r/musicians • • Oct 02 '25

To all the people here that complain scenes are just full of gatekeepers and politics, you ever think maybe YOUR music and band’s image just isnt considered good enough?

11 Upvotes

I feel like people here should hear the harsh truth. As an ex gatekeeper i can tell you right now alot of peoples bands arent as good as they think or they’re just simply not good enough. For example there could be two pop punk bands.

One pop punk band is full of 30 year olds playing generic chord progressions and singing cringe lyrics about teenagers (gross coming for almost 40 year olds)

Vs another pop punk made up of actual teenagers that spend all day practicing so they know how to play their instruments really well. The kids are always gonna win. Is what it is


r/musicians • • May 12 '25

I can’t stand using a click track.

0 Upvotes

I’m not saying I can’t stay on rhythm. I’m saying I like working with rhythm-keepers that speed up, slow down, and otherwise change things around as the feeling of the music makes them inclined to do so.

There’s something that feels really constricting about having to stay at a perfect pace at any given moment. Something inorganic about it, like it’s too perfect, too manufactured rather than handcrafted. I’ve never heard a drummer play something highly technical while staying on perfect time with a click track and said to myself “wow that’s impressive”. I say “wow that’s impressive” when drummers play something impressive while also letting the music take them on a journey.

Am I alone in this? It’s become an actual point of contention when I’m working with other musicians. We write something that we really like, and then we go to record it using what we have and they put a click track on and I swear it’s like I get taken out of it completely. The few times I’ve convinced them to just do one take without it, it comes out fine far more often than it doesn’t, but when we’re recording like that we’re just trading their comfort for my own.

EDIT: Hey there, bud. Before you comment saying something to the effect of “playing to a click and having a groove aren’t mutually exclusive”, first of all, who hurt you? Second of all, please check the comments because… drum roll… I agree! I was trying to just state a preference, not say that anything is better or that something can’t happen with a click.

EDIT 2: Also, I’m not saying that I have perfect internal time. I don’t. I’m just saying that perfect time doesn’t really interest me in a rhythm section. In fact, I far prefer a rhythm section that lets their internal rhythm take them where it goes. That’s all. I’m not better than anyone.


r/musicians • • Oct 16 '25

Finally am in the perfect band. No more flaking, no more hobbyists holding things back, no more mediocre hobbyist in general

0 Upvotes

I am so in love cause for the first time i dont have to carry the whole ship here. I dont have to come up with every part or book everything. These guys actually know people. I advise everyone on here to look for a good unit. Stop dealing with anxiety filled losers that get nothing done


r/musicians • • Aug 25 '24

Sick Of Musicians Using Backing Tracks

25 Upvotes

Don’t know if this is just where I am but all I see are musicians using backing tracks. They turn the backing tracks up really loud as well so you can hardly hear their instruments or singing, it just seems super lazy and inauthentic. But they’re still getting paid! Is this music now! It’s just karaoke except you can hardly hear the vocalist(s).

This feels so wrong because a musical performance is meant to be live, not pre-recorded! Do people actually like this? As a musician I can’t stand it but I’ve seen a lot over the past few years.

As for solo performers who can’t find other people I still think many of us would rather listen to an acoustic performance than a full backing track hiding the singing and playing of the performer. Plus the variation in timing is what makes a live performance engaging, not just following a backing track, there’s no emotion I feel. I’ve never seen this backing track thing pulled off well either. It’s especially bad with drums as there is no human feel and it never sounds as good as a live drum set being played.

This is crushing because how about all the musicians who don’t hide behind a backing track and have to actually sing and play their instruments well? They’re having to compete with this. I hate this lack of creativity,

Do you think it’s just pubs which allow this? Do you think actual music venues like the cavern club would not allow backing tracks?

I do wish to say that maybe having the odd pre-recorded instrument playing can be ok (I wouldn’t personally but there may be a situation where it’s ok). But I’m talking about acts which have the full karaoke backing tracks playing, some even feature the same instruments as which the band are playing like lead guitar. And they keep the harmonies in from the backing track. I’m hoping this is just local pubs.

Sorry for the rant but it’s just been on my mind recently

I’m open to other opinions and would love to hear your thoughts on full backing tracks being used by musicians.


r/musicians • • Aug 23 '24

The delusion of grandeur expressed by the modern day bedroom producer is extremely aggravating.

