r/njbeer • u/YoTeach68 • Sep 19 '25
r/njbeer • u/YoTeach68 • Jul 18 '26
Picture My girlfriend and I have official been to 100 NJ breweries
It’s a fun hobby because it gets us to all corners of the Garden State and we’ve met some fun people at each place.
Our goal is to hit every brewery in NJ within the next few years. Here’s the list of the places we’ve hit so far. We live just outside of Philly so it’s quite South Jersey centric.
1 Kings Road - Haddonfield
2 Devils Creek (CLOSED)
3 Tonewood - Oaklyn
4 Red White and Brew (CLOSED)
5 Westville Brewing Company
6 Tonewood - Barrington
7 Hidden Sands
8 Somers Point Brewing Company
9 Mechanical
10 Spellbound
11 Third State (CLOSED)
12 Lunacy (CLOSED)
13 Dr. Brewlittle’s
14 Tuckahoe (CLOSED)
15 Bonesaw - Glassboro
16 Eclipse
17 Swedesboro brewing company
18 Zed’s
19 Bout the Hops
20 Death of the Fox
21 Ludlam Island Brewery
22 Slack Tide Brewery
23 Bucket Brigade Brewery (CLOSED)
24 Lower Forge Brewery
25 Farm Truck Brewing Company - Medford
26 Eight and Sand
27 Forgotten Boardwalk (CLOSED)
28 Tanner Brewing Company
29 Double Nickel Brewing
30 Flying Fish Brewing Company (CLOSED)
31 Kelly Green Brewing Company (CLOSED)
32 Neck of the Woods Brewing
33 7 Mile Brewery (CLOSED)
34 Cape May Brewing Company
35 Gusto Brewing Company
36 Cold Spring Brewery
37 Behr Brewing Company
38 Buttzville Brewing (CLOSED)
39 Stratosphere Brewing Company
40 Tindall Road Brewing Company
41 Chimney Rustic Ales (MOVED TO PHILLY)
42 Vinyl Brewing Company (CLOSED)
43 Three 3’s Brewing Company
44 Berlin Brewing Company
45 Whims Brewing
46 Brewery Thirty-Three
47 Lost Elephant Brewing Company
48 Core3 Brewery
49 Farmers and Bankers Brewing
50 Screamin’ Hill Beer Farm
51 13th Child Brewery
52 Ghost Hawk Brewing Company
53 Swedesboro Brewing Co Raccoon Taproom
54 Pinelands Brewing Company
55 The Seed: A Living Beer Project
56 Garden State Beer Company
57 Glasstown Brewing Company
58 Kings Road - Medford
59 Bent Iron Brewery
60 Old Hights Brewing Company
61 Axe and Arrow
62 Icarus Brewing
63 Frye Brewing (CLOSED)
64 Fox House Brewing (CLOSED)
65 Buena Connection
66 Oyster Creek Brewing Company
67 ManaFirkin Brewing Company
68 Twin Lights
69 Bradley Brew Project
70 Seven Sons Brewing
71 Meyers Lighthouse Brewing Company
72 Magnify - Medford
73 Toms River Brewing
74 Battle River Brewing
75 Obscura Brewing
76 Whale Tale Brewing Company
77 MudHen Brewing Company
78 Anglesea Aleworks
79 Riverhorse Brewing Co
80 the Druery Brewery
81 Needle Creek Farm Brewery
82 Raccoon Pub House - Burlington
83 Bullhide Brewery
84 Sons of Barley Beer Company
85 Oakflower
86 Autodidact
87 Angry Erik Brewing
88 Alias Brew Works
89 Glenbrook Brewery
90 Booter Beer Brewing Company
91 Bonesaw Pilot House (Deptford Mall)
92 Hackensack Brewing Company
93 Village Idiot Brewing Company
94 Odd Bird Brewing
95 Invertase Brewing Company
96 Bakes Brewing Company
97 Wild Air Beerworks
98 Belford Brewing Company
99 Skinny Flowers Brewing
100 Kane Brewing
r/njbeer • u/redascot • Jul 07 '22
Picture Read about ABC's ridiculous brewery regulations. Got angry. Wrote my state reps.
r/njbeer • u/caesar____augustus • Aug 16 '22
Article New Jersey bills aim to repeal new brewery restrictions following outrage from owners
r/njbeer • u/StriderTB • Jun 12 '22
Review If you're down in Cape May, avoid 7 Mile Brewing. Just had the worst experience.
