r/nancydrew • u/nuggetsofchicken • Apr 04 '23
DISCUSSION 💬 Am I just the only person who has no faith in this company?
(nancythedrew from Tumblr here. I know the sentiments there are very different but I'm just so confused by the hype here on Reddit. Many links are to my own blog bc I could just find what I was looking for easier to make the point))
They have literally told us for 8 years now that they have plans for another game and now all of a sudden they make an announcement to say they're "working" on it? How is that not incredibly offensive to all of the fans that they lied to up until this point? The fact that they think they have done -anything- to warrant the description of "working" on a game only just now tells you they have been knowingly dragging us along for years promising another game with not a single shred of concrete work done.
I do not think the trademarks are compelling. I'm not an IP lawyer, I'm just a dumb civil litigation lawyer, but my understanding of trademarks is that it is hella easy and relatively cheap to file for a trademark. Companies will just snag random trademarks that they might maybe kinda plan on using some day. It's almost like how back in the early internet days you would just purchase a bunch of URLs in case you could sell them to someone who wants it later.
The fact that a trademark was FILED on March 30, and the teaser was dropped that weekend for a new game is not anything to applaud. That to me seems like they literally just got the trademark in because they just got the idea for the TITLE of the game. Also can we talk about how fucking generic the "Case of the Missing Clue" name is? To me this screams a last ditch attempt to drop another game and to generate hype before they lose their audience even though I doubt they could even tell us the basic premise of the mystery.
Let's say another game does happen. Have we gotten any indication that it isn't gonna be just like MID? Have we heard anything about HeR actually hiring in-house writers, animators, etc.? Based on everything HeR has shared on their social media, MID was 10/10 a great success for them. They loved that Unity software they bragged about and are still proudly promoting it as their latest game. I'm not saying that HeR needs to come out and admit that MID is shit, but from everything I'm seeing in the latest posts, this seems to be still a 3d rendered style.
Also the animation in that video is piss poor. It looks like something you make in a gen ed animation class in high school where they have to show Accounting majors how to make a 30 second clip for their final project. No, it's not intentionally crappy because HeR got "hacked," the hacking bit is far gone. This is clearly supposed to be demonstrating HeR's actual take and perspective on the status of their game making. If we are gonna defend this as some sort of being hacked gimmick, then we must also think that the announcement of the next game is also a mouse. It's not. This is supposed to be a straightforward representation of "Herinteractive responding to the question."
I'm not trying to be that asshole (I kind of am, a little) but I'm just genuinely so confused by the overwhelming excitement and positivity I'm seeing over this. We know the reason HeR had to cut staff and lost steam was because their outside investor decided to stop funding them. This business was never profitable on its own the way it was operating to produce the 32 original games.
The shittiness of MID seems to be indicative of the way HeR is able to produce games without this outside funding. It's the reuse of Unity templates and the absolutely ridiculous number of firms they outsourced to to get the game complete. This is the cost-cutting reality of the fact that HeR's business model was not sustainable. I haven't heard anything suggesting more investors, more hiring, a different strategy, etc. for this "new era" of HeR as a business. "New" isn't even accurate. This is the same business model and people who brought us MID and who lied to us for the past 8 years saying that there was a game in the works.