r/nommit • • Feb 04 '10

Session 1: The narwhal bacons at midnight.

2 Upvotes

I declare the first session of the parliament of Nommit to be open as of now. The theme shall be "reddit memes." I will be the Judge, and there is no Prime Minister for this session, so anyone can post the first law.

For consistency sake, remember to post your laws as "1.X: A short description" where X is the law number. If two laws are posted with the same law number, the first (chronological) constitutional law will go into effect, and the others will be marked unconstitutional.


r/nommit • • Feb 07 '17

Suggestion Rules, Metarules, & Zerocracy

0 Upvotes

As Zero State grows, we now need to develop delegation and administrative structures to deal with new challenges arising. This demand, however, raises broader philosophical issues in turn, which must be at least briefly addressed if we are to set up efficient, ethical systems. Better to get this right now, than deal endlessly with broken or unfair systems later.

I will outline three issues below, in order to fuel and focus further debate.

RULES

We are planning what is essentially an entire State judicial system, although right now we have no need for, or ability to implement such a grandiose thing. The way forward is to plan out the theoretical basis and specifications of such a system, in such a way that it is both compatible with our Principles and can be instantiated in a scalable, modular fashion. In other words we’d implement basic social network admin rules now, rolling out more sophisticated systems as they are required, but having a single consistent ethical and theoretical basis underlying the entire endeavour. I must stress that the ethical aspect is particularly important, since there is a kind of paradox at the heart of ZS: We are building a community with the aim of creating a (virtual, distributed) State, but we collectively oppose the violent excesses of traditional centralised, authoritarian States. If our State is to be ethical and decentralised, we must be careful to start as we mean to go on, balancing the various factors and ethical requirements carefully.

So let us begin. Up until now, the rules of acceptable behaviour on all ZS mailing lists, forums, and social network presences have been implicit. We will now make them explicit, starting small, and amending them as need be over time.


The following list of rules applies to all core ZS forums, mailing lists, social network presences, and physical meetings.

It is applied and amended by representatives of Project ORG-1 (Principles and Projects). Lists of officially recognised ZS admins and the procedures they follow will be listed in the Project ORG-1 section of this wiki.

RULES:

  1. Most generally we encourage behaviour (including verbal behaviour) compatible with the Zero State Principles. Active opposition to the Principles (as opposed to measured, constructive criticism) is incompatible with ZS membership, and therefore not considered acceptable in core ZS forums.

  2. We expect that all those who use ZS resources will at least seriously attempt to demonstrate respectful, polite behaviour in their use of those resources.


As mentioned above, all of this raises the question of how we derive the mandate of any given administrator to make their judgements and apply bans. I wouldn’t bother asking such high-flown philosophical questions if we were just talking about internet mailing lists, but if Zero State’s goals are achieved in future, then what we’ll have been doing here is laying the foundation stone of an entire State judicial system. That act carries a grave ethical responsibility, and must be taken seriously.

The question of how to derive the mandate for the enforcement of rules is an area I refer to as meta-rules.

META-RULES

We have said repeatedly that we want Zero State to be decentralised and democratic. Even more specifically, since the outset I have opposed an over-reliance on the mechanics of representative democracy, which actually divorces most people from decision making processes, and which therefore isn’t really democratic in any deep sense at all. The alternative, of course, is direct democracy. Direct democracy, however, is known to only work well in small groups, and completely fails in groups of over 200 people. This means that any large-scale direct democratic system must be modular, comprised of many small groups.

At this point I will begin to make a few simple, clear suggestions as to how we might move forward. At the same time, however, I must stress that this is a debate still in progress, and my suggestions are just that. As much as it is ironic, it would appear that I have to kickstart our experiment in formal democracy with a unilateral, even dictatorial act. I can accept that for the simple reason that once democratic bodies are set up, their participants can vote to change anything they want within the broad parameters of the established system.

