There are 2 research articles that I have been taught from at Uni that back me up on my reluctance to let my baby cry it out. One, was an experiment involving two groups of babies in, I believe, an orphanage. One group was attended to in all their physical needs, but were deprived of touch and emotional interaction. The other received both physical and emotional attention. The group that did not receive the emotional attention were growth stunted, while the emotional attention group thrived. Two; there was a study to map the area of the brain that ‘lit up’, or was used, when a person experienced emotional pain. The study found that the same area in the brain that is activated for emotional pain was the same for physical, indicating that both are as impacting as each other. Besides this, every baby website I’ve read tells you that crying is the only mechanism of communication and how you respond to that crying is what develops attachment and builds trust.
My bub is 4 weeks old. Nearly every car trip has been an absolute nightmare in terms of baby crying within minutes of driving. And it’s the most heart felt sob that turns into a desperate scream. It’s different to the rest of the cries. I can understand overtired and hungry cries now and differentiate them.
So Baby gets completely beside themselves in the car and then wants to feed right in the middle (or more times) of the car trip. In the multiple times I have tried, we spend more time stuck on the side of the road than we do driving. It ends up being a leap frog of a trip. Stopping, starting, stopping, starting. And either eventually, after hours, getting to the destination or turning back home.
Baby’s feeds are still too close together to make easier travel progress and bub won't take a dummy or a bottle to be soothed. (I’ve been working on stretching out feeds from the initial on demand snacking). With all the stopping and starting, bub gets overtired and won't settle down for at least 20 mins with boob. And then in the midst of this car nightmare our other bub, 2yrs old, gets upset and we just have a car full of tears. It's so stressful.
So, I have decided not to go anywhere with baby until the dummy or bottle or something else works to help baby get from A to B.
This has been met with criticism from friends (no family, so nothing from that side of things). I also attend church and the pressure to get there is fairly big. If we were closer to public places it might be passable to let baby cry for a few minutes to get to the shops or church. But at present we are 30-40 minutes away and I’m not gonna let my bub scream unaided for that long.
In terms of on demand feeding, the feeds have been so close together that I have been stuck to a chair for the last 4 weeks. Feeds were initially every ten minutes and have now stretched to an hour, or longer if I can get bub to connect sleep cycles. NGL the mental load has been massive and the physical/emotional toll has been draining. BUT, people’s response to this isn’t “how can I help in the midst of this?” but rather “you need to put her down in her crib and let her cry it out so you can get a break”. I’m all for a break but not at the expense of my 4 week old. I don’t agree with the general sentiment that if babies physical needs are cared for then baby is ok, even if crying.
This 4 week old is as much a person as a full grown adult and I’m not about to traumatise them when it’s my sole responsibility to care for this vulnerable little person. You can see the ramifications of neglect on little babies on YouTube from like the 60s. It’s not pretty. People relegate babies to forgetful non-aware blobs. I disagree. They may not remember the exact details of the moment but I believe these moments foster who they securely or insecurely grow up to be.
Everything everyone has suggested to ease the car or lengthen feeds/get bub to sleep, I have tried and keep on trying to no avail. But one thing I am really not comfortable with is just letting bub cry it out. For their sake but also for mine. It just does not make sense to me in a natural sense that a baby who is obviously having a negative experience and a mother feeling the maternal instinct to protect and care is supposed to be ignored and that it is considered normal to do so. This pressured, busy western civilisation has lost the art of the family.
Please note, I’m not judging anyone who has let their baby cry it out. Sometimes there is no other way. I’m in a position where I can choose to or not.
But is anyone the same as me?
End of rant.
Edit: Regarding the neglect study, my point was that the principle is that there is a significant effect of physical touch and emotional attention on a child. 10 minutes down the road a few times of crying it out to get to a destination is not neglect. But for me it is 30-40min to get to town and would be multiple times a day/week to get to events. So I believe to leave my baby without reassurance all those times would impact baby in a detrimental way. And the pressure to conform to this practice of multiplied CIOs in the car in this pressured day and age is not ok with me.