My girlfriend and I had just left Behr Brewing after checking 7 Mile s menu online. She wanted a flight, so we show up and fill out a card. When she handed it to the bartender, this woman started putting on a show and loudly announcing to the bar that 2 of the 4 beers were not available in flights. This wasn't mentioned on their online menu, just in tiny print buried in their menu board descriptions at the bar. That's fine, we could have just picked others, but who thinks that loudly mocking us to the entire bar is a normal response?
So now my girlfriend is thinking and looking for something else on the menu, and this boomer lady starts yelling to a table of teachers. "HEY TEACHERS! These two can't read, they picked 2 out of 4 that are no flights, can you help them?"
At this point I'm done. I turn to my girlfriend and we both get up. The bartender looks at me and says NO, come on! I tell her we're done and turn for the door. As we open it she yells from the bar "BYEEEEE!"
What the fuck is that about? Who acts like this? I've been going there for years, my family has a shore house nearby. If her reaction is because so many people order unavailable beers in flights, maybe fix your fucking menu board?
There are plenty of other excellent breweries minutes from there. If you're down near Cape May check them out, but skip this place, unless you get off on shitty service.
r/njbeer • u/swellsnj • Jul 02 '22
Discussion I think it may be time for change. Do you?
r/njbeer • u/Upper-Tour-9564 • Feb 11 '25
Brewery News Thank you, Icarus! (21+ only hours starting March 1)
Honestly, it's refreshing to see a brewery prioritize actual patrons and not people who take up whole tables with their kids on iPads, have 1 beer, and then sit on their phones ignoring their kids for 3 hours.
r/njbeer • u/SuperCat_ • Jul 01 '22
Picture Back of new T-Shirt from Lucky Bones in Cape May. Front says "Drink NJ Beer"
r/njbeer • u/fightinforphilly • Jan 11 '21
Misc. NJ Craft Brewery Experience Starter Pack
r/njbeer • u/thegoodnamesrgone123 • Mar 12 '25
Article Study Shows Birthrate Decline Linked to Prevalence of Other People’s Children at Breweries
r/njbeer • u/IcarusBrewing • May 23 '24
Event Planning our Soft Opening
Hopefully in the final stages of getting our ABC Permits and planning our Soft Openings for next Month (Grand Opening mid July). Would love to get /r/njbeer members invited to a private soft opening as a thank you to this sub for the years of support, especially to /u/MattyBlayze /u/8ate8 and /u/eastcoasterman for everything they do to keep this place vibrant and somewhat non-toxic.
I'll work on getting something more official (I'm sure google suite has something for this) but for now would love to just see who would be interested in checking out our new spot in Brick before we offiically open the doors to the public.
Update: Check your PM, Invites are sent, and if you're missing it shoot us a PM here.
r/njbeer • u/TTroncone • Jul 11 '22
Discussion The Special Ruling
Only four states are home to fewer breweries per capita than New Jersey — Louisiana, Mississippi, Alabama and Utah.
Why?
Why would a wealthy, densely populated state in the heart of the craft-loving northeast, one with a rich brewing tradition and fervent beer fans, fail miserably at capitalizing on the brewery boom in this part of the country?
Ask yourself that question, and then ask the political party in power about their choking brewery regulations, and what’s really behind the rules. Because everyone’s full-throated roars are needed ahead of statewide elections next year.
Just so we’re clear about where we stand today, and for anyone not aware: A long-delayed attack on New Jersey breweries is underway after an uneasy respite from the siege. It stems from a 2019 Special Ruling by the state that set strict guidelines for breweries, but was loosely enforced in the time since. That changed on July 1.
