Last updated November 2026. I went back through this post, fixed the parts that were wrong or out of date, and added ListenBrainz and the newer Lidarr companion apps. Changelog is at the bottom.
So you cancelled Spotify, Apple Music, Tidal, or whatever you were paying for, and now you have a local library and no idea where new music is supposed to come from. People found music for decades before recommendation engines existed, and the tools for doing it yourself are better now than they have ever been. This is how I'd rebuild the discovery habit without resubscribing.
1. The old ways still work
Radio. College, community, and freeform stations are programmed by DJs who play records because they like them. WFMU (freeform, New Jersey) and KEXP (listener-supported, Seattle) are the two everyone names, but your local college station deserves a try too. Nearly all of them stream online and post playlists, so if something catches your ear you can look it up by timestamp later. NTS does the same thing as an internet-only station.
Record stores. Read the staff picks wall. Dig through the used bins. Five dollars on a record with a great cover from a band you've never heard of pays off more often than it should. If there's no store near you, Discogs is the closest thing to flipping through bins online. Record Store Day Black Friday is November 27 this year if you need an excuse to go.
Shows. Get there for the openers. Somebody booked the opener because they fit the headliner you already paid to see. Showing up early costs nothing extra, and most nights you'll walk out with at least one new name to look up.
Labels. When you find an artist you love, check who released the record and work through the rest of the catalog. Sub Pop, Dischord, Relapse, 4AD, Warp, Touch and Go, Hydra Head, Def Jux. A few of those have closed or gone quiet, but the back catalogs still map out a whole scene. Discogs and MusicBrainz both let you browse by label.
Reviews and liner notes. Pitchfork, AllMusic, The Wire, The Quietus, Stereogum, and Bandcamp Daily all still review records. Liner notes are the less obvious source: thank-you lists, producers, guest players, who engineered it. On MusicBrainz, the relationships on an artist page show every other band the members have played in.
People. Genre subreddits, Discord servers, RYM lists and boards. Someone obsessive about one genre will beat collaborative filtering every time. Find where your genre hangs out and read the new release threads.
2. Feeding Lidarr
One thing up front: Lidarr manages and monitors a library. It doesn't recommend anything. Discovery comes from what you point it at.
MusicBrainz. All of Lidarr's metadata comes from MusicBrainz. Once you add an artist, Lidarr tracks their releases, limited to the release types in your metadata profile. If EPs or live albums aren't showing up, check that profile first. MusicBrainz has no "similar artists" feature (that's ListenBrainz, below). What it does well for discovery is relationships: members' other projects, label rosters, and series.
Import lists. These are the built-in types under Settings > Import Lists:
Last.fm User. Pulls artists from a user's listening history or loved tracks. It can be your account or anyone's whose taste you trust.
Last.fm Tag. Top artists for a genre or style tag.
MusicBrainz Series.
Spotify Followed Artists, Playlists, and Saved Albums. These have been unreliable this year after changes on Spotify's side. Check r/Lidarr for the current state before you spend an evening troubleshooting.
Lidarr Lists, Headphones, another Lidarr instance.
Custom List. Any URL that returns a JSON array of MusicBrainz IDs. This is how most third-party tools hook in.
There is no built-in "similar artists" list. Lists also sync slowly on purpose, so treat them as "add eventually" and be patient.
Last.fm. Scrobble everything you play. After a few weeks the recommendations page and the similar artists on any artist page get useful, and they come from what you actually listen to. Then point a Last.fm User import list at your own account and Lidarr picks up the artists you keep going back to.
ListenBrainz. This is the biggest thing missing from the original post. It's the open source scrobbling service from the MusicBrainz people, and it can import your Last.fm history. Every Monday it builds you a Weekly Exploration playlist of tracks you haven't heard and a Weekly Jams playlist of things you have. The Fresh Releases page shows new albums, filtered to your taste if you want. It also shows you users with similar listening, and browsing their top artists is a good way to lose an afternoon.
Lidarr companion apps. A handful of self-hosted tools now sit beside Lidarr and handle the recommending:
Sonobarr. Takes your Lidarr artists, asks Last.fm for similar ones, and can seed from your ListenBrainz Weekly Exploration playlist. Adds what you approve back to Lidarr.
Mixarr. Pulls from Last.fm, ListenBrainz, Spotify, Tidal, Deezer, and others, then gives you a review queue so nothing gets added without your say.
Aurral. Artist discovery and request manager for Lidarr, built on your library, tags, and Last.fm.
MusicSeerr. An Overseerr-style request and discovery front end for Lidarr.
Explo. Grabs your ListenBrainz playlists and fetches the tracks from Soulseek or YouTube. It doesn't need Lidarr at all.
These are all young projects. Read the repo before you point one at your library.
