r/nerdfighters • • Nov 12 '23

disappointed and angry with this fandom

8 Upvotes

this will get down voted and possibly banned but here we go. the way this fandom is reacting to world news and the way the green brothers are handling is honestly awful.

no one is telling them to explain what's going on, they should do whatever they want in their free time however not liking ot reposting a single thing about a ceasefire is honestly disgusting.

as people who have built their empire on wanting equal healthcare to everyone especially those in poor countries, why is it hard to condemn the banning of medical supplies to gaza, or the cutting of electricity that ended up killing 30+ premature babies on ventilators yesterday? cholera is ramping due to no access of water, kids are dying from dehydration. pediatrics and cancer hospitals were bombed.

I don't wanna hear about your stance on this war but claiming you (john brothers and nerd fighters) care about health equality for everyone while staying not only silent but also saying you understand why the brothers are staying silent is absolutely disgusting and honestly with the state of this subreddit, it's clear that their opinions matter cause some people on here have horrible takes. why is it that brown and palestinian lives matter less? especially when your taxes are funding this.

  • an arab living in the ME who's been a nerd fighter for 7+ years, who has friends in gaza.


r/nerdfighters • • Jun 06 '25

Is Hank intentionally being coy?

0 Upvotes

Video after video of his recently just seems to be "OMG I can't believe these capitalists are focusing on the accumulation of capital to better their own situation instead of focusing on the betterment of America".

No shit dude. The entire neoliberal project was assuming that capitalists doing capitalism would coincidentally better America. You know this. I know you know this. You actively practice this. Why do you keep posting this videos where you act confused and don't address the actual issue?


r/nerdfighters • • Feb 19 '24

An old nerdfighters thoughts on this P4A

34 Upvotes

I remember when P4A was an attempt to take over youtube by creating videos for charities on a certain day (we did it!!), there was no taking in of money. No donations. Just youtubers making the world aware of their favorite charities.

In the years that followed it seems less and less about nerdfighters and the charities we wanted and more and more about the charities dictated to us. I really felt it this year first when the partners for health portion was ripped away from the Maternal Health center at Sierra Leone and dedicated to tuberculosis just because when John changes what he believes is most important than no discussion, and culminating with this Dustin fiasco and a dedicated contribution to anti-lgbtqi organization.

Hank put out a beautiful statement before the p4a this year stating that you did not have to contribute money, but then they set up polls all thru the live stream that were tied to the amount you contributed. The rich decided on the P4A mascot, the poor had no voice. And the nerdfighters videos had little place in this P4A, the amount of cutaways to watch them together was less and less.

As a very old, poor, queer nerdfighter, I felt inconsequential and ignored


r/nerdfighters • • Nov 03 '25

"We've Lost Control of AI" is a stain on SciShow's record

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

I'm as much affected by Gell-Mann amnesia as anyone. I'm not a subject expert on most topics covered in SciShow. But I am a computer scientist.

We know that LLM fear-mongering is free marketing for AI companies. And this piece sums up to just that.

Sponsored by ControlAI, Hank explains why everyone should be afraid of (theoretical) things like superintelligence and AGI. To the surprise of nobody, their advisors are AI safety CEOs.

In the video, Hank warns about not anthropomorphizing LLMs. But then he does exactly that, attributing intent ("it wants to"), emotion ("it feels") and cognition ("it thinks/knows") to LLMs, throughout. All ingredients for human malice.

In reality, the fact that LLMs are fundamentally nothing more than glorified auto-complete, immutably holds true. At least for now. There has been no further breakthrough in modeling. Just gloss, paint and perfume (e.g. larger models, tweaks in training, smarter prompting).

LLMs are a new addition to the technologists' toolbox and they sure hold some value. But they are also the subject of the largest and most over-inflated marketing campaign in human history. And Hank bought the tip.

IMHO this SciShow video will age like promo for some long-dead crypto asset from 10 years ago. It's a shame to use SciShow as a vehicle for that.