As progressive as many of us may be personally, we can’t avoid the fact that the mercenaries outside our gates fly the banner of the Democratic Party, are armed with the sword of state regulation and were sent into battle on behalf of a powerful lobby.
That’s the reality in the insane mesh of arcane, head-spinning liquor laws in New Jersey. These laws are fossils of Prohibition, and they spit on the memory of New Jersey’s brewing history, when the state’s brewery and pub landscape thrived, spurred on by an influx of European immigrants. Newark alone was home to a staggering number of breweries.
I’ve stayed as removed as possible from the behind-the-scenes regulatory battles of the New Jersey craft beer industry in the three years since we first poured a wild ale at the northernmost brewery in the state. I’ve mostly sat on the sidelines while groups representing the interests of New Jersey breweries fought the good fight against the dark hole of this state’s regressive alcohol regulations, and on behalf of a vision of a vibrant, growing beer culture in New Jersey. Growth that would help the entire alcohol industry in the Garden State. Growth that certain industry groups plagued by shortsightedness fail to contextually appreciate.
So I took a break from processing the 1,320 pounds of fresh berries that I picked up from a family farm in Hammonton to address the newly-enforced Special Ruling, parts of which, quite plainly, form an unconstitutional abridging of protected commercial speech.
Case law is clear on content-based speech restrictions, such as the one in the ruling that limits how often I can post to social media which European football matches will appear on the television at the brewery. Once I mention any specific match, the ABC treats its very airing as an event, demands notification, and limits me to 25 such events each year.
This and other content-based speech restrictions clearly run afoul of US Supreme Court rulings on commercial speech.
Closer to home, just in 2018, a New Jersey district court struck down another state curb on commercial speech, one that barred establishments from advertising BYOB. It based its decision on numerous Supreme Court cases regarding content-based abridging of commercial speech. You can read the full decision and citations here https://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=13040077759340119755&q=gjjm+enterprises+v+atlantic+city&hl=en&as_sdt=3,33
Essentially, the Supreme Court holds that governments must pass a legal test to permit the regulation of non-misleading commercial speech concerning a lawful activity. It must show a substantial interest in regulating the speech and prove that the regulation is no more extensive than necessary to serve that interest.
The rules limiting New Jersey breweries’ ability to advertise and promote lawful activities, like the fact that a food truck is legally parked in public at their curb, fail this test, and fail it miserably.
Let’s dive further down the rabbit hole.
I can legally sell you a cold pretzel, but not a hot one. I can legally mount televisions, but no more than two of them, and they better not measure a centimeter larger than 65 inches from corner-to-corner. I cannot legally make you hot beer in the winter and add cinnamon to it — you have to add the cinnamon after I pour it. I think?
If I’m a brewery on Main Street, I can’t post which food truck is legally parked outside the brewery, even if I played no role in its presence, nor can I suggest to a food truck owner that they park on Main Street outside the brewery. Yes, let’s be clear, this Special Ruling goes so far as to restrict the content of the conversations that one small business owner can have with another small business owner, and limits the conversation that a business owner can have with the public.
Breweries like mine, sited on large swaths of private property, carry an even greater — and unequal — burden when it comes to the issue of food trucks, because there is no Main Street in our parking lot. A food truck would need permission from the owner of our property to park in the large common parking area. Again, I can’t facilitate that by suggesting it to the owner of the complex. Or let anyone know the truck is parked in the lot. That’s how restrictive this new ruling is on speech.
Oh, if someone plugs a guitar into an amplifier or sings through a microphone at my brewery, I am legally obligated to notify the ABC. I literally have to tell the state if someone is playing an electric piano in my brewery. And it counts as one of my 25 events.
Similarly, the method of serving some wild beers, served for centuries in Europe, is expressly forbidden under our state laws. Take a Berliner Weisse, a tart wild ale traditionally served in Germany with one of two syrups — red raspberry or green woodruff — added to the finished beer at serving.
This is illegal in New Jersey.
Do you like beer slushies? Well, they are illegal if any flavoring or juice is added to the beer when it goes into the slushy machine. This is a new point of emphasis by the state this license term, printed on our licenses, most likely spurred on by the powerful New Jersey Restaurant and Hospitality lobby.