It would appear that there are three levels of democratic mechanism currently being discussed:

  1. Small groups of citizens, spontaneously forming and self-regulating.

  2. Judgements made by groups of administrators on contentious, or non-trivial issues.

  3. A top-level democratic body which forms laws and appoints administrators.

I would suggest a system in which these three levels are connected, operating to complement each other’s functions. Any group of twenty five (or more) citizens may formally put their names to any decision, and as a matter of default it must then be respected by others. Such citizen statements could be negative (such as warnings or bans – effectively a kind of “citizen’s arrest”) or positive and constructive. If we wish to follow ancient Icelandic nomenclature, we could call these groups “Things”. Things exist only to make a formal judgement or series of judgements at one time, and then are considered dissolved. They are impermanent, by definition.

If an officially recognised administrator believes that any given judgement is inappropriate or in some way incompatible with ZS Principle, or if it is opposed by another Thing making a negating statement, then the matter goes up an administrative level. This is the level where decisions are made by administrators. Lone administrators can make routine judgements as per rules laid out by the representatives of Project ORG-1, but if the judgement is potentially contentious then a group of five administrators must reach a majority decision on the matter. Similarly, any judgement made by a lone administrator may be appealed once, in which case it must be taken before a group of five administrators.

The third democratic level is that of the senate. Any decision made by administrators (alone, or in Fives) which seems potentially inappropriate, worthy of reconsideration, or incompatible with ZS Principle may be considered by the senate. The senate is a group of exactly twenty five people who make the majority of high-level administrative decisions on behalf of Zero State. The senators are elected once a year, at the ZS AGM, held in a virtual venue on the first weekend in May. All senators must face re-election each year on exactly the same basis, but there is no limit on the number of times any person may be elected to the senate. All ZS citizens are entitled to vote in these elections. The senate would elect a spokesperson from among their number – a position which exists for the one-year life time of any given senate – whose job it is to encourage constructive, balanced debate, break ties in voting where necessary, and generally foster an attitude of productivity within the senate.

Of course, this system is both bottom-up and top-down, in that citizen group judgments, appeals and queries move up the chain via administrators to the senate, while matters of applied Principle and top-level policy decisions are passed down, through the administrators to the citizenry. It is intended that such a system would allow two-way feedback on developments in opinion which may arise anywhere within the system.

ZEROCRACY

Finally, I must note that Zero State has never been intended to be entirely democratic. Indeed, “Zerocracy” is the word we coined to describe “a kind of (true) meritocracy” balanced with direct (and limited representative) democracy. In other words, participation of the citizenry in all decisions is to be encouraged, but at the same time we value knowledge, skill, expertise and commitment, no matter who may demonstrate such virtues. We don’t want mindless mob rule on sensitive issues, which could easily undo the entire ZS project, or at very least obscure its originally intended spirit.

In order to balance merit (broadly defined) and democracy, we must also include institutions which play some part in top-level decision making, but which are not required to run their own affairs democratically. As with the whole of government relative to the citizens, the jurisdiction and influence of these institutions must be carefully circumscribed. They have a role, and their internal workings need not be democratic, but their influence can never exceed a certain level, or cross certain lines.

We cannot predict what such institutions might develop in the fullness of time, so it is better to define the limits of their total or collective influence – relative to the various democratic mechanisms already described – through the inclusion of a fourth and final administrative level. Broadly speaking, the sum of these non-democratic functional bodies should not have an influence that significantly outweighs that of the senate in making top-level decisions. This works both ways, however – an elected senate, essentially a popularist vehicle, cannot be allowed to exert undue influence over the more meritocratic aspects of ZS. Indeed, the ZS Principles make explicit our opposition to both authoritarian mob rule (e.g. aspects of Stalinism or Fundamentalism) and the excesses of uncontrolled, unaccountable Capitalism, so it would be a mistake to develop similarly unbalanced systems ourselves.

