r/netflixwitcher • • Nov 20 '25

Liam is better?

91 Upvotes

Am I the only one who sees it that way? I think Henry made a really good Witcher. But I find that Liam’s interpretation is much closer to the Witcher from the books and the games. Am I the only one who sees it that way? And if not, why do you see it differently?

I also find season four of the series stronger than the second and third. They have moved closer to the books again from the story.


r/netflixwitcher • • Oct 30 '25

Witcher Season 4

4 Upvotes

To be honest, I prefer the acting of Liam Hemsworth over Henry Cavill as true portrayal of Geralt. This season seems to come back to the books and games better than the previous 3 seasons.

Kudos to Netflix reeling it back in. The last 3 seasons were meant to lay the foundation. Now we have the action most of the little boys crave for and us women get the Geralt we want. 🫡 his and Yennefer's connection feels more fluid too.


r/netflixwitcher • • Jul 27 '23

Show Only S3 episodes 6,7,8 were AMAZING!

2 Upvotes

I watched in one go with a dropped jaw. Finally, because the first part was, unfortunately, a bit too boring for me, but these 3 episodes made up for everything. I loved the fast pacing, and unpredictable plot turns, and really loved the way it was directed and filmed. The shooting angle was amazing. Finally, we've got some close-ups and some alt angles not just two heads talking to each other. King Vizimire was so good, as always. He's one of my favorites in the show and Stregoborg!!! Absolutely all fighting scenes were done and shot perfectly, in an interesting way, dynamically. The whole Thannedd coup was top-notch!

And Bart Edwards is the cherry on top. I just wished there was more of him. He's my favorite male actor in the whole saga since the first season. Also loved to see a glimpse of Gaia Mondadori as Pavetta and Emma Appleton as Renfri, I loved both of them in S1 so much. And each time I heard the music from S1 it gave me goosebumps.

I really enjoyed the story of how everything turned out. I don't know about book accuracy (and it doesn't matter to me) but now I feel like I really want to see what's next.

And... 3 episodes is too little :( Give me more!


r/netflixwitcher • • Jan 26 '23

Just finished Season 2, what's up with all the hate?

3 Upvotes

First of all, I like this serie, both season actually, though watching this and the r/witcher sub this serie didn't feel really appreciated, idk if I just found the few comments against this serie

I haven't read the books nor played the game, I don't really mind if the writers are not really faithfull to them, If you want a copy of a game just play the game again, instead another piece of media of the same universe can be enjoyed by whom liked the style and the environment of that universe.

I've heard criticism on the acting though I won't talk about that because I don't really have much of an eye for it. No one's acting was that bad that even I noticed, that for sure.

I didn't really get was is going on with Henry, Liam and Lauren, nor who the last one is, is there something or someone that sums it up?

And since I'm already here, a video-summary of the serie? There are a couple things I didn't understand, like the thing in the first episode of those born on a certain day.

Sorry for any mistakes, I'm not a native english speaker, also please comment any problem this serie has that I didn't notice nor hear.

Last thing, is the prequel serie good? (I'll probably watch it anyway but at least I'll know what to expect)

Edit: I'm not gonna comment over the fact that they changed too much, idc. If you have criticism about what the charcters did, instead of what the book version would have done, please share, that's what I'm looking for. (Like Francesca should have been more powerfull)


r/netflixwitcher • • Nov 30 '22

Spin-off I honestly can't wait for Blood Origin! The most anticipated show this year. The world premiere is set to be on 12.12 in London

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/netflixwitcher • • Oct 23 '23

The most unpopular take?

11 Upvotes

I don’t really like the Witcher books or games, but I love the TV show.

I abandoned the books after like book 4 or 5. The style of writing just couldn’t hold my interest.

I’ve attempted to play the Witcher games a few times. I have both 2 and 3 and have never made it past the tutorial levels.

But I really enjoy the show. I don’t think it’ll be a cultural touchstone like Game of Thrones, The West Wing, or the Simpsons, but it’s throughly engaging and compelling and I enjoy the piss out of it.

