r/murakami • • Aug 05 '24

Stop reading murakami's books

10 Upvotes

Like come on, if you gonna complain about murakami's books on the sexual parts and the weird sexual parts or on the way he writes about females in a sexual way then please stop reading his books bcs you're complaining about a japanese writer who was born in 1949, who again wrote and published his books in the late 70's and who lived in a different generation with a different mindset and a different prespective in life.


r/murakami • • Aug 31 '26

Main Characters

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

I have a feeling that all of Murakami's main characters follow the same personality framework: introverted, non-chalant, observant, with little to no judgment of situations. Whereas all female characters feel like different people.

I am now halfway through "The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle," having recently finished "Sputnik Sweetheart" and "Norwegian Wood." Okada Toru, Watanabe Toru, and K feel like exactly the same characters to me. I don't think it's necessarily bad, I just did not take any pause between these 3 books, so now being halfway through The Wind-up Bird Chronicles I feel a little tired.

Do you guys feel the same about Murakami's MC?

Pictures of me holding my physical copy šŸ«”šŸ‘


r/murakami • • Jan 04 '24

the elephant in the room - murakami’s boob obsession NSFW

0 Upvotes

I’m not sure how I don’t see more people talk about this, but I think the way Murakami portrays women in his books is perverted and a little difficult to stomach. I’ve heard so many great things about this guy, so i read 1Q84 and Killing Commendatore. I do like his writing style a lot, and I want to like him. but the boob obsession is fucking weird. Almost every time a new female character is introduced, it comes along with a weirdly detailed description of her boob shape and size. Often, the main characters will have girlfriends that are never referred to as their names, just ā€œmy older married girlfriendā€ / ā€œmy married girlfriendā€ or a variation of that. I read 1Q84 first, and thought Tengo was maybe just like that as a character, but in Killing Commendatore it was the same thing. It also happens with minors. In 1Q84 the girl was 17 and the guy was in his 30s, which made me uncomfortable, but I let it slide. It felt like every time the 17 year old girl was brought up, an in depth description of how her boobs looked in her shirt that day followed. Then in Killing Commendatore, similar thing - but 13 year old girl, 40s (?) guy. He was ALWAYS talking about how her breasts looked and whether they were developing. I guess I just don’t understand how you guys can look past this and enjoy his work. It’s just so creepy.


r/murakami • • Aug 13 '24

I hate The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle

4 Upvotes

I know this is one of the favourite books of a lot of people, but, honestly, I found it really boring. I like the topic of the book and the story is not bad, but why did he have to write 900 pages?? I've read long books like the Magic Mountain of Thomas Mann and I loved them, so the length is not the problem. The problem is that is very very very boring. I'd like to ask people who loved it, what did you found interesting in it to keep turning pages enjoying it?


r/murakami • • Dec 15 '24

Unpopular opinion?

2 Upvotes

I read a couple of books by Haruki Murakami. My first read was Men without women. Found the concept of that book really different, so I decided to read more of his works. Next I think I read The Birthday Girl, followed by the Kafka on the shore and the Norwegian Woods. So, the more I read his work, the more I have disliked his work. I found the elements in his work repetitive and failed to understand occurrence of some parts, maybe that is the reason why I was not able to connect much to his writing.


r/murakami • • Nov 09 '24

Does Toru rape Naoko in Norwegian Wood? NSFW Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Not sure if this is a wild theory, but after finishing and re-reading Norwegian Wood, I came to the conclusion that Toru raped Naoko. I’m mostly basing this off the line she says to Reiko towards the end, ā€œI never want to be violated like that again,ā€ referring to the time her and Toru had sex. The chapter where they do have sex, Naoko is drunk and extremely emotional, and Toru seems to take advantage of this heightened emotional state to have sex with her. Afterwards, Naoko needs to leave Tokyo to the mental sanitarium, obviously to deal with underlying trauma and mental health issues, but also as a result of Toru raping her. Of course they had an intensely romantic relationship following that night, and Toru seemed to genuinely care and love for her. Naoko also seems to care about him, but I returned to the first chapter where he says that ā€œNaoko never loved me.ā€ Towards the end, it seems like Naokos mental health has deteriorated significantly but also she has a clearer perception of her past with Toru. Any thoughts on this?


r/murakami • • Apr 26 '21

Wind up bird chronical is too wordy

1 Upvotes

I've just started reading it, my kindle tells me I'm 24 % through it only so far. I'm at the part where the leftinent tells his background story in the war setup.

And don't get me wrong, before this chapter I was really into it and it had my attention. But I just can't stop thinking about how this chapter is so wordy, and hasn't gotten to a real point all this while.

I feel like I'm losing interest, and I've read a couple of Murakami books and they have my heart, and that's the only reason I'm sticking around.

But it's been three days since I am at this chapter. I just can't seem to keep myself glued to this. Whenever I start, I don't feel like going along and I stop.


r/murakami • • Dec 19 '24

The wind up bird chronicle-least favourite

0 Upvotes

I've read almost all of Murakami's novels but I have to say The wind up bird was the most disappointing. I finished it quickly and sometimes couldn't put it down, that said, reading it was fun, but overall I was left with a "what the fuck was that" feeling. I think it was there theeee most gruesome and violent book and I was so desperately waiting for things to tie together but it felt like he just dropped a bunch of lore in the last couple paragraphs and left it at that.