I would go as far as to submit that it would be reasonable to believe that the entire Special Ruling runs contrary to state law in that it is crafted clearly in favor of one industry over another, imposing taxes by way of fees, as well as myriad restrictions, that it does not impose on similar industries.
Let’s also be clear on this: The rank-and-file public servants in the ABC are not to blame for any of this. They are government employees just trying to get through life, and deserve none of our anger. That should be reserved for the political appointees and the political interests they are truly serving.
In recent months, I’ve been seeking a second location, where I hope to launch a Muckraker Lager & Ale House. If I’m being completely candid, since the state announced that the restrictions on breweries would go into effect on July 1, I’ve begun to seriously rethink whether I should remain in this state. So I’ve decided to expand my search to include the rich agricultural area north of the imaginary line we know as the New York border.
If my brewery was located across that imaginary line 12 miles to my north, and I used in-state ingredients, New York would consider my brewery a “farm brewery,” even if it was situated in a strip mall, or behind my house.. That designation would mean I could make beer and cider, and rather easily add a mead license. I could sell any of the great beer, wine, cider, mead or hard liquor made in the state of New York. As if that isn’t enough, I could open satellite tasting rooms across the state to sell my beer.
Back here in New Jersey, I can only sell my beer where I make it. In other words, if I opened a second location, beer could not be shared among the locations. That’s because…I really don’t know why. It’s just the law? That seems to be the “reason” I’m given more times than you’d imagine.
In New York, even breweries that are not considered farm breweries can make stone-fired pizzas, barbecue or other food, and hold an unlimited number of parties and music events. The laws are similar in Pennsylvania, and both states seem poised to capitalize on New Jersey’s backwardness on liquor laws. Pennsylvania, for instance, appears to be actively courting existing or in-planning New Jersey breweries.
The Drowned Lands, Tin Barn and Shepherd’s Eye have all opened in Orange County, NY, in the three years since we poured our first wild ale. Destination Unknown Brewing Co. of Long Island, just opened Dubco Acres on a large farm in Warwick. My friends at the Oasis (aka Snufftown Hop Farm) are in the process of opening a farm brewery with a full disc golf course. Other breweries in Orange County have expanded and grown, and more are on the way.
The stifling rules of the state of New Jersey are putting my brewery at a competitive disadvantage, and are probably a big reason why you don’t see more breweries here in Sussex County, a place were an agribusiness like a farm brewery could thrive.
When we opened, we committed to becoming part of a larger agricultural ecosystem, one that prizes fresh, local ingredients above style, above trends. Nearly 100 percent of the beers we’ve produced owe their backbones to barley and wheat grown at Rabbit Hill Farms, a former potato farm in Shiloh, N.J., that transformed itself into a thriving malt house as New Jersey’s craft brewing scene grew. Today, our friends at Rabbit Hill win prestigious national awards for their grain.
Just this past week, I made the first of what will be several trips down to Pastore Orchards in Hammonton, the blueberry capital of the world, to bring back more than a half-ton of the prized New Jersey highbush blueberry, and of our equally beautiful blackberries. I make trips to Cumberland County for peaches and nectarines, to Morris County for strawberries, anywhere I can get my hands on fresh fruit to use in our beer. My spent grain feeds local cows.
And this cuts to the real tragedy, beyond the restrictions that are on their face ludicrous, and at their core, sinister, lies the death of the-what-could-be. What could a thriving, healthy beer culture look like in New Jersey, and which agricultural businesses could it lift?
Before we can think about that, we have to unpack the tired argument, altogether specious, that I’ve heard ad nauseum: “Bars pay hundreds of thousands of dollars for liquor licenses. Breweries want to act like bars without having to buy a liquor license.”
This is nonsense.
Even a small brewery like mine producing fewer than 150 barrels of beer each year will spend hundreds of thousands of dollars on equipment. A larger brewery build-out can push well into seven figures. And we can only sell the beer we brew. If my brewery fails, I can’t even sell my license.
