r/neilgaiman • • Jan 15 '25

News This lives rent free in my head

Post image
13.3k Upvotes

r/neilgaiman • • Jan 22 '25

The Sandman My wife has Neil Gaiman’s signature tattooed on her forearm.

4.9k Upvotes

My wife and I had a close friend who took his own life several years ago. The friend had a magnificent tattoo on his back, and we decided it would be meaningful for us to get tattoos in his honor. Our friend was a huge fan of Sandman, so my wife decided to get “I am hope” as her commemorative piece. Furthermore, she thought it would be cool if it could be in Gaiman’s own handwriting. So she tweeted at him with her idea, and he actually responded to connect her with his assistant. My wife followed up, and after a few exchanges and a couple weeks of waiting, she got a small envelope from New Zealand with a piece of paper that had “I am hope” and Neil Gaiman’s signature, each written three times slightly differently so she could pick her favorite. She ended up getting both the quote and his signature tattooed.

I know her. She’ll never get it removed or covered up. She’ll forever have a visible reminder on her arm, not just of the friend that we lost, but of the fact that people contain multitudes, and that even the person going out of their way to be nice to you may be doing something monstrous to someone else.


r/neilgaiman • • Dec 22 '24 Diamonds are Forever Helpful Heart of Silver Take My Silver

Recommendation You don't need to scour Gaiman's work for supposed evidence of his guilt.

4.5k Upvotes

I'm seeing more and more posts doing this, but it isn't a rational way to go about discussing his guilt or innocence. Vladimir Nabokov, who was very devoted to his wife and lived a quiet life collecting and cataloguing butterflies, wrote Lolita, which is a very disturbing and perverse book. Stephen King who, aside from his battle with drug addiction, has a history of being very faithful to his wife and being a pretty nice guy overall, has some truly questionable and perverted scenes in his books, such as the sewer escape scene with underage kids in the book version of IT.

You can't reliably tell based on their books what a writer is actually like because many writers like to explore extreme ideas in their writing even if they don't have any intention of harming or manipulating anyone in their real life. The opposite is true as well as there have been writers who wrote stories that aren't particularly perverse but did horrific things in real life, like feminist fantasy author Marion Eleanor Zimmer Bradley apparently being involved in the prolonged child sexual abuse of her children with her 2nd husband, who was a convicted child sexual abuser.

The point here is that the guilt or innocence of a writer is found in the testimony of the victims and real-world evidence of their crimes, not in their fiction.


r/neilgaiman • • Jan 14 '25

Meme Some of y'all

Post image
4.3k Upvotes

r/neilgaiman • • Jun 18 '25

Meme Has this already been posted?

Post image
3.8k Upvotes

r/neilgaiman • • Jan 17 '25 Unity Bless Up

News I’m not throwing away my books

2.9k Upvotes

I’ll keep this short.

I am a SA survivor, and when I saw the headline I believed those women 100%. With that being said, I am not throwing away my NG books, because screw that, they aren’t HIS books, they are MINE. They have been made mine throughout years of reading and re-reading. They have been made mine through how they have shaped me and brought me joy. I absolutely refuse to let a monster take more.

It is remarkably unfortunate that someone can be a talented storyteller and a deplorable human being. Perhaps my view stems from years of taking back what I perceived was taken from me through my SA experience. But I will be both a voice of support for the women he has harmed, and a continued reader of MY books.

(To be clear this is my personal decision on the matter, everyone should do what feels right to them. There is no right answer)

EDIT: before you comment re-read the above statement.

FINAL EDIT: I’d like to thank everyone for sharing their views on this post. Regardless of the nature of the comment, the discussion as a whole has been deeply beneficial to me, and I appreciate you all. My hope is that, regardless of where you stand in the matter, it has been beneficial to you as well.


r/neilgaiman • • Jan 17 '25

Question Do people seriously not know the legal risk NY Mag put themselves in?

