r/noir • Noir Fan • Oct 15 '25

Winter commute

Post image
2.2k Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

4

u/allmimsyburogrove Oct 16 '25

Yep that's noir

3

u/sniffedalot Oct 16 '25

I would say there is nothing noir about it except for the format of the photo.

2

u/Upstairs_Drive_5602 Noir Fan Oct 19 '25

Others seem to disagree, but that's fair enough. You could have just downvoted the post and scrolled on. I'd say there was more to "Noir" than 1930s guys with hats and guns lurking in smoky alleyways.

2

u/sniffedalot Oct 19 '25

It's a good photo, it's just not 'noir' which means to me that there is something foreboding in it and noir is usually associated with crime, and detectives.

1

u/Upstairs_Drive_5602 Noir Fan Oct 19 '25

There is no narrative . . . yet, but surely there could be one with a sense of mysterious foreboding.

Let's imagine that the girl on the streetcar isn’t going home; she’s going back, back to the grimy downtown office where she left the envelope she shouldn’t have opened. The snow muffles the city, but not the thoughts running through her head. We don't know exactly where she worked, though the man she worked for liked to call her “his eyes and ears.” His name is on every file she shouldn’t have seen . . .

4

u/UK_Max Oct 15 '25

Perfect

1

u/taylordthegreat Oct 16 '25

Hmmm it’s a cool image, but based on the amount of misplaced grain, dust, and snow in the shadows, I’m gonna call this AI. OP, can you confirm that this is an actual photo? Where did you find it?

1

u/Upstairs_Drive_5602 Noir Fan Oct 18 '25

I get this all the time and I must say that it annoys the hell out of me. If a photo ever is AI - or AI enhanced - I'm totally unaware of it. I simply post things I find elsewhere that seem to me appealing. Who knows what processes the original photographer might have used and frankly, does it really matter? Either you like an image or you don't.

1

u/taylordthegreat Oct 16 '25

I’ll answer myself here- it’s a photo! Taken by Kevin Nkrumah, an incredible photographer

1

u/anrasparklerhouse Oct 17 '25

Lovely window sight shot. I’m in a good mood for more! Nostalgic vibes.

2

u/Upstairs_Drive_5602 Noir Fan Oct 17 '25

It's good to receive a friendly comment. So thank you for that! I'd posted something else (now deleted) and I was greeted by shouts of "AI slop" etc. Not very encouraging.

3

u/Thoth1024 Oct 15 '25

Fantastic!

So atmospheric!

3

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '25

Beautiful.

2

u/MeanCat4 Oct 16 '25

Beautiful photo! 

2

u/Awkward_Daikon_992 Oct 16 '25

Ah, those were the days.

1

u/espexporerguy Oct 16 '25

I wish I had a pic like that from my younger years...

1

u/Legitimate-Koala-373 Oct 16 '25

Poignant and mysterious and beautiful

1

u/geri73 Oct 16 '25

I love this.

1

u/FinancialLunch5749 Oct 17 '25

I love this borderline historical style, it looks like Robert Dooisneau 🤩

1

u/Baz_123 Oct 17 '25

She looks as if she's deep in thought. Possibly sad, possibly thinking of what to do about it. She's breathtakingly beautiful.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '25

She's sad, leaving town, no money, hoping to find comfort somewhere warm and sunny.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '25

That’s so dramatic

1

u/matfralo Nov 02 '25

AI is bs for photography :(