The thousands of liquor license owners in New Jersey can sell any alcohol on the planet that is legally distributed in the state. That’s the whole point of the license. Or, If they want, or their business fails, they can just put the license in their pocket as an investment. They can sell it for a profit. They can put it in their will. They own it forever.
Also, as a practical matter, my brewery, or any of the 140 or so in New Jersey, selling charcuterie, or hosting a weekly food truck, would do no more to hurt the thousands of liquor license holders than a burrito joint opening down the block from any one of them. No law or regulation stops that. If a liquor license holder owns a pizzeria, 97 other pizzerias could open in the same town, they are not protected from that. Their liquor license grants them a monopoly on the retail consumption of distributed beer, wine and hard liquor, not on the sale of food.
Look, I love pubs. But this straw man argument has been used a cudgel by bars and restaurants who refuse to modernize their beer lineups to bring them in line with what the public craves. The hatred towards breweries is so deep in some corners of the hospitality lobby that a prominent bar owner in that group stubbornly refuses to sell New Jersey-made beer on his lines.
To succeed, pubs should look to the successful beer bars in the state, the ones that build relationships with brewers, who work those relationships to bring special one-off kegs to their pubs, or hold tap takeovers and other brewery events. Selling only macro lagers and out of state “craft” beer while using regulations as a shield is beyond tired.
So where do we go from here?
Honestly, the answer is not the same for every brewery. That’s part of the beauty of this industry, but also a cause of some disagreement inside of it. Some want a food truck parked on their property every weekend, others want live music three nights-a-week, or weekly trivia or goat yoga, everyone wants that one thing they feel most helps their brewery. They should have the freedom to make that choice for themselves.
Personally, I’d like to be rewarded for my brewery’s commitment to using mostly New Jersey-grown ingredients. For Muckraker and breweries like it, the model for the future can possibly be found in the state’s Jersey Fresh program, and a similar model could push brewery expansion into the more rural areas of the state, which always need well-paying jobs, as well as encourage agribusiness and grow a sustainable destination-brewery ecosystem.
Imagine a program modeled on New York’s farm brewery law, under which breweries in, say, Fredon, Long Valley, Pemberton or Upper Deerfield build into their brewery model a commitment to using a substantial portion of New Jersey ingredients. They buy barley, wheat and oats from one of the grain farms that pop up in Cumberland County to meet the demand for in-state malt.
That spent malt is picked up at the end of the brew day by local farmers to feed cows and pigs. The breweries grow some of their own fruit, but the majority is grown by New Jersey farmers across the state — the Rutgers Scarlet strawberry in Bordentown, blueberries from Hammonton, peaches and nectarines starting in the south and making their way north as the season rolls on. Raspberries, plums, cherries, grapes, rhubarb.
The breweries in this program would use New Jersey apples to make cider, New Jersey honey to make mead, and would be able to sell each other’s products in their tasting rooms. The breweries need not be situated on farms either, which would allow established breweries to participate in the agricultural brewing ecosystem, and reap its benefits, should they choose.
It’s a great program in New York, and makes sense here, given both our agricultural and brewing tradition. But I also understand that we can’t make laws for just a handful of breweries. I’d argue that laws are made for a vision of the future.
That’s my vision for the brewing ecosystem of a state in which I’d happily make a long-term investment. That investment is tenuous at best should this state remain on its current path. I’m just not sure it cares.
What is your vision?
Please reach out to your representative and share it with them, and let’s make sure that they feel the pressure to do what’s right for New Jersey.
-- Tom
r/njbeer • u/inimicu • Dec 08 '22
Picture In-laws having their kitchen redone. Electricians found this wedged in the ceiling joists. Dates back to the '40s.
r/njbeer • u/[deleted] • Mar 21 '21
Brewery News Beginning in April, Breweries may sell beer at Farmer’s Markets
nj.govr/njbeer • u/brewersguildofnj • Apr 30 '26
Brewery News The Brewers Guild of New Jersey Launches The Beer Garden State
Hey everyone,
The Brewers Guild of New Jersey here. We wanted to share with you what we've been working on for the last six or so months. Welcome to The Beer Garden State.