2.7k Upvotes

I’ve seen multiple posts on this sub from people wondering about the “legitimacy” of the “accusations” against NG. NY Mag is a major publication and not only that, the NG story is a FRONT PAGE story. You understand that went through legal and editorial clearance, plus fact checking, yeah? From the journalist that broke the Joss Wheaton story? Just wild to me that people don’t know what that means. Like, if I’m a lawyer, and my job is to protect my massive publication from legal troubles, I am not going to let them publish an article about a famously litigious author from a insanely litigious organization without a place to stand firm on. This is an incredible piece of journalism, not only in its actual research and writing, but in the bravery to take on an extremely powerful person and publish insanely brutal facts about their actions. NG won’t ever be willing to risk the process of discovery to actually sue them, mark my words.


r/neilgaiman • • Jan 13 '25

News There Is No Safe Word (A Vulture investigation/feature on allegations against Neil Gaiman)

Thumbnail
vulture.com
2.6k Upvotes

r/neilgaiman • • Jan 14 '25 Bless Up

News People keep comparing Joss Whedon to Neil Gaiman, and it's weird and needs to be discussed.

2.3k Upvotes

Since the article came out last night I keep seeing people say 'Oh, I've lost all my respect for him, just like Joss Whedon.' Or 'oh he's a wolf in sheep's clothing, just like Joss Whedon.' I just want to say I find this comparison very odd and shows we have no levels for wrongdoing anymore. On the very surface yes they're are some similarities, both were very vocal about their feminist leanings, and both were very active in nerdy fan circles, and both turned out to be pricks. However, that's where the similarities end. We need to understand that wrongs aren't on the same level, and saying I feel the same about Gaiman as I do about Joss Whedon I think underplays just how awful what Neil Gaiman did.

Joss Whedon turned out to be abusive to actors, treated women who worked for him badly, ran toxic writers' rooms and appears to be an all-around nasty piece of work. However, unless I've missed something he has never broken the law, or physically hurt anyone. The things that came out about Neil Gaiman are fucking horrific on a level I can barely comprehend. It's not the same, we need to come to terms that what he did, making people eat bodily excretion with his son in the room is a level of depravity that's just on another level. I think comparing him to run-of-the-mill monsters really underplays the horror of what he did, and that's something that should not be underplayed. I understand it's hard to fully comprehend and making comparisons may allow some way of processing it, or putting it a kind of relatable context, but we need to come to terms with just how far over the line is crimes are. What Gaiman did walks into lines of horror that are just beyond anything, please don't minimize them by comparing him to some other dick.


r/neilgaiman • • Jan 25 '25

Anansi Boys Dark Horse Comics Cancels Neil Gaiman's 'Anansi Boys' Admist Scandal

Thumbnail
fictionhorizon.com
2.1k Upvotes

r/neilgaiman • • Jan 28 '25 Heartwarming

News Too much parasocial here

1.7k Upvotes

Look, I get it. I love Neil Gaiman's books since I'm a teenager (so 25 years ago and counting), Neverwhere was a huge impact on me and on my creativity, and I reread it religiously every year. I am extremely disappointed in the author. But some of the reactions here are not healthy. I understand being angry, being disappointed, being sad... up to a certain point. Beyond that point, it turns into pure parasocial phenomenon, and that's not healthy. Honestly, going through the 5 stages of grief, feeling depressed for days, cutting your books, wondering what to do when you've named your child Coraline (and seeing some people say 'Well, just change it then!')... it's too much. You make yourself too vulnerable for someone you don’t know. And when I see some people asking for other unproblematic (but until when?) authors to read and love, it feels like it's going in circles. Take care!


r/neilgaiman • • Jan 29 '25

News Stage adaptation of Coraline cancelled after allegations against Neil Gaiman

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
1.5k Upvotes

Everything else aside, I really feel for the playwright and composer who would have put so much of their time and energy into adapting Coraline for the stage.


r/neilgaiman • • Feb 02 '25

News Terry Pratchett estate removes Neil Gaiman from Good Omens kickstarter

1.5k Upvotes

r/neilgaiman • • Jan 13 '25

News I can't even 'separate the art from the artist' because, well, go back and read Calliope now.

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

r/neilgaiman • • Jan 16 '25

News Statement from Colleen Doran (Sandman: A Game of You artist, Troll Bridge artist, Good Omens graphic novel writer/artist)

1.4k Upvotes

Via her Patreon

"I am sure you have all heard the news, and while I am not in a position to discuss, I am also not the story and it is not about me. Whatever I am feeling or going through is not the issue.

