r/netsec • • May 29 '14

BitLocker Drive Encryption Technical Overview

http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/cc732774(v=ws.10).aspx
0 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

15

u/[deleted] May 29 '14

This is the ideal time for posting this.

-2

u/[deleted] May 29 '14

Since there's a lot of lack of information out there on Bitlocker and how it can be utilized in the wake of the Truecrypt issues, above is the link for a good technical overview of how Bitlocker works.

34

u/holtr94 May 29 '14

This still doesn't clear up any of the issues that make Bitlocker a terrible replacement for Truecrypt. Bitlocker is still closed source and made by Microsoft, and we have no idea what backdoors (probably) exist in it.

8

u/ranok Cyber-security philosopher May 29 '14

Your argument is completely flawed. If you don't trust MS, and are using MS bitlocker, you are clearly using MS Windows, which you don't trust. If you don't trust MS, then use Linux and LUKS, both of which are open-source.

4

u/holtr94 May 29 '14

If I was using TrueCrypt to keep my Hard Drive safe and a government agency got a hold of it they will not decrypt it without my key, as TrueCrypt did not have backdoors. Bitlocker in the same scenario would not be secure as it probably has backdoors allowing the agency to access the data on the drive without my key.

Sure Windows might have backdoors, and they could allow the agency to intercept your Truecrypt key. However this would require them to know about your PC ahead of time, gain access to it, and monitor it with a backdoor. All of that requires some kind of remote access (or they install a device), as any local storage of the key would be encrypted by Truecrypt and unrecoverable. That could be noticed by you.

I agree that Linux + LUKS is the best solution for security, but Windows + Truecrypt is way better than Windows + Bitlocker.

4

u/ranok Cyber-security philosopher May 29 '14

I disagree. Let's ignore the possible backdoor in the Windows version of TrueCrypt and assume there isn't one. There is no trusted boot mechanism for TrueCrypt. If Microsoft is in cahoots with NSA, or anyone compromises your system (remember, there is no trusted boot), it is trival for them to replace TrueCrypt in-stitu and have it backdoored for later retrival at a border. The most concerning aspect of this is that anyone who compromises you system can perform this operation or anyone with physical access can perform an evil maid attack, whereas Bitlocker is only vulnerable to someone with the alledged backdoor.

1

u/holtr94 May 29 '14

Bitlocker is still vulnerable to the evil maid attack. Bitlocker allows un-trusted code to run, it just wont decrypt the drive. An attacker could install a fake password prompt, record the password, then say the password was wrong, uninstall itself, and reboot. Bitlocker and LUKS also don't provide any of this protection unless you use a TPM. When someone has undetected physical access all bets are off anyways. They could install a hardware keylogger, or any number of parasite devices.

My point was in the scenario where an agency gets your Hard Drive the Truecrypt encryption is better than Bitlocker.

-1

u/[deleted] May 29 '14

Bitlocker combined with Secure Boot does not allow untrusted code to run. This hole is already fixed in modern Windows machines with UEFI.

-1

u/datchronchron May 31 '14

Because UEFI/Secure Boot/any TPM technology is definitely not backdoored in any way.

-1

u/[deleted] May 31 '14

I wish you would provide proof rather than conjecture.

2

u/datchronchron May 31 '14

http://kevtownsend.wordpress.com/2013/08/23/is-windows-8-an-nsa-trojan/

http://techrights.org/2013/06/24/nsa-and-uefi/

Not sure what definitive proof you want me to provide with something like this, there is plenty of proof the NSA has consistently tried to back-door US industry-led crypto efforts (eg - previous IBM and Microsoft crypto changes and backdoor keys). I would treat any security claims that any secure boot technology makes as highly suspect with regards to the NSA.

→ More replies (0)

8

u/iggystarpop May 29 '14

Bitlocker is fine if you're trying to protect against corporate espionage. Jury's still out on the government surveillance question.

0

u/[deleted] May 29 '14

[deleted]

8

u/iggystarpop May 29 '14

No, there are 14 attempts at selling potential bitlocker exploits. On an anonymous and untraceable marketplace. Somehow I doubt that many of those are legit.

-1

u/[deleted] May 29 '14

Ummm... actually everything on that board is vetted and legit.

