r/newspapercomics • • Jul 10 '26

How does this subreddit feel about the Comics Curmudgeon?

1 Upvotes

A few months back I discovered a website called joshreads.com, AKA The Comics Curmudgeon. Real name Josh Fruhlinger, he criticises comics everyday since 2004 (in fact tomorrow will be the 22nd anniversary of the site).

Reading his posts, I honestly have no idea why this guy is so popular. Sure, there are some independent reviewers I like, like this guy for instance. While I don't agree with everything he says, he generally for the most part gives valid reasoning as to why he doesn't like a certain album (although he does get butthurt haters who don't like admitting when their favourite rock artist makes a subpar release).

I don't feel the same for Fruhlinger. He often rips apart various strips for no reason, and while I agree with some of the things he said, I feel he's overly harsh to a lot of strips, particularly For Better or For Worse. I especially scoff at his claim that he's a fan of the aforementioned strip; Like... no dude. Just admit you despise it. You're not fooling anybody.

What bothers me the most about him is the influence he has on the comic strip community. There's an animated movie from 2007 called Ratatouille, and one of the antagonists is a famous food critic called Anton Ego, nicknamed "The Grim Eater," on account of the fact he has ridiculously high standards for food, and gives scathing reviews to any restaurant that doesn't meet said standards (which is a lot). He gave quite a nasty review to the film's central restaurant Gusteau's, which causes it to lose one of its five stars. A reviewer for the film said they found it unbelievable that the restaurant would lose a star because of one reviewer, which shows how grossly said reviewer underestimated the influence a single critic can have.

Point is, that's how I feel about the Curmudgeon in terms of influence. Sites that cover comic strips, like TV Tropes for instance, when talking about various elements in the strip, it feels like they can't go one or two pointers without directly quoting Fruhlinger. There's nothing wrong with citing critics, of course, but when you base your views on something entirely on a reviewer, it makes you look like you can't think for yourself.

Another example of his influence is how overhated FBoFW because after he (and other bloggers) started crapping on it nonstop. Not only was the strip so overhated in the 00s, most people my age nowadays hate the strip as a whole, and if I'm not mistaken, the writer for the strip, Lynn Johnston, said Fruhlinger and the various "snarkers" were one of the reasons she retired the strip. Thankfully, he hasn't talked about the strip much since 2012, only making one post about it since in 2020, but the damage was already done.

Granted, he's not the worst reviewer I've seen; he's not smug and self-righteous like say, ArcRoyale, but still, I find him tiresome. And he's like what, 50 now? Retire already, for Chrissakes.

But, that's just my opinion. I'm curious to see how you all feel about him.


r/newspapercomics • • Sep 12 '20

Pretty good discussion of how Scott Adams embraced the Pointy-Haired Boss and the Alt-Right

Thumbnail
theawl.com
2 Upvotes

r/newspapercomics • • May 27 '25

GoComics difficulties may be affecting cartoonists

1 Upvotes

It seems that several independent comics artists announced that they will be taking a break -- I can't help but wonder if these independent strips' fans are among those to be most severely affected by the changes to the site, so the fans have (at least for the time being) left, can't deal with it anymore. (This is only my speculation.)

Tonight, the "like" thumbs-up button has disappeared on all comments and I can't tell if it's my computer or if they're removing it to fix it, or what. I wish they'd bring back the old GC interface until all the bugs are resolved.


r/newspapercomics • • May 02 '13

A group of cartoonists are taking an unusually political stance against gun violence

Thumbnail
demandaction.org
0 Upvotes

r/newspapercomics • • Apr 18 '17

Charmy's Army - April 17th, 2017

Thumbnail
charmysarmy.wordpress.com
0 Upvotes

r/newspapercomics • • Apr 10 '17

Charmy's Army - April 10, 2017

Thumbnail
charmysarmy.wordpress.com
0 Upvotes

r/newspapercomics • • Sep 09 '19

My Comic Strip goes APE SPIT CRAZY! [OC]

Thumbnail
charmysarmy.wordpress.com
0 Upvotes

r/newspapercomics • • Mar 25 '12

The 9 Most Striking Cartoons About Trayvon Martin and the Florida Shooting Tragedy

Thumbnail
washingtonpost.com
0 Upvotes

r/newspapercomics • • Sep 04 '19

Here is the UNCENSORED version of this week's comic strip!!! [OC]

Thumbnail
charmysarmy.wordpress.com
0 Upvotes

r/newspapercomics • • Feb 17 '25

News

0 Upvotes

Where can i get digital newspaper or read news online without any subscription? r/news


r/newspapercomics • • Apr 19 '25

GoComics paywall avoider

3 Upvotes

I need help with avoiding the GoComics paywall, is there anything to help avoid the paywall?


r/newspapercomics • • Nov 10 '24

Today's Family Circus vs. Family Circus strip from 1996

11 Upvotes

r/newspapercomics • • Jan 31 '13

Requiem for a Dreamliner?

Thumbnail
newyorker.com
1 Upvotes

r/newspapercomics • • Feb 19 '17

The Story of 'Carmen' as explained by George Herriman (Krazy Kat)

Thumbnail
strippersguide.blogspot.com
1 Upvotes

r/newspapercomics • • Jul 17 '19

Backstage at the WWE Headquarters... [OC]

Thumbnail
charmysarmy.wordpress.com
1 Upvotes

r/newspapercomics • • Apr 06 '17

Charmy's Army by Davy Jones - April 3, 2017

Thumbnail
charmysarmy.wordpress.com
1 Upvotes

r/newspapercomics • • Jul 09 '19

Hitting Up the Syndicates

Thumbnail
charmysarmy.wordpress.com
1 Upvotes

r/newspapercomics • • Apr 03 '25

The absolute IRONY of Calvin and Hobbes being in this popup

Post image
4 Upvotes

Forgive me if I'm wrong, but isn't Watterson highly critical of comic strip commercialization? No doubt he'd hate this BS as well


r/newspapercomics • • Oct 30 '25

A weird theory(?) I heard about last year.

Post image
7 Upvotes

In 2024, I frequently read Arlo and Janis strips on go comics. Normally after I'd read them, I'd also read the comments people made sometimes under them, and a reoccurring topic that would be brought up every so often was that Janis cheated on Arlo?! It was so strange to me. I tried to do some backchecking on the claim but found nothing. Multiple people would mention it on various older strips that were available on the website, and I just couldn't wrap my head around it. Has anyone else heard about this?


r/newspapercomics • • Jun 08 '25

The comic strip Dustin has a weird tendency towards sexualizing Dustin's 16-year-old sister Meg

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/newspapercomics • • Jun 15 '20

How do you read your comics?

2 Upvotes

I’ve cancelled my newspaper subscription, but would still like to enjoy my favorite comics. I know I can visit webpages individually, but I’d still like the newspaper experience where I have each comic for the day on a single page. Would love to hear from folks on any apps or other means of getting this experience. Thanks!!


r/newspapercomics • • Jun 01 '20

Parental Guidance (Language Warning).

Thumbnail
gocomics.com
3 Upvotes

r/newspapercomics • • Dec 05 '15

Bizarro - Dec. 5

Thumbnail
comicskingdom.com
3 Upvotes

r/newspapercomics • • Aug 28 '25

Puro kayo DPWH, kamustahin din natin ang COA

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/newspapercomics • • May 07 '13

15 Historic Cartoons That Changed The World

Thumbnail
buzzfeed.com
0 Upvotes