Rate Your Music. RYM has the deepest genre tree anywhere, and the charts for a narrow subgenre and year range will turn up records no algorithm will. You can export your own ratings and catalog as a CSV from your profile. Charts have no official export, there is no API, and scraping is against the terms of service and can get your account banned. So read the charts like a person and add what you find by hand.
beets. If you run beets next to Lidarr, the lastgenre and fetchart plugins ship with it and fill in genres and cover art. They help with tagging more than discovery, but good genre tags make your own library easier to explore.
3. Other sources
Bandcamp. Follow fans whose collections you like and your feed turns into a list of what they're buying. The recommendations at the bottom of album pages and the genre tag pages are good for artists with real audiences and no algorithmic reach. Bandcamp Friday, when Bandcamp waives its cut, has eight dates in 2026. The last one this year is December 4. Purchases download as FLAC, and from there it's a manual import into Lidarr or a beets import.
Every Noise at Once. Glenn McDonald's genre map at everynoise.com. He was laid off from Spotify in December 2023 and lost the data access that kept the site current, so it's now a frozen snapshot and a lot of the interactive parts are dead. The map is still the best way I know to see which genres sit next to the ones you already like. Take the genre names somewhere else to find the music.
AllMusic and Discogs. AllMusic artist pages list similar artists, influences, and followers, all picked by editors. Discogs is better for credits: who played on what, which producer keeps turning up on records you like, what else came out on the same label that year. Start with an artist you know and keep clicking.
YouTube and yt-dlp. Label channels, full live sets, and mix channels are good for scouting, and YouTube's recommendations are decent once you're deep in niche content. The audio is lossy, so I treat it as a way to hear something before I go find a proper copy.
Soulseek. Browse the shares of a user who has something obscure you already love. You'll find forty albums you've never heard of in ten minutes. It leans toward niche genres, bootlegs, and out-of-print material, which is exactly what streaming services never carried.
The short version: scrobble everything, follow labels and people instead of playlists, let Lidarr handle the monitoring, and buy from Bandcamp when you can. It takes more effort than opening an app, and it gets you a lot further.
Community additions
Thanks to everyone in the comments. I rechecked these in November 2026.
r/obscuremusicthatslaps. A subreddit that is exactly what it sounds like. (via u/sgdonovan79)
Record store mailing lists. Turntable Lab and Forced Exposure send regular emails with new arrivals and staff picks. Support your local shop too. (via u/cideron)
scrobblerad.io. A web radio player focused on indie, college, and listener-supported stations around the world, and it scrobbles what you hear. I described this one wrong the first time. It doesn't build radio from your Last.fm history. (via u/malist42)
thejazztome.info. Liner notes and reviews for around 700 jazz albums, browsable by year, label, writer, and artist. Still being updated. (via u/atgrogg)
zig-zag.fm. A discovery tool built around hopping from one release to the next, still in early access. The commenter says it draws on Discogs data. (via u/c2prods)
hiresaudio.online. A site covering hi-res and CD-quality audio, including lossless internet radio stations. Handy if you run a WiiM or another network player. (via u/jonnieggg)
di.fm. Around since 1999, with channels for house, trance, drum and bass, ambient, and dozens of subgenres. (for u/trav_is86)
SoulSync. This has grown a lot since I first listed it. It monitors artists, builds its own Release Radar and Discovery Weekly style playlists, mirrors playlists from Spotify, Tidal, Qobuz, and Deezer, downloads what's missing from Soulseek and other sources, and works with Plex, Jellyfin, or Navidrome. (via u/BoulderBadgeDad)
LLM gap analysis. Export your collection as a text file, ask an LLM what's missing based on what you own, and add the good suggestions to Lidarr. Check everything it suggests against MusicBrainz, because these models will invent albums. (via u/cocineroylibro)
Changelog, November 2026
Rewrote the Lidarr import list section. The first version claimed a Last.fm "similar to" list, Last.fm top charts, and MusicBrainz collections. None of those exist. It also said Spotify playlists needed community scripts, when they are built in.
Removed the claim that MusicBrainz has similar artists.
Removed Last.fm groups. Those went away in the 2015 redesign.
Fixed the RYM section. There is no chart export, and scraping is against their terms.
Fixed the Headphones description. Lidarr is a fork of Sonarr, and Headphones is a separate, older project.
Updated Every Noise at Once, which has been a static snapshot since December 2023.
Corrected the scrobblerad.io description and refreshed the other community links.
Added ListenBrainz, the Lidarr companion apps, and a few more sources.
u/Junior_Lake pointed out in the comments that the original read like an AI list. That was fair. It was drafted with AI help, and some of the errors above got through because of it. This version has been checked line by line. If something is still wrong, say so and I'll fix it.