Hello everyone,
I wanted to post an update about the future of this project. The topic is pretty complex, and I’m going to try to summarize the most important parts, but I’m sure I’m going to miss a lot of stuff. I’ll probably be adding updates to the thread and will just mark it with *Edit.
The last few days here have been pretty wild. I did not know this announcement was going to happen this week, and was in no way prepared to create this project. But, when the announcement happened, it was my gut instinct to hop in and work towards a better future of what was redditgifts and could be so much more. So, here I am, here we are.
To start with, I want to acknowledge that I know everyone wants to just get going and launch something. This is totally understandable. There are other projects being started that are most likely going to pop up before this one does. There are a bunch of reasons why we are not in a race, and I’m going to put them here so that everyone knows what we are going through on our side, to do this right, for you.
The Idea
This may sound simple, lets just replace redditgifts and get it started again!
Here is the reality - redditgifts was amazing. It was started and built in a very short amount of time (about 2 weeks). We invented something, a lot of things actually. It was also a very complex project organizationally. It was started as a volunteer effort and then transitioned to being a part of reddit. We had a dedicated team for a small amount of time and things were really taking shape and moving in the right direction. Then that ended, and the progress stagnated. This brings me to the guts of what I’m thinking about:
The intentions of redditgifts were important. There were a few things that were really good, namely Secret Santa and Redditgifts For the Teachers. Everything else was good, but could have been so much more and so much better. I have also had years to reflect and ponder ideas that would be so much better. I’m not ready to discuss any of these in particular because there are a lot, but I will say that there is more to be invented, and this project could really make an impact on the world. This is what I am working towards.
The Problems
There are a number of considerations that I am factoring into the future. There are a ton of solutions to these problems, so it’s important to take a bit of time and just make sure they are really considered and planned for. To set the stage of these, let’s assume that the idea above is all figured out. Here are the problems:
The organization - this project is going to be big, and it needs to be structured correctly. This means legal work and setting up some kind of entity. Because I don’t know the idea yes, and also due to some of the problems I’ll list below, we can’t really get started on this yet. It’s also possible that this step isn’t totally required at first, but I have it in the back of my mind as something I know we’ll need to figure out (I’m not actively putting any time into thinking about this).
Building it - this is actually what I am best at. For those who don’t know, I have been an engineer for > 20 years, and for the past 10 years have been a product manager. I am great at coming up with ideas, bringing resources together, putting together a project, executing it in the most efficient way, and the launching it and (hopefully) finding success. It’s a very complex process that involves a lot of stuff, I’ll just list a few here so that you can kind of get a sense of what all needs to work together to make a project really successful (idea, design (user experience and user interface), engineering (this involves quite a bit), marketing (copywriting, launching, promoting, etc), community management and support. There is also this reality that a lot of people don’t really understand, which is the more people work on a project, the harder it is, the slower it goes, and the quality suffers. So, it’s a very fine balance of organization and execution. This is a common reason projects die, either before they launch, or early in their existence. If we’re going to build it, let’s really build it so that it has the impact we all want and need. It’s not going to take a huge amount of time to get to a starting point, but the investment up front is very important. For some context, I have 300 people who have volunteered their expertise, there are already logos, names, ideas, and whatnot going around. This is amazing, it’s important to keep going, but we have to be very deliberate about making sure they all fit together correctly.
Maintaining it and making it run - this was by far the hardest thing about redditgifts. It is also going to be the hardest thing about this project. For redditgifts, it was a full time job for a number of people, and then there were a number of volunteers who did a ton of work also. Also note, there is a lot of personal information dealt with in the support process, so you can’t really have volunteers do it (for legal and ethical reasons). Also, without amazing, efficient support, the project will simply fail.
Money - this isn’t about profit, it’s about everything else. There are infrastructural costs (servers etc), but if the project works like I think it will, we’re going to get to a point pretty damn quickly where there will need to be some paid people (support most likely). I believe the community would easily support this, but the idea and execution plan needs to be put together before we jump on this. I am inspired at how many people have offered donations and kickstarters/patreons etc, but right now isn’t the time. It will come :)
Building for success - the definition of success for this project is going to be simple(ish) - it needs to be a project that needs to be fun and make a lot of people happy. I’ll get a bit business-y here, so bear with me. This is for lack of a better term, a “consumer product”. This means there are metrics that HAVE to happen to make it successful. We learned a lot at redditgifts, and I’ve learned even more since. To put it simply, you need to launch with a lot of people, you need these people to keep using it, and you need to bring in more people consistently. If you don’t have all 3 of these things, the project will die.
The Opportunity
We have so much amazing stuff going for us here. We have a large group of passionate, caring people. We have the basis for a product that we already know people love. We have people who really know how to do this (including most importantly the community).
This is going to happen, it is going to work, and it is going to be so much more, and so much better than what we have had. We deserve it, the world needs it.
How we Make it Happen
We need to keep doing what we are doing. The community here is now over 16,000 members. The newsletter has more than 3,000 subscribers. We are organized and are communicating well. This all needs to keep happening at a good rate. If we stop growing, we’re going to have some pretty big hurdles to overcome. If we become less organized, the project will probably not work. This is why I have not been willing to move to or add discord. Discord is essentially ephemeral communication, meaning that the people who know what is going on, and are a part of important conversations, really have to be around at the right time. It is a terrible community platform for things like this that need a ton of collaborative organization. In short, please, please, please keep spreading the word. It seems like I’m saying this just because I want the project to be huge, but that’s really not the reason. The reason is if we don’t keep up a head of steam while we’re building and launching, the success rate goes down very quickly. If people want to organize around one thing right now to have the biggest impact it would be this. Put together a group, a plan, and make it a focus? Just a suggestion.
TL;DR - this is complex, it needs some up front planning and coordination, it is going to happen, it is going to work, it is going to be better, and it won’t that that long, but it will take time, and we need everyone to be a part of this.