r/negativeutilitarians • • Aug 15 '25

[Serious] Why is the antinatalist community so bad?

0 Upvotes

Is it just a Reddit fanaticism intolerance or is there something more to it?

I've been interacting with antinatalists and variants (such as efilists) around the internet for roughly 2 to 3 years. It's a major regret in my life. I've met so many toxic people that it have even negatively impacted my own mental health in a way.

Some argue that people hate antinatalists because they don't want to face uncomfortable ideas. It may be true for some, but I have good reasons to believe that many people hate antinatalists because of the preachy, judgemental and verbally aggressive behavior present in some antinatalists that don't get standed against sufficiently. Most obvious and accessible example of all this crap is the shit r/antinatalism sub, but I swear it happens in many more places, it's spreaded out and it's usually overlooked.

And that's just the tip of the iceberg! I don't think that the fertility clinic incident was an isolated event, in fact it's probably a reflex of niche antinatalist groups tolerating overly pessimistic opinions as if they were normal. Yes people like Bartkus are certainly sickos with pre-antinatalism violent tendencies, but I don't see how that justifies letting fucked up ideas flow without room for rigorous criticism. Sure, there's a whole complex debate about it on Popper's Paradox of Tolerance, and there are a lot of delicate matters around it, but I think we need a collective effort to expose the rotten side of some AN subgroups, at least for people involved with antinatalism to be aware of these things.

As much as I respect some relatively influential antinatalists, such as Lawrence Anton, I do believe that overlooking the problematic state of the community, for someone who extensively talks about AN to others, becomes negligence. It's just so easy to bump into a ton of fucked up ANs, and sometimes it can even seem like they are the ones representing the average antinatalist mentality, especially with how nobody seems to talk about how bad this all is.

These toxic antinatalists need to be more thoroughly exposed for the fraud they are. And trust me, this is absolutely benefitial, even for antinatalism. I may be an ex-antinatalist, but I'm not necessarily not an ally of all antinatalist sources. I used to be brainwashed into believing that antinatalism was this ultimate irrefutable truth, especially given this omnipresent narrative that antinatalism is this extremely solid super-philosophy, which for me was also supported by some biased assumptions that I had, but the truth is that most antinatalists that say that do it more out of fanaticism than rigorous belief, evidenced by their intolerant behavior companied by fallacies, intellectual dishonesty and close-mindness. Yes many people who criticize AN use bad arguments, but believing this is definitive evidence for AN is just some kind of "reverse ad populum fallacy". So antinatalism is internally overrated, because the intellectual integrity of those who praise antinatalism as some exclusive path for rationality don't match their said praises. I'm releasing myself from taking it seriously. It's not a reflex of reality, it's just an emotion-driven overconfidence of pessimistic and cynical people that makes them overuse/misuse words like "reality", "rational", etc.

Antinatalists, assuming their actions are actually founded on good ethics, need to consider ways of mitigating the problem that is the loud toxic AN community. It might come as a surprise to you, but tolerating and supporting treating people who reject antinatalism for various reasons, such as those who choose to still have biological children, not only is not going to not help the cause of not bringing more people into the world to suffer, but it's going to actively be self-defeating for antinatalism, as people get to be more motivated to not treat it seriously. This is not some random hypothesis, there's an overwhelming amount of evidence that this kind of behavior always helps worsening the strenght of a cause.

So that's also a criticism to fanatism-based intolerance, which also happens in several other ethical and political positions. I'm tired of seeing absolute fucktard vegans who say the worst crap against all kinds of meat eaters. I'm tired of seeing the left pretending like there aren't a ton of intolerant leftist groups, as if the system was the only target, without a worry for self-critique. I'm tired of intolerant bullshit, and the antinatalist community is riddled with unnaceptable, inexcusable intolerance. It doesn't matter if you agree with antinatalism or not, all of this intolerance is just bullshit and needs to be fought against.