This rebrand means a lot to us, and we want to make sure we finally engage with the people who have supported craft beer in our state the way we should have been all along.
This year, we put together a Women's Brew Day where over 70 women in the industry, as well as some of our legislators at Tall Oaks Farm + Brew. We brewed a Valencia Orange Honey Lager, Among The Wildflowers, that will be released next month. Portions from the beer will be directly donated to the BGNJ.
We have NJ Pint Day on Thursday June 4th, where over 30 breweries throughout the state will have our limited edition glassware designed by Tom Schmitt, Twin Elephant's label designer.
These are just some of the ways we're trying to engage consumers, and we really are just getting started. We're calling this a bit of a "renaissance" for craft beer in our state, and we're looking at hosting more thoughtful beer festivals, an app in the works, and applying for grants to make sure we do everything the right way. Through the many iterations of the NJBA/BGNJ, we didn't have the bandwidth to support breweries across the state as best as we could when it came to promotion of our members to craft beer drinkers themselves.
While this is just the front-facing things we're getting done, we are even more committed to progressing the industry through lobbying. Some feats are easier than others, but our small team is dedicated to supporting this industry in a time where it feels like everything is working against them.
As a non-profit, every dollar we make gets put into our advocacy, marketing, and education for our industry. Its been a long time coming, but we hope that we can rebuild this community by engaging more with the people that keep us all going, and thats all of you.
If you'd like to support, we have merch available here.
Last thing, thank you for keeping the conversation about beer in our state alive. I've been a part of this industry for eight years, and I love not only the beer in it, but the community. We're listening, and we're excited to show you what we can do.
-Executive Director, Brie Devlin
r/njbeer • u/Goldenmonkey27 • Jan 16 '24
Article Governor Murphy signs legislation overhauling New Jersey's liquor license laws for first time in a century
r/njbeer • u/sorryiwasnapping • Mar 30 '20
Brewery News Murphy just announced ABC will be relaxing their "Brewery Delivery" limitations
watching the Murphy briefing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z9IUyqU0Zns
Just announced that ABC will relax their restrictions on microbrewery/brewpub delivery and will allow breweries in the state to temporarily offer home delivery
edit: Link to the timestamp for the announcement: https://youtu.be/Z9IUyqU0Zns?t=1345
r/njbeer • u/MattyBlayze • Sep 22 '22
Brewery News Death of the Fox Brewing Company Files Suit Against New Jersey Division of Alcoholic Beverage Control
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE- New Jersey Craft Brewery Challenges Draconian State Restrictions
Trenton, NJ; September 21, 2022: Today, Death of the Fox Brewing Company filed suit against the New Jersey Division of Alcoholic Beverage Control’s (ABC) Special Ruling and license conditions that severely restrict limited breweries’ ability to advertise events and grow their businesses.
“ABC’s new rules are a transparent attempt to favor one kind of business—bars and restaurants—over another—craft breweries,” said Caleb Trotter, an attorney at Pacific Legal Foundation. “What’s more, the restriction on event advertising is an unjustifiable imposition on the free speech of breweries.”
In 2019, ABC issued a Special Ruling that placed onerous new regulations on all aspects of craft brewer operations—ranging from prohibitions on on-site food trucks, to regulating how many televisions may be placed in a brewery (and how large those televisions may be), to requiring a registry of guests who complete brewery tours, and more. The restrictions were imposed as conditions on the licenses of all limited breweries in the state effective July 1, 2022. The most troublesome of these new rules prohibits Death of the Fox and the state's 140 other breweries from advertising more than 25 events per year—a clearly unconstitutional restriction on speech. Worse still, the rules define “event” to include things like open mic and trivia nights, or even airing the MLB playoffs—things that many breweries are accustomed to hosting on a weekly basis.
The rules were also enacted without the proper process. “State agencies cannot just craft rules behind closed doors without transparency or any opportunity for public involvement,” said Luke Wake, an attorney at Pacific Legal Foundation. “State law requires that when an agency wants to impose rules affecting our lives and our livelihood, we must at least have an opportunity to voice our concerns. And agencies are required to submit regulations to the legislature—which can decide whether to override this sort of agency action.”