The final administrative “layer” I envisage is a committee known as “Sansad” (Sanskrit for ‘House’), which is essentially a microcosm of the entirety of ZS, and whose function it is to balance, veto, and guide the various meritocratic and democratic bodies. The decision-making powers of Sansad would be clearly delineated, with an emphasis upon passive balancing between the decisions of the other bodies, only exerting active influence over other bodies within ZS where strictly necessary and allowed by a clear jurisdiction. Sansad would have ten (and only ten) members, which might be considered grouped roughly according to three functions, as follows:

Four committee members, each representing one of the four ZS Projects. How the Projects nominate their spokespeople is entirely up to them. More generally, these four representatives would be responsible for pursuing agendas toward the further development of ZS, inspired by comments in an OWS article entitled “Six people you need to start a revolution“. In the terms of the article, the representative of Project PHI [Philosophy] would be entrusted with fostering intellectual connections and community both within and beyond ZS. The ORG [Organization] representative would handle matters of security (including anonymity & P2P decentralisation) and political activism (given that the two issues seem increasingly interrelated). The RES [Resources] representative would speak to issues of “sympathetic elites” and “insiders” as described in the article. The MED [Media] representative would be responsible for developing a community of artists, musicians, gamers and subculture enthusiasts in order to communicate ZS ideas to as large a proportion of the general population as possible.

A second group of three committee members would represent TETRAD and the ZS Affiliated Organizations – (1) The Praxis and (2) Consensus (with Zero State Media effectively represented by the Project MED spokesperson) – and (3) a Diplomatic Corps tasked with maintaining good, constructive relationships with friendly organizations of various types.

The final three committee members would be the spokesperson for the Senate (elected from within the senate at the beginning of each May), a spokesperson for all remaining meritocratic Institutions which may arise within ZS over time (elected from or appointed by the leaders of those Institutions), and myself in my capacity as Founder of ZS. I reserve the right to maintain a place on this committee, because I strongly feel that it is important that the original tone, spirit, and intent of ZS is safeguarded from “mission drift”. It is possible that after some time I would choose to no longer sit on the committee, but in that case I would be replaced by a “Founder’s representative” to continue the role of safeguarding the original spirit and intent of ZS.

The development of a clear jurisdiction for all of the bodies described above is clearly very important, and as a first step in that direction I would recommend that no single person can simultaneously hold two positions in any of the bodies described in this post. For example, no member of Sansad could be elected to the senate, senators could not also be administrators during their term of office, and none of the above may be allowed to count among the 25 people in a spontaneous citizen’s group during their term of office.


r/nommit • • Sep 04 '13

Round News Round 3-2 Results

0 Upvotes

354 - proposed by /u/Ienpw_III

Transmute 111.

I think mutable rules should be able to take precedence over immutable rules if they explicitly state so.

For: /u/Nichdel, /u/Ienpw_III

Against: /u/VorpalAuroch

FAILS


355 - OOPS - proposed by /u/Ienpw_III

Append to 342:

Such proposals count as a single rule-change (of the highest-scoring type among the rule-changes that comprise the proposal) in relation to points.

For: /u/VorpalAuroch

Against: /u/Nichdel, /u/Ienpw_III

FAILS


356 - Nommitian Central Bank - proposed by /u/Ienpw_III

Add a new rule:

There exists a Nommitian Central Bank (NCB) which holds all points not held by players. The total of all players' points plus the number in the NCB's reserves equals the Money Supply.

The Treasurer is a cabinet position. The Treasurer may create or destroy any number of points in the NCB's reserves.

Amend 351 by adding:

Unless otherwise explicitly stated, it is impossible to reduce the NCB reserves or any player's points below 0.

For: /u/Nichdel, /u/Ienpw_III

Against: /u/VorpalAuroch

PASSES


357 - The determination of a non-legislative, reactionary judicial system act - proposed by /u/Ienpw_III

Add, to the end of rule 347, "Calls for judgement should not be used to attempt to bypass the legislative process."