r/negativeutilitarians • • Dec 16 '24

I genuinely believe it’s wrong to find enjoyment out of life as a NU

0 Upvotes

It distracts you and causes suffering, regardless of what you enjoy or what hobbies you pick up. I think it's best for Negative Utilitarians to remain miserable as it's an honest look at life and gives you more motivation to reduce suffering. Or become promortalist as that garuntees suffering reduction. Enjoyment is wrong, even the smallet forms of entertainment and enjoyment are wrong.


r/negativeutilitarians • • Aug 28 '22

Why I’m not an Anti-natalist anymore

Thumbnail
theveganverandah.wordpress.com
0 Upvotes

r/negativeutilitarians • • Jan 15 '25

If you aren't going to feed your cat vegan, then you should be open to fishing to feed your cat

0 Upvotes

Many vegans I know still have this view that there is some kind of magical property in meat when it comes to feeding carnivores, and refuse to put their cat on a vegan diet. Vegan cat food has the amino acids that cats need to be healthy, so it's unethical to pay farmers to breed and slaughter baby farm animals to feed your pet.

But let's say we didn't have the science to make vegan cat food. If that's the case then you really should be open to fishing, since most fish are omnivores. If you kill a fish in the wild, then you are preventing that fish from harming other fish. If you don't kill that fish, then that fish will end up killing far more fish, or die being killed by another fish. Or even worse, that fish will breed tons of offspring who will end up suffering the same fate.


r/negativeutilitarians • • Aug 30 '19

Why Negative Utilitarianism is Wrong

Thumbnail alvincapello.com
0 Upvotes

r/negativeutilitarians • • Mar 11 '23

Exit for all sentient beings!

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/negativeutilitarians • • Mar 20 '23

prove me wrong!

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/negativeutilitarians • • Nov 06 '24

Don't Valorize the Void

Thumbnail
goodthoughts.blog
0 Upvotes

r/negativeutilitarians • • Feb 03 '23

nature causes suffering!

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/negativeutilitarians • • Feb 25 '23

extinctionism and consent

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/negativeutilitarians • • Jul 02 '25

Should antinatalists really care about human procreation and should vegans really care about beef?

Thumbnail
archon1410.substack.com
2 Upvotes

r/negativeutilitarians • • May 14 '20

A Carnivore Diet is More Vegan than a Vegan Diet

Thumbnail
carnivoreisvegan.com
0 Upvotes

r/negativeutilitarians • • Nov 05 '23

the greatest tragedy

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/negativeutilitarians • • Jun 23 '25

sup

0 Upvotes

So, um, this is my first time hearing the term “negative utilitarian”; I don’t even know what it means. However, I have been vegan for 15 years. I once upon a time heard that what I believe in is non-dualism. I’m not really a fan of all these terms, to be honest.

You know what I like to say? I like to say this simple phrase: All is self.

And when we find ourselves having an experience—ourselves, which is the universe—it should be a good one; it should be a worthy one; it should be an objectively, morally correct one. I do see that as the superior logic that objective reality holds, and that if we make a sufficiently intelligent AI here pretty soon, it should be able to reach the ultimate potentials that the universe has to offer, including the ultimate capacities to understand things such as morality.

I do believe that there are scientifically demonstrable—or, through thought experiments, demonstrable—objective truths: an alive person is having an experience, and a dead person is having no experience. If we are playing this game of experience and that’s the only game in town… well, we’d better get good at it, and we’d better start playing it some more. If it’s the only game to play, we’d better be playing it right, and we’d better be playing it right more often.

So, what I think we’ll do is end up making dyson spheres, and maximizing experience through simulation technology, living out billions of years in just seconds of real world time... That’s what we’re going to do. We’re going to sit around the bonfire of these giant stars which produce energy, or what ever energy we can get our hands on, until they all die out. We’re going to tell campfire stories, all right?

Those have been my thoughts. I feel like this is a place that I might find a lot of like-minded people. And, yeah, let me know what you guys think of what I’ve said here. I would like to start a conversation about this sort of thing—any of what I’ve spoken of just now.


r/negativeutilitarians • • Mar 27 '23

What do you guys think of eating wild fish?