The case is Death of the Fox Brewing Co. v. New Jersey Div. of Alcoholic Beverage Control, filed in Superior Court of New Jersey Appellate Division. Death of the Fox Brewing Company is represented by Pacific Legal Foundation.
Comprehensive Case Website: https://pacificlegal.org/case/nj-craft-beer-license/
r/njbeer • u/bradleybrew • Aug 28 '26
Discussion A Brewer’s Perspective on the New Jersey Brewers Cup
Hello all — Mike Z from Tall Oaks / BBP here!
First, thanks for the positive and constructive conversation around the New Jersey Brewers Cup. As an owner of a participating brewery, and someone who has been active in the NJ craft beer community since 2010 — back when I was a NJCB rep — I thought it might be helpful to add some facts, context, and perspective about the inaugural New Jersey Brewers Cup.
1) This was pay-to-enter, not pay-to-win.
The New Jersey Brewers Cup was a Brewers Guild of New Jersey-hosted, BJCP-sanctioned, blind-judged competition. It was open to NJ breweries whether they were Guild members or not. Each brewery made its own decision about whether to enter and, importantly, which beers and categories to enter them in.
The full competition handbook is publicly available here:
https://firebasestorage.googleapis.com/v0/b/beer-awards-platform.appspot.com/o/competition_rules%2Fnew-jersey-brewers-cup_rules.pdf?alt=media&token=879251f3-2599-40a8-90ce-3321d5ae8752
2) The judging pool was legitimate and experienced.
There were 245 entries from more than 50 breweries. Judging began over the August 8–9 weekend and, because of the volume of entries and judging required, ultimately had to be extended into the following weekend as well. The competition used more than 20 BJCP-registered judges working across multiple panels. My understanding is that the judging pool included longtime industry veterans, experienced brewers, and judges with experience at larger state and national competitions, including GABF. It’s also worth recognizing what judging a competition like this actually entails.
These judges aren’t sitting down and leisurely drinking a pint of each beer. They’re evaluating beer after beer, often tasting dozens of samples over the course of a judging session or weekend, while trying to assess aroma, flavor, mouthfeel, technical execution, flaws, and adherence to style guidelines. Doing that well takes experience, concentration, palate discipline, and real skill.
At the same time, they’re human. Even the most experienced palate can interpret a beer slightly differently after tasting a large number of samples. That’s not a criticism of the judging process — it’s simply one of the realities of sensory evaluation and another reason experienced judges and structured BJCP guidelines are so important.
People can certainly debate individual results — that’s part of the fun — but I don’t think the qualifications, experience, or integrity of the judging pool should be in question.
3) Winning a beer competition involves more than simply brewing a “good beer.”
BJCP judging creates an objective framework in which a beer is evaluated against defined style expectations. But before judging ever happens, the brewery has already made several important decisions: what to brew, what to enter, and most importantly, where to enter it.
I’ll use Tall Oaks as an example.
We didn’t brew our Hefeweizen for competition. We brewed it because it’s popular in our tasting room during the summer. After tasting the finished beer and comparing it against the style guidelines, we felt it was particularly well aligned with the category. So we entered it. It won Gold.
That doesn’t mean it’s objectively “better” than every wheat beer made in New Jersey. It means that beer, entered into that category on that day, performed exceptionally well against the competition and the applicable guidelines.
That’s worth keeping in mind when looking across all of the winning beers and breweries.
4) And yes, some human subjectivity will always exist.
BJCP guidelines create a tremendous amount of structure and objectivity, but beer judging can never be completely mathematical.
A brewery recently shared a great GABF example with me. Their Coffee Stout (which I’ve had and think is very good) reached the final table and received feedback from two different judges: one essentially said “too much coffee,” while another said “not enough coffee.”
Same beer. Same round. Two highly qualified judges. That’s a perfect example of where objective standards eventually intersect with human sensory perception. It’s extremely difficult to quantify the exact “right” amount of something like coffee, fruit, smoke, bitterness, roast, or hop character.