I’m even looking forward to a new actor’s take on the show. In fact, my biggest gripe might be that I just don’t find Gerald that interesting. His stoic grunts are amusing, but I don’t really connect with the character.

The supporting cast though, they’re phenomenal and make the show compelling.

So roast me, tell me why I’m wrong. Downvote me to hell, or upvote out of spite, either way, I’m looking forward to enjoying a new season.


r/netflixwitcher • • Oct 17 '25

Who is actually excited for season 4 (like me)? Il

37 Upvotes

I need to find some non-haters please! I don’t say the Netflix show is perfect, but it’s an adaptation from the books and I want to find some people who actually understand what that means. I love the show for Joey Batey, for Anya Chalotra, and I am really excited for Laurence Fishburne as Regis! I think the show Triss is extraordinarily beautiful and so not care about anyone complaining about the “wrong skin colour” of any of the characters. And: I don’t think that Henry Cavill IS Geralt. The could have cast a total no-name and he could have also played the part. So, where are my people who have positive things to say about the Netflix show?


r/netflixwitcher • • Nov 12 '22

Quick rant before I leave the sub

7 Upvotes

You all are fucking delusional. Left the main Witcher sub because of the constant stream of negativity over s2 because this sub was (at the time) pretty much made up of just those who ENJOYED the Netflix show. Now all you fucking weirdos had to come and ruin this sub too. The show has a 75% audience score on rotten tomatoes and every single person I’m talked to IRL at work and otherwise have loved the show. I loved the books and the games and the show is fucking fantastic. The show is not the universally despised garbage heap you all make it out to be. You’re all miserable, and could greatly benefit from touching some grass. That is all


r/netflixwitcher • • Dec 29 '22

Spin-off I kinda dig Blood Origin Spoiler

17 Upvotes

I do like how they tried to tell a story about what happened before the conjunction of spheres. I don’t think it was mentioned in the books how or what happened before the events. Now that monster part was a bit ridiculous.

Apart from that i really wish Netflix wants to continue so i can keep watching the television with my dad


r/netflixwitcher • • Nov 04 '25 Bless Up

Hemsworth’s take on Geralt is better

140 Upvotes

I enjoyed Cavill’s version, but it was always too gruff monster slayer for me. I felt it missed the mark on the moral complexity of the character. What Hemsworth has done is much closer to how I imagine Geralt from the books. His take is just much more nuanced and vulnerable. Which suits this period of the story better. I just wish they had casted Hemsworth from the start, because I can totally understand why some fans find a main character recast so jarring. I do think this season is the best we’ve had since season 1 though, even if the writing can be rough at times.


r/netflixwitcher • • Oct 16 '25

Official The Witcher: Season 4 - Character Trailer

Thumbnail
youtube.com
9 Upvotes

r/netflixwitcher • • Jul 09 '23

Season 3 is surprisingly good

5 Upvotes

As a huge fan for years (read the books more than once, played every video game (although not cannon from my perspective)) I can truly say that season 3 is the best so far considering cannon. I saw things that I was looking for, moments, phases, and felt the nostalgia from the reading experience. It was great. Sure Netflix did some huge mess with some of the short stories and especially with season 2, but I think the series is like a fruit that turned eatable. First time it felt like they actually read the book and understood it, sure not perfectly but it was damm satisfying to watch. Hope they will continue and can’t wait for the seasons to come (I know season 3 hasn’t finished but still) It’s a shame it won’t be Henry playing geralt but its not the most impotent thing, which is in my opinion bringing this masterpiece to the big screen and give it the respect it deserves


r/netflixwitcher • • Aug 12 '23

Unpopular opinion: Liam is going to be so good as Geralt.