See also: https://www.reddit.com/r/nerdfighters/comments/1ol65t5/follow_the_money_hanks_weird_increase_in/

Edit: I want to clarify that I am not advocating for AI deregularization. But for objective reporting.


r/nerdfighters • • Jul 18 '25

Asking an AI to describe a person's smell

2 Upvotes

So, in the essay about Scratch n Sniff Stickers (The Anthopocene Reviewed) John makes a proposition; that if we have an AI that was based on all the written prose, and we asked it to describe the smell of a person. It would be extremely inaccurate.

In 2025, with ChatGPT on my phone. I could actually try this out. I am just left amazed at how corect he was. I saw the response and it seemed exactly like the description of characters in novels, or a description of a personality. The response didn't resemble anything close how people actually smell. Or at least, how I remember their smell.

I love this book, every time the essays make me think/feel something new.


r/nerdfighters • • Feb 22 '23

A Vlogbrothers video addressing Harry Potter

0 Upvotes

I think there is a need for Hank and/or John to make a video on the Vlogbrothers channel addressing HP and JKR, and how discourse surrounding the same affects Nerdfighteria. As a Jewish non-binary person with a transfeminine partner, I think the absence of this conversation on the main channel is making me feel less welcome in the Nerdfighter community, and I suspect there may be others who feel the same.

*Let me clarify that, so there's no misunderstanding.*

I'm not trying to suggest that anyone in the Nerdfighter community has behaved in a way that is intentionally transphobic, nor am I saying that either of the Green brothers have done the same. In fact, both have signed a public letter in support of trans folks, Hank has tweeted about the issue, and they discuss it in episode 245 of Dear Hank & John. What they say in that podcast is really beautiful and I highly suggest people go listen to it.

The problem is that 1) those instances do not address the antisemitism and racist microaggressions in the books that have been highlighted by many, and 2) not everyone in Nerdfighteria consumes the same Nerdfighter content. Some people only watch the Vlogbrothers videos. Not to mention that Vlogbrothers videos are somewhat the highest level of authority for establishing Nerdfighter culture and what the community is about. Not everyone knows to go to twitter or listen to the podcast. And that leaves a vulnerability in our community, where not everyone is on the same page about where Nerdfighteria as a whole stands on this issue.

During the P4A, I saw discourse about the HP trivia that occurred during the livestream, and there were people who expressed real discomfort with seeing HP stuff used in the community. And many of the responses focused on how people are choosing to view the art beyond the artist. Which is a totally valid conversation! But to me it came across as "You shouldn't feel uncomfortable because it's more nuanced," which is a take I and people in the trans and Jewish communities hear a lot that does not actually address the harm we are feeling. It bothered me enough that I ended up missing the rest of the P4A livestream, which was sad because I really enjoy watching every year.

HP was my entire life and personality for fifteen years, so I get that this is complicated and there's grief and nostalgia and other things to wrestle with. But to me, engagement with HP in public spaces needs to come with a big asterisk now. There needs to be community-wide understanding that when we talk about HP, we are doing so while also actively working to 1) view the series and franchise under a critical lens, 2) avoid giving JKR any more money or engagement statistics (such as the number of people streaming the movies or reading the books on Kindle), and 3) support the communities that JKR and her work actively harms. I think the best and most efficient way of doing this is through an official Vlogbrothers video that says something to that effect. I think it is also important to do this through a Vlogbrothers video because of the past videos and songs made in celebration of HP, some of which really helped Nerdfighteria grow in size as a community early on. It's important to say "This is how we've interacted with HP in the past, and here is how we are committed to engaging in a different way now."

I guess here is my big point. *Saying that this issue is nuanced, and that there is room for interpretation and separation of the author from the work, is totally a valid point but cannot be the end of the conversation. And when it is, it sends the message that Nerdfighters who feel active harm from the HP series do not have a place in Nerdfighteria to feel safe and supported.* I have been a proud Nerdfighter for ten years now, and I want to continue that. But to be honest, I feel less welcome and safe without the acknowledgement of harm and the active message of support.


r/nerdfighters • • Aug 16 '25

Hank is wrong about Trump's attack on universities

0 Upvotes

TL;DR The threat that universities provide is that they historically provide a platform for student activism, organization and political action.