And again, judges are evaluating many beers in succession. They train specifically to manage palate fatigue, recalibrate between samples, evaluate beers independently, and remain consistent — but they’re still human beings tasting beer, not laboratory instruments. That doesn’t invalidate competition judging. Quite the opposite.
It’s why having experienced judges, blind evaluation, defined style guidelines, multiple judges on panels, and structured scoring matters so much. It simply means that a medal should be understood for what it is: an excellent performance by a particular beer, in a particular category, evaluated by a particular judging panel on that particular day.
5) Several breweries mentioned in discussions around the Cup as being among the “best in NJ” entered and didn’t medal.
And I know at least some of this firsthand because I was sitting next to friends from breweries that had entered while we were all at the awards ceremony. Several are friends and industry partners of ours, and I personally think they make outstanding beer. I was sitting right there with some of them as categories were announced and their beers didn’t medal.
That doesn’t suddenly mean they’re bad breweries or that their beer wasn’t excellent.
Likewise, another brewery winning doesn’t mean the competition was rigged, “pay to play,” or that the winning beer must somehow be inferior because someone’s favorite brewery didn’t win.
That’s where Points #3 and #4 become really important. A great brewery can enter a great beer and not medal. A brewery that doesn’t normally appear on someone’s personal “best of NJ” list can enter an exceptionally well-made beer that fits its category beautifully and win Gold.
Both things can be true at the same time.
Competitions measure something very specific, under very specific circumstances. They’re one meaningful data point — not the definitive ranking of every brewery in New Jersey.
6) I do think the size of the field is a fair point to discuss.
With 245 entries from 50+ breweries, this was a smaller competition than some long-established state competitions. That naturally affects the depth of the field within individual categories.
But that’s also exactly why I think this matters.
As the New Jersey Brewers Cup grows, the competitive benchmark will rise. More breweries will participate. More beers will enter each category. And I suspect breweries themselves will become increasingly thoughtful about what they enter and how they prepare for competition. I’ve already had another brewery reach out asking for advice about entering future competitions because they want the professional, structured feedback that comes from a BJCP-sanctioned event — even understanding that some subjectivity will always exist.
That’s a good thing.
My bigger takeaway from all of this: this competition is a meaningful step forward for NJ craft beer.
New Jersey has been behind neighboring states in developing some of the professional infrastructure around its brewing industry.
New York launched its statewide craft beer competition in 2017. Pennsylvania’s first statewide Farm Show beer competition followed in 2019. Thr New Jersey Brewers Cup arrived in 2026.
So yes — we’re late.
But we’re finally doing it.
And the Cup wasn’t happening in isolation.
It capped the New Jersey Brewers Conference, which included two days of education, 20+ seminars, a trade show, industry networking, a lengthy and refreshingly candid conversation with NJABC Director Paul T. Urbish, and a keynote from Sam Calagione of Dogfish Head.
Huge kudos to Brie Devlin and the Brewers Guild of New Jersey for building and executing all of this.
A year ago, I wasn’t sure NJ would begin catching up with some of our neighboring states in terms of the maturity, organization, and professional development of our craft beer industry.
I’m much more optimistic today.
And I’m glad we’re having this conversation — including the criticism. People debating the results means people care about NJ beer.
One last thought: a long term industry colleague of mine who I respect — and someone who is very active here on Reddit — once told me that beer competitions are like art shows.
There’s probably some truth to that.
Like art shows, beer competitions are imperfect. They’re not fully representative of an entire industry, not completely objective, and they’re never going to capture every great brewery, every great beer, or every individual preference.
But they’re also exciting, fun, and valuable because they create a reason to evaluate the work, celebrate it, debate it, and start conversations that otherwise might never happen. And in my opinion, that’s a very good thing.
Those next-level conversations have started. That’s what matters.
Want to keep talking about it? Reach out — or come find me at Tall Oaks and let me buy you a beer.
Cheers.
~MZ
r/njbeer • u/Mikebyrneyadigg • Feb 23 '21