Book 1 and 2 i found were much "better" than book 3. Book 3 i was just sort of lost? I mean, i get that all his books give you that feeling but idk this one felt different. And some parts of the story i really wanted to know more (like with "what happened in the night" , or May kasahara's boyfriend or Cinnamon- which btw was cinnamon the boy in "what happened in the night????) but they felt abandoned.

The juice of it for me is this: i liked reading it, I didnt like how it came together.


r/murakami • • Mar 31 '22

Finished Kafka On the Shore. Not impressed. Spoiler

12 Upvotes

This is my seventh Murakami book, so I’m well aware his work isn’t meant to be rationalized; it’s more you either understand this feeling/experience or you don’t, but I just really didn’t enjoy Kafka on the Shore even though it’s one of his most well known books.

To me this story just seems to have absolutely no cohesion and therefore no real purpose. I got bored because the story kinda seemed to be random ideas thrown together. There’s the pointless cat torture scene with a random flute man who we barely hear about again. Then as always there has to be the weird sexual dynamic included in every Murakami book. This is actually my least favorite thing about his writing. It’s so repetitive and uncomfortable that you can’t help but feel it’s Murakami’s own obsession.

The dream rape scene, the meaningless connection between the old man Nakata who lost all his knowledge in the woods during the war and Kafka, the sexual relationship between his mother (?) and her 15 year old self and his sister, and the hinting that Kafka is actually his own mother’s lover somehow in some time warp, all just kind of made a perfect recipe for a disappointing book. Maybe i’m missing something?


r/murakami • • Oct 13 '25

Has he ever NOT been gross to girls/women? Gimme a list PLEASE.

0 Upvotes

Ok I love Murakami and have read many of his novels and short stories but I'm really done with enduring his needless over sexualization of every female character in almost everything he's ever written. No female character is safe, not children, not the elderly, especially not women my age. So I'm just wondering if anybody here can list off some of his work where he's not super gross to girls/women PLEASE and THANK YOU. I'd actually like to continue reading his work for some reason.


r/murakami • • Jul 17 '25

Giving up on 1Q84

7 Upvotes

I really enjoyed Kafka on the Shore, finding it super readable. Interesting characters, immersive descriptions, good dialogue - both inner thoughts and conversations. The ending didn’t land for me but whatever.

I liked Hard Boiled Wonderland and the End of the World even better. The shadow was my favorite character, oddly enough, but anyway an easy and interesting read trying to puzzle out how the 2 stories would fit together and what was really going on. Also not crazy about the ending here, but I started to think maybe Murakami’s books are like Lost or Game of Thrones - fun in the telling but just not able to stick the landing.

Now I’m miserable with 1Q84 and bailing on it. A real slog for me, not enjoyable at all. I don’t like anybody in it. Wound up at one point flipping pages to skip an absurdly long description of the history of a cult compound. Reality seems to be off a bit, and I really wanted to care about that but it just couldn’t draw me in. Seriously too much rambling with no consequences or progression for long periods.

I’d like to give the author another try and would appreciate a good recommendation based on my experience so far. Many people like 1Q84, so maybe I’m just difficult.


r/murakami • • Jul 15 '22

1q84 is grossing me out

0 Upvotes

I'm 650 pages in and I'm not sure if i can continue. I could stomach Kafka on the Shore but 1q84 is just a nasty read for me. If I continue am I going to get some form of explanation as to why so much pre menstrual sex is happening? It's not fun, or intriguing anymore


r/murakami • • Nov 22 '25

Why does everybody hate Haruki Murakami

4 Upvotes

every time I tell someone who my favorite author is, they look at me like I just said something controversial


r/murakami • • Feb 16 '26

Short Chapter from My Story

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

This is a short writing for one of the chapters from my story. Since there is a mention of Murakami's work within this writing, I don't know if it's appropriate to post them here.

I wanna know what could be the critique (or review) of this writing.

English is not my first language, so sorry for any mistake appeared within this post.

Edit: this writing is the translation from the original language into English.


r/murakami • • Apr 16 '26

i read: WHAT I TALK ABOUT WHEN I TALK ABOUT RUNNING

3 Upvotes

I don't like recommending and being recommended books. I feel when it comes to books, people should stumble upon them rather than being directed. There is a sense of satisfaction when you truly discover a great book by yourself. At least this the case for me. The same goes for music. Movies, I don't really care too much.

I have known Murakami Haruki for a long time now, maybe 10 years? But I've never read any of his books. One part of me wanted to learn Japanese first and then read it in its original text (because I live in Japan), the other part of me was just lazy.

Since last year I have read two of his books: After Dark and Norwegian Wood. I think he is an exceptional story teller but an average story writer. That's my unpopular opinion, sue me.

But I stumbled upon one of his other books. A memoir rather. We might have read many novels but we don't know how a novelist thinks. This memoir is about his thought process as a novelist. It's about running, thinking, and writing.