The recent vlogbrothers video on the topic was upsetting to me. I love Hank's projects, his communication skills and what he's done for the internet and world as a whole, but that video was insufficient on many levels.

Hyperfixation on the "Trump" individual:
Generally speaking, this is a common feature overwhelmingly present in western political analysis - be it fault or strategy. Strategy when done on purpose with the objective of obfuscation, fault when done against one's own interests as is the case here. Trump has agency, has power, has all of that jazz, but he is still mainly a mouthpiece for a ruling class. He was put there by billionaires and represents them. Landowners, oil barons, industry leaders, big data etc.

Research:
While this point is mostly true, it is not in the interest of the american ruling class to halt *all* research. Historically, this cessation of research is done by the american ruling class to OTHER countries so that they don't develop their own industries (petrochem in various middle-eastern countries for instance). Not having their own high-tech industries makes them dependent on the american industrial complex. We sell crude oil and buy back all sorts of plastics, processed fuels etc. Same thing with minerals - sell ores and buy back fully built expensive machinery.

Culture War:
To say that the attack on universities is "part of the culture war" to some degree is to essentially fall for the propaganda. Keywords "Cushy jobs", "international", "woke" etc are used to PAINT universities as this bastion of liberal thought and therefore justify an attack by "The Republicans" or "The Narcissist Authoritarian", when reality is starkly different. Community colleges are the realest threat here. Community college teachers have extremely difficult and low-paying jobs, they mostly serve local usually non-immigrant populations (though some local populations are mostly immigrant, afaik there are entire immigrant neighborhoods in the US).

The Real Reason:
As said in the TL;DR, there is a VAST history internationally of universities being fertile ground for student activism and eventual community organizing. In the US specifically there is one example that I believe suffices: The Black Panther Party, started in college by two students. Generally speaking there is a huge rich history of student activism that has been a consistent threat to the ruling class and I'm absolutely astounded that none of it was mentioned in the video or in the comments below.

Sorry for the wall of text, sorry if I came off harsh, sorry if this kind of post isn't welcome here but I've been passionately watching Hank Green's many projects for so, so long and couldn't help myself. DFTBA


r/nerdfighters • • May 15 '22

Can we talk about the state of Complexly/DFTBA?

0 Upvotes

I went to college with several truly fantastic human beings who were going to school with the express intent of using the skills they craft there to better society. A lot of them went from undergrad straight into the non-profit world, aware that the salaries weren't great but that they would be doing the work that makes a difference. And a few years on now, none of them are still there. The low pay horrific grind mentality that destroys idealistic undergrads in the non-profit sphere ate them. And it really bothers me to see Complexly/DFTBA use the vocabulary and practices of that industry to recruit employees for their positions as a for profit company. The last several positions they have posted to their website/twitter have expected degrees or several years of professional experience and offered only ~$40k salaries and required that the applicant move to Missoula, a city where affordable housing is quite literally non-existent. How can Hank and John believe they are ethically operating a business like this? It's an ecommerce platform/content shop. It is not a 501c3. These practices are quite blatantly exploitive.


r/nerdfighters • • Jan 26 '17

Re: Adam Ruins Everything - Why Building a Border Wall Makes No Sense

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/nerdfighters • • Oct 07 '13

Hank quote!

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/nerdfighters • • Dec 30 '24

Did anyone else feel a little weird about Hank's "Honey" video?

7 Upvotes

I was really enjoying it, then ...

That sudden pivot to sell low quality cookware. What even was that? I just kinda stopped the video and sat there in my living room. I almost felt like I had been betrayed.

DFTBA stuff, good.store stuff, that's fine... and for a good cause! But Hank suddenly selling on the channel just felt really gross.


r/nerdfighters • • Oct 10 '14

Transcripts - Alex Day

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/nerdfighters • • Jul 19 '24

Dear Hank: Please, Please, PLEASE Get Off Of Twitter, It Is Destroying You

136 Upvotes

Video Context.

Nothing in this video describes me, and I doubt it describes most other people either, because there are very few people left in the world that actually use Twitter. It's bots, terminally online doomers, extremists, and addicts.

