r/networking • • 10d ago

Career Advice Lancom

Hi

I’m currently applying for a job as consultant for a SME MSP. They use lancom for wifi, network switches and watchguard for firewall. Lancom is totally unknown for me. Is it a good brand? Also watchguard is known for me but not sure if it’s a good brand. Was wondering some feedback from other professionals. I currently have 7 YOE but somehow it feels like a step back as they seem to be more b brands?

8 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

6

u/Commercial_Tone_3115 10d ago

Lancom is bigger in the EU than they are here in the US for sure. I remember looking at some of their VoIP solutions years ago and ended up going Grandstream.

I don't really consider them to be on the same level as say an Arista/Juniper(HPE)/Cisco type vendor.

5

u/NKLP00 10d ago

I work with Lancom in multiple SMB environments daily. I have mixed feelings on Lancom. Their routers and older APs (LN-Series) are built on a completely custom OS. No Linux Kernel, no BSD but build from scratch. They still port some common libs though. Their newer APs are built on OpenWRT but with completely custom management and less features (than even their older APs which where essentially full routers and L4-firewall minus VPN and dynamic routing).

Fragmentation is one of their biggest issues since they are not doing custom silicon and only partly custom software. The routers are consistently LCOS. Older APs are LCOS, newer ones LCOS LX (OpenWRT-Base). Their older access switches use LCOS SX 3.X, newer ones LCOS SX 4.X which are just bought from the OEMs. I have seen those webuis with a different logo at other vendors before. Aggregation-/Core-Swiches use LCOS SX 5.X which is just Broadcom Fastpath with minor modifications.

They feel like something in between SoHo and "true enterprise" brands.

I could really write all day but to summarize from a technical perspective:

Lancom positives:

- Independent router OS made in Germany (unaffected by Linux Kernel Vulns)

- Reliable Hardware that rarely breaks

- Sell routers with VDSL-Modems and VOIP functionallity

- Free, publicly avaliable Software Updates for every Router, Switch, AP without License (NOT the NGFWs with LCOS FX though)

- One time Purchase Licensing for features like captive portal, more parallel VPN connections and AP-Slots in WLAN Controllers

Lancom Negatives:

- Fragmented Software (Different Config, Concepts across Routers, APs, Switches) and even three completely different Softwares across just switches

- EoL 5 Years after EoS even if devices would still be capable (may still get some Security Updates within the same subversion though)

- Software developement is slow and "Lantools" (Config Utilities) feel stuck in the past; terrible Webui on the Routers

- Wifi is generally good but APs sometimes struggle with connections to their controller or randomly loose the connection to the controller (WLAN Controllers are LCOS custom OS while modern APs are Linux)

- LCOS feels very antiquated (WAN-Interfaces are a completely different Type of Interface; Seperate Firewall-Tables for IPv4 and IPv6 with completely different fields/features; very little NAT options; no OSPFv3)

- Pushing hard towards Lancom Management Cloud which just didn't feel mature in any way in my recent tests

1

u/Complex-Marketing-75 8d ago

Would you recommend Lancom for European SMBs (more ‘S’ than ‘M’) ?

I’m currently assessing which brands to choose to grow our new telecom business and would like to opt for European brands where possible. I already have MikroTik and Teltonika in the workshop, but they have their flaws (so I’m making up for this with HPE Aruba Instant On).

It seems to me that Lancom’s price puts it out of the question.

1

u/NKLP00 8d ago

For example if you need all-in-one routers for multiple very small sites then yes. They have devices that can do it all including wifi, VDSL, VOIP, 5G all in one device.

From my perspective as a network admin I would stick with Mikrotik as their routers and switches are way faster for the price and have more features.

My company sticks with Lancom primarily because of german BSI-Compliance and them offering direct manufacturer support incl. optional 24/7 support and next business day replacement.

1

u/Complex-Marketing-75 8d ago

Ok thanks.
And for WiFi only, would you stick with MikroTik too ? I'm testing the Teltonika TAP400 (with a custom OpenWrt)

1

u/NKLP00 7d ago

I haven't used Mikrotik wifi yet. Only used Unifi, Lancom, Omada and OpenWRT which all worked well for me.

3

u/cryptochrome 10d ago

Lancom is a dinosaur in the industry. I think we used their gear as far back as the early 2000s. Here in Germany, where they are from, they are one of the market leaders for networking in the SMB segment.

1

u/OkRuin9092 10d ago

Using Watchguard and they are decent maybe not fortigate but you can configure it fast and simple.

Switching right now from Lancom to Unifi because the cloud is evolving but not in the right speed and you have to buy the license for cloud management from time to time.