123 Upvotes

I hate the idea that ordinary people will see the “easy” lifestyle of any prevalent artist and then think that they can make it themselves. so many talentless musicians fill my instagram feed with “don’t miss out on our tour!” “big things coming!” and on feedback forums/channels it’s so bad. like dude shut up and make something good in silence. You think that just because the economy is shit and you don’t know how to be innovative that music will save you from financial misery?

I immediately dislike anyone who is involved in music for reasons other than unity, creation, curiosity, and fulfillment. maybe a few other reasons, you can assume the rest. MONEY comes AFTER a breakthrough, if you so wish. Influencers who make content for musicians on how to make an “algorithm friendly” beat pisses me the fuck off.

it takes a certain individual to create good art. if you feel it within, i’m so happy for you. if you have a business degree and then decide the doors in front of you are too difficult to open so you turn to music, I think you should seriously consider slapping yourself in the face.

Am I the only one who feels this sort of veiled resentment for imposters?

edit- can someone here explain the divide between people who agree with my post, and those who are losing their shit over it?

I seriously don’t understand why so many people here think that my opinion is a huge chip on my shoulder.

My concern has nothing to do with young, naive musicians. in a way I still am myself. i’m basically saying that, those who pursue music KNOWING their soul belongs to a different trade should stop “clogging the system” as some here have put it. It must be a hard concept for people to wrap their head around, that there are tons of bands and projects out there who are backed by scum. Who hasn’t met scum? anyone here?

I thought the tone of my post made it obvious i’m exaggerating. who could actually be as angry as the character I portrayed. it’s obviously irony-tinged ragebait. that’s just how I do things on reddit.

there’s a horde outside of my home right now. torches, picketers holding things that say, “I can’t beat” looks a lot like those things that went down in 2020.


r/musicians • • Feb 06 '26

I absolutely loathe singer songwriter stuff for some reason. Specifically just one vocal and acoustic. I can't explain why but I literally don't like a single song I've ever heard in this format

0 Upvotes

I don't know if it's that every singer songwriter sounds like a complete self absorbed narcissist or complaining in a sorrowful way about their past experiences and regrets? idk...its the most downer music I can think of and I fucking can't stand it. surely I'm not alone in this thought? also reddits newest update is annoying as it doesn't capitalize every sentences first word and you can't see WHT you're typing without scrolling


r/musicians • • Mar 31 '25

Is 40 too old to continue to play, write and preform music?

25 Upvotes

Hi everyone hope you all are doing well. I’m a 38yr old musician with a band. I’ve been doing this group since i was 28 so about 10 yrs for this specific group but I’ve been writing and playing since i was 14. I guess my question is, when should i call it quits? This group i have now has had some success but honestly not enough to financially justify the amount of money and time I’ve put into it. I’ve made nothing back and have broken even on the few occasions I’ve been lucky. It feels like I’m throwing money into a fire pit these days. Should i continue or stop? I can’t seem to make a decision and it’s plaques me most days. Any advice would be greatly appreciated.


r/musicians • • May 31 '26 This

Owner from Hell.

11 Upvotes

Yall I wanted to share a story about my gig tonight.

I took a 3 hour set as I wasn’t booked this Saturday, but my previously scheduled plans allowed my to take something.

I took this gig on 2 days notice (for cheaper than normal) for a little exposure. Upon arrival I was told that I HAVE to use the house system, which is completely overkill for acoustic sets. I grinned and bore the fact that I would sound like shit through a Pyle 8 channel system direct into a LD PA vs my Bose that I have dialed in for myself.

I start jamming and immediately start getting attention from passers by who stop in because I’m playing. Hell the bar across the street had people clapping.

That’s when I was hit with the most disrespectful act from the bar owner. He walked over and reached across the railing of the fence and turned down the shitty PA system without even introducing himself.

I sat there completely shocked and decided to play a particular Cee Lo Green song, before packing up my stuff and leaving less than an hour into the gig.

All this for a low paying gig on 2 days notice. Don’t play for cheap, don’t be a doormat. Personally, my self-respect is worth more than 200 bucks.


r/musicians • • Aug 30 '25

Gave an opportunity to a musician whos been overlooked by the scene for years and this is how it went

112 Upvotes

So basically I throw shows from time to time in the Austin tx area and last night i threw a real banger. Got 2 really well known country acts to headline along with 3 openers and we sold out a whole lawn.

First guy opening i hand picked. His name is john and id seen him plucking his guitar and singing his heart out in local bars all over tx for over a decade. He grew up here obviously.

Day of the show i get a mass text chain from john. Hes asking me what tuning his guitar would sound best in, how many guest lists he can bring, how much time does he have, etc.