Hank, you are very obviously addicted to twitter, but still smart enough to intellectualize your addiction. From an outside perspective, the mental gymnastics on display here - combined with the seeming impression that it's something everyone is experiencing - are absolutely insane. Here is a gentle reality check.

First, I can assure you that it is not any harder to get news and information without social media than it was 15 years ago - that is to say, a dependence on Twitter to "know" is not about "know," it's about Twitter. Between basics like youtube headlines, word of mouth, your media outlet of choicce, and google searches, you can find virtually everything you'd actually need to know, and it's an easy guarantee that with the possible (but even then unlikely) exception of hard-right media providers, you will not end up more misinformed or isolated through using them than you will via social media.

Second, I promise that if the world is going to dramatically change in a weekend, you'll still be able to learn all you need to about it without social media's minute-to-minute updates, because the entire wider internet - news media especially - is now formatted to provide that information in a much more fact-checked and edited way than what you'll see on social media. The only (theoretical) advantage that doomscrolling provides is that amid a hornet's nest of misinformation, you might learn some new fact 5 minutes earlier than someone else. Unless you're seeking updates on nuclear warfare (in which case it might still be better to wait for verified information), a dependence on Twitter to be "current" is once again not about "current", it's about "Twitter."

Third, social media is not an antidote to strangely-shuffled priorities or worldviews, it's the cause. If your goal is to understand what's happening and contextualize it in the world you already know, you do that by ignoring the issue (unless it directly affects you - as in, your health or safety) until such a time that you can get a reasonable, objective understanding of the situation - and at most, that will usually take about 24 hours. Sprinting around while blindfolded is the opposite of this, and exactly what a social media feed does during a current event. There are a wide variety of sources that will tell you exactly what you want to know, exactly the way you want to hear it, or exactly the way you don't want to hear it - a dependence on Twitter to "contextualize" your surroundings and observe history is not about "context", it's about "Twitter."

Finally and most importantly, the world that social media presents isn't just skewed, but flat out wrong, most of the time. The biggest illusion it sells is that "the Discourse"tm actually matters to begin with. You want to know what matters and is worth talking about? The complete presidential immunity that the supreme court codified this month. Or the near-complete repeal of any regulatory ability by the federal government that they similarly cemented through the repeal of Chevron Doctrine. Or the outrageous, disturbing post-election playbook imposed by Project 2025. Or the alarming swing towards hard-right policy that EU's election saw. Or the current president's inability to form complete sentences. All of it predicated on the continued blind robbery of the world population by the 1%, and the mechanisms of control (including the trappings of social media, the one you are actively perpetuating) they manipulate to do so.

These are all things that cannot have enough attention given to them. They are the world we're living in. They are all things that need to be talked about, and things that we need to learn to navigate the consequences of, and which will, each and every one, have much larger, much more far-reaching consequences on our own lives than the color of shirt being worn by a doomer during the botched assassination attempt (and associated conspiracies) of the literal fascist running for president.

Nobody should be using Twitter. Period. And no amount of rationalization can change that.


r/nerdfighters • • Aug 20 '26

I got hit by the biggest spoiler... Am I cooked?

1 Upvotes

Guys... Something really bad happened...

I'm a relatively new nerdfirgther, and I'm slowly making my way through the Green Brothers' books.

I was about to read Looking for Alaska, it had been almost a year since I picked up a new John Green book. Everything was fine up until this point, BUT THEN i made the mistake of doing a little research... You know, to see what the book was about, what some of the comments are...

I got spoilers for the countdown. I know what it is counting towards.

I mean, I normally believe that you enjoy a work of art not necessarily because of the ending, but the whole story (otherwise you could've summarised the whole thing in a paragraph or two), BUT COME ON, THE COUNTDOWN??

I feel really bummed out and my motivation to read has died down, yet I'm still a little curious about what's going to happen in the book. What do you guys think I should do?

Extra question: At what age were you when you first read the book? I'm currently 19 and in a few years into uni, so idk if a high school story will be that enticing to me. (Which is one of the reasons I'm excited for H,E to have characters in their 20s!)


r/nerdfighters • • Nov 11 '21

Starting to feel rubbed the wrong way by Hank.