For: /u/VorpalAuroch, /u/Ienpw_III

Against: /u/Nichdel

PASSES


358 - Rules about Rules That Make Sense - proposed by /u/Nichdel

Repeal 342

Because I'm going to integrate omnibuses below

Amend 105

replace:

A rule change is any of the following: (1) the enactment, repeal, or amendment of a mutable rule; or (2) the transmutation of an immutable rule into a mutable rule or vice versa. (Note: This definition implies that, at least initially, all new rules are mutable; immutable rules, as long as they are immutable, may not be amended or repealed; mutable rules, as long as they are mutable, may be amended or repealed; any rule of any status may be transmuted; no rule is absolutely immune to change.)

with:

Any of the following are rule changes: (1) the enactment, repeal, or amendment of a mutable rule; or (2) the transmutation of an immutable rule into a mutable rule or vice versa. An omnibus is a collection of related rule changes.

Bam, simple omnibuses.

Amend 109

replace:

The Speaker shall give each proposed rule change a number for reference. The numbers shall begin with 301, and each rule change proposed in the proper way shall receive the next successive integer, whether or not the proposal is adopted. In an omnibus proposal, each rule change receives its own number.

with:

The Speaker shall give each proposed rule change a number for reference. Each rule change (including those in an omnibus) proposed in the proper way shall receive the next successive integer.

Omnibuses get numbered individually

Amend 305

replace:

When a proposed new rule or transmutation is passed, the proposer gains 5 points. When a proposed amendment or repeal is passed, the proposer gains 10 points. Anyone who votes against any proposal that passes gains 5 points. If a proposal fails with 0 FOR votes, the proposer loses 5 points.

with:

When a proposal passes and DOES NOT create a new rule, the proposer gains 10 points. When a proposal passes and DOES create a new rule, the proposer gains 5 points. Anyone who votes against any proposal that passes gains 5 points.

Omnibuses are a single proposal, so they still only get 5 or 10 points. Also reworded this a bit.

For: /u/Nichdel

Against: /u/VorpalAuroch

FAILS


359 - proposed by /u/Nichdel

Add rule:

This is a small scam.

Nichdel gains exactly

seven hundred points.

For: /u/Nichdel

Against: /u/VorpalAuroch

FAILS

Speaker's note: Nichdel instructed me to submit as many extra votes as he was allowed to; this turned out to be 0. This would not have passed anyway; the second line is 6 syllables.


360 - proposed by /u/Nichdel

AMEND 329

replace:

Players found by judgement to have broken a rule are subject to the following penalties:

  • Their points shall be reduced by five.

with:

Crimes fit a specific category and have at least 1 criminal trait. A criminal is someone found guilty of a crime.

The following are criminal traits:

  • Intent - The criminal wanted to do it, or something that would intuitively lead to it.

  • Harmfulness - It was destructive to collective play, or an individual's attempt at play.

  • Planning - The criminal expressed intent to do so or went through the steps necessary to prepare.

The following are categories of crime:

  • Gamestate Tampering - Changing the rule set, player set, or other necessary game information to contain false information (or lack true information).

  • Harming The Community - Disobeying the rules of reddit or the reddiquette (except for the parts pertaining to voting) within /r/nommit.

  • Gumming The Works - Making meaningless or excessive proposals with no intent for them to pass. Making meaningless or excessive Calls For Judgement with no actual dispute or confusion on the matter.

  • Abusing Power - Making blatantly incorrect Judgements, blatantly excessive or illegal punishment, or using power maliciously. This DOES NOT include using power in an attempt to win, unless the attempt is otherwise illegal.

  • Multiple Jeopardy - Making multiple Calls for Judgement against a player for the exact same alleged instance of a crime, or making multiple blatantly false accusations of crime against a particular player.

The following are legal punishments for crimes with all traits:

  • SUSPENSION FOR X DAYS - Where 7 < X < 31.

  • BANISHMENT - The criminal is no longer a player.