I told him all the info he asked and then an hour before doors he told me he had anxiety and didnt know if he can make it

He ends up making it and playing for 15 mins and off stage gets really persistent about the pay and honestly being really pushy. Gave him his $100 and sent him on his way. It turns out he got black out drunk at the bar that night and groped multiple women leading to him getting KO cold by one of the bfs. I dont what to do anymore.


r/musicians • • Sep 15 '25

Is this a subreddit for all musicians than why are posts talking about touring and gigging met with such hostility in the comments and downvoted to oblivion

5 Upvotes

r/musicians • • Aug 16 '25

Being called rude for having standards. Am i wrong for not wanting to start projects with bedroom musicians when i clearly state i seek out musicians with live band history

0 Upvotes

Im a drummer from LA and unfortunately the groups i made music with for years(moderate success) have all disbanded or moved on from music. I on the other hand am still tryna be active in a band so ive been posting the best vids of my playing online and reaching out to my irl connects at the same time.

Ive gotten offers but most are from bedroom musicians or beginners. i am not tryna knock anyone but im 10 years experienced already. Some musician friend have told me im rude and give everyone a chance. But i already know with most bedroom musicians or beginners it takes literal years before they get with the program or they just move on from music


r/musicians • • Sep 03 '24

Our culture loves music but hates musicians

392 Upvotes

I "made it" but what i experience is such bullshit:

People have spent thousands on seeing me play live/merch/etc, and yet nobody actually respects my talent past the show theyre at or past while they listen to my work. People straight up dont care if i get paid like they do when they do work, but they always want more music and shows from me. Fuck you ya worthless Americans and your unfounded jaded mentality where you somehow deserve free music even though we pay to make it + sweat equity and all the while this culture looks down on us. Fuck. You.


r/musicians • • Mar 02 '25

Stop charging hourly rates for music lessons! We can do better...

0 Upvotes

I think musicians are criminally undercharging for music lessons.

All the time I see people offering lessons for anywhere from $25 - $60 per lesson, and still charging by the hour!

Hourly rates make it so difficult to make a sustainable living from teaching because it introduces so many problems (cancellations etc.)

So many are afraid to charge what they are worth because they think people won't pay but the truth is, people will pay for good private music education.

Switch to a monthly fee, raise your rates and see what happens, I bet you would be surprised how many people will say yes.

Higher rates also incentivise you to become a better teacher because you're actually being paid what you're worth!

I made a video about this here: https://youtu.be/W6Z_hlXgwZo

I'm curious what you think.


r/musicians • • Jul 21 '26

Happy 62nd Birthday Chris Cornell!

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/musicians • • Nov 15 '25

How depressing is the dominance of cover bands?

18 Upvotes

I know it’s a way to make money, but man. So damn sad.


r/musicians • • Jul 10 '25

People who claim the music scene is just favoritism or friend based nepotism,maybe those people earned their opportunities

2 Upvotes

Coming from the punk diy it was very common for bands to throw their own shows and also other bands gigs. A band that you see opening first slot, their singer probably set up the entire show. Their guitar player made all the flyers. Theres a lot of thankless that go on within a music scene.


r/musicians • • Dec 21 '24

My drummer cannot drum to any guitar riff I write.

0 Upvotes

For context I am a guitarist and my buddy is a drummer. He has been a drummer for a decade. Whenever we jam and I play a guitar riff, he struggles to play the drums to it.

Specifically he tries to find a beat at first, but he ends up only hitting the snare drum off beat to start his drum line. Most songs I hear have the snare getting hit on a specific part of the guitar riff to make it pop, he hits the snare drum every beat.

How do I explain to him that I need him to play a beat relative to the riff and not just keep a time signature every second? I am playing in 4:4 constantly so I think it shouldn’t be that hard to find a beat and not just hit the snare drum every beat. Yet I am just a guitarist and do not know much about drums, so how do I explain to him in terms that we will both understand? Thanks


r/musicians • • Dec 10 '24

Confusion over AI made music vs. music

3 Upvotes

A little while back I responded to someone who felt very discouraged about trying so hard to make music and felt why bother if they have to compete with AI made music. He felt AI was going to take over.

Just now I am seeing a thread that is discouraging me because too many responses are indicating that people cannot determine the distinction between the two. So, I am going to break it down, the same way I did to the above mentioned person, for any of you who are failing to understand exactly what music is:

Al created music will never surpass music created by people when it comes to those who understand real music and take it seriously.