Thumbnail
imgur.com
0 Upvotes

r/nerdfighters • • Oct 20 '23

Hurt by the Silence: Hank and John Green's Absence in a Sea of Misinformation

0 Upvotes

Before I begin, I would like to preface this post by mentioning that although I am hurt, I am not trying to incite controversy or create division within the community; My intentions are pure, and I wish to see people enlightened.

Hank and John Green are my role models. They communicate and educate with a strong sense of open-mindedness, and a willingness to tackle quirky and complicated issues. Even though I may not have always agreed with their opinions, I always respected them for their dedication to fighting ignorance with knowledge.

When the recent Ukraine-Russia conflict made headlines, the Green brothers created an explainer on the conflict and its roots to help people understand the situation, encouraging thoughtful discourse.

Now, in the midst of rampant misinformation and state-backed propaganda, the one guiding light I could always rely on to challenge ignorance is missing.


r/nerdfighters • • Dec 13 '25

The amount of waste for 6 socks is a bit ridiculous.

0 Upvotes

I appreciate that there isn’t much plastic but this is still a bit much.


r/nerdfighters • • Aug 01 '25

John Green quote spotted in the wild

Post image
1 Upvotes

Playing a stupid cellphone game Tiny Towers (add Sinyk 8HKJ4 if you play) and saw this on their in game flavors text.


r/nerdfighters • • Feb 02 '15

Meninist Makeup Tutorial (hilarious satire)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
20 Upvotes

r/nerdfighters • • Nov 13 '18

Hank, this is a really bad take. You can critique the system you're in without being a total apologist. NSFW

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/nerdfighters • • Jan 16 '13

Don't get me wrong, I still enjoy his songs but....

Thumbnail
qkme.me
4 Upvotes

r/nerdfighters • • Jan 22 '25

Redirect tweets through Xcancel?

0 Upvotes

Some subs which don't want to ban tweets entirely are enforcing proxying Tweets through Xcancel, a Nitter privacy frontend which stops Twitter from collecting data about you. Is this something this sub would consider implementing in lieu of a total ban?


r/nerdfighters • • Oct 27 '16

Does anyone else like Hank and John less and less as time goes on?

0 Upvotes

At first when I first saw their channel I loved it. They seemed down to earth, smart and generally cool guys. I watched their other channels as well (Crash course, SciShow etc.) and loved those as well. I read Johns book and was amazed by them and I remember watching all of their videos in the course of a few days.

Lately though as I watch their videos and just generally look at all the things they are doing I started to really not like them. They have gotten way to pretentious over the last few years. Their other channels are going downhill as well (Crash Course seems particularly inaccurate sometimes and way to oversimplified, let's not even mention th Enviromental Determinism video).

I could go on and on, but I'm curious, is it them changing or it's just me changing and seeing them differently?


r/nerdfighters • • Oct 13 '14

Alex Day - Catching The Rain

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/nerdfighters • • Apr 19 '15

So does anyone want to talk about Alex Day?

5 Upvotes

So ever since the beginning of the scandal, I always kind of sided with Alex. I mean, yeah there were a lot of people coming out and saying that Alex did a lot of crappy things to them, but in the end, it was just hearsay. There wasn't any hard evidence. Even though Alex admitted that some of those stories were true, it still wasn't like he "raped" anyone. And I know that rape can be applied to any sexual acts without consent, but labeling him as a rapist? I think its a lot more accurate to say that he was a dick. And that sucks. We shouldn't like dicks, but dicks can change. In his newer videos (especially "The Past"), Alex seems to have really learned his lesson and it seems like he has become a lot more respectful of women. Honestly, and I'm gonna get accused of victim blaming here, but I think this could have been avoided if fans weren't so enamored of Alex. I feel like there were a lot of fans that just wanted to have sex or kiss Alex, so he started to get a warped point of view of women. This doesn't absolve him of his behavior, but I just think that with Youtube celebrities, or any celebrities, we need to be a little more understanding because they aren't in the same position as we are. So do we forgive Alex day, yet? Personally, I do and I have been enjoying all of his new videos.