed off as I noticed the date, and my face dropped.
His face, usually so chipper, turned somber.
“Right. It’s today, isn’t it?”
“27 years, Travis,” I murmured. “27 years and I still remember when I first met him.”
He nodded. “Come here, Matt,” he said softly, holding me for a while.
I didn't cry. I barely cried about Tyler. But by that point, Travis knew me well enough to know when Tyler was on my mind. He never told me to just not think about him, or to think positive; he usually didn't say anything. He just held me, just to let me know that he was there to listen, but that I never needed to explain myself to him.
Overall, life has been better since 2009.
But now and then, I look at the old K-Bar I’ve kept after all these years. I never touch it, placing it at the top of my closet. My nostrils fill with cigarette smoke. My ears fill with the drawl of Tyler’s casual cruelty. I see an empty baseball field and a bloody bottle. I think about why I have to live with this, knowing what I do about Tyler, and wondering if there was still more that I didn't know. Why, Tyler? I ask in my mind. Why did you leave me with all of this? But I know the answer. Kids are cruel, and teens are monsters, but Tyler was always special. He was one of the worst. And yet he left me with terrible memories and happy ones alike, as well as many unanswered questions because of the same reason he never tried to hurt me before that night.
Because we’re friends.