Al music is created with algorithms and the more successful it is the more it is evident that people are sheep. Music keeps cycling as time goes on because individuals continue to come up with new and original ideas, which are not formulaic. Al will never be able to do that because algorithms are based on what has already happened.

Music is a form of expression. AI cannot express itself. It has no emotions or thoughts. Music comes from the soul. Let me remind those of you who forgot, or have never been told and do not know, the fact that music comes from the soul is so true that it is the name of an entire genre that can NEVER be duplicated. It's pretty simple really.


r/musicians • • Dec 14 '25

Whatchagonnado?

3 Upvotes

1999 - Napster arrives and all the hipster’s in their teens and twenties think it’s great. “Music should be free!” they cried.

2025 - Music is free and all the musicians in their teens and twenties are crying “I can’t make a living playing music!”


r/musicians • • May 21 '26

Why isn't the voice considered an instrument?

0 Upvotes

I was looking at another post in r/musicians and there were comments about singers being "a dime a dozen" or "they're just a singer do they don't really understand a musician's craft".

I (41f) am a vocalist but I also play other instruments. But I remember a jazz vocalist friend who doesn't play other instruments but who has an incredible voice and career, still encountered this mentality from her bandmates who were "serious jazz musicians unlike her." She had been developing her voice for years, studied vocal performance at postgrad level, and does a serious amount of maintenance and preparation of her voice to maintain her stamina.

Training and taking care of your voice is a craft. There's a lot of technique and skill that goes into a great vocal performance. The lead singer's voice can make or break a band.

The voice is an instrument and I question the motive or mindset behind the idea that it isn't. Sometimes I wonder if it's because vocalists are often female that it's under-valued.


r/musicians • • Jul 06 '25

If you know, you know.

Post image
90 Upvotes

r/musicians • • Feb 22 '26

We tried recording our rehearsals. Here's why it died for us.

0 Upvotes

Hi r/musicians,

A few days ago I posted about some ideas I was bouncing around in order to tackle some problems we were facing regarding our rehearsal structure.

You guys came up with a LOT of ideas and suggestions for my band, and almost 80% of you recommended that we start recording our rehearsals. Thank you for that!

Thing is, we DID actually record our rehearsals a while back, but it came to a halt because I honestly found it to be a bit tedious. After every rehearsal I would take my USB drive back home and do the following:

  1. Import into Audacity

  2. Split the clip up and cut out all the talking in between songs

  3. Apply some basic normalization

  4. Export each song and give it a title

  5. Upload to Google Drive and keep a good structure so it doesn't get lost

  6. Communicate via Messenger that the recordings are now available

  7. Get a few thumbs-up reactions on that message

..And then it just.. dies... We didn't really have a structure in place to create notes from the individual songs, solos, intros etc.

I took my original idea and almost scrapped 100% of the app I had already almost built. I'm now working on something new;

A site that lets you upload your full rehearsal audio, and in one go get automatically split clips which you can then map to the songs you play in your band (you might play Wonderwall 8 times in a row - who knows). You can then drag timeslots on the waveform of these clips and create notes and tasks, which can then be assigned to the individual members of your band.

I'm almost ready to show it to the public, and can't wait to let you guys try it out.

Does this seem like something you'd be interested in? Are you experiencing any of the pains I'm describing here, and if so; would an app like this help?

Very curious to learn about y'alls workflows on this.

Thanks in advance!


r/musicians • • Jan 30 '25

Why didn’t I make the band?

3 Upvotes

Hello, everyone. I’m a 23 year old male drummer who’s been playing drums for about 12 years. I teach percussion lessons once a week at a high school and twice a week at Music and Arts. I also play in two bands (one jazz, one funk), but we typically have about one show every 1-2 months.

Two months ago, I auditioned for an indie rock band with ~80k listeners on Spotify and a decent sized fan base in my city. These guys are all my age and we all went to the same university (I graduated one year before them). I thought the audition went great. I played two of their songs and I didn’t miss a single beat. However, a couple weeks later their guitarist informed me that they were gonna roll with another drummer.

I felt pretty confident in my playing ability; I majored in music and had play drums since I was 11. So, I asked him if there was anything specifically I needed to work on and he said, “You played great. You’re a funny guy. Honestly it didn’t come down to just drumming. We were really impressed, there were just a lot of other factors that went into us going another direction.”