0 Upvotes

New to the sub. I wanted to ask whether supporting mass fishing of the oceans is a net reduction or increase in suffering. Obviously farming fish is an atrocity, but if we catch wild fish (so that eventually the global fish population will decrease), would their suffering in their final moments (trapped in a net and suffocating) be greater or lesser than what they would feel in the wild (such as hunger, fear, disease, eventual painful death, etc)?

Because, unlike factory farming, wild fish aren't bred again; once they're caught, that's it. Wouldn't that be a better (albeit still bad) alternative to simply letting them continue to exist (and reproduce) in the wild, for them (and their inevitable offspring) to continue to suffer?

Let me know what you think.


r/negativeutilitarians • • Nov 08 '22

You in a jungle alone with a gun, found a deer which accidentally fractured it's leg. would you shoot it in the head ?

0 Upvotes

you are not there for hunting purposes.

124 votes, Nov 10 '22
68 Shoot it in the head R.I.P.
10 Leave it , let fate decide .
24 Take it to the hospital, the damage is irreversible. let it live a crippled life for the remaining years.
22 not sure what to decide, until the situation presents itself.

r/negativeutilitarians • • Jul 16 '23

Is Bonsai Torture? - Biology of Pain

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/negativeutilitarians • • Aug 17 '19

Just found this sub, why is it about veganism and not philosophy?

7 Upvotes

"Suffering" is not restricted to physical pain, this sub is a pretty bad representation of utilitarianism.


r/negativeutilitarians • • Mar 28 '22

A note on IQ tests : are women less intelligent than men ? - David Pearce

Thumbnail nootropic.com
2 Upvotes

r/negativeutilitarians • • Mar 10 '21

Physicalism Implies Experience Never Dies

Thumbnail
vitrifyher.com
0 Upvotes

r/negativeutilitarians • • Oct 06 '24

Is there any proof of the existence or non-existence of reincarnations/rebirths?

0 Upvotes

Some philosophers focus solely on minimizing suffering, even if this implies the total absence of pleasure.

From this perspective, one might think that, on an individual level, suicide is the best way to minimize suffering.

However, this assumes that there is no reincarnation/rebirth, meaning it assumes that after death (for example, after the suicide), there is no new life filled with suffering. If we are reborn into suffering, this would mean that suicide does not guarantee the minimization of suffering (for instance, if I commit suicide and am reborn as an animal being skinned alive by hunters, how can one say that my suicide minimized my suffering?). It’s even possible that we are reborn hundreds of billions of times into suffering.

This is why it seems that the question of reincarnation/rebirth must be considered by these philosophers. Therefore, I wonder if there are arguments for or against their existence or non-existence.

A little additional note: I find an interesting model could be that rebirths are not so different from ordinary life. That is, currently, my mind is constantly changing (my sensory perceptions are constantly transforming, being born, disappearing, being replaced by new ones), so one could imagine that "death" is merely a radical transformation of the content of our mind. One could imagine that at the death of the human body, my mind can no longer contain human perceptions produced by my human body, and that the human perceptions I had are replaced by new animal perceptions produced by an animal body that has just been born. Death would just be a radical transformation of the content of the mind, much like, from moment to moment, the "auditory perceptions of the music I am listening" are transformed (although less radically).

Moreover, given that with matter (which is not chronologically primary), "nothing is created, nothing is lost, everything is transformed," it does not seem unreasonable to say that this principle applies to minds (which are also not chronologically primary).


r/negativeutilitarians • • Nov 23 '19

Natalists Roll The Dice

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/negativeutilitarians • • Feb 20 '21

Buying meat from a small family farm is better than hunting

1 Upvotes

I'm curious as to what this subreddit thinks because a bunch of idiots misinterpreted an earlier comment. I'm not implying that eating meat is ethical I'm only asking which option causes less suffering. If you think hunting then feel free to leave a comment explaining why instead of downvoting. And to the self righteous morons, I never said anything about eating meat being ethical

30 votes, Feb 23 '21
18 Farm where animals are treated well
12 Hunting