  • LOSE X POINTS - Where 0 < X < 101.

  • LOSE 1 ELDER POINT

The following are legal punishments for crime with 2 or more traits:

  • SUSPENSION FOR X DAYS - The criminal is unable to make game actions for X days, where X < 8.

  • LOSE X POINTS - Where X is between 0 and the amount of points the criminal made in the last 2 rounds.

The following are legal punishments for any crime:

  • LOSE X POINTS - Where X is between 0 and the amount of points the criminal made in the last round.

A crime is determined to be so by a Call For Judgement of the form "PLAYER has committed the crime of CRIME" with arguments that attempt to establish that PLAYER has indeed committed a crime and establish which traits are shown.

If the Judge finds the CFJ TRUE, the Judge should also include their decision on how many traits the crime shows and a statement of the form "PLAYER is sentenced to PUNISHMENT," which shall have legal effect to carry out PUNISHMENT on the player. Only one punishment can be assigned per crime.

A crime can be revisited and the judgement can be reversed, but only within 2 rounds AND the same game of the original Call For Judgement. This starts with a Call For Judgement of the form "PLAYER is innocent of CFJ," where CFJ is the Call For Judgement PLAYER was found guilty in.

All points lost from a punishment go to the NCB. All points returned from a reversal are taken from the NCB.

For: /u/Nichdel

Against: /u/VorpalAuroch

FAILS


361 - proposed by /u/VorpalAuroch

Amend 203:

In order to slow down points-based wins (which as I demonstrated can be very rapid with the current submission density), change

A player may win via a) having 100 positive points, b) discovering a paradox in the rules, or c) discovering that play has become impossible.

to

A player may win via a) having 500 positive points, b) discovering a paradox in the rules, or c) discovering that play has become impossible.

For: /u/Nichdel, /u/VorpalAuroch, /u/Ienpw_III

Against:

PASSES


362 - Another Exercise in Thematic Reasoning - proposed by /u/VorpalAuroch

Each game of nommit shall have an official Theme, which shall be decided by the Speaker with 2|2 Elder Support before the game is started.

The game's Theme SHOULD be noted in the subreddit sidebar.

For: /u/Nichdel, /u/VorpalAuroch

Against: /u/Ienpw_III

PASSES


Points:


/u/comex has been deregistered for inactivity.


r/nommit • • Sep 03 '13

CFJ: UNDECIDED CFJ 3-2

0 Upvotes

A game of nommit that is considered to be over by all players of it, is over whether or not it ended in a legal way (per the rules).


r/nommit • • Dec 03 '16

Moot request: sficht

0 Upvotes

As of now /u/sflicht has three open proposals in violation of rule 206. Since the most important rule 101 states "All players must always abide by all the rules in effect." and /u/sflicht did not abide by rule 206. My interpretation of rule 101 is that /u/sflicht is therefore no longer a player and loses all rights given to players by subsequent rules.

Edit: corrected username misspelling.

Edit: Also the term "open proposal" in rule 206 needs clarifying.


r/nommit • • Dec 02 '16

Invalid Proposal [Proposal] - The submitter of a proposal's vote shall not count

0 Upvotes

Pretty simple one here, could protect against silly rules getting through if there is a lull in participation.


r/nommit • • Dec 02 '16

Invalid Proposal [Proposal] Rule enforcement

0 Upvotes

I propose enacting a new rule with the following text:

Whenever a player finds another player to be in violation of any rule the accusing player may make a post tagged [Dispute] at the beginning of the title. This post must detail the player that is found in violation of the rules, a listing of which actions of the player are found to be in violation of which rules, and if necessary a detailed reasoning why that would be the case.

This dispute post will be voted on according to the same rules as rule-change proposals except that neither the accusing player nor the accused player are allowed to vote. If the dispute passes according to these rules the accused player will be officially recognized as being in violation of the rules. If, however, the dispute post does not pass according to the rules of voting the accusing player shall be recognized as being in violation of the rules.