People have suffered and that is the issue.

I will finish Good Omens and make it everything I dreamed it would be the day I sat down to do what I thought would be my dream job. My second dream job that is, Chivalry was the first.

But with the sweet comes the sour.

I became quite ill at the news. But I'm an adult and have resources. And I am drawing on those resources and planning for the future.

Some people don't have those options.

I will not trauma dump on you. I've done enough of that in the past.

But I will thank you for your kind support and hope that support is also directed to those who need it most.

Thank you."


r/neilgaiman • • Jan 04 '25

Recommendation Unwanted gift of Gaiman books - what we did

1.3k Upvotes

My child was not happy to receive a couple of new NG books for Christmas.

For some background, they are named after a Gaiman fictional character and are in high school. We have had talks about the situation and their English teacher even talked about this in class. The class had a whole nuanced discussion on separating the art from the artist. My child has put a lot of thought on how to live with this situation and they decided they don’t want to add to Gaiman’s wealth.

Relatives know my child is named after a Gaiman character. They were gifted with 2 new copies of his books for Christmas. They would not have minded if the books had been used.

I tried to calculate the royalties NG received from these books. They were paperbacks so I estimated 8% of list price. I then made a donation of ten times that amount to RAINN. This was some consolation to my child. It made what to them was a sucky situation (being gifted the books) tolerable.

Edit: Just clarifying, my child is not upset about their name and feels fine about it. The name is ours now. This is not about that. I was just pointing out the name because it is why my child is aware of and interested in the NG situation.


r/neilgaiman • • Feb 15 '25

Shelfie Came across this in the used bookstore today

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

r/neilgaiman • • Jan 16 '25 Diamonds are Forever Heartwarming

News Dear Scarlett

1.3k Upvotes

Dear Scarlett,

I am also a survivor. My story went public six years ago. My abuser was a publisher and poet and he had been my teacher when I was 14 years old. I know what you're going through and I've been in your shoes, I still have to wear them everyday.

I wanted to send this out to you here in case you have been scrolling and seeing all of the posts about your abuser and not you. Your personhood is in my heart right now. I support you, I believe you, I see you.

My daughter's name is Scarlett, and I'm so proud that she shares your name. What you went through is a nightmare that is coming to light, yet still it persists. Once you're out in the open the private pain becomes public interest, discussion fodder, topical. And one day people will stop talking about it and you will still be left holding the bag with whatever is left of the pain.

I promise you I will never stop talking about it or you. I won't forget your personhood. You and the other victims come first above Neil, or his work, or whatever people got out of him. That's for them, and that's fine, but for you I want so much better and so much more.

Thank you for continuing to persist through this. Your truth is so hard to carry and the burden collapses souls. You are not alone. You deserve so much more than what was done to you. I am so unbelievably proud of the strength and courage that you have. Every truth told raises the voices of others who are suffering in silence, and it also validates those of us who have spoken out before you-- together we are a mass of truth, we have seen what others have turned their eyes away from, and we don't let it die in darkness.

Scarlett, I am rooting for you. I am proud of you beyond measure.


r/neilgaiman • • Sep 16 '24

News From Amanda's Instagram

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

This is the shirt equivalent of an obvious sub-tweet, but I think it hits the nail on the head. So many men can see the big picture and have general compassion for women but can't seem to pull it together when their own needs/wants are involved.

(This, of course, applies to all people in many contexts--but a certain man's treatment of women in general vs their own interpersonal relationships is the topic at hand).


r/neilgaiman • • Feb 08 '25 This

Meme The money must flow

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

bottom text


r/neilgaiman • • Jan 14 '25

Recommendation Just to let people know that Amazon/ audible are allowing refunds on Gaiman’s work if you decide you don’t want to have the digital books anymore, even for those purchased years ago.

1.3k Upvotes

r/neilgaiman • • Jul 05 '24 Take My Silver

Recommendation After Listening to all four episodes: the facts themselves are bad

1.2k Upvotes

Let's take a step back and assume, for the sake of argument, that literally everything that the women are saying is false, and that Gaiman's version of events is closer to the truth. It is as exonerating as it can possibly be.