27 Upvotes

It's easy to pick old photos of liam and turn them into a ridiculous geralt, or ai generated, they all look bad. But people, Hate it or not, Liam 100% fits into the role. His face is so so similar to the one in the games. I mean, for all the players out there, it's literally him. I know it's sad to see Henry leaving, but i can't wait to see Liam as Geralt because he totally fits for me.


r/netflixwitcher • • Nov 06 '25 This

The books are the reason season 2 and 3 derailed the show

0 Upvotes

Season 1 of the show is clearly the most universally loved of the seasons, I think it’s because it adapts the short stories of the last wish and the sword of destiny. Those books are the most accessible and probably the most fun to read. Full of adventure and classic witcher stories. Season 2 and 3 having to adapt blood of the elves and time of contempt which are extremely dense, slow paced, character driven books. They’re basically all geopolitics and court intrigue. Having that straight after a season 1 of some of the most exciting stories from the books, people were always going to get whiplash from how quickly the saga slows down in pace. It isn’t until now season 4 which is adapting baptism of fire which is where the saga gets back to a more adventure style classic witcher based story we’re seeing that same charm of the first season starting to come back with Geralt and the Hansa, Regis etc. All of this to say the best parts of the story from the books has still to come. The truth is Blood of the elves and time of contempt were always the most boring of the original saga and this was probably always going to happen with an adaptation. General audiences are gonna get whiplash from that change in pace.

Edit: This is obviously a controversial take, but I think a lot of people are latching onto this post as me saying. Books bad, can’t have good show about them. The point I’m making is that the show runners clearly struggled with trying to keep the pace and feeling of the first season, while trying to adapt two books that are literally night and day different in tone and pace than what season 1 had to pull from. I often see people complain about the liberties taken with the source material in season 2. The changes made are pretty much 90% so they didn’t have to sideline Yennefer like she is in that period of the books. Which makes total sense considering it’s a netflix show they wouldn’t want to write off one of their highest paid actors for a full season.


r/netflixwitcher • • Jan 18 '23

Why is CD Projekt Red Allowed Creative License, but Netflix Isn't?

0 Upvotes

Most critics and many fans have dismissed Blood Origin for being a typical forgettable, low-effort, generic TV endeavor. Not terrible, not un-entertaining, just not very good.

But the people who truly hate it with passion and fury and review bombing it with 1-star, hating on it all over this sub, and calling it the worst thing they've every seen... the common thread for their supposed reasoning is that it allegedly disrespects the source material. "Why even call it Witcher!" they say. I've yet to see any concrete examples (what Minnie Driver likens as the "first VERSION of a Witcher" does not retcon or conflict with the established lore), but regardless these people clearly had an axe to grind before they even saw it and were offended by the mere idea of Netflix creating an original story that doesn't follow the books. But the games themselves did just that!

Here's what I don't understand.

Video game developers working for CD Projekt Red came up with completely original stories without Sapkowski's involvement that take place after the books and everyone acts like these games are part the original source material. I've seen "books/games" used over and over in this sub as if they're two equal components of the same holy gospel.

But when television producers working for Netflix come up with a completely original story that takes place before the books, this is somehow blasphemy?


r/netflixwitcher • • Jul 27 '23

Let’s Give Liam a Chance.. Spoiler

18 Upvotes

I loved the books. I loved the games. And I’ve loved the show despite a rocky Season 2.

I just binged S3V2 this morning, and I thought it reflected the major arcs of the books perfectly, in its own way. Vilgefortz was brutal, Tissaia was tragic, Yennefer evolved, and Geralt is tougher than ever, having been freed of his neutrality, and emboldened by love.

In fact, I’m so excited to see Ciri and the Rats, that I’m ready to forgive the drama, and watch Liam don the grey wig.

Thoughts?


r/netflixwitcher • • Aug 02 '23

Why do so many people actively want the show to cancel?

34 Upvotes

Like if you don’t like it don’t watch it but at least let them finish it they could change for the better (doubt). Netflix won’t sell the rights till at least 5+ years and no one will try and remake it. If they do it would be incredibly hard to get a pilot pitched with the “failure” of this series. If you are a book fan Try and view it as a adaptation instead if that helps.


r/netflixwitcher • • Nov 04 '18

You cannot defend these casting choices

0 Upvotes

They are simply awful. What's worse, however, is that people have been exercising soem really intense mental gymnastics to try to justify them.