The Secretary will record the result on a wiki page that shall be linked to on the side.

If any player is recognized as being in violation of the rules on three different occasions that reddit user shall from that point on no longer be regarded as player and lose all rights the rules grant to players.


r/nommit • • Dec 08 '16

Invalid Proposal [Proposal][Amendmend] Dynasty specific rules

0 Upvotes

EDIT: Withdrawn! This is a really bad idea. Any Dynasty could just make a rule that they won and nobody could stop them.

I propose amending rule 103 to add a subclause that reads:

Players that are members of a dynasty may make dynasty specific rules. These rules must have the tag [Dynasty] in their title in addition to all other demanded formalities. Dynasty specific rules only apply to members of the same dynasty as the proposing player had when proposing the rule. A player may not leave his dynasty while he has open dynasty specific rule-change proposals. Eligible voters on dynasty specific rule-change proposals are only the subset of eligible voters as determined by all other applicable rules that are also member of the same dynasty when the voting period ends. The founder of this dynasty has a veto right during the voting period. If the founder comments with a single "veto" (case insensitive) in the first line, the proposal will fail immediately. Dynasty specific rules that have passed will be tagged with the name of the Dynasty to which they apply in the wiki. Amendment and repeal proposals may only be made by members of the same dynasty.


r/nommit • • Dec 10 '16

Did Not Pass [Proposal][Enactment] removal of dynasty points

0 Upvotes

A Dynasty will have one point removed from it every time a member of said dynasty make a failed proposal


r/nommit • • Dec 02 '16

Invalid Proposal [Proposal] - Only active players can create proposals

0 Upvotes

For a player to create a proposal, they must be an active player. To be considered active they must meet the following 2 criteria:

  1. A player is active if they have voted on a proposal on at least twice, 24h apart, in the preceding week (defined as the previous 168h), not including the current date (defined as 24h before the post has been made) OR have voted on 2 of the most recent 10 proposals regardless of when those votes occurred.

  2. They have voted on a proposal at least once more than 2 weeks (defined as 336h) prior to the date of their new proposal OR voted on any proposal during the month of November 2016.

Any proposal created by an inactive player should be immediately closed with a citation of this rule.


r/nommit • • Dec 02 '16

Invalid Proposal [Proposal] - Only active players may vote - V2

0 Upvotes

For a player to create a proposal, they must be an active player. To be considered active they must meet the following 2 criteria:

  1. A player is active if they have voted on a proposal on at least twice, 24h apart, in the preceding week (defined as the previous 168h), not including the current date (defined as 24h before the post has been made) OR have voted on 2 of the most recent 10 proposals regardless of when those votes occurred.

  2. They have voted on a proposal at least once more than 2 weeks (defined as 336h) prior to the date of their new proposal OR voted on any proposal during the month of November 2016.

Any proposal created by an inactive player should be immediately closed with a citation of this rule.


r/nommit • • Dec 02 '16

Invalid Proposal rule enforced fun

0 Upvotes

How about changing 101 to say: 'All players must always abide by all the rules that they think are fun. :-)' ?

So if someone passes rule 100 'i win, and everyone has to stop playing', I don't have to abide by this because I don't think that's fun, so I keep on playing.


r/nommit • • Nov 30 '16

Did Not Pass Proposed Rule: /u/veganzombeh will not change rules, or instigate new rules, on a Tuesday or a Thursday.

1 Upvotes

r/nommit • • Nov 30 '16

Did Not Pass Proposed Rule: All future rules shall be written in the Georgian alphabet

1 Upvotes

r/nommit • • Dec 09 '16

Did Not Pass [Proposal][Enactment] The Elected Role of CSS Manager

1 Upvotes

This rule would create the elected position of the CSS Manager.

The CSS Manager's job would to be edit the CSS if a rule is added that changes the CSS (like the rule I made that disables downvotes).