Again, I'm not recommending anything.


r/murakami • • Aug 12 '24

Does Colourless only resonate with lonely/repressed/insular men?

0 Upvotes

I just finished the book and had some mixed feelings about it, so I came online to read others opinions and it seems that every most upvoted and positive comment seems to be from individuals who see some of Tzukuru in themselves.

I thought the story demonstrated some clear talent and Muakami’s style embeds you in the world of his characters - but I can’t understand the praise I see about it being ā€œlife changingā€


r/murakami • • Apr 10 '24

I just DNF’d 1Q84 at 50%

0 Upvotes

(Small Spoiler Warning)

Right off the bat, I feel the need to say this book has so many cool ideas, so many potentially mind bending story elements that could have made it impossible to put down. POTENTIAL is the key word here.

I made it halfway through this mammoth of a book (500 pages) and I honestly enjoyed pretty much all of it. However, even after 500 pages, I felt as if I was still reading the ā€œsetting-upā€ section of a book. I know not all questions can be answered at once but you’d think after the length of an average novel, you’d get at least one answer.

There are soooo many crazy elements and questions that Murakami introduces like the double moons, the ā€œLeaderā€, and the Little People that I would really love to see the pay off for but the pace of everything is just wayyyy too slow. I’m a big Stephen King and Anne Rice fan so I don’t mind lengthy descriptions or big books in the slightest but this takes that to a far extreme.

I think giving a book 500 pages before dropping it is beyond fair. I really enjoy Murakami’s writing style and the crazy dream quality that seems to envelope everything. I can even tolerate how sexually strange he is in seemingly every chapter (and I thought Stephen King was horny!).

A book that is 1000 pages has to give you SOMETHING to string you along from chapter to chapter but this whole book has just felt like a waiting game. Kinda like homework you have to do before you’re a allowed to get the fun stuff.

Anyway, I’ll probably try Murakami again soon, maybe a shorter novel. I have a feeling we will get along in the right circumstances.


r/murakami • • Sep 09 '21

found a little error

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/murakami • • Oct 08 '26

The Swedish Academy snubbed Haruki Murakami again.

67 Upvotes

I honestly think they are NEVER going to give it to him, even though he has deserved it for years.

The Nobel Prize in Literature has turned its back on Murakami once again. I won’t get into whether giving it to Anne Carson is deserved or not — it probably is. But at this point, the message is crystal clear:Ā they simply do not want to give it to him.

It feels like they are just waiting until his name cools off completely, until he sinks to the very bottom of the candidate list and no one even remembers him as a contender anymore. Only then will they even consider it.

A real shame, honestly.


r/murakami • • Apr 29 '22

Murakami books or stories without sexism

0 Upvotes

I tried to read first person singular and Norwegian Wood. I enjoyed parts of Norwegian Wood and then the second half completely ruined it for me, with the way the women were portrayed and talked about. With first person singular I found myself enjoying some stories and then rolling my eyes almost anytime he wrote about women, with the exception for the last story. I think he has beautiful writing style, so I would love to know if he has a book or stories with either no women or minimal. Is there anything people would recommend for me or should I just conclude that Murakami isn't for me?


r/murakami • • Apr 13 '26

Is The City and Its Uncertain Walls related to Hard-Boiled Wonderland and the End of the World in anyway?

0 Upvotes

Read both back-to-back recently and couldn’t help but realise the similarities of the town in the walls. In the latter, it is revealed that the town (the End of the World), is in the main character’s mind. But in the prior, that man is nowhere to be seen. Does he exist in the prior, or have any correlation with it? I doubt Murakami would reuse only the scenery and environment, but cut the character out of the frame.


r/murakami • • Jun 05 '24

this fucking guy (major kafka spoilers) Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/murakami • • Dec 01 '25

Which of the Murakami’s works contain extremely violent scenes in the plot? (Scared of them) NSFW Spoiler

1 Upvotes

After I finished Kafka On The Shore, I decided that maybe I can pick up another book from Murakami from the library, but maybe, just maybe I think I should’ve read some warnings before the Wind-Up Bird Chronicle. The page 159 was scary enough for me to keep on reading, as I can’t easily bear violent scenes. As such, I want to ask you who have read many of Murakami’s books, are there any works by Murakami that I should be careful of when I’m reading?


r/murakami • • Mar 10 '25

First Time Murakami reader

0 Upvotes

I’m a first time Murakami reader, and I began with The City & It’s Uncertain Walls. I’m 145 pages into it, & here are my two impressions:

  1. his writing feels very repetitive

  2. the narrator of Part One gives off pervy, Lolita-esque vibes

Does it get any better? It’s starting to feel like I’m in sunk-cost territory.


r/murakami • • Jan 06 '24

What's the relevance of right wing in Norwegian Wood?

Post image
0 Upvotes

It seems like it's mostly background - literally just some guys at the dormitory, but then the book cover is also reminiscent of the Nazi Germany flag. Is there some deeper meaning to that stuff? Was there a strong right wing movement in 1960s Japan? Is it something about characters and social class?