For starters, randomly black Fringilla caused some people to perpetuate this "Nilfgaard is a world-wide, multiracial empire"

No, it's not. Nilfgaard doesn't even take up half of the Continent, considering the fact that beyond the Fire Mountains, there's Zerrikania, Hakland and God only knows what. Nilfgaard definitely doesn't reach to Zangwebar or Ofir, which lie beyond the ocean. Furthermore, Nilfgaard is imperialistic, not multi-cultural, and definitely not multiracial. It lies on the very south of the Continent, yet people living there, such as Emhyr, are white. Going up and conquering countries further and further to the North, you won't just suddenly encounter a piece of land that's basically Africa. It's a geographical impossibility. Nilfgaard is based on the Holy Roman Empire, which was a 100% white.

A other "argument" I've heard is that characters like Fringilla can magically change their appearance on a whim, so she just magically changed herself into a black woman. Now, not only I find the notion of "wearing" a different race like a costume ridiculous, it doesn't work like that. Sorceresses are given their new, artificial appearance after they pass the exams. They don't just transform their entire bodies based on a whim. The best mages of the North couldn't heal Triss' scars after Sodden, but I'm supposed to assume that Fringilla alone changed her entire race on a whim? And she just happened to pick a woman from Zangwebar?

Not to mention, Fringilla is incredibly similar in appearance to Yennefer, whose skin is literally paper-white. That's the whole point; she resembles Yennefer so much that Geralt enters a relationship with her.

Others claim "Well, obviously, there's a huge influx of people from Ofir and Zangwebar coming to the Continent, so they races are mixed."

That's nonsensical. These are quasi-medieval times. The intercontinental journey is incredibly long, difficult and dangerous. During the entire Saga, only a single merchant from Zangwebar is mentioned. Once. Not more. Not a single person from Ofir appears.

And the two Zerrikanians that we see are white blonds. The misconception about that stems from the comic books, where they were portrayed as Arabian against the author's wishes.

The Continent is racially diverse. It has elves, dwarves, halflings, gnomes and humans. And all of these humans stem from one group of settlers that arrived there 500 years ago. They stem from one source nad there was no time for them to evolve into different races.

This casting goes against the lore. The actors aren't picked based on how much they fit their character.

Theyre based on race. It's going to be a total and utter disaster.


r/netflixwitcher • • Jun 30 '23

I've turned off season 3 before episode 2 finished.

3 Upvotes

Seriously just stick to the source material... The plot is all over the place and now Dandelion is keen on men.... Why put time and energy into something that isn't even in the story....I'm over this shit.


r/netflixwitcher • • Oct 30 '25

I'm absolutely loving this two

Post image
22 Upvotes

Two episodes in, my first impressions are that Liam Hemsworth makes a great Geralt and Laurence Fishburne's Regis seems to be a 10/10 portrayal of the character we all love, minus that atrocious wig, straight out of the source material. Looking forward to the next episodes


r/netflixwitcher • • Jul 31 '23

I am excited to see Liam Hemsworth as Geralt

0 Upvotes

Obviously not ideal from a showrunning perspective. But I'm excited to see another actor's interpretation of the role come to life on screen.

Comparing different actors as James Bond, Spiderman, Batman, etc. adds a lot of fun to being a fan. Cavill knocked it out of the park, but I'm just as thrilled to see Hemsworth.


r/netflixwitcher • • Jan 31 '22

Show Only There is no such thing as cold

0 Upvotes

There are so many things to get upset about in this show, but the thing I hate the most is how it's all shot in snowy -10°C contintental winter and every single character walks around with no more than a linen tunic. Completely breaks any sort of immersion for me and I can't stand it.

I didn't spend 10 years of modding my Skyrim to be so realistic as to freeze my character to death in 5 minutes should they not have the proper winter gear equipped in the wilderness just to watch these ridiculous dialogues unfold while the people participating in them shouldn't by all rights be able to do more than chatter their teeth.

Fuck that dude.


r/netflixwitcher • • May 29 '23

Meme It’s insane to think that this person is an actual writer on the show. That’s why we get fan fic-tier writing

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/netflixwitcher • • Jan 30 '22

Black and purple. Black and gold. But Yennefer only wears Black and White. You had one job Netflix

Thumbnail
gallery
429 Upvotes