The CSS Manager has the final say on if these changes actually go through, so long as the voted rule has over 50% aye votes.


r/nommit • • Mar 01 '10

Session 2: Droids and Dragons

1 Upvotes

Session 2 has started since it is past midnight in GMT. After the Prime Minister makes the first law, other ministers will be able to jump right in. I'll keep the Summary/Active ministers list below. The theme is "SciFi vs Fantasy."

For consistency sake, remember to post your laws as "2.X: A short description" where X is the law number. If two laws are posted with the same law number, the first (chronological) constitutional law will go into effect, and the others will be marked unconstitutional.


r/nommit • • Feb 09 '10

1.20: TUNGSTEN_MAN wins round 1 act

1 Upvotes

1.20: TUNGSTEN_MAN wins round 1


r/nommit • • Feb 13 '10

1.36: Thar sh-blows

1 Upvotes

Narwhals can vomit words into laws following all laws that it chows down upon.


r/nommit • • Feb 27 '10

Session 2 Call to Arms

1 Upvotes

If there is enough ministers to warrant it, I'd like to start up Session 2 on Monday. The theme for this session will be "SciFi vs Fantasy." (Take that as you will.)

If you would like to join, please post under this call to arms. Session 2 will start Monday if at least 4 ministers are interested. Any other players may join in the first week, and their activity time will start from the beginning of the session. After the first week, no new players may join.

So post away if you would like to join. If Blaidd_Dwrg is playing, he gets the privilege of Prime Minister and gets to post the first law.


r/nommit • • Feb 18 '10

End of Session 1

1 Upvotes

It appears to me (and correct me if I'm wrong) that I am the sole remaining active minister and due to Article 6 this should close session 1. It seems like things died down in the last few days, so I don't know if there's still any interest in continuing onto another session.


r/nommit • • Feb 09 '10

Notes from the Judge

1 Upvotes

Hey, just posting some things here.

  1. Sorry if I can't get to judging a law all that quickly. I have a new, big project at work, so I need to focus on that.

  2. I will be giving bonus style points for laws that add restrictions to future laws (like 1.18), or introduce win/lose conditions that are not overly specific (no "ungood wins" laws).

  3. I finished a google chrome extension. It aids judges in marking a post as valid, invalid, proposal, and aids in getting the post date of a post. This makes judging much easier and less tedious :) Here it is.


r/nommit • • Jun 14 '13

Round News Round 2 Call For Votes and Discussion

1 Upvotes

As last time, message me your votes. Quorum is 3 people.

Proposals

305 by /u/VorpalAuroch (Simple Majority)

Name: Proposal Encouragement and Stabilization Act

Proposal: Amend Rule 211 to

Voters who voted against proposals which are adopted receive 10 points apiece. Players whose proposals are adopted shall receive 5 points.

306 by /u/Ienpw_III (Simple Majority)

Name: An Act to Strengthen Nommit 2's Nomic Tradition and Heritage

Short title: Paradox Act

Proposal: Add the following to the end of rule 203:

If a player discovers a paradox in the ruleset that player wins as above.

307 by /u/schoolmonkey (Unanimous)

Proposal: Rule 112 be made mutable.

No CFJs

Discuss whatever you want in the comments.


r/nommit • • Aug 13 '13

CFJ: TRUE CFJ C4

1 Upvotes

I ask for judgement on the following:

All rules that are part of the current ruleset are 'in effect.'


r/nommit • • Aug 13 '13

CFJ: FALSE CFJ C3: Initial Set

1 Upvotes

I call for judgment of the statement

The initial rules of this game are these.

The judge is /u/Ienpw_III


r/nommit • • Aug 12 '13

CFJ: FALSE CFJ C1: Initial Rules

1 Upvotes

Judgment on the statement

The Initial Rules, as used by Rule 343, are those listed in the Initial Rules section of this page, whether or not those rules are currently in force.

Randomly-Selected Judge: /u/Nichdel