I didn’t ask for any further explanation, because I felt like it wasn’t my place. But I’ve actually been pretty torn up about it since then. Indie music is my jam. Jazz and funk are great and all, but I’ve seen myself as an indie/rock musician. In the process of overthinking, I’ve come down to 3 possible answers to what these “other factors” may be:

1: I have a “job”. I told them I work teaching music. But I made it very clear that I did not want to be a music teacher for the rest of my life. I make my own schedule and I work in the mornings from 8-11. Even then, I could always switch my lesson times with my high schoolers. Also, Music and Arts allows gig leave, so I let them know that me working wouldn’t ire at all with making music with them. To be frank, I’d even leave my job to make music. But, I worry that me even saying I had a job turned them off to the idea of letting me in the band. I think they may have been looking for someone with a lot more free time on their hands, but idk.

2. I don’t have recording experience. They had asked me during the audition if I had any experience recording songs. I told them I didn’t have much; I was in a garage rock band in university for a couple months and we only recorded 5 songs in our bassists living room. Additionally, I played drums for a musical at our college and we recorded the soundtrack at a local recording studio, but it was one day for 3 hours and that was it. This band had multiple songs out on Spotify, and their top song just hit 2 millions streams. I feel like the idea of recruiting some “studio newbie” to come an play for them didn’t sound appealing.

3. (The big one which is probably the only factor) I have a Bible verse in my Instagram bio. I’ve been a Christian for a while, but I never give off that impression whenever I’m hanging out with people. I have a Bible verse in my Instagram bio because it does mean something to me (the Bible verse isn’t even one that could be interpreted to mean anything hateful), but I’m not one to flood my stories with scripture and Christ-like messages (I post a lot of memes on my story). Many people actually meet me, hang out with me, see my instagram and say, “oh, you’re a Christian? Interesting.” I’m worried that that’s the REAL reason that they didn’t want me in their band. While none of them have any religious evidence in their social media profiles, I honestly have no clue as to whether or not they have any sort of beliefs, but I’m pretty sure they want to keep it that way. They’re an indie band. I worry that it’s just because of my bio that they denied me a spot in their band. They probably don’t want any of their fans thinking that they hold certain beliefs, or they simply want to keep anything political/religious/controversial out of their music. And I totally get that and don’t have a problem with that. It’s just like… what am I supposed to do if that IS the reason? I don’t care if any of them or all of them aren’t Christian. The majority of my friends from college are atheist. But I feel like they simply didn’t want to just say “hey, we like you but if you join our band, we’d like you to take that Bible verse out of your bio”. Who would wanna say that tbh? It would make sense if that was the reason; why would they just say “other factors” instead of “we’re looking for someone who just has more time or more recording experience”? Does this make sense? Is this why I didn’t make the band? Is it a collection of all three?

And what do I do now? Should I take the Bible verse out of Instagram bio if I ever want to make it as a rock musician? I don’t mind at all, but some people who I’ve talked about this with have said, “No dude, stand by your beliefs. If you didn’t present yourself as some religious fanatic when you auditioned, it shouldn’t have mattered to them. It’s all about your ability and your vibe.” But I still feel unsure. In the audition, we all joked around. We talked about dark memes. There was crude humor shared amongst all of us. We all spoke some cuss words. Ranted about college. I wasn’t intentionally trying to be “edgy”; that’s just how I am. The vibes were off the charts. But is that one Bible verse what’s keeping me from making it? And if so, is it worth just changing? Or is there a completely different line of reasoning as to why I didn’t get in that I’m just missing entirely.

TL;DR: I didn’t make a band. I’m sad. Is it because I have a job, don’t have much studio experience, I have a Bible verse on my Instagram, or anything else? If so, what should I do to change this outcome moving forward so I can finally play the music I wanna play? Or should I just start a band of my own?


r/musicians • • Oct 10 '25

Putting together a list of Venues in the USA and how much they. WHY??? keep reading

0 Upvotes

UPDATE: THIS IS SPECIFICALLY FOR BARS AND RESTAURANTS THAT HIRE COVER BANDS.

LIST LINK IN THE COMMENTS

why? because I am sick of bookers lying about how much venues pay and getting 200% more than the musicians.. or greedy singers making $800 while the musicians get paid $200 and lying that that's what the venue pays.

This way when you get a gig offer, you can see the approximate the venue pays, and this way you can negotiate your price. ENOUGH IS ENOUGH!!! Musicians screwing over other musicians for their own benefit when they are not bringing audience at all at everyone is getting there at the same time and playing the same dumb covers should not be a thing! If you wanna earn double me or three times more.. have an audience.

I COULD MAKE THE LIST PUBLIC FOR EDIT, but I'm afraid it'll get destroyed.