Gaiman still has a history of exploiting younger, inexperienced women who are either starstruck by him, or dependent on him, causing an absolutely massive power imbalance. He does this despite being married in an open relationship, and seems unwilling to be clear that he cannot commit to them.

This is if he is being entirely honest. At one point in the podcast to exonerate himself, he sends an email of K saying that she can't wait to visit, her "loins are desperate" (not exactly it, but close) that's from 2017, way after their relationship ended. When the journalists dug deeper they found that it was part of an email chain where he told her he was working with David Tennant, who she had a crush on, and her jokey "horniness" is clearly in reaction to Tennant. This shows that he is absolutely willing to mislead or to misrepresent evidence when it comes to this.

While there is no direct evidence of assault in Scarlett's story, there's a lot of smoke. Gaiman being accused of assault by Scarlett's friends is indisputably something that happened. As is her saying that what happened "pushed boundaries" at the time.

If you insist that the benchmark needs to be: overt rape or bust, then sure, the evidence is probably insufficient. Even the podcast seems to walk it back to "sexual abuse" the vast majority of the time. But...sexual abuse is pretty bad. There is a very wide spectrum of treating women in a shitty way before you get to outright sexual assault.

I say this as a Gaiman fanatic. As someone who is irrevocably influenced by his work. I listened to all four of these episodes because I care deeply, and what we know for certain really sucks.


r/neilgaiman • • Jul 12 '24 Heart of Silver Take My Silver

Sub News Update

1.2k Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I wanted to take this opportunity to provide some updates regarding the direction of our community. After carefully considering all the feedback received, I have decided to shift the focus of the sub from Neil and his personal life to solely his work. This decision was not made lightly, and I spent considerable time pondering this matter.

Consequently, you may have noticed some changes, such as the removal of Neil’s face as the sub's avatar, the retirement of the “Good Gaiman” flair, and some adjustments to the rules. I have also archived older posts and updated the automod. This also means the response thread will now be closed. It's important to note that this change is not intended to discourage discussions about Neil's life or the significance of biographical context in his work. Instead, it aims to foster meaningful analysis and critique of his work within those contexts, along with other forms of literary criticism.

In arriving at this decision, I sought guidance from Reddit’s crisis management team and consulted with moderators from other subs focused on notable individuals. I also reviewed information from sexual assault support sites, as well as reports and papers from educational institutions and law firms. Additionally, I reflected on my own experiences with grooming and considered this matter from the perspectives of being a partner, a parent, a child, and a sibling. It is essential to approach this situation with integrity and empathy for all parties involved.

Our community is committed to upholding the principles of believing victims and recognizing the presumption of innocence until proven guilty. These are not conflicting ideas but fundamental principles that ensure fairness for all involved: we believe when someone says something happened to support a fair investigation while also believing the accused is innocent to ensure fair representation. We are not vigilantes.

Moving forward, the sub will enforce a zero-tolerance policy for defamation, including victim blaming and baseless accusations. I strongly advise you to refrain from spreading rumors or speculations in this sub.

I assure you that if corroborating investigations or legal proceedings arise, we will adapt our approach accordingly. Again, I want to emphasize that I have no personal or professional association with the individuals involved, and I have not received any guidance from them or their teams regarding the management of this community.

I understand these changes may be upsetting for many of you, but please know that these are temporary measures to maintain a respectful and inclusive community without the risk of the sub itself being banned.

Thank you

Edit: if you still have a need to discuss and process the allegations, there is an unaffiliated sub specifically for that at r/neilgaimanuncovered/

Again, if you are struggling with this situation, I encourage you to take time for self-reflection and consider supporting a local charity through donations, volunteering, or other means. Taking positive action in our communities can help us through challenging times.


r/neilgaiman • • Feb 17 '25

News Rolling Stone piece on Diddy and Gaiman. Excellent.

1.2k Upvotes

Rolling Stone article. This is not paywalled, but you need to click off the subscribe beg to get the article to "unblur."

ETA: Good lord, WHY would this get downvoted?


r/neilgaiman • • Feb 19 '24

Good Gaiman Neil Gaiman on political correctness

Post image
1.2k Upvotes