2

u/iggystarpop May 29 '14

Link? If everything on that board is legit, then why doesn't MS just purchase the information about those exploits and fix them?

2

u/Kah-Neth May 29 '14

Because they may exist by design.

0

u/iggystarpop May 29 '14

Wow Microsoft must have really bad internal communication problems if they independently inserted 14 different vulns into a single piece of software!

0

u/[deleted] May 31 '14

I follow the exploit market pretty regularly but I've never heard of $DARKNODE. Would you mind explaining what it is?

0

u/[deleted] May 29 '14

[deleted]

6

u/[deleted] May 30 '14

Microsoft can be legally compelled to insert backdoors, whether it is profitable or not. Any business could be for that matter.

0

u/[deleted] May 30 '14

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] May 30 '14

I doubt it, at least if the backdoors are just design flaws and bugs.

0

u/[deleted] May 30 '14

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] May 30 '14

I know it's not falsifiable, but we know there are perverse incentives for individuals and organizations to do such things so only optimism would lead us to discount the threat. Besides, making exploits look like accidents allows access for privileged agents while maintaining plausible deniability for the businesses doing the bug planting.

0

u/InVultusSolis May 31 '14

Not always. What if MS were forced to use an NSA-supplied set of initialization vectors, and an NSA-supplied algorithm for entropy? This would be significantly harder to detect with closed source.

2

u/InVultusSolis May 31 '14

Open source / closed source has NEVER proved its merit as being more or less secure than one another

There is overwhelming evidence that OSS is more secure in practice. Look at the long history of IE bugs, even constraining ourselves to the domain of browsers.

3

u/holtr94 May 29 '14

This is not about vulnerabilities as a result of bugs, rather intentional vulnerabilities, or even master keys purposely put in. For example Microsoft could easily have a master key to Bitlocker drives and we would never know. Could someone have put a master key in TrueCrypt? Sure, but we could find the code and remove it. Even the potential to find and out these backdoor attempts makes it more secure than a platform where it is impossible to know. Plus Microsoft is known for cooperating with the NSA.

1

u/nocnocnode May 31 '14

Microsoft has billions at stake and has such a huge target vector that any known vulnerabilities would indeed be known and as of yet, no known vulnerabilities that aren't inherent in any software encryption to begin with are known regarding bitlocker.

The CVE bulletins shows many, many critical errors in the past with all ('popular') operating systems involved, including Microsoft. If there is a flaw in Bitlocker, it will not risk Microsoft's billions. Microsoft is well known for managing its reputation. The most Microsoft will take is a hit on its reputation, which it will then 'patch' in its next update.

edit: spelling (popuplar -> popular)

1

u/[deleted] May 30 '14

It's funny to me that a lot of people apparently don't trust bitlocker because of alleged and illogical backdoors but they are presumably ok with running Microsoft domain controllers, CAs, and other servers like Exchange.

1

u/InVultusSolis May 31 '14

Fuck that, I don't use any of it.

4

u/420burritos May 29 '14

Bitlocker is not an apt replacement for truecrypt for anyone who may ever potentially need to safeguard their data from their own government. Until we have such tools freely available, we as a society will never have true information freedom/security. Hopefully the assumed shutdown of the truecrypt project has nothing to do with any government, but on the off chance that it does we as a people need to have these tools at our disposal more than ever before. I personally believe the truecrypt stunt was meant as a prompting to society that the truecrypt author(s) cannot continue to fight the good fight on their own (for whatever reason) so they have decided to highlight the necessity in the hopes that it will inspire invention. I choose to believe that secretly the truecrypt devs are cheering on the next generation of truecrypt and that this is (counter-intuitively) the single best course of action he/she/they could take to inspire it.

5

u/Scamp3D0g May 29 '14

I hope so, but sadly I think it's more likely that corks are popping in celebration at Fort Meade.

3

u/overflowingInt May 29 '14

All I've seen are articles saying the FBI couldn't decrypt TrueCrypt. Nothing about the NSA not being able to. We can't reach conclusions about that aspect.

-5

u/ranok Cyber-security philosopher May 29 '14

Bitlocker is more secure than TrueCrypt. I would advise switching ASAP. If you do not